Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bansidhar Dhandhania v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax

Patna High Court
Nov 8, 1943
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Reference under section 66(3), Indian Income-tax Act, 1922)

Factual and Procedural Background

This reference arises from questions posed by the Commissioner of Income-tax under section 66(3) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922. The underlying dispute concerns whether members of a prominent Dhandhania family should be assessed as a continuing Hindu undivided family (HUF) or as separate partnership concerns following alleged partitions and partnership instruments executed in 1935–1936.

Key factual matrix (drawn from the opinion): - Harchand Rai (deceased) had two sons, Anandram (ancestor of the Bhagalpur group) and Gobardhan Das (ancestor of the Calcutta group). Members of these branches had been assessed earlier as an undivided Hindu family under the name Harchandrai Anandram. - For the assessment year 1936–1937 the assessees filed applications under sections 25A and 26 (and related provisions) claiming that the family had separated into two groups (Bhagalpur and Calcutta) and that the Bhagalpur group itself had subdivided into three groups represented by Dwarka Prasad, Rai Bahadur Bansidhar and Kedarnath. - The assessees produced documents including an unregistered agreement dated 4 February 1936, a registered deed of partition dated 7 May 1936, deed(s) of release, and a registered partnership deed of 31 July/1 August 1936. Books of account and oral evidence were also produced. - Income-tax Officers and the Assistant Commissioner examined these materials and reached findings at different stages: they accepted partition between the Bhagalpur and Calcutta groups but rejected internal partition among the three Bhagalpur branches for the purposes of section 25A, and refused registration under section 26A on the ground that the business remained that of a joint family or that the partnership deed was colourable. - The Commissioner set aside one appellate order for procedural irregularity but later, in subsequent proceedings, declined to refer questions of law to the High Court and largely upheld the view that no genuine internal partition in definite portions had occurred among the three Bhagalpur branches. - The present reference to this Court required answers to two specific questions about (1) whether the three named Bhagalpur members were joint or separate in law, and (2) whether the business of Harchandrai Anandram was the business of the HUF or of the named persons in partnership.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. In the facts and circumstances of the present case, are Rai Bahadur Bansidhar Dhandhania, Dwarka Prasad Dhandhania and Kedarnath Dhandhania to be considered as joint (members of a Hindu undivided family) or separate in law for the purposes of section 25A?
  2. In the facts and circumstances of the case, is the business of Harchandrai Anandram to be considered the business of a Hindu joint family or that of the persons named above in partnership (for the purposes of section 26A)?

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's (petitioners') position

  • Claimed that the previously assessed undivided Hindu family had separated into two groups (Bhagalpur and Calcutta) and that each group had further internal arrangements — specifically the Bhagalpur group claimed subdivision into three branches with specified shares (each of the three having 2 annas and 8 pies).
  • Produced documentary evidence: books of account showing separate debits/credits and profit adjustments; an unregistered agreement (4 Feb 1936); a registered deed of partition (7 May 1936) and registered partnership deed (31 July/1 Aug 1936); deeds of release and allocation of businesses.
  • Submitted that businesses had been allocated and profits/losses adjusted in accordance with agreed shares from 1931/1932 onwards (and more regularly from 1935/1936), and that partnership registration under section 26A was appropriate for the firm Harchandrai Anandram (Bhagalpur).

Income-tax Department / Revenue position

  • Income-tax Officer(s) and the Assistant Commissioner found there was a partition between Bhagalpur and Calcutta groups but held there was no real or complete partition among the three brothers within the Bhagalpur group: no documentary evidence of division of moveable or immoveable property inter se, no clear date of separation, and continued joint possession/management of properties.
  • Argued that section 25A requires the family property to be partitioned in "definite portions" and that the three Bhagalpur branches had not achieved such a partition (house properties and jote lands remained undivided). Therefore the family should continue to be assessed as an undivided Hindu family for those unpartitioned properties.
  • Further contended that the partnership deed (31 July/1 Aug 1936) was colourable or legally defective (e.g., omission of capital amounts, lack of capital accounts) and thus registration under section 26A should be refused.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sardar Bahadur Sir Sunder Singh v. Commissioner of Income-tax, United and Central Provinces (Privy Council) Holds that section 25A contains no prohibition on members of an undivided Hindu family entering into a partnership in respect of a portion of joint property; a Hindu undivided family can part with an item of property if proper steps are taken; partial partition affects assessment only for the portion partitioned. The court relied on these observations to conclude that a partial partition (specifically of businesses) does not prevent the members from entering into a partnership in respect of that portion; it supported treating the partitioned businesses as separated from the remaining joint family property for tax purposes.
Gordhandas T. Mangaldas v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay (Beaumont C.J. & Kania, J.) Interprets "definite portions" in section 25A as ordinarily implying a physical division of property (a "portion" as part of property, distinguished from a mere "share" or interest). Recognises that where physical division is infeasible (e.g., certain businesses) division may be effected in the books as definite portions. The court applied this principle to distinguish between business property (which may be partitioned by books/accounts) and immoveable/house properties (which ordinarily require physical earmarking). This assisted in finding that business partition could qualify while unpartitioned house properties kept the family joint for those assets.
Saligram Ramlal v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Punjab (Lahore High Court) Maintained that section 25A contemplates actual partition by metes and bounds and that the phrase "partitioned... in definite portions" was intended to require actual division of family property. The court cited this case as articulating the stricter view requiring actual physical partition; it was considered in the discussion but the court ultimately followed the reasoning of Gordhandas (Bombay) as more persuasive on the need for physical division except where property nature makes physical division infeasible.
Sher Singh v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Punjab (Lahore High Court) Held (on its facts) that section 25A does not require partition of family property by metes and bounds and that, at least in respect of a business, "partitioned in definite portions" can mean partitioned in definite shares recorded in accounts. The opinion notes this contrary decision and explains it may be distinguished on facts (it focused on business partition). The court considered the divergent authorities and adopted the approach that physical division is required for many properties but that business partition can be effected by definitive shares in accounts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds from the factual findings of the Income-tax Officer(s), the Assistant Commissioner and the Commissioner, and applies the relevant statutory text and precedents:

