Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Luithukia v. Rishang Keishing Others

Gauhati High Court
Jul 12, 1988
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The case concerns the disappearance of Budha Singh, who left Champhung village on 4th November 1983 and was taken away by army personnel at midnight on 6th November 1983. His family, including his wife (the petitioner) and brother Pishak Singh, made inquiries with the army and police but were given conflicting information. The army claimed Budha Singh voluntarily accompanied them and subsequently left an army column to contact a village Gaonburah, after which he was not seen again. The petitioner filed a writ petition in December 1983 due to the unexplained disappearance. Despite the passage of about five years, no reliable information about Budha Singh's whereabouts was obtained. The case involves allegations of illegal detention and possible death while in army custody, and the petitioner seeks relief through the writ of habeas corpus or appropriate compensation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Budha Singh was illegally detained or had died while in the custody of the army following his disappearance in November 1983.
  2. Whether the writ of habeas corpus can be maintained given the prolonged disappearance and lack of production of the detained person.
  3. The nature and extent of relief or compensation that can be granted to the petitioner in the absence of the detained person.
  4. The respective roles and responsibilities of the armed forces and civil authorities under the Armed Forces Special Powers Act, 1958, in cases of detention and custody.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Budha Singh was forcibly taken away by the army on 6th November 1983 and has not been seen since.
  • The version of the army regarding voluntary accompaniment and leading an army column is disbelieved, especially given contradictions and omissions in official communications.
  • The army failed to produce Budha Singh despite repeated inquiries and representations, indicating illegal detention or death.

Respondents' (Army and State) Arguments

  • Budha Singh voluntarily accompanied the army on 6th November and cooperated in leading a security column on 7th and 8th November 1983.
  • Budha Singh left the army column to contact a local Gaonburah and did not return or contact the army thereafter.
  • Additional affidavits and reports, including a wireless telegram and a source report, suggest sightings of Budha Singh after his disappearance, though these are not strongly supported.
  • The petition is not maintainable because an FIR was lodged and Major Anand was not made a party.
  • If Budha Singh is presumed dead, compensation or exemplary costs may be appropriate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nungshitombi Devi v. Rishang Keishing (1982) Scope of sections 4 and 5 of the Armed Forces Special Powers Act, 1958; role of armed forces and civil authorities. The Court reaffirmed that armed forces act in aid of civil power and must hand over arrested persons to police promptly; no military rule exists in India.
Sebastian M. Hongray v. Union of India (1984) Issuance of writ of habeas corpus; awarding exemplary costs when detained persons are not produced and presumed dead. The Court followed the principle of awarding Rs. 1,00,000/- as exemplary cost to petitioner’s wife, recognizing the failure to produce the detained person.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court closely examined the conflicting versions of events regarding Budha Singh's disappearance. It found the army's claim that Budha Singh voluntarily accompanied them and led an army column to be unconvincing, particularly since earlier official correspondence from Major Anand omitted these details. The Court also rejected the reliability of subsequent reports and affidavits suggesting sightings of Budha Singh, citing lack of corroboration and probable bias of witnesses.

Given the absence of any credible information about Budha Singh's whereabouts for approximately five years, the Court accepted the submission that he should be presumed dead. However, recognizing that the writ of habeas corpus cannot lie if the person is dead, the Court modified the relief to grant compensation instead.

The Court emphasized the constitutional framework governing the armed forces' role under the Armed Forces Special Powers Act, 1958, reiterating that the armed forces must cooperate with civil authorities and promptly hand over detainees to police. This underscores the illegality of any prolonged detention without accountability.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the petition and ordered payment of Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) to the petitioner, the wife of Budha Singh. The liability for payment was apportioned with 25% to be paid by the State of Manipur and 75% by the Union of India, reflecting shared responsibility due to the army being called to aid the civil administration.

The decision directly provides monetary relief to the petitioner in light of the presumed death of Budha Singh while in army custody. No new legal precedent beyond the application of existing principles from cited cases was established. The judgment also reinforces the constitutional limits on armed forces' powers and the necessity of cooperation with civil authorities in matters of detention.

Show all summary ...

B.L. HANSARIA, J.

(1.) -This is yet another case of counterfeit release. The first case of this nature dealt with by this Court was of Chaoba Singh which was the subject matter of Nungshitombi Devi v. Rishang Keishing1, judgment in which had caused a flutter and which still holds good as Special Leave Petition against the same was dismissed by the Supreme Court on 29.4.83 in SLP No. 3257/83. Next such case was dealt with directly by the Apex Court in Sebastian M. Hongray v. Union of India, in which ultimately exemplary cost of Rs. 1,00,000/- was awarded to each of the two concerned women, vide Sabastian M. Hongray3.

(2.) In the present case the petitioner is the wife of one Kh. Budha Singh. Her case is that on 4.11.83 Budha Singh had left Champhung village for his native village Pungdongbam to attend a function there. At the midnight of 6.11.83 army personnel took Budha Singh away. On 7.11.83 Pishak Singh, brother of Budha Singh, visited the army camp at Nongdam village and enquired about the whereabouts of Budha Singh but no information was divulged to him. Pishak Singh informed the petitioner about this and lodged an ejahar with the 0/C, Lamlai P. 5. He also contacted the President of the Civil Liberties and Human Rights Organisation (CLAHRO), Impbal. The President wrote a D.0. letter to Major S. C. Anand of 61 Infantry Brigade. He also met the Brigadier on 10.11.83 who informed him that Budha Singh was involved in anti-national activities and after collection of some information from him he would be handed over to the police personnel as soon as possible. As by 28th November, the where about of Bhudha Singh could not be known, the President of the CLAHRO wrote another letter to Major Anand. In the meantime Major Anand wrote to the President of CLAHRO stating that Budha Singh had been called for questioning by the army on 6th and 7th November in connection with the report about his anti national activities. On both the days he was asked to report the next day to clarify the doubts but he neither returned nor reported to the army since 8th November, 1. 1982(1) GLR 756. 2. AIR 1984 SC 57.

(3.) AIR. 1984 SC 1026. Major Anand reiterated that Budha Singh had not been arrested by the army at any stage. As whereabouts of Budha Singh could not be known and nothing was heard about him by his family members the present application was filed in December 1983. It is pity that this petition is being disposed of today after about 5 years. Though long 5 years have passed nothing has been heard about Budha Singh. 2A. The case of the Army as transpires from the affidavit-in-opposition filed by Major Karamjit Singh is that Bhudha Singh was contacted at 2100 hrs f 6th November and he voluntarily accompanied the security forces. Again on 7th November Budha Singh voluntarily came and extended cooperation to lead a column of security forces which had started in the evening of 7th November. By the early hours of 8th November Budha Singh led the column to an abandoned hut which was allegedly a meeting place of the extremists near Champhong village. When no extremist was found in the hut, Budha Singh requested that he be allowed to contact the local Gaonburah, who, according to Budha Singh, knew about the exact location of the hideouts of the extremists. He also assured that he would return at 1200 hrs He requested that no security force personnel should accompany him lost he might be identified as supporter/informer of the security forces. The further case of the respondents 2 and 3 is that Budha Singh, after having left the column as aforesaid did not return and since then Budha Singh neither contacted the security forces nor has any of their troops seen him. 3. Shri Nilamani Singh first submits that version of arrest etc. given by Pishak Singh should be accepted by us as it finds support from the FIR, lodging of which has been accepted by the State. We find force in this submission as Pishak Singh, a poor unsophisticated villager from a hill area, would not have got in touch with police as early as 8.11.83 seeking help to find out his brother if Budha Singh would have voluntarily left the house on the night of 6th as is the case of the army. The learned counsel then contends that the army has given two versions relating to Budha Singh. Learned counsel draws our attention to the statements made by Major Anand in his letter to the President of CLAHRO wherein nothing has been stated about any action of Bud ha Singh relating to his leading a army column to Champhong village. As the aforesaid letter was written after the matter was investigated in detail, as stated in the letter it is urged by the learned counsel that if Budha Singh would have led any column to Champhong village and would have left the column allegedly to contact the village Gaonburah, these facts would have definitely found place in the letter of Major Anand which however is absolutely silent about this aspect of the case of the army. Learned counsel finally contends that the story of Budha Singh leading any column to Champhong village and his leaving the column allegedly to contact the village Gaonburah are all matters of afterthought and no reliance should be placed on this case of the army. We are inclined to accept this submission of Shri Nilamani Singh. In the first version of the case given out by Major Anand nothing has been stated about this apart of the case of the army. As Major Anand had written the letter after investigating the matter in detail, this part of the case of the army would not have missed Major Anand. We would, therefore, hold that the story of Budha Singh leading the army column on 8th November to Chembhong village is not believable. We also do not believe that Budha Singh had allegedly left the army column on 8th November to meet the village Gaonburah. If he would have done so it would not have been difficult on the part of the army to file any affidavit of the village Gaonburah which has not been done.

(4.) To lend assurance to the case of the army, respondents 2 and 3 filed additional affidavit on 12th December, 1984 enclosing as Annexure-I a W.T. message dated 9.1.84 from the Superintendent of Police/ClO, Manipur that Budha Singh was seen on a motor cycle with one Biren Singh on 3.1.84 at Lamleng gate while they were proceeding towards Ukhrul. This W.T. message does not inspire any confidence inasmuch as in the affidavit filed on behalf of the State of Manipur on 5.3.84 nothing has been stated about this W.T. message. According to the State, after the Chief Minister had received a representation from the petitioner on 5.12.83 all concerned were requested to find out Budha Singh, and so if the State police would have located Budha Singh, the State machinery must have been acquainted about it, as even the Chief Minister had been approached to find out Budha Singh. The source of information is also value as it speaks that the matter was reliably learnt. Who is the author of information is not known. This apart, there is no supporting material to assure our mind about the truthfulness of the news sent by the W.T. message in question. To lend credence to the W.T. message, Biren Singh whose mention has been made in the communication could have been asked to file an affidavit. But this has not been done. For these reasons we are not inclined to place reliance on the aforesaid communication.

(5.) This is however not all. The additional affidavit has sought to reply on a Source Report dated 4th April, 1984. It has stated that one Havildar Ranjit Singh who was leading a army column had seen three persons moving under suspicious circumstances near the international boundary and when they chased them they proceeded towards the border crossing it. One of the persons of the group was identified as Budha Singh. In support of this Source Report, respondents Nos. 2 and 3 filed an affidavit of Havildar Ranjit Singh dated 12th day of December 1984. We have not felt inclined to place full reliance on this piece of information because we have our doubts regarding proper identification of Budha Singh by the Havildar. We have said so because the statement in the affidavit that Havildar Ranjit Singh know Budha Singh since November, 1983 as the latter used to come to the army camp for giving certain information is of doubtful veracity inasmuch as nobody else has spoken about visit of Budha Singh to the army camp to give information. This apart, from the D.O. letter of Major Anand dated 26.11.83 of which reference has been made earlier it appears that according to the army Budha Singh was involved in anti national activities and it is for this purpose that he was called for questioning by the army on 6th and 7th November 1983. A person who was regarded to have indulged in anti national activities could not have come to the army camp for giving certain information to the army. Further as nobody else had supported the version of Havildar Ranjit Singh, we do not think if we would be justified in rejecting the case of the petitioner solely on the basis of the affidavit of Havildar Ranjit Singh who is definitely an interested person.

(6.) Because of all the above, we entertain no doubt that Budha Singh had been apprehended by the army on the night of 6.11.83 and since then nobody has seen him. The question is whether he is dead or still under the custody of the army. Learned Advocate General contends that as long 5 years have since elapsed we should assume that Budha Singh is dead. We are inclined to accept this submission of learned Advocate General. Question is what relief can be granted to the petitioner if Budha Singh is taken to be dead. Apparently writ of habeas corpus cannot lie but that cannot sound a death-knell to the petition. We have to modify the relief and pass such appropriate order as may be deemed fit and proper by us.

(7.) At this stage it would be useful to refer to two decisions of the Supreme Court in Sabastian M. Hongray v. Union of India (supra). In that case the army had taken into custody two persons-Shri C. Denial and Shri C. Paul. On being satisfied that these persons had been taken into custody by the army, the Supreme Court had directed for issuance of writ of habeas corpus to produce these two persons before the Court. This is the subject matter of first Hongrays case. The second Hongrays case deals with the aspect which is more relevant for the case at hand and the same is that on the failure of the Union of India and its officials to produce the aforesaid two persons, exemplary cost of Rs. 1,00,000/- was awarded to the wives of the two detained persons about whom it was reasonably believed that they had met unnatural death. Learned Advocate General contended that if the Court be of the view that Budha Singh is dead we could award such cost, compensation or damage as deemed reasonable by us. On the facts and circumstances of the case and taking a clue from Hongrays case we are satisfied that awarding of a sum of Rs. 1,00,000/would be the proper relief to be granted to the petitioner who is the wife of Budha Singh and we order accordingly.

(8.) Having come to this conclusion, it is not necessary for us to examine in detail the legal submissions made by the learned Advocate General, but the same deserve to be put on record and answered summarily. The first submission of the learned Advocate General is that as an F.I.R. had been lodged relating to disappearance of Budha Singh the present petition is not maintainable. We do not think if lodging of F.I.R. can be a good ground to reject a writ of habeas corpus if a case for the same is made out. Another submission advanced by the learned Advocate general with some amount of vehemence is that as Major Anand had not been made a party by name the petition is not maintainable. In trying to satisfy us about this defect of the submission, it is contended by the learned Advocate General that when a person comes praying for a writ of habeas corpus the Court calls upon the person who has custody of the detained person to produce him. From the averments made by the petitioner in the application, we do not find any mention of the fact that Major Anand had detained Budha Singh or the former was in custody of the latter. The allegation of illegal detention has been made in a general way against a military personnel under the command of respondents 2 and 3. Respondent 2 is General Officer Commanding, Manipur Sector and respondent No. 3 is Brigade Major, Manipur Sector; and as such we do not find any allegation in the petition relating to detention of Budha Singh by Major Anand requiring dismissal of the petition on the ground that Major Anand was not made a party.

(9.) In usual course was would not have been required to say anything more but then it seems that a misconception persists relating to the role of armed forces when they are called in aid of the civil power under the provisions of the Armed Forces Special Power Act, 1958, for short the Act. This Court had occasion to deal with this aspect of the matter speaking through one of us (Hansaria, J.) in Nungshitombi Devi v. Rishang Keishang (supra). We reiterate what has been stated in the aforesaid case regarding the scope of sections 4 and 5 of the Act. We do not propose to burden this judgment with what has been stated in the aforesaid judgment in this regard except that the same has our approval.

(10.) Another aspect of the matter, however, deserves to be gone into by us. This aspect is related to the role which the district administration has to play after the armed forces have been called in aid of the civil power. A view seems to be gaining ground that after armed forces are deployed in the disturbed area, the civil authorities as if cease to function. But as pointed out in Nungshitombis case though the armed forces have been given wide powers by the Act, these are sought to be confined within the narrow limit and in this limit also they do not really supplant the ordinary machinery for maintaining law and order or for that matter public order, but they supplement the working of ordinary law enforcing machinery. According to us the civil authorities and the armed forces have to work as hand in glove and not in suppression of any side. It is because of this that the Act requires by its section 5 that any person arrested and taken into custody by the armed forces have to made over to the officer-in-charge of the nearest police station with the least possible delay, May we say that in our Constitutional set up there is no provision for a military rule in any part of the territory of India. Of course, the armed forces must be allowed free hand in so far as dealing with insurgents or terrorists are concerned but then while dealing with others they have to strike a balance between crushing of violence and crushing of liberty. Further the armed forces must act in cooperation with the district administration and not as an independent body. Of course, so far as operational part of the activity of the armed forces is concerned, they must be given free hand; but in other matters they must take the civil authorities in confidence and work in harmony.

(11.) In the result the petition is allowed by ordering payment of a sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) to the petitioner. Of this amount 25% shall be paid by the State of Manipur and the remaining 75% by the Union of India. We have saddled the State also with liability because it cannot shed its responsibility in the matter completely as after all the army was called to aid it. This amount would be paid to the petitioner within a period of 6 weeks from today.