- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sirazun Nessa v. State Of Assam And Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
The writ appeal concerns whether the second wife of a Mohammedan employee is entitled to a share in the family pension of her late husband. The appellant married the deceased during the subsistence of his first marriage. The deceased had children from both wives. After separation and a maintenance case resolved by compromise, the deceased applied to include the appellant as a nominee for 50% pensionary benefits. The deceased retired in 2003 and died in 2006. Both wives claimed family pension benefits, but the department was inclined to sanction pension only to the first wife. The writ petition filed by the second wife was dismissed by the Single Judge, leading to this appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the second wife of a Mohammedan employee is legally entitled to any share in the family pension of her deceased husband under the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969.
- Whether the Conduct Rules prohibiting second marriage without government permission render such a marriage void for pension claims.
- The applicability and interpretation of personal law (Mohammadan Law) in determining entitlement to family pension.
- The extent to which pension rules recognize claims by more than one widow.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant contended that as a Mohammedan, the deceased was permitted under personal law to marry a second wife during the subsistence of the first marriage, entitling her to a proportionate share of the family pension.
- Relied on Supreme Court judgments including Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar and a Gauhati High Court decision in Amina Khatun v. Jahura Khatun to support entitlement.
Respondents' Arguments
- The Agriculture Department noted pension papers processed before the deceased's application to include the appellant as nominee and that the first wife was the recognized nominee in service records.
- The Accountant General's office contended difficulty in ascertaining the legality of the appellant’s marriage and relied on service records and Pension Rules.
- The Single Judge relied on Conduct Rules, which prohibit second marriage without government permission, to hold such marriage void for pension claims.
- The Single Judge differentiated between personal laws, rejecting the second wife’s claim under Conduct Rules and rejecting a Hindu second wife’s claim under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar, (1971) 2 SCC 330; AIR 1971 SC 1409 | Pension as property; withholding pension without valid reason violates Article 19(1)(f) of the Constitution | Supported the view that pension rights are property rights governed by personal law; favored entitlement of second wife under Mohammedan law. |
| Amina Khatun v. Jahura Khatun, 2004 (Supp.) GLT 67 | Entitlement of second wife to proportionate family pension under Pension Rules and personal law | The court preferred this judgment, holding that multiple widows under Mohammedan law can claim pension proportionately. |
| Suraiya Sultana v. State of Assam, 2006 (Supp.) GLT 5331 | Application of Conduct Rules prohibiting second marriage without government permission | Single Judge relied on this case to deny pension to second wife, but this court distinguished and set aside that reasoning. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the relevant Assam Services (Pension) Rules, particularly Rule 9 and Rule 143, which define pension and family members entitled to family pension. Rule 143 includes only one widow at a time, but notes recognize the possibility of multiple widows, with pension payable to the eldest surviving widow. The court noted that personal law governs marriage validity and consequent pension rights. The Conduct Rules require government permission for second marriages but do not void such marriages if valid under personal law; violation of Conduct Rules may lead to disciplinary action but cannot deny pension rights. The court found the Single Judge’s reliance solely on Conduct Rules to deny pension to the second wife unsustainable. The court preferred the reasoning in Amina Khatun over Suraiya Sultana, emphasizing that pension is a property right and the personal law of the deceased governs entitlement. The court directed the Accountant General to determine the proportionate pension share in accordance with Mohammedan law, allowing the parties to obtain civil court decrees if disputes arise.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is allowed and the impugned judgment is set aside.
The appellant second wife is entitled to a proportionate share of the family pension under Mohammedan law. The Accountant General is directed to determine the pension distribution, considering claims of both widows and the applicable personal law. If disputes over the ratio of shares arise, the parties may seek resolution through civil court decrees. This decision directly affects the pension rights of the parties involved and clarifies that Conduct Rules cannot override valid personal law marriages for pension entitlement. No new precedent beyond the case’s facts is established.
B.D Agarwal, J.:— A short but an important question of law involved in this writ appeal, is as to whether the second wife of a Mohammedan employee is entitled to any share in the family pension of her late husband. Having answered the issue in the negative by the learned Single Judge, the writ petitioner has challenged the judgment and order dated 23.3.2010, passed in WP(C) No. 2450 of 2007.
2. We have heard the argument of Shri A.M Mazumdar, learned senior counsel for the appellant/writ petitioner. The State of Assam (respondent Nos. 1, 5 and 6) were represented by Sri B. Gogoi, advocate; Agriculture Department (respondent Nos. 2 and 4) were represented by Sri C. Baruah, learned standing counsel. Respondent No. 7, i.e, the Branch Manager of the United Bank of India as well as the first wife of the deceased, Smt. Anwara Begum (respondent No. 8) did not turn up, despite being notified.
3. The facts in a narrow compass are that the appellant had married late Asoddar Ali Tapadar in the year 1971, during the subsistence of his marriage with the respondent No. 8. As per pleadings in the writ petition, the deceased had eight children through the first wife and three children through the 2nd wife. Due to some matrimonial discord, the appellant had started living separately from her husband since 1985 and had also filed a case, being M.R No. 20/1985, seeking maintenance allowance from her husband. The said case culminated in compromise and her husband agreed to pay a sum of Rs. 1,500 per month towards her own maintenance as well as their children. It was also pleaded in the writ petition that after retirement from service, the deceased submitted an application before the concerned department on 22.9.2005, requesting inclusion of the name of the appellant as a nominee to receive 50% pensionary benefits after his death. It may also be mentioned here that the appellant/respondent retired from service on 31.12.2003 and died on 1.10.2006 Thereafter, both the appellant and the respondent No. 8 had staked their claim for retrial benefits, and having learnt that the concerned department is likely to sanction the payment of pension in favour of the first wife (respondent No. 8), she filed the writ petition, which came to be dismissed by the impugned judgment.
4. Agriculture Department submitted its affidavit-in-opposition in the writ petition, pleading that the pension papers were processed in the year 2003 and till then the name of the respondent No. 8 was not reflected in the service record and being the wife and nominee of the employee. However, the fact of submission of an application by the deceased employee on 22.9.2005 to that effect has not been disputed by the aforesaid respondent.
5. During the course of hearing of the appeal, learned standing counsel for Agriculture Department has reiterated the aforesaid facts. At the same time, the writ petitioner had also annexed a copy of the application of the deceased employee, submitted to the Director of Agriculture (respondent No. 2) on 22.9.2005, and the authenticity of this document has also not been disputed in the affidavit submitted by the respondent No. 2.
6. Sri Baruah, learned standing counsel to the Accountant General also submitted that his office has taken initiative to finalise the pension in the name of respondent No. 8, as the name of the writ petitioner did not find place in the service dossier. The learned standing counsel has also contended that it is difficult to ascertain on the part of the Accountant General as to whether the appellant/petitioner is a legally married wife of the deceased employee. In our considered opinion, since the respondent No. 8 herself did not challenge the marriage the appellant with the deceased, the office of the Accountant General cannot suo motu go into this aspect. His office, at best, can examine the claim of the pension, on the basis of the service record as well as the relevant Pension Rules. At the same time, the deceased was an employee of Assam Government in the Agriculture Department. He retired as Village Level Extension Worker (VLEW) from the office of District Agriculture Officer, Cachar, Silchar. Hence, the claim of person has to be examined by the concerned Department as per provisions of “The Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969”.
7. Rule 9 defines ‘Pension’ whereas, rule 143 specifies, inter alia, the names of legal heirs of the deceased employee in order of preference who are entitled to Family Pension. For ready reference, it would be just and proper to reproduce rule 9 and the relevant paragraphs of rule 143 which are as follows:
“9. Pension.— Except when the term “Pension” is used in contradistinction to Gratuity, “Pension” includes Gratuity and Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity.”
“143. (i) Family for the purpose of rules in this section will include the following relatives of the officer—
(a) wife, in the case of a male officer;
(b) husband, in the case of a female officer;
(c) minor sons; and
(d) unmarried minor daughters.
Note.— 1(c) and (d) will include children adopted legally before retirement.
Note. 2 — Marriage after retirement will not be recognized for purposes of rules in this section.
(ii) The pension will be admissible—
(a) in the case of widow/widower up to the date of her/his death or remarriage whichever is earlier,
(b) in the case of a minor son, until he attains the age of 18 years,
(c) in the case of an unmarried daughter, until she attains the age of 21 years or marriage whichever is earlier.
Note. — In cases where there are two or more widows, pension will be payable to the next surviving widow, if any. The term ‘eldest would mean seniority with reference to the date of marriage.” (emphasis supplied)
(iii) Pension awarded under the rules in this section will not be payable to more than one member of an officer's family at the same time. It will first be admissible to the widow/widower and thereafter to the minor children.
(iv) ***
(v) ***
8. Sri Mazumdar, learned senior counsel for the appellant has submitted that since the deceased was a Mohammedan by faith, he was permitted under his Personal Law (Mohammadan Law) to marry the appellant even during the subsistence of his marriage with the first wife and as such, the appellant/writ petitioner is legally entitled to inherit the proportionate Family Pension. To buttress his submission, learned senior counsel has relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court rendered in the case of Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar, (1971) 2 SCC 330 : AIR 1971 SC 1409, which was followed by the 2nd round of litigation between the same parties as reported in 1984 Supp SCC 410 : AIR 1984 SC 1560. The learned counsel has also relied upon the judgment of the Gauhati High Court given in the case of Amina Khatun v. Jahura Khatun, 2004 (Supp.) GLT 67.
9. After going through the impugned judgment, we have noticed that the learned Single Judge has though referred the judgment of Amina Khatun (supra) but has differed with the ratio laid down therein. At the same time, his Lordship has reiterated the view taken by him in the case of Suraiya Sultana v. State of Assam, 2006 (Supp.) GLT 5331. Strangely, in both the cases, i.e, Amina Khatun (supra) and Suraiya Sultana (supra) the attention of their lordships, with regard to the judgment of the Supreme Court, was not drawn. The learned Single Judge had no occasion to consider the Apex Court judgment on the point.
10. In the case of Suraiya Sultana the learned Single Judge had the occasion to decide two writ petitions; filed by the two wives, claiming their respective share in the Family Pension. The first writ petitioner was a Mahamadden by faith, whereas the 2nd writ petitioner was a Hindu by faith. While dealing with the case of the Mahammedan wife, the learned Single Judge dismissed her prayer with the aid of rule 26 of the Assam Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1965 (‘Conduct Rules’) which prohibits Government servants from contracting 2nd marriage without first obtaining permission from the Government, notwithstanding such a subsequent marriage is permissible under the personal law. According to his lordship, in view of the aforesaid service condition, the 2nd marriage of a Government employee without permission from the Government is void and only the widow and children of a valid marriage are entitled to the Family Pension.
11. While rejecting the claim of the 2nd wife of a Mohammedan employee, the learned Single Judge did not address the legality of such marriage under the personal law. In other words, the claim of first writ petitioner was rejected on the ground of violation of the Conduct Rules alone. However, the prayer of the 2nd wife (widow of a Hindu employee) in the second writ petition was rejected holding that such marriage is hit by section 5 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. To put it differently, his lordship held that Hindu law does not permit 2nd marriage during the subsistence of first marriage and if the husband and spouse are living at the time of 2nd marriage. In this way, the learned Single Judge examined the case of the Hindu wife, taking into consideration her personal law. In other words, the learned Single Judge did not rule out the possibility of taking into consideration the personal law of the legal heirs of the deceased while determining the claim for family pension.
12. As noted earlier the instant writ petition was decided on the basis of the ratio laid down by his lordship in the case of Suraiya Sultana (supra) and also reiterated rule 143(iii) vis-a-vis rule 26(i) of the Conduct Pules.
13. Whereas, in the case of Amina Khatun (supra), another learned Single Judge of this court has taken a view that rule 143 does not rule out the possibility of entertaining the claim for family person by more than one spouse of a deceased Government employee, after referring the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Deokinandan Prasad (supra) as well as the relevant provisions of Pension Rules. His lordship upheld the judgment of a civil court about the entitlement of proportionate Family Pension by the second wife of a Mohemadan employee.
14. In the case of Amina Khatun (supra), the learned Single Judge has taken into consideration the Note appended to rule 143 (ii) of Pension Rules, (quoted ibid.)
15. It is true that under rule 143(i) there is no indication of entitlement of family pension by more than one wife. However, in the Note appended to rule 143(ii) definitely points out consideration of the claim for family pension by two or more widows. The aforesaid rule, as a whole, indicates that the eldest surviving widow would be entitled to the family pension. At the same time, the rule has not ruled out taking into consideration the valid marriage of two or more wives by a Mohammedan employee.
16. At this stage, we would like to address the effect of ‘Conduct Rules’, while determining the claim of the family pension. As noted earlier, the learned Single Judge has referred to rule 26 of the ‘Conduct Rules’; which has put certain pre-conditions for contracting a second marriage. Admittedly the ‘Conduct Rules’ do not totally prohibit marriage, provided it is permitted under the personal law and custom of the concerned Government employee. The only rider is to obtain permission from the Government. In our considered opinion, any violation of the Conduct Rules may entail disciplinary proceeding during the service tenure of a Government employee but my such violation does not amount to declaring 2nd marriage between the two Muslim spouses void, provided it is otherwise legal and valid. Hence, the rejection of the claim of a second Mohemadan wife with the aid of ‘Conduct Rules’ is unsustainable in law.
17. In the case of Deokinandan Prasad (supra), their lordships have held that “Pension is a property of a Government servant and withholding of the same for no valid reason offends article 19(1)(f) of the Constitution of India”. In our view also a “property” is an actionable claim and the rights and liabilities over such properties have to be determined in accordance with he personal laws of the parties. In other words, we are of the opinion that the view taken in the case of Amina Khatun (supra) appears to be more rationale than the judgment rendered in the case of Suraiya Sultana (supra).
18. For the foregoing reasons, we are in agreement with the view taken in the case of Amina Khatun (supra) in preference to the decision taken in Suraiya Sultana (supra) as well as the impugned judgment. As a corollary, the impugned judgment is hereby set aside. It is held that the appellant writ petitioner is entitled to the proportionate Family Pension, which would be determined by the office of the Accountant General, Assam, and for this purpose the said authority may ask both the surviving widows of the deceased to clarify the ratio of their claim in accordance with the Mohemadan law. In the event of any dispute about the ratio, the parties may be asked to bring appropriate decree from a competent civil court.
19. In the result, the appeal stands allowed, subject to the observations made in the preceding paragraphs.
Alert