  1. Findings of fact by revenue authorities:
    • All authorities accepted partition between the two larger groups (Bhagalpur and Calcutta) following the 1936 registered instruments; assessments have been made separately for those groups.
    • The primary factual dispute was whether the Bhagalpur group (three brothers/branches) had undergone a genuine partition among themselves in "definite portions" so as to displace assessment as a continuing undivided family for all relevant assets.
    • Income-tax Officers and the Assistant Commissioner found: (a) account books showed separate charging of some personal expenses and some allocations of profits/losses to branches; (b) numerous immoveable properties (house properties, gardens, jote lands and zamindari) remained undivided among the three branches; (c) no physical division of many assets and no clear allocation of the house/garden properties among the three sections; (d) some partnership instruments existed but were challenged as colourable or legally defective by revenue authorities.
  2. Statutory construction and precedents:
    • Section 25A requires that (i) a separation of members has taken place and (ii) that joint family property has been partitioned among members or groups in definite portions. If no order under s.25A is recorded, the family is deemed to continue as an HUF under the Act.
    • The Court examined the differing judicial views on whether "definite portions" requires a physical/metes-and-bounds partition. It identified two lines of authority: the Gordhandas (Bombay) approach favouring physical division except where the nature of property (e.g., a business) makes physical division unfeasible; and other cases taking a broader view permitting division by ascertainment of shares.
    • The Court gave particular weight to the Privy Council decision in Sunder Singh which holds that section 25A does not prohibit members of an undivided family entering into a partnership in respect of portion(s) of the joint property and that a HUF can part with items of property if it takes proper steps. The Privy Council observation was read as permitting recognition of partial partition affecting only certain assets.
  3. Application to the facts:
    • The Court accepted the finding that partition between Bhagalpur and Calcutta groups had occurred and that assets/businesses had been allocated between those groups (this separation had been recognised and separate assessments followed).
    • With respect to the Bhagalpur group inter se, the Court found that, for the businesses, the three branches had defined shares in account books and that profits/losses and many business expenditures were debited/credited separately. The Court treated these book allocations and the registered partnership documents as sufficient to treat the businesses as partitioned and run in partnership by the three named persons, since physical division of a business is often infeasible and can be effected by accounting division.
    • However, the Court also found that the house properties, jote lands and certain zamindari interests remained undivided among the three Bhagalpur branches and that those immoveable properties had not been partitioned into definite portions assignable to individual branches.
    • On these combined findings the Court concluded that there was a partial partition: the businesses had effectively been partitioned (and could be treated as partnership property of the three named persons) while other family properties remained undivided and continued to constitute joint family property for assessment purposes under section 25A.
  4. Conclusion on the questions of law:
    • The Court relied on Gordhandas (Bombay) to require physical division for immoveable property where practicable, and on Sunder Singh for the proposition that members may form a partnership in respect of partitioned portions; the Court thus reconciled that business partition could be recognised by accounts while unpartitioned immoveable properties continued the HUF status for those assets.
    • Two judges (Manohar Lall, J. and Chatterji, J.) reached the same practical answers: the three named Bhagalpur persons must be deemed to continue to be a Hindu undivided family in respect of those assets not partitioned in definite portions; but the business of Harchandrai Anandram is to be regarded as the business of the three persons in partnership, insofar as the businesses have been partitioned and their shares defined and accounted for.

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • Rai Bahadur Bansidhar Dhandhania, Dwarka Prasad Dhandhania and Kedarnath Dhandhania are to be deemed to continue to be a Hindu undivided family (joint in law) for the purposes of section 25A in respect of those family properties which have not been partitioned in definite portions.
  • The business of Harchandrai Anandram is to be considered the business of Rai Bahadur Bansidhar Dhandhania, Dwarka Prasad Dhandhania and Kedarnath Dhandhania in partnership (the businesses were partitioned or allocated and the accounts show defined shares and separate debiting/crediting of profits/losses; consequently the partnership characterization for the businesses is accepted for the purposes of section 26A registration and taxation of those business incomes).

Immediate consequences for the parties:

  • The assessed status is split: (a) the businesses allocated to the Bhagalpur group are treated as partnership business of the three named persons; (b) the remaining unpartitioned house properties, jote lands and certain zamindari remain part of the continuing HUF and are assessable as such under the Act.
  • Costs: the success in this Court was divided; each party bears its own costs. The Commissioner is ordered to refund Rs. 100 deposited by the assessee as costs of the reference (as stated in the opinion).

Broader legal implication: The Court applied existing authorities (notably Sunder Singh and Gordhandas) to reconcile that partial partition can be recognised — particularly that businesses may be partitioned and treated as partnership by accounting division—while immoveable family properties may require physical earmarking to be regarded as partitioned "in definite portions." The opinion does not purport to establish a novel rule beyond applying these authorities to the facts before it.

Show all summary ...

Manohar Lall, J.:— This is a reference by the Commissioner of Income-tax under section 66(3) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, for the opinion of the Court on the following questions:

(1) In the facts and circumstances of the present case are Rai Bahadur Bansidhnr Dhandhania, Dwar kaprasad Dhandhania and Kedarnath Dhandhania to be considered as joint or separate in law?

(2) In the facts and circumstances of the case is the business of Harchandrai Anandram to be considered as the business of a Hindu joint family or that of the persons abovenamed in partnership?

It is necessary to give succinctly the facts of the case and then to collect the findings at one place because of the very unnecessarily lengthy order passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, a perusal of which involves great labour and time and sometimes makes it difficult to distinguish whether he was stating the contention of the assessee or arriving at a finding of fact.

Harchand Rai, deceased, was the father of Anandram and Gobardhan Das—also dead. Anandram was the father of Dwarka Prasad, Rai Bahadur Bansidhar and Srimohan, deceased, father of Kedarnath. These will be described either as the assessee or the Bhagalpur group for the sake of convenience hereafter. Gobardhan Das, the brother of Anandram, was the father of Jwala Prasad, Hira Lal and Chotey Lal to be described hereafter as the Calcutta group. These persons belong to the well-known Bhagalpur family of Dhandhanias who carry on a number of extensive businesses in this province and in Bengal. Up to the financial year 1935-1936 these persons, who were undoubtedly members of a joint Hindu family governed by the Mitakshara law, used to be assessed to income-tax as such; but when the assessment came to be made in respect of 1936-1937 for the previous year ending October, 1935, it was claimed on behalf of the assessees who were described in the notice as Harchandrai Anandram—the names of the original ancestor and the elder son, the father of the Bhagalpur group—that the family became separate and was now carrying on business in partnership—the application was made under sections 25(A) and 26. Under the former section the claim made was that the assessment should be made first of all in two groups as partnership concerns, that is to say the Bhagalpur group and the Calcutta group. The Bhagalpur group, it was further claimed, had been subdivided into three separate groups each represented by the head, that is to say, Dwarkadas, Rai Bahadur Bansidhar and Kedarnath with equal shares of 2 annas and 8 pies each. The Income-tax Officer accordingly had to consider whether the claim could be entertained within the meaning of section 25(A)(3), and secondly whether, he should Register the partnership as required by section 26A and called upon the claimants to produce evidence in support of the claim.

The assessee produced amongst others an unregistered agreement dated the 4th February, 1936, between the Bhagalpur and the Calcutta group, a registered deed of partition dated the 7th May, 1936, between the same parties, and an agreement and declaration regarding the zemindary properties of the same, date. Two deeds of release by the Bhagalpur group in favour of the Calcutta group in respect of certain house properties and by the Calcutta group in favour of the Bhagalpur group in respect of house properties bearing the same date, 7th May, 1936, were, also produced. The deed of allotment showed a number of businesses which were allotted separately to the Bhagalpur and the Calcutta groups. On the 20th December, 1935, the Calcutta group instituted a suit on the original side of the Calcutta High Court against the Bhagalpur group. The material allegations in the plaint at page 65 are that the plaintiffs and the defendants were still carrying on business in co-partnership in the name and style of Harchandrai Anandram at Bhagalpur with branches in Calcutta and elsewhere. Then the shares of the parties are mentioned, and it is concluded that owing to several disputes and differences which have arisen between the parties the plaintiffs claim dissolution of the partnership business with its several branches and pray for the usual decree and also for the appointment of a receiver. On the 24th of December, 1935, the notice regarding dissolution of the partnership was published in the Statesman at Calcutta (page 67) which also refers to the advertisement published in the Calcutta Exchange Gazette, dated the 19th December, 1935. On the 2nd of January, 1936, the plaintiffs filed a petition in the Calcutta High Court praying for withdrawal of the suit on the ground that as the parties had come to an amicable settlement out of Court it was not necessary to proceed with the suit. The petition was apparently granted and the suit was allowed to be withdrawn, but no order to that effect has been produced before us. The parties then entered into an unregistered deed of agreement of dissolution of partnership on the 4th February, 1936 (page 69). On the 7th May, 1936, they executed a registered deed of dissolution of partnership (page 75).

Before the Income-tax Officer Rai Bahadur Bansidhar, Babu Motilal and Babu Dwarka Prasad gave their statements on oath and written declarations were made by Hira Lal, Chotey Lal and Jwala Prasad who appeared in pursuance of the notices issued under the provisions of 26(A) of the Act. Books of account for a large number of years were produced before the Income-tax Officer.

By an order dated the 23rd March, 1937, the Income-tax Officer held that he was satisfied that there was separation of this Hindu undivided family into two groups which I have described as the Calcutta group and the Bhagalpur group. He then proceeded to consider the plea of further sub-division among the Bhagalpur group. No documentary evidence was produced before him regarding separation among the three brothers of Rai Bahadur Bansidhar, nor was any document produced to show division of the family assets moveable or immoveable amongst these three brothers. The claim which was made before him was that separation had taken place either in 1988 corresponding to 1931 A.D or 1992 corresponding to 1935 A.D The Income-tax Officer states at page 5:

“The actual date of separation and the manner of separation was not indicated in any of the documents and Rai Bahadur Bansidhar Phandhania, for whom I have great respect, states in his recorded statement, that there was no separation by any registered deed, there was no accounting of assets and liabilities and there was no allocation among different members as the status quo remained the same and it was not considered necessary that any such accounting should be made. It is stated that since 1988 they began to keep separate accounts of their personal expenses and since that year he considers there has been legal separation. He says that he treats separation since 1988 because they have been debiting personal expenses separately and crediting profits also separately. In his proper statement the assessee did not say beyond saying that any partition of the Hindu undivided family properties was effected except that a list of house properties was made out and it was divided into two portions. Some of the houses remained in possession of Dhandhanias of Calcutta and others in the hands of Dhandhanias of Bhagalpur. There was no partition of Hindu undivided family property either in 1988 or in 1992 among the three brothers of Rai Bahadur. Being questioned as to the actual date of separation, the assessee could not say on what date the separation actually took place. It is stated that once separation took place in 1988 and then again in 1992. On questions being put by in pleader the assessee replied that real separation took place in 1988 and in 1992 there was separation of business and written agreement.”

The Income-tax Officer went elaborately into the account books of 1988. He found that the parties were having joint mess and worship and that there was no division of any moveable or immoveable properties in any definite, portion; on the other hand all the houses at Bhagalpur and zamindari and gardens were in joint possession of the assessee, and further that the business, house properties and zemindari were all being managed jointly. He also found that there was no division of capital either in 1988 or 1992, and that the value of zemindari properties had not been adjusted and credited in account of members. He further pointed out that the agreement of declaration regarding the zemindari property was also between the two groups and that the Bhagalpur group was to manage the property on behalf of all. He also points out that the public notification in the press and the Gazette was regarding the division between the two groups but no notification was published for the information of the public that Rai Bahadur Bansidhar, Dwarka Prasad and Kedarnath had also separated.

In the result the Income-tax Officer rejected the claim of the assessee as he held that there was no actual separation of the Hindu undivided family, and he could not register the deed of partnership which in his opinion still belonged to the joint Hindu family and not to any partnership family.

