- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Gauhati University v. Shri Bhabendra Nath Thakuria And Others Opposite Parties.
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff instituted a suit against Gauhati University and the Secretary, Board of Higher Secondary Education, claiming that the age recorded in his Matriculation certificate and Service Book was incorrect, asserting his correct age as 15 years 10 months based on his date of birth (4th May, 1938). The plaintiff sought a decree declaring the correct age, a direction to correct the age in the Matric Certificate, costs of the suit, and any other entitled relief.
The plaintiff subsequently filed an application to amend the plaint under Order 6, Rule 17 read with Order 1, Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), seeking to add the Government of Assam, the Director of Veterinary and Animal Husbandry, and the Board of Higher Secondary Education as pro forma defendants. The amendment was allowed by the learned Munsiff, leading to the University filing the present revision petition challenging that order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the amendment of the plaint to add the Government of Assam, the Director of Veterinary and Animal Husbandry, and the Board of Higher Secondary Education as pro forma defendants was permissible under Order 6, Rule 17 CPC.
- Whether the parties sought to be added are necessary or proper parties to the suit.
- The effect of non-joinder or misjoinder of parties in the context of necessary and proper parties under Order 1, Rules 9 and 13 CPC.
- Whether the learned Munsiff erred in allowing the amendment without determining the status of the parties to be added.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (University)
- The amendment was allowed in violation of Section 80 of the CPC.
- The suit is bad for non-joinder and misjoinder of necessary parties.
- The defendant contended that necessary parties were not added but did not specify who those parties were or their nature of interest.
Respondent's Arguments (Plaintiff)
- The Government of Assam and the Director of Veterinary and Animal Husbandry have no role in correcting the age but are to be made pro forma defendants.
- The Board of Higher Secondary Education was not originally made a party as it did not issue the Matric Certificate and is not involved in the suit, but is also to be added as a pro forma defendant.
- Relied on a prior decision (Prabin Chandra Phukan v. Gauhati University) to support the amendment.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Udit Narain v. Additional Member, AIR 1963 SC 786 | Definition of necessary and proper parties | The Court referred to this precedent to distinguish between necessary parties (without whom no effective order can be passed) and proper parties (whose absence does not prevent an effective order but whose presence is necessary for a complete decision). |
| Prabin Chandra Phukan v. Gauhati University, SA 21 of 1979 (decided 23.3.82) | Support for amendment of plaint | The Court examined this decision but found it did not assist the plaintiff in justifying the amendment of the plaint in the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the nature of parties sought to be added under the amendment application, emphasizing the distinction between necessary and proper parties as established in Udit Narain v. Additional Member. It noted that Order 1, Rule 9 CPC protects suits from being defeated by misjoinder or non-joinder of parties except in cases of necessary parties, where the absence is fatal.
The Court observed that the defendant (University) raised a plea of non-joinder and misjoinder but failed to specify who the necessary parties were or their interest, and the trial Court did not frame any issue on this point. Consequently, the defendant's objection was deemed waived if the parties are proper parties rather than necessary parties.
Applying Order 6, Rule 17 CPC, the Court held that amendments are permissible only if necessary for determining the real questions in controversy. Since the Government of Assam, the Director, and the Board were stated by the plaintiff to be pro forma defendants with no substantive role in the age correction, the amendment did not meet this criterion.
Thus, the learned Munsiff's order allowing the amendment was held to be illegal or materially irregular because the status of the parties was not determined, and no real question arose between the parties regarding their addition.
However, the Court directed that if the trial Court later finds these parties to be necessary, the plaintiff should be given an opportunity to add them with due regard to Section 80 CPC before dismissing the suit.
Holding and Implications
The Court allowed the revision petition and set aside the order of the learned Munsiff allowing the amendment of the plaint. The amendment application was dismissed.
The Court emphasized that the trial Court should not dismiss the suit outright if it finds the parties sought to be added are necessary but should allow the plaintiff an opportunity to add necessary parties in compliance with Section 80 CPC.
No new precedent was established; the decision directly affects the parties by invalidating the amendment order but leaves open the possibility of adding necessary parties at trial.
1. In this revision petition, the petitioner has challenged the order of the Munsiff (3) Gauhati given on 11.12.87 in TS. No. 45 of 1986 allowing the amendment of the plaint.
2. The plaintiff instituted the suit against the Gauhati University and the Secretary, Board of Higher Secondary Education claiming—
“(1) That the Suit be decreed by declaring that the age recorded in Matriculation certificate and on the basis of it, as recorded in the Service Book of the plaintiff is wrong and the correct age of the plaintiff is 15 years 10 months according to his date of birth i.e 4th May, 1938.
(2) That the defendant be directed to correct the age in the Matric Certificate of the Plaintiff as 15 years 10 months in place of 19 years.
(3) The costs of the suit.
(4) Any other relief which the plaintiff is entitled to.”
3. The plaintiff filed an application for amendment of the plaint under Order 6, Rule 17 r/w Order 1, Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure for making the Government of Assam, the Director of Veterinary and Animal Husbandry and the Board of Higher Secondary Education. In the application for amendment, it is stated that the Government of Assam and the veterinary Department has nothing to do with regard to the correction of the age in the Matric Certificate of the plaintiff, however, the Government of Assam and the Director are to be made as pro forma defendants As regards the Board, it is stated that the Board was not made a party as the Matric Certificate was not issued by the Board, and that the Board is in no way involved in the suit, but the Board also is to be made as a proforma defendant. The learned Munsiff allowed the amendment. Against that order, the University has filed this petition. Mr. A.C Sarma a, the learned counsel for the petitioner, has submitteed that the amendment was allowed in violation of the provisions of section 80, CPC. I am not dealing with the submission of Mr. Sarma as the petition can be disposed of on another ground.
4. It has been settled that a necessary party is one with out whom no order can be made effectively; a proper party is one in whose absence an effective order can be made but whose presence is necessary for a complete and final decision on the question involved in the proceeding (see Udit Narain v. Additional Member, AIR 1963 SC 786).
5. Order 1, Rule 9, CPC provides:
“No suit shall be defeated by reason of the misjoinder or non-joinder of parties, and the Court may in every suit deal with the matter in controversy so far as regards the rights and interest of the parties actually before it:
Provided that nothing in this rule shall, apply to non-joinder of a necessary party.
6. Order 1, Rule 13, CPC reads:
“All objections on the ground of non-joinder or misjoinder of parties shall be taken at the earliest possible opportunity and, in all cases where issues are settled, at or before such settlement, unless the ground of objection has subsequently risen, and any objection not so taken shall be deemed to have been waived.”
7. A of reading Rules 9 and 13 together indicates that, except in the case of necessary party, non-joinder or misjoinder is not fatal to the suit, and that all the objections on the ground of non-joinder or misjoinder not taken at the earliest opportunity shall be deemed to have been waived. But, in the case of a necessary party, these Rules are not applicable in view of the proviso to Rule 9. Therefore, in a suit, if a necessary party is not added, the suit shall be dismissed, not by reason of the non-joinder of parties but because of the fact that no order can be passed effectively or no relief can be granted to the parties on records.
8. In the written statement of the defendant (the University), it is stated that the “suit is bad for non-joinder and misjoinder of necessary parties”. But the defendant has not stated who are necessary parties who have not been added, or, who are required to be added, and the nature of the interest of those alleged necessary parties. The Court framed four (4) issues. But the Court has not framed any issue regarding misjoinder or non-joinder of the parties. If the Government of Assam, the Director and the Board are proper parties, the defendant have, on the facