Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

V.S. Natesa Chettiar v. V.E.R.M. Annamalai Chettiar

Madras High Court
Nov 21, 1922
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

We do not agree with the opinion of the learned District Judge that the omission to take objection to the assignment of the decree being recognised and to its transmission to the Tiruvalur Court for execution precluded the judgment-debtor from raising the question in the executing Court that the decree was not then executable in the manner proposed by the decree-holder. The Small Cause Court at Madras did not adjudicate on the executability of the decree when it ordered it to be transmitted for execution.

The other distinction attempted to be made is between creditors who are on the schedule and those who are not.

At the time of an insolvent's discharge Sect.45 (2) of Act III of 1907 gives a release to the insolvent from all debts entered in the schedule. But after adjudication and before discharge Sect. 16 treats all creditors alike as to their remedy against the person and property of an insolvent during the pendency of the insolvency proceedings. This section in Cl. 2 (b) absolutely prohibits execution proceedings being taken against the person and property of adjudicated insolvents except with the leave of the Court and that was the law in force at the time when the appellant was adjudicated insolvent and under Sect. 6 of the General Clauses Act the introduction of Act V of 1920 which repealed Act III of 1907 could not take away his right.

This District Judge's order is set aside and the order of the District Munsif dismissing the execution application is restored with costs here and in the District Court.

C.KAppeal allowed..