Against this decision there was an appeal to the Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax who affirmed the order of the Income-tax Officer. The Commissioner, who was then approached under section 33, by an order dated the 5th December, 1938, set aside the findings of the Income-tax Officer because he appeared to have based his conclusions on some enquiries which he made behind the back of the assessee. In the meantime the assessment came to be made for the succeeding years 1937-1938 and 1938-1939. The assessee put forward the same objection and claimed to be separately assessed and also asked for the registration of the new partnership. But his claim was rejected under sections 25A and 26 of the Act by another Income-tax Officer who came to the same conclusions adverse to the assessee except that he accepted the contention that there was specification of shares of the three brothers of Rai Sahib Bansidhar although there was no physical division of the shares of this family. Against the assessment for the year 1937-1938 no appeals were filed under sections 25(A) and 26(A); but against the assessment for the year 1938-1939 two appeals were filed, one against the order under section 25A and the other against the order under section 26A passed by the Income-tax Officer on the same day, 13th January, 1939. The Income-tax Officer who made the assessment in 1938-1939 points out in his order at page 15 that the case of the assessee before him was that the family had separated in 1958 Sambat corresponding to 1901 A.D and that the partition was improved upon by another partition in 1988 corresponding to 1931 A.D superseding the former partition. After examining the evidence produced before him this Officer came to the same conclusion that all that happened before 1935 A.D was nothing beyond the first stage of partition in a Mitakshara family and that also not so particularly among the members of the Bhagalpur group, and that after December, 1935—apparently he is thinking of the dates of partition and agreement and declaration of shares in 1936—there followed a partition between the Calcutta group and the Bhagalpur group, a final and real partition this time. He says:

“In the previous two alleged partitions A's group and G's group used to remain joint owners with specified shares, but this time there was a real and final separation. Some business concerns were allotted solely and separately to A's group and some to G's group. It was after this separation that separate assessments on G's group called Dhandhanias of Calcutta, and on A's group called Dhandhanias of Bhagalpur, began to be made at Calcutta and this place respectively. This partition also did not touch the internal relations between the members of A's group; all of them remained joint owners of the whole lot of properties coming to their shares; unity of possession continued as before.”

In the result he refused the claim of the assessee under section 25A and refused to register their partnership under section 26A.

The appeal against this order and the previous remand by the Commissioner with regard to assessment year 1936-1937 were disposed of by the Assistant Commissioner in an exceedingly lengthy order which covers 33 printed pages (pages 18-50) on 12th June, 1940.

His findings may be summarised thus: (1) The ascertainment of shares of 1958 and 1988 between the A and G groups seems to be merely a preliminary process with a view to ultimate separation as was done in 1992 and it was for this reason that the members of the family never seriously took the ascertainment of shares as constituting partition until actual separation of the two groups took place and they applied for partition before the Income-tax Officer only at this last stage, and that the 1958 ascertainment of shares cannot legally constitute partnership (page 47, paragraph 67); (2) By conduct of the parties it is clear that there has been no disruption among the members of the family and there was no intention to have separate status as partners; (3) The Bhagalpur group got lands at Bhagalpur town and at Mandar Hill on which the two sections of the family have built joint garden houses. These were undivided properties of A group acquired and constructed after the alleged 1988 partition. These garden houses are intended to be jointly occupied and the shares in these properties have not been defined; (4) House properties and garden and town lands worth Rs. 1,60,400 were allotted to A group and similarly properties of the same value were allotted to G group and although it was possible to physically divide these properties among the three sections of A group, this was not done and these properties falling to the share of A group remained undivided and even in Municipal Registers mutation of names of three sections of the family has not been taken and most of the properties in the Municipality stand in the name of Rai Bahadur Bansidhar Dhandhania. The A group has further jointly acquired and developed the house properties; (5) In no document the shares of the three sections in these houses and gardens have been defined. In the deed of release executed by A group in favour of G group the houses are mentioned as one undivided unit belonging to Dwarka Prasad Dhandhania, Rai Bahadur Bansidhar Dhandhania and Kedarnath Dhandhania collectively referred to as Dhandhanias of Bhagalpur. It is significant that in the document defining shares in zamindari and jote lands these house properties and gardens are not included. In the result he held that there has been no real partition among the sons of Anandram and they are still joint with undivided status of property and business and, therefore, the Income-tax Officer was right in refusing to pass an order under section 25(A), and that there was no contractual partnership among the sons of Anandram and the partnership deed dated the 1st of August, 1936, is a colourable document not intended to be acted upon.

The Commissioner by his order dated the 26th August, 1940, refused to interfere under section 33 and substantially came to the same findings. It was argued before him that it was impossible to apportion the business between the three members without destroying it but he, while admitting some practical difficulty in so doing, thought that it was not impossible because the various debtors, creditors, shares and securities, etc., relating to the business could be apportioned. He then says that it is not understood why the various house properties, which are over a dozen, were not distinctly earmarked and allotted to different members or groups of members of the family although it was admitted before him that it, could have been done. He then says

“Besides, according to the petitioners' argument, if the businesses alone belonged to the partnership, the Hindu undivided family of Anandram evidently still existed as far as these house properties were concerned. Even assuming for a minute (though not admitting) that the alleged partition was made only of the businesses' and not of the house properties originally owned by the Hindu undivided family of Anandram, it may be stated that section 25A has no application where there is only, a partial division of the joint family property without the division in the joint status of the members and a disruption of the family.”

He finally concludes at page 57:

“In the present case, even a partition by metes and bounds of the three businesses owned by the family of Anandram could have been effected by grouping smaller properties with bigger businesses and bigger properties with smaller businesses. Besides, there was no reason whatsoever not to earmark and apportion at least the 14 or 15 house properties specifically amongst the various members as was done at the time of the partition between the Bhagalpur and the Calcutta groups. I, therefore, agree with the lower authorities that the petitioners have not complied also with the second requisition of section 25A.”

In the concluding paragraph the. Commissioner observes that although every formality for showing a separation of the members of the Hindu undivided family of Anandram and partition of his joint family properties has been gone through, he finds that no genuine separation has taken place among the members of the Hindu family of the Bhagalpur group hitherto assessed as undivided and that the joint family properties have not been really partitioned among the various members thereof in definite portions as required by section 25A of the Act as it stood before the amendment of 1939.

On the 26th August, 1940, the Commissioner refused to refer any question of law for the decision of the High Court because he thought that the questions were merely questions of fact. He passed similar orders with regard to the contention of the assessee to be allowed to be registered under section 26A of the Act.

After giving these somewhat lengthy quotations from the orders of the Income-tax authorities, I now proceed to consider some of the cases which would help in giving the correct answer to the questions framed above.

In a recent decision of their Lordships of the Judicial Committee in Sardar Bahadur Sir Sunder Singh v. Commissioner of Income-tax, United and Central Provinces Sir George Rankin, who delivered the judgment of the Board, pointed out at page 127 that the contention of the Commissioner that for the purposes of the Income-tax Act members of an undivided Hindu family cannot enter into a partnership in respect of a portion of the joint property which they have partitioned among themselves was wrong as the section contains no warrant for any such prohibition. His Lordship also held that if though the joint Hindu family has come to an end it be found that its property has not been partitioned in definite portions, then the family is to be deemed to continue—that is to be an existent Hindu family on which assessment can be made on its gains of the previous year; and further that a joint Hindu family can part with an item of its property, to a stranger or even amongst its own members, e.g, by partition, if it takes the proper steps.

There has been a considerable diversity of judicial opinion as to whether section 25A requires actual division of the property and not a mere notional severance by the ascertainment of shares. In Gordhandas T. Mangaldas v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay, the learned Chief Justice and Kania, J. have considered this question at great length. The learned Chief Justice deals with the matter thus at page 249: “Apart from authority, I should feel no doubt that section 25A contemplates a physical division of the property. I think that the expression ‘definite portions’ indicates a physical division in which a member takes a particular house in which he can go and live, or a piece of land which he can cultivate, or which he can sell or mortgage, or takes particular ornaments which he can wear or dispose of, and that the expression ‘definite portions’ is not appropriate to describe an undivided mare in property where all that a particular member can claim is a proportion of the income, and a division of the corpus, but where he cannot claim any definite portion of the property………………..in connection with property I should say that a portion means a part of the property, whereas a share indicates the interest of some individual in the property. A room may be said to be a portion of a house; it cannot be said to be a share of a house, although it may represent the share of a particular person in the house. ‘Portion’ seems to me the apt word for division of property, and ‘share’ for division of interest, and it is significant that portion is used in section 25A. No doubt the expression ‘division in definite portions’ will have to be construed with regard to the nature of the property concerned. A business cannot be divided into parts in the same manner as a piece of land; division may only be possible in the books. Special cases will have to be dealt with by the Income-tax Officer when they arise. If he comes to the conclusion that, having regard to the nature of the property, what has been done amounts to a division in definite portions, he will record his finding under sub-section (1); if he comes to the conclusion that it does not, then he will have to go on assessing the family under sub-section (3)”. Kania, J. gave a separate judgment to the same effect.

I do not propose to consider any other case because in my opinion the questions can be answered accurately by applying the principle of this case which was relied upon by Mr. S.M, Gupta, who appeared for the Income-tax Department, and keeping in view the weighty observations of their Lordships in Sunder Singh's case.

The findings arrived at in this case are that there has been a partition in definite portions between the two groups, i.e Calcutta and Bhagalpur, and they are being assessed separately since 1936-1937. With regard to this assessee the further finding is that as to the three or four businesses allotted to them their shares have been defined in the account books and separate expenditures are being debited to the shares of each of the members. I am reading from page 40 (order of the Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax):

“The Income-tax Officer in 1933-1984 and 1934-1935 found that profits were not credited to the family members and only in 1935-1936 he found that distribution of profits in to prior accounting year 1989-1990 was completed. I think the assessee's explanation for late adjustment is acceptable and all adjustment of profits or losses in the various years under consideration may be taken to be bona fide adjustments and not afterthoughts to conform to the story of the alleged 1988 agreement.”

The assessee has further shown that profits and losses were adjusted from 1988-1989 to 1992-1993 (page 39, lines 3 and 4). The Assistant Commissioner has devoted one paragraph (34) to consider the assessee's system of noting expenses in the account books from 1988-1989 and observes that personal expenses are separately incurred by each member and debited to the name of each (see page 47, line 34). The assessees have also definite shares in the zemindary properties but they have not divided the jote lands nor have they, divided the 14 or 15 houses which have been allotted to them on partition from the Calcutta group.

In my opinion it must be held on the above quoted findings that the assessee is no longer a joint undivided Hindu family—the three brothers have definite shares defined by the deed of agreement and registered deed of partnership executed at the time of the separation from the Calcutta group; their shares are defined in the Collector's papers and their profits, loss, income and expenditure are debited and credited in their books of account regularly kept and believed by the Income-tax authorities. Having defined shares in the businesses they can only enjoy their shares separately in this way.

But has there been such a division or partition as is contemplated by section 25A of the Act? So far as the businesses are concerned it is impossible to divide them except by sharing all the profits and losses at the close of the year or whenever the accounting comes to be made for the profit and loss of the business of the relevant years. As I have just stated it is found as a fact that the accounts of income and expenditure are kept separately. But there is also a definite finding that the house property and the jote lands have not been partitioned. It must, therefore, be held that there is no complete partition but only a partial partition. But such a partial partition comes within the operation of section 25A of the Act as observed, by their Lordships in Sunder Singh's case, and the Commissioner's view to the contrary is wrong. The members of the assessee's family in these circumstances must be deemed to continue to form a joint Hindu family for the purpose of assessing them on that portion of the income which is derivable from those properties which have not been partitioned in definite portion other than the businesses.

I would, therefore, answer the questions in these terms:

(1) Rai Bahadur Bansidhar Dhandhania, Dwarkaprasad Dhandhania and Kedarnath Dhandhania must be deemed to continue, to be a Hindu undivided family.

(2) The business of Harchandrai Anandram cannot be considered to be a business of a Hindu undivided, family but must be considered to be the business of the persons named above in partnership.

As the success in this Court has been divided, each party will bear his own costs, but the Commissioner will refund the sum of Rs. 100 deposited by the assessee as costs of the reference.

Chatterji, J.:— This is a reference by the Commissioner of Income-tax under section 66(3) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, as it stood before the amendments of 1939, and arises out of an appellate order of the Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, dated the 11th June, 1940, refusing to make an order under section 254(1) and also refusing registration of a firm under section 26A of the Act.

The appellate order of the Assistant Commissioner relates to assessment made in 1936-1937 and 1938-1939 on a Hindu undivided family consisting of two brothers Dwarka Prasad and Rai Bahadur Bansidhar Dhandhania, their deceased younger brother Srimohan's son Kedar Nath and their sons and grandsons. This family represents the branch of the elder of two brothers Anandram and Gobardhan Das who were the sons of Harchandrai. Anandram was the father of Dwarka Prasad and his two brothers. Gobardhan Das's branch is represented by his three sons Jwala Prasad, Hira Lal and Chotey Lal and their son's.

