- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Fotick Chunder Dey Sircar v. E.G. Foley And Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
The central factual predicate in the opinion is that a landlord obtained a decree for rent. The legal question arose in the aftermath of the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, whether a landlord who obtains such a decree may, in the first instance, proceed to attach the movable property or the person of the judgment-debtor, or whether he is obliged first to attempt execution of the decree by putting up for sale the tenure in respect of which rent is in arrear.
Procedurally, the District Judge held that the landlord is not entitled, in the first instance, to attach the movable property or person of the defaulting tenant. The District Judge relied on the decision in Lalit Mohun Roy v. Binodai Dabee (14 C 14). The court whose opinion is summarized disagreed with the District Judge's conclusion, set aside the order of the lower Appellate Court, and restored the orders of the first Court with costs of all Courts.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, after the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, a landlord who obtains a decree for rent is, in the first instance, entitled to attach the movable property or the person of the judgment-debtor, or whether the landlord is obliged first to endeavour to execute the decree by putting up for sale the tenure in respect of which rent is in arrear.
- Whether the "charge" declared by Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, is the same type of "charge" as defined by Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act, thereby importing provisions of the Transfer of Property Act (including Sections 81, 82 and Section 68) to limit the landlord's remedies.
- Whether provisions such as Section 68 of the Transfer of Property Act apply so as to restrict a landlord's remedies after a decree for rent has been obtained.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondents' Arguments (as presented by Dr. Banerjee)
- Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, declares rent to be "a first charge" on the tenure; this "charge" is argued to be the same as the "charge" defined in Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act.
- If Section 65's "charge" is the same as that in Section 100, then "all the provisions thereinbefore contained" in the Transfer of Property Act (i.e., provisions prior to Section 100) applicable to a mortgagor/mortgagee should, so far as applicable, be read as applying to the landlord as owner of the tenure.
- Consequently, the provisions relating to a mortgagee instituting a suit for sale of mortgaged property (including Sections 81 and 82) and the disabilities contained in Section 68 of the Transfer of Property Act would apply to the landlord, preventing the landlord from proceeding in the first instance against movable property or the person of the tenant.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Lalit Mohun Roy v. Binodai Dabee, 14 C 14 | Under the old rent act (Act VIII of 1869) if a landlord wished to proceed against immovable property in the first instance, the immovable property to be attached and put up for sale was the tenure in respect of which rent was due. The decision was under the earlier statute. | The court distinguished this authority: it was decided under the old rent act and the judgment expressly did not decide the question of proceeding against movable property in the first instance. Therefore it does not support the District Judge's broader conclusion that a landlord cannot, in the first instance, attach movables or the person. |
| Decision by Petheram, C.J., and Ghose, J. (unnamed in the opinion) | Held that the view taken by the District Judge (that landlord is not entitled in the first instance to attach movables or the person) was not correct. | The court relied on this authority to fortify its conclusion that the District Judge's interpretation was incorrect and that the legislature did not intend to impose the old act's restrictions on landlords under the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by (i) examining the precedent relied upon by the District Judge, (ii) analysing the statutory argument advanced for the respondents, and (iii) considering legislative intent and principle.
First, the court observed that Lalit Mohun Roy v. Binodai Dabee was decided under the old Rent Act (Act VIII of 1869), and that the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, had materially altered the conditions. In that case the court had held only that if a landlord proceeded against immoveable property in the first instance, the tenure in respect of the rent must be the property attached and sold. That case did not address the landlord's right to proceed against movable property in the first instance; therefore it does not support the District Judge's broader conclusion.
Second, addressing the respondents' statutory argument, the court analysed the relationship between Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act and Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act. The court noted that Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act applies certain provisions "as to a mortgagor" (Sections 60–66) and certain provisions "as to a mortgagee instituting a suit for the sale of the mortgaged property" (Sections 67–77), but Section 68 is not one of the sections made applicable by Section 100. Thus Section 68 was not incorporated by Section 100.
Further, the court reasoned that even if Section 68 were applicable, it deals with cases where a mortgagee may bring a suit for the mortgage money and not with the post-decree process of selling property in satisfaction of a decree; any disability under Section 68 would cease with the obtaining of a decree. Accordingly, the argument that Section 68 restricts the landlord's remedies after a decree was not sustainable.
Finally, the court considered legislative intent and principle. Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act was held to be an enactment for the benefit of the landlord, conferring rights denied to ordinary creditors. Applying the Transfer of Property Act provisions in the manner contended for would, at least temporarily, deprive the landlord of remedies enjoyed by ordinary judgment-creditors. Given that earlier Rent Act provisions limiting the order in which a defaulting tenant's properties could be sold (Sections 59–61 and 65 of the old Rent Act) find no place in the Bengal Tenancy Act, the court was not persuaded that the legislature intended to impose the old act's constraints on landlords under the 1885 Act. The court found support for this view in the decision by Petheram, C.J., and Ghose, J., which held the District Judge's view incorrect.
On these grounds the court concluded that the respondents' statutory contention should not prevail.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court set aside the order of the lower Appellate Court and restored the orders of the first Court with costs of all Courts.
