Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Skinner v. Orde

Allahabad High Court
May 29, 1876
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

[231] The cause of action in this suit accrued to the plaintiff in August, 1861, when his father died; and the period during which the suit might legally be brought is 12 years. If the suit can be held to have been instituted on the 21st February, 1873, the date on which the application for permission to sue in forma pauperis was first presented to the Subordinate Judge of Meerut, it is clearly within time; and there can be no doubt that, had the application of the 21st February, 1873, been granted, the suit would rightly be deemed to have been instituted on that date. But that application never was granted, and was indeed virtually withdrawn on the 27th November, 1871, by the plaintiff's offer to pay the amount of the fee chargeable on the plaint under the Court Fees Act before the inquiry into his pauperism had been concluded: and his application was not numbered and registered and assumed to be the plaint in the suit under the provisions of S. 308, Act VIII of 1859, in consequence of proof of his pauperism, but in consequence of the payment by him of the proper fees. But there is no provision in the law which allows the application presented under S. 299 of the Code to be deemed the plaint in the suit when such application has been in effect revoked and superseded by the payment of the fees chargeable under the Court Fees Act. In such a case we conceive that the date of the presentation of the plaint and institution of the suit must be taken to be the date of the payment of the fees; and we are therefore unable to rule that the lower Court has erred in declaring the present suit to have been instituted after the lapse of the period allowed by the law. We have no alternative but to dismiss the appeal with costs.