Up to 1935-1936 the two branches of Anandram and Gobardhan Das consisting of their sons and grandsons, as aforesaid, were assessed as a Hindu undivided family, the assessment being made in the name of Messrs. Harchandrai Anandram. During the next assessment year, i.e, 1936-1937 the assessees filed on the 30th July, 1936, an application under sections 25A and 26 claiming that though assessed as a Hindu undivided family, they were in fact separate and were carrying on business in partnership and that assessment should be made in two groups as partnership concerns, the first group consisting of Dwarka Prasad, Rai Bahadur Bansidhar Dhandhania and Kedar Nath each having 2 as. 8 p. share, collectively called the Dhandhanias of Bhagalpur and the second group consisting of Jwala Prasad, Hira Lal and Chotey Lal, having 3 as., 2 as. 6 p. and 2 as. 6 p. share respectively—collectively called the Dhandhanias of Calcutta. Again on the 31st October, 1936, Kedar Nath Dhandhania of the first group filed an application under section 264 praying for registration of the firm Harchandrai Anandram of Bhagalpur.

In support of their claim the assessees produced both oral and documentary evidence. The documentary evidence consists of the following among other documents:—

(1) Books of account,

(2) Unregistered deed of agreement regarding dissolution of partnership executed on the 4th February, 1936, by the aforesaid six members of the two groups,

(3) Registered deed of dissolution and partition dated the 7th May, 1936, executed by the same six members of the two groups,

(4) Registered deed of release of the 7th May, 1936, by the Dhandhanias of Calcutta in favour of the Dhandhanias of Bhagalpur in respect of some house properties,

(5) Registered deed of partnership of the firm Harchandrai Ananaiam, dated the 31st July, 1936, executed by the Dhandhanias of Bhagalpur.

Upon the evidence, and particularly in view of the registered deed of partition dated the 7th May, 1936, which shows actual division of the businesses and house properties of the family between the two groups aforesaid, the Income-tax Officer by his order dated the 23rd March, 1937, held that

“there was separation of H.U.F in two groups, one consisting of Dwarkadas, Bansidhar and Kedarnath, and other Jwala Prasad, Hiralal and Chotey Lal”.

As the Calcutta business was allotted to the second group called the Dhandhanias of Calcutta and their head office was in Calcutta, the Income-tax Officer referred their case for assessment to the Income-tax Officer of Calcutta. This group has no concern with the case now before us.

As regards the other group called the Dhandhanias of Bhagalpur, the Income-tax Officer by the same order dated the 23rd March, 1937, held that there was no separation among them inter se and that their partnership deed dated the 31st July, 1936, could not be recognised as the business belonged to their joint family and not to a firm. Accordingly he refused to make an order under section 25A(1) in respect of their group and also refused registration of their alleged firm. Assessment was made on them as a Hindu undivided family.

On appeal to the Assistant Commissioner this assessment was confirmed by his order dated the 7th October, 1937. On an application for review under section 33, however, the Commissioner by his order dated the 5th December, 1938, set aside the order of the Assistant Commissioner and remanded the appeal to him for rehearing according to law, because he had made some enquiries behind the back of the assessees and his decision was apparently influenced by the result of such enquiries.

In the meantime assessments were made for the years 1937-1938 and 1938-1939. The assessees reiterated the same claim under sections' 25A and 25A and with the same result. There was no appeal in respect of the assessment for 1937-1938, but from the order which was passed on the 13th January, 1939, in respect of the next year's assessment two appeals were preferred, one regarding the rejection of the claim under section 25A and the other regarding the rejection of the claim under section 26A.

These two appeals were heard along with the appeal relating to the assessment for the year 1936-1937 which had been remanded by the Commissioner. All the three appeals were dismissed by the Assistant Commissioner by his order dated the 11th June, 1940, which has given rise to this reference.

The questions which have been referred to this Court under section 66(3) are:

(1) In the facts and circumstances of the present case are Rai Bahadur Bansidhar Dhandhania, Dwarkaprasad Dhandhania and Kedarnath Dhandhania to be considered as joint or separate in law?

(2) In the facts and circumstances of the case is the business of Harchandrai Anandram to be considered as the business of a Hindu joint family or that of the persons above-named in partnership?

The first question has reference to section 25A and the, second to section 26A.

Section 25A, so far as it is material to the present case, runs as follows:—

“25A.(1) Where, at the time of making an assessment under section 28, it is claimed by or on behalf of any member of a Hindu family hitherto assessed as undivided that a partition has taken place among the members of such family, the Income-tax Officer shall make such inquiry thereinto as he may think fit, and, if he is satisfied that a separation of the members of the family has taken place and that the joint family property has been partitioned among the various members or groups of members in definite portions he shall record an order to that effect:

Provided that no such order shall be recorded until notices of the inquiry have been served on all the members of the family.

(3) Where such an order has not been passed in respect of a Hindu family hitherto assessed as undivided, such family shall be deemed, for the purposes of this Act, to continue to be a Hindu undivided family.”

It is clear that for the purposes of section 25A mere disruption of the family is not enough, but the joint family property must have also been partitioned among the various members or groups of members in definite portions. There is, however, a divergence of judicial opinion as to whether the use of the expression “definite portions” in the section implies that there should, be actual division of the family property.

In a very recent case of the Bombay High Court, Gordhandas T. Mangaldas v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay, decided by Beaumont, C.J and Kania, J., it was held that the expression “definite portions” indicates a physical division and is not appropriate to describe an undivided share in property where all that a particular member can claim is a portion of the income and a division of the corpus, but where he cannot claim any definite portion of the property. Beaumont, C.J, drew a distinction between the words “portion” and “share” and said “No doubt the words sometimes may be used interchangeably, but in connection with property I should say that a portion means a part of the property, whereas a share indicates the interest of some individual in the property…………‘Portion’ seems to me the apt word for division of property, and ‘share’ for division of interest, and it is significant that portion is used in section 25A No. doubt the expression ‘division in definite portions’ will have to be construed with regard to the nature of the property concerned. A business cannot be divided into parts in the same manner as a piece of land; division may only be possible in the books”.

The same view was taken by the Lahore High Court in Saligram Ramlal v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Punjab. Addison and Sale, JJ., who decided that case said “The principal contention before us was that section 25A did not contemplate an actual partition by metes and bounds of the joint family property. It seems to us that it is impossible so to hold. If actual partition had not been contemplated the clause, ‘and that the joint family property has been partitioned among the various members or groups of members in definite portions’ would not have been added to the section; for the clause immediately preceding it would be sufficient if the law was that actual partition of the property was not necessary”.