Implications:
- The court rejected the respondents' contention that Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, must be read with Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act so as to impose upon the landlord the disabilities (including Section 68) applicable to mortgagees or mortgagors under the Transfer of Property Act.
- The opinion indicates that the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, was not intended to carry forward the old Rent Act's restrictions that would tie the hands of a landlord; thus the court refused to adopt an interpretation that would curtail landlord remedies in the manner argued by the respondents.
- Direct effect on the parties: the orders of the first Court are restored and the respondents' statutory argument was rejected. The opinion does not indicate that it establishes any new, broad precedent beyond the resolution of the present controversy, but it does rely on prior authority to support the conclusion reached.
1. The question that arises for consideration in this ease is whether, since the passing of the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, a landlord who obtains a decree for rent is entitled, if he pleases, in the first instance, to attach the moveable property, and, if he pleases, the person of his judgment-debtor, or whether he is obliged, in the first instance, to. endeavour to execute his decree by putting up for sale the tenure, the rent in respect of which is in arrear, and for which he has obtained a decree.
2. The District Judge has held that the landlord is not entitled, in the first instance, to attach the moveable property, and, if ha so pleases, the person of the defaulting tenant.
3. In support of this view, the District Judge has relied upon the case of Lalit Mohun Roy v. Binodai Dabee 14 C 14. With reference to that case, which was decided by Mr. Justice Ghose and myself, two observations are to be made. First, it was a decision under the old rent act (act viii of 1869), and we especially called attention, at the conclusion of our judgment, to the fact that the conditions of things as they existed under that Act had been entirely altered by the Bengal Tenancy Act.
4. In the second place it is to be observed that in that case we held that if the landlord wished, in the first instance, to proceed against any immoveable property of the defaulting tenant, the immoveable property which he must attach and put up for sale is the tenure, in respect of the rent of which he has obtained a decree.
5. We said nothing as to the landlord's right to proceed against the moveable property of the defaulting tenant in the first instance. That question was not before us.
6. Upon these grounds we are of opinion that the case cited does not support the conclusion at which the District Judge has arrived.
7. On behalf of the respondents it has been pointed out that, by virtue of Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, rent is declared to be "a first charge" on the tenure; this "charge," it was argued, was such a "charge" as is defined by Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act, and being such a "charge" it was argued that '"all the provisions there in before contained" (i.e., in the Transfer of Property Act) "as to a mortgagor," so far as might be "applied to the plaintiff, appellant, as the owner of the tenure," i.e., "as the owner of the property;" and that the provisions of as. 81 and 82 of the Transfer of Property Act, and all the provisions there in before contained (i.e., previous to Section 100) "as to a mortgagee instituting a suit for the sale of the mortgaged property, so far as might be, applied to the plaintiff, he being a person having such charge;" and it was further contended that amongst the provisions there in before contained applicable to the plaintiff were the disabilities contained in Section 68 of the Transfer of Property Act.
8. One answer to this argument is this: The provisions of section 68 are not amongst those which are referred to in Section 100.
9. Section 100 speaks of the "provisions contained as to a mortgagor" and "as to a mortgagee instituting a suit for the sale of the mortgaged property." The provisions dealing with the rights and liabilities of a mortgagor are contained in Sections 60 to 66 inclusive.
10. Sections 67 to 77 inclusive deal with the rights and liabilities of a mortgagee; and of those sections the only one which Section 100 makes applicable to "a person having a charge not amounting to a mortgage" are those relating to "a mortgagee instituting a suit for the sale of the mortgaged property;" and Section 68 is not one of those sections.
11. And, further, supposing that Section 68 has any application to the matter, it only deals with oases where a mortgagee, may bring a suit for the mortgage money; it can have no reference to cases where after a, suit has been brought and a decree obtained, the mortgagee seeks to sell any property in satisfaction of his decree. The disability, if there was any, ceased with the decree.
12. This, we think, is a sufficient and complete answer to Dr. Banerjee's argument. But we are not prepared to admit that the "charge" referred to in Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, is such a "charge" as is defined by Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act. Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, is an enactment for the benefit of the landlord. It gives him rights which are denied to other creditors. The effect of acceding to Dr. Banerjee's argument would be to deprive the landlord, at any rate for a time, of one of the rights and remedies which an ordinary judgment-creditor enjoys.
13. Seeing that Section 65 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, is an enactment for the benefit of the landlord, and considering that the provisions of Reng. Act VIII of 1869 as contained in Sections 59 to 61, and Section 65 as to the order in which properties belonging to a defaulting tenant might be brought to sale, find no place in the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885, we cannot believe that it was the intention of the Legislature to tie the hands of a landlord, as they were tied under the old act. We are fortified in the view we take by a decision (Petheram, C.J., and Ghose, J.) where they held that the view taken by the District Judge, in the present case, was not correct.
14. Upon principle, therefore, and, so far as the cases go, upon authority, we are of opinion that the contention of Dr. Banerjee ought not to prevail.
15. We accordingly set aside the order of the lower Appellate Court and restore those of the first Court with costs of all Courts.
Alert