- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Madho Lal And Another (Decree-Holders) v. Katwari (Judgment-Debtor).
Mahmood, J.:— The facts of this case are very simple. The appellants decree-holders are zamíndárs of the village in which to land to which this litigation relates is situate and that land we hypothecated by Musarnmat Katwari, judgment-debtor respondent, to the appellants on the 24th February, 1876. The money due upon that mortgage not having been paid, a suit was brought thereunder resulting in the claim being decreed on the 24th February, 1882. The decree specifically directs that the land now in question should be sold in enforcement of the lien.
By an application made on the 9th February, 1884, the decree of the 24th February, 1882, was sought to be put into execution by the decree-holders appellants, but such execution was resisted by the judgment-debtor, Musammat Katwari, upon the ground that the land which she held was an occupancy tenure which could not be transferred under s. 9 of the Rent Act and this plea having been accepted by the lower Courts, the application for execution has been disallowed.
From the order so disallowing the application this second appeal has been preferred and I am of opinion that it should prevail. There is no question that the land held by the respondent, Musammat Katwari, is an occupancy tenure, such as that contemplated by s. 9 and within the prohibition of that section against transfer. The nature of such tenures with special reference to the question of transferability was fully discussed by me in Gopal Pandey v. Parsotam Das (1), though, I being in the minority, the majority of the Full Bench held that the hypothecation by an occupancy tenant of his right of occupancy was not a transfer within the meaning of s; 9 of the Rent Act of 1873, which Act would govern the hypothecation of the 24th February, 1876, whereon the decree was obtained by the appellants on the 24th February, 1882. From the opinion expressed by the majority of the Full Bench in that case I still dissent with profound respect, the more so because I find it difficult to reconcile the ratio decidendi of that ruling with a more recent Full Bench ruling, Ganga Din v. Dhurandhar Singh (2) in which they held that an usufructuary mortgage was a transfer and the prohibition of s. 9 of the Rent Act applied to such a case.
But it is not open to me to consider in this case the question as to the validity of the hypothecation of the 24th February 1876, or the correctness of the decree of the 24th February, 1882, because that decree having been passed, the proceedings which have given rise to this appeal were taken only in execution of the decree, and, as such, this Court, as much as the Courts below is bound to give effect to that decree. Mr. Kashi Prasad, however, contends on behalf of the respondent that the specific provisions of s. 9 of the Rent Act having prohibited transfer of such occupancy holdings, the lower Courts were right in not giving effect to the terms of the decree and in declining to sell the property by auction in execution of that decree. For this contention the learned pleader relies on Naik Ram Singh v. Murli Dhar (3), where it was held by the Full Bench that the land-holder who had attached an occupancy right of an occupancy tenant in certain land in execution of a decree before Act XII of 1881 came into force, was not entitled under s. 2 of that Act to bring such right to sale after that Act came into force, that section not saving the right of the land-holder to bring such right to sale in execution of the decree and s. 9 of that Act expressly prohibiting the sale of such a right in execution of a decree.
If the Full Bench ruling relied upon were on all fours with this case, I should of course have felt it my duty to have followed it, sitting as a single Judge, but the case is distinguishable from the one before me. In the case before the Full Bench the decree was a simple money decree, so far at least as the property which had been attached in execution thereof and to which that litigation related was concerned. In the present case the decree of the 24th February, 1882, is not a simple money decree. It is a decree which decrees a claim for money and orders sale by specific enforcement of lien against the land which forms the subject-matter of this dispute. It may be that the decree was erroneously passed, but the Court executing that decree has no power to go behind it and to decline to execute it, because such a refusal to execute the decree amounts to nullifying the decree altogether. This view was expressed by me in the case of Bisheshar Rai v. Sukhdeo Rai where the case was very similar to this and Oldfield, J., concurred with me in holding that when a decree is passed and specifically directs the sale of a tenure which may or may not be transferable, the Court executing the decree is bound to give effect to it and not to question the validity of the decree. I still adhere to the views which I expressed in that case and following them am constrained to decree this appeal and setting aside the orders of both the lower Courts, to remand the case to the Court of first instance for executing the decree of the 24th February, 1882, with reference to the observations which I have made. Costs will abide the result. I wish only to add that I must not be understood to say anything as to whether the auction-sale which would take place in execution of the decree would or would not convey any valid title to the purchaser.
Cause remanded.
Alert