Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kinmond v. Jackson And Anr.

Calcutta High Court
Aug 27, 1877
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This suit was instituted by the plaintiff seeking an injunction to restrain the defendants from infringing an invention related to the rolling of tea leaf, the specification of which was filed under Act XV of 1859 on 6th November 1865. The plaintiff also sought an account of profits made by the defendants and damages. Prior to this suit, the court had decided in favor of the plaintiff in related rules concerning infringement by the defendant W. Jackson, whose invention was found to be substantially an imitation of the plaintiff's. The parties consented to use the affidavits and materials from those prior proceedings as evidence in this suit. The plaintiff, having elected to seek an account of profits rather than damages, raised the question of the applicable limitation period for the account of profits claim.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to an account of profits for the infringement of the invention.
  2. What is the applicable limitation period for the plaintiff’s claim for an account of profits: one year under Article 11 of the Limitation Act, or six years under Article 118?

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant contended that Article 11 in the second schedule to the Limitation Act applies, which prescribes a one-year limitation period for suits for damages for infringing a copyright or any other exclusive privilege.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff argued that having waived damages and seeking an account of profits instead, the suit is equitable in nature and falls under Article 118 of schedule ii, which applies where no limitation period is otherwise provided.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Indian Copyright Act XX of 1847, Section 16 Provided a twelve-month limitation period for civil actions for infringement of copyright. Its limitation provision was repealed by the Indian Limitation Act IX of 1871, necessitating reliance on the new Limitation Act's provisions.
Indian Limitation Act IX of 1871, Article 11, Schedule II Prescribes a one-year limitation period for suits for damages for infringing copyright or any other exclusive privilege. The court held this article applies generally to all civil suits for infringement, including suits for an account of profits, not just damages.
Patent Act XV of 1859, Section 22 Authorizes an inventor to maintain an action against infringement of an exclusive privilege granted by the Act. The court interpreted "action" broadly to include suits for damages as well as suits for an account of profits.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by acknowledging the plaintiff’s established right to an injunction based on prior findings of infringement. The key legal question was the limitation period applicable to the plaintiff’s claim for an account of profits. The defendant relied on Article 11 of the Limitation Act, which limits suits for damages relating to infringement to one year. The plaintiff argued for a broader equitable limitation under Article 118, given the claim was for an account rather than damages.

The court examined the repealed provisions of the Indian Copyright Act XX of 1847, which had a twelve-month limitation for civil actions, and noted that the Indian Limitation Act IX of 1871 repealed those provisions for civil suits and replaced them with Article 11. The court interpreted the term "action" in the Patent Act XV of 1859, Section 22, as encompassing all civil suits for infringement, including those seeking an account of profits.

It was reasoned that the limitation period should not differ merely because the plaintiff elected an account of profits instead of damages, as both remedies serve to compensate for infringement. Consequently, the court concluded that Article 11’s one-year limitation period applies equally to suits for an account of profits.

Therefore, the plaintiff was entitled only to an account of profits for one year prior to the filing of the suit.

Holding and Implications

The court held that the plaintiff is entitled to an injunction and an account of profits for one year from the date of filing the plaint. The plaintiff’s election to claim an account of profits does not extend the limitation period beyond one year as prescribed by Article 11 of the Limitation Act. The plaintiff was also awarded costs on scale 2.

The direct effect of this decision limits the plaintiff’s recovery to profits made within one year before the suit, and no new precedent regarding limitation periods beyond this case was established.

Show all summary ...

1. This was a suit for an injunction to restrain the defendants from infringing an invention of the plaintiff for the rolling of tea, leaf, the specification of which was filed, under the provisions of Act XV of 1859, on the 6th November, 1865; and the plaintiff also prayed for an account of the profits made by the defendants, and for damages.

2. The question of infringement has virtually been decided by our judgment in the several rules obtained by the plaintiff on the one hand, and the defendant, W. Jackson, on the other, which was given on the 19th of August last. In the first of those rules we decided, that Jackson's invention, the specification of which was filed on the 25th of April, 1873, was substantially an imitation of Kinmond's; and it is admitted, that between that date and the commencement of this suit, the defendants have been making, using, and selling a number of machines in accordance with that specification. The parties have very properly consented, that all the affidavits and materials which were used before the Court on the argument of the rules, should be taken as evidence in this suit. The infringement, therefore, being established, it is clear that the plaintiff is entitled to the injunction for which he prays.

3. As regards the rest of his claim the defendant objected at the trial, that the plaintiff was not entitled both to damages and to an account; and that he must elect between the two remedies. This is quite true, and the plaintiff has, accordingly, elected to have an account of the profits; but then comes the only real question in the case, for how many years before suit the account is to be taken.

4. The defendant, contends that Article 11 in the second schedule to the Limitation Act is the one applicable to this suit. That article enacts, that in a suit for damages for infringing a copyright or any other exclusive privilege, the period of limitation shall he one year from the date of the infringement.

5. On the other hand, the plaintiff contends, that as he has waived his claim for damages, and asks to have an account instead, the suit is one which would have been brought in a Court of Equity in England for an injunction and an account; and, therefore, that Article 118 of schedule ii applies to this case, as being a suit for which no period of limitation is provided elsewhere in the schedule.

6. I was of opinion at first, that the plaintiff's contention was right; but upon consideration, and more particularly having regard to the repealed section of the Indian Copyright Act XX of 1847, and to the Patent Act of 1859, I have come to a different conclusion.

7. By the Kith section of the indian copyright act it was provided, that "all actions, suits, bills, indictments, informations, and other criminal proceedings for any offence committed against the Act, shall be brought, sued, and commenced within twelve calendar months next after such offence committed." The Indian Limitation Act IX of 1871, Section 2, repeals Section 16 of Act XX of 1847 to the extent of the words "actions, suits, and bills." It thus repeals the limitation prescribed by that section in the case of civil proceedings, actions, suits, and hills for infringement of copyright; and then by Article 11, Schedule ii, enacts, that, in suits for damages for infringing copyright or any other exclusive privilege, the period of limitation is to he one year, beginning to run on the date of the infringement. There can be little doubt, that the intention of the framer of Article 11 was to supply the provision repealed in Article 16 of Act XX of 1847, relating to civil suits; and I think we ought to read the words of Act IX as not confined to what is technically known at common law as an action for damages but as meaning generally every civil suit seeking a remedy for infringement, &c.

8. We have then also to look at Section 22 of the Patent Act XV of 1859, which enacts that an action may be maintained by an inventor against any person who, during the continuance of any exclusive privilege granted by this Act, shall, without the license of the said inventor, make, use, soil or put in practice the said invention, &c, provided that no such action shall be maintained in any Court other than the principal Court of original jurisdiction in civil cases, &c.

" This is the section under which an inventor has his remedy by civil suit for any infringement of his exclusive privilege. The term used an action"
is quite general, and includes every form of suit, whether an action for damages (in the technical sense), or a suit for an account of profits.

9. In my opinion Article 11 of schedule ii embraces any suit or action brought under section 22 of act xv of 1859, and there was no intention of drawing any distinction between a suit framed as an action for damages, and one framed as a suit for an account. The taking of an account of profits is only a mode of compensating an inventor for the infringement of his privilege other than by an assessment of damages, and it seems unreasonable, that if the period of limitation is one year in the one case, it should be six years in the other. We think, therefore, that the plaintiff is entitled to an account of the profits for one year only from the date of the filing of the plaint; and he will have his costs of suit on scale 2.