But in a later case of the Lahore High Court Sher Singh v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Punjab, decided by three Judges, Jai Lal, Dalip Singh and Skemp, JJ., an exactly opposite view was taken. It was held that section 25A does not require actual partition of the family property by metes and bounds as a condition precedent to the recognition of a partition under that section. The attention of the learned Judges does not appear to have been drawn to the earlier case of Saligram Ramlal v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Punjab. In that case, however, their Lordships had to deal with the question of partition of a business. Dalip Singh, J., who delivered the judgment (Jai Lal and Skemp, JJ. agreeing), said “it seems to me clear that in the case of a business at any rate the only reasonable meaning of the words ‘partitioned in definite portions’ must be ‘partitioned in definite shares’.” The decision, therefore, may be distinguished on the facts, though the proposition of law laid down was rather widely expressed. This decision was considered in the Bombay case already cited.

I am inclined to agree with the view taken in the Bombay case, Gordhandas T. Mangaldas v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay. If mere ascertainment of shares and division of the income of the undivided property according to the ascertained shares were to be held sufficient to constitute partition in definite portions, the clear provisions of section 25A would be defeated in the case of a Dayabhag family. In a Dayabhag family shares of the members are always ascertained, whether the family be joint or separate. Where the family is joint, there is no division of the income of the joint family property but it is brought into the common chest and is spent for joint family purposes. The family may become separate without the family property being actually divided; for instance, where the income of the undivided family property is divided and appropriated by the members according to their respective shares. In such case the first condition laid down in section 254, namely, that “a separation of the members of the family has taken place”, is satisfied, but not the second, namely, that the joint family property has been partitioned in definite portions. Unless this second condition is also satisfied, the section cannot operate. It therefore follows that the section requires physical division. Where, however, physical division is not feasible, as in the case of a business, partition in definite shares will be enough as indicated by Beaumont, C.J

Now, in the present case the Assistant Commissioner has held that

“there has been no real partition among the sons of Anand Ram and that they are still joint and undivided in status and property and business”.

This is apparently a finding of fact, but whether there is evidence on which it was open to the Assistant Commissioner to come to this finding is a question of law: see Sardar Bahadur Sir Sundar Sinah v. Commissioner of Income-tax, United and Central Provinces in which their Lordships of the Privy Council, in dealing with the question whether an instrument of partnership tendered under section 264 was a genuine transaction or was executed by way of presence in order to escape liability for tax, said. “To decide that an instrument is in this sense not genuine is to come to a finding of fact; whether there was evidence on which it was open to the income-tax authority to come to such a decision is a question of law”.

The case of the assessees was that in 1988 Sambat (1931) there was separation between the three branches of their group, which may be called the Bhagalpur group, as well as between the three branches of the other group, which may be called the Calcutta group, that since then the members representing the six separate branches were carrying on businesses in partnership, that in Magh 1992 Sambat (February 1936) the partnership between them was dissolved, and there was partition of the businesses according to the terms embodied in the registered deed of dissolution and partition dated the 7th May, 1936, and that then the members of the Bhagalpur group entered into a fresh partnership the terms of which were embodied in the registered deed of partnership dated the 31st July, 1936.

The assessees produced account books from 1987-1988 Sambat to prove that the six branches were carrying on business in partnership in six shares, i.e, 2 as. 8 p., 2 as. 8 p., 2 as 8 p., 3 annas, 2 as. 6 p., and 2 as. 6 p., and that profits and losses were adjusted in accordance with these shares. The Assistant Commissioner examined these account books very carefully and came to the conclusion

“I think the assessee's explanation for late adjustment is acceptable and all adjustment of profits or losses in the various years under consideration may be taken to be bona fide adjustments and not afterthoughts to conform to the story of the alleged 1888 agreement”

(see paragraph 43 of his order). He also found that

“profits or losses were adjusted in the six group accounts every year up to 1992-1993 (three months) and after that in three group accounts when the Dhandhanias of Bhagalpur came into possession of the Bhagalpur gaddi”

(see paragraph 44 of his order). He further found that from 1988 the expenses on account of common messing of the three branches of the Bhagalpur group, who were living at Bhagalpur, and their other common expenses such as, for horse and carriage, cows, garden, were incurred jointly and shared equally by the three branches and that other personal expenses of each of these branches, e.g, expenses for marriage and religious ceremonies, medical treatment, ornaments, private travelling and pilgrimage, purchase of fruits and other personal purchases, educational expenses of children, etc., were debited to three separate khatas newly opened, namely, A/c Dwarka Prasad Moti Lal (Moti Lal being the son of Dwarka Prasad), A/c Bansidhar Sheokumar (Sheokumar being the eldest son of Bansidhar) and A/c Sreemohan Kedarnath (see paragraph 34 of his order). It may be mentioned here that the members of the Calcutta group were living in Calcutta.

It appears that the original undivided family had the businesses styled (1) Harchandrai Anandram, Bhagalpur, (2) Srimohan Pannalal Mills, Bhagalpur, (3) Half share of the Sri Bihariji Mills, Patna, (4) Half share in the Monghyr Electric Supply Co., (5) Harchandrai Gobardhandas, Calcutta and (6) Sri Annapurna Mills, Benares. The registered deed of dissolution and partition dated the 7th May, 1936, shows that the first four businesses were allotted to the Bhagalpur group and the last two to the Calcutta group. The deed also shows that until the dissolution and partition the members of the two groups had been carrying on the businesses in partnership in six shares, as already mentioned.

The family was also possessed of some zamindaries, jote lands, house properties, gardens and town lands. The house properties, garden and town lands were divided between the two groups, but the zamindaries and jote lands were left joint. The fact that the zamindaries and jote lands were left joint did not affect the partition between the two groups for the purpose of section 25A, because, as pointed out by the Assistant Commissioner (paragraph 62 of his order), these properties did not form part of assets yielding profits taxable under the Income-tax Act. Admittedly there has been no division of any of the landed properties among the members of the Bhagalpur group inter se.

The reasons given by the Assistant Commissioner for rejecting the claim under section 25A. (see paragraph 68 of his order) are mainly (1) that “The 3 sections of the family continue in the same state of joint messing and joint residence and have all the essential features of an undivided Hindu family”, (2) that the house properties, gardens and town lands which were obtained by them at the partition between the two groups remained undivided, though it was possible physically to divide them, and (3) that there is mere definition of shares in the partnership deed dated the 31st July, 1936, but no partition in definite portions, as contemplated by section 25A. He altogether overlooked his previous finding (see paragraphs 43 and 44 of his order) that profits and losses were adjusted every year according to the shares of the different branches of the family. There is also his finding (see paragraph 34 of his order) that the personal expenses of each of the three sections of the Bhagalpur group were debited to their respective khatas. As regards the businesses, there is nothing in the order of the Assistant Commissioner to suggest that physical division of these businesses was feasible. The Commissioner in his order passed under section 33 says

“In the present case, even a partition by metes and bounds of the three businesses owned by the family of Anandram could have been effected by grouping smaller properties with bigger businesses and bigger properties with smaller businesses”.

This might have been possible if the entire joint family properties had been partitioned. But there was no legal bar to their effecting a partial partition, that is to say, partition of the businesses only.

From the aforesaid findings of the Assistant Commissioner the inference legitimately follows that the businesses were divided between the members of the family in definite portions, though the family remained undivided so far as the landed properties are concerned.

The question then arises whether partial partition can be recognised for the purpose of making an order under section 254. In the Privy Council case of Sir Sunder Singh their Lordships with reference to section 25A, said. “On this section the contention of the Commissioner is that for the purposes of the Income-tax Act members of an undivided Hindu family cannot enter into a partnership in respect of a portion of the joint property which they have partitioned among themselves. But, in their Lordships' view, section 25A contains no warrant for any such prohibition. It has no reference at all to any case in which the Hindu undivided family remains in existence at the time of assessment. No difficulty whatever in the assessment of a Hindu, undivided family is caused—or was ever thought to be caused—by the facts that in one year it has certain assets and certain income therefrom and that in the next year it is found to have parted with one asset and to be no longer in receipt of the same income. The same assessee has a different income in each year—that is all. It matters nothing whether the particular asset no longer possessed by the undivided family has become the separate property of a member or belongs to a stranger.” Further their Lordships said. “But it (a Hindu undivided family) need not have the same assets or the same income in each year, and it can part with an item of its property to its individual members if it takes the proper steps”. From these observations it does not follow that partial partition can be recognised under section 25A. All that their Lordships say is that if there has been a partial partition, the income of the portion of the property partitioned will be excluded from the assessment on the undivided family and will be liable to be taxed separately. Section 25A, in my opinion, refers to a family as one unit. If a portion only of the joint family property has been partitioned, that portion ceases to belong; to the joint family, but the joint family still remains. So long as the joint family remains, no order under section 25A can be made. This is clear from the following passage in the above quoted observations of their Lordships of the Privy Council. “It has no reference at all to any case in which the Hindu undivided family remains in existence at the time of assessment”.

Though, therefore, there has been a partition of the businesses, as I have held above, the family of the assessees must be regarded as an undivided family for the purpose of section 25A. Consequently the first question referred under section 66(3) must be answered as follows:

Rai Bahadur Bansidhar Dhandhania, Dwarka Prasad Dhandhania and Kedarnath Dhandhania are to be considered as joint in law.

The second question, as I have already stated, has reference to section 26A. The relevant portion of the section is as follows:—

“26A.(1) Application may be made to the Income-tax Officer on behalf of any firm, constituted under an instrument of partnership specifying the individual shares of the partners, for registration for the purposes of this Act and of any other enactment for the time being in force relating to income-tax or super-tax.”

The firm of which registration was sought under section 264 was constituted under the partnership deed dated the 31st July, 1936, (registered on 1st August, 1936). The Assistant Commissioner has held

“that there is no contractual partnership among the sons of Anand Ram and the partnership deed dated the 1st August, 1936, is colourable document, not intended to be acted upon”.

This finding is substantially based on the supposition that the alleged partnership business belongs to the joint family. Paragraph 68 of his order opens with the following sentence

“In the present case, I hold that partition under section 25A and therefore registration under section 26A cannot be allowed for the following reasons”.

The word “therefore” which I have italicized suggests that in the opinion of the Assistant Commissioner registration under section 26A must be refused if partition under section 25A were to be disallowed. In clause (1) of the same paragraph he says

“But in judging the genuineness of a so-called deed of partnership, the conduct of the former members of a joint Hindu family must be looked into. Their conduct viewed by an outsider is such that the alleged contractual relationship (as against coparcenery relationship) cannot be judged. There is no outside social conduct to show that the former coparcenary has dissolved.”

This shows that in his opinion the genuineness of the partnership deed depends upon whether the coparcenery was dissolved. In clause (8) of the same paragraph, however, he says

“Further the fact regarding separation and partition of joint family members does not itself entitle an assessee to claim registration under section 26A. It has to be seen whether the partnership deed itself is a legally correct document to be accepted for registration. I hold that the document does not satisfy the test.”

The question of the legality of the document is quite different from the question whether it is a colourable document. The document on the face of it specifies the names of the partners and their shares, provides for taking of accounts and distribution of profit and loss at the end of Diwali of each year and also makes some other provisions appropriate to a partnership. The Assistant Commissioner points out certain defects, the most important of which are that there is no mention of the capital invested in the new business, and that no capital accounts were started by the three partners with equal sums. But omissions of these details in the partnership deed in no way affects its validity.

As pointed out by their Lordships of the Privy Council in the above cited case of Sir Sunder Singh, there is nothing in section 25A to prohibit the members of an undivided Hindu family from entering into a partnership in respect of a portion of the joint property which they have partitioned among themselves. I have already held that the businesses were partitioned among the three branches of the assessees' family. The business of Harchandrai Anandram therefore does not belong to the joint family. There was no justification for the Assistant Commissioner's finding that the partnership deed dated the 31st July, 1936, is a colourable document. The second question referred under section 66(3) must, therefore, be answered as follows:—

The business of Harchandrai Anandram is to be considered is the business of Rai Bahadur Bansidhar Dhandhania, Dwarika Prasad Dhandhania and Kedarnath Dhandhania in partnership.

As regards costs, I agree to the order proposed by my learned brother.

H.R.K
Answer accordingly.