Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Narain Chunder Chowdhry v. Taylor

Calcutta High Court
Jun 12, 1878
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

Regular Appeal from a decree passed by the Deputy Magistrate and Collector of Rajmehal, dismissing the plaintiff's suit.

The suit was for possession of certain lands called Taruf ??? alias Manick Chuck, which were alleged to form portion ??? a zemindary which was purchased by the plaintiff at an ??? sale for arrears of revenue, on the 21st of May 1874. The ??? alleged that the zemindary was one which had been ??? settled in 1793, at a jumma of Rs. 1,477-2, which ??? plaintiff still continued to pay; that the Ganges then ??? the south-western boundary of this zemindary, the lands ??? dispute forming a portion of the north-eastern bank of the ??? that in 1848 the lands in dispute were measured as part ??? plaintiff's zemindary, though they were then under water in ??? of the river having gradually shifted its channel to ??? north-east; that in consequence of the continued shifting of ??? channel to the north-east, the lands in dispute re-formed on the south-western in the year 1863, and the following years; ??? that the defend then took possession of them.

It appealed that the former proprietor of the zemindary, Sheoba Nath Misser, instituted a suit against the present defendants in the Court of the Deputy Collector of Bhangulpore for possession of these lands as forming part of the zemindary, but on the 28th of February ??? that claim was dismissed. The plaintiff in the present suit held that decision was not binding on him, he being an action-purchaser under Act XI of 1859, but the lower Court held that it was. The Court held also that the suit was barred under the 12 years rule of limitation. The fifth issue framed by the lower Court was: “The lands in dispute having been ??? with defendant under section 6, Act IX of 1847, which settlement is declared to be a final proceeding, is not the plaintiff ??? from bringing this suit which is ??? a suit to set aside such ??? The learned Judge says in his judgment: “With reference to the fifth issue this suit cannot be brought. Section 5, Act IX of 1847, states that when an ??? the ??? be remitted ???. It is not optical to the ??? to continue to pay and to hold a ??? on the dismissed land in case of its re-forming, as the ??? appears to think. The case of ??? v. ???, 18 W.R, 64, lays this down ??? clearly, through the Act itself is so clear that a ruling is not ???.” The plaintiff appealed.

Baboo ??? chunder Sen for Appellant.

Baboo ??? for the Respondent.

The judgment of the High Court (1) is as follows:—

This suit was ??? for ??? of Hosainpur alias ??? No. 518, and ??? from the ??? of suit laid as ??? the property.

Upon the written statement of the defendants it appears that a permanent settlement and assessment of rent in respect of the land in dispute had been made under the orders of the Board of Revenue, and it was insisted that such settlement was final, and not open to question in a civil suit. The ground of limitation was also set up.

The Extra Assistant Commissioner, without going into the merits threw out the plaintiff's suit, first, on the ground that the plaintiff was barred, inasmuch as twelve years had elapsed from the time of the accretion of the land, and the taking possession by the defendants; secondly, because three years limitation applied from the date of the survey Deputy Collector's award; and, lastly, because by Act IX of 1847, the Court was debarred from entertaining the suit.

As to the first two grounds, it is clear that the plaintiff would not be barred because he is an auction-purchaser of the estate, and, as such, is entitled to recover it free of all encumbrances; and his cause of action, by whatever period of limitation restricted, would arise from the time of his purchase, and the period of limitation is to be computed from that time; and it seems that the present suit is brought within three years from the date of the plaintiff's purchase.

As regards the objection under Act IX of 1847, the Judge as ??? quite misconceived, it seems to us, the case in 18 W.R, 64—??? Ramjiwan Singh v. Collector of Shahabad, to which ??? has been made, and there is an express authority in 23 W.R, 38—case of The Collector of Moorshedabad v. Roy ??? Singh Bahadoor, for holding that while, no doubt, the action taken by the Revenue authorities as to a settlement is final and cannot be questioned, that by no means debars a proprietor from ??? before a Civil Court his right to hold the property under ??? settlement that may be made. The judgment of the Court ??? therefore, must be set aside as erroneous, and the case ??? go back in order to a trial on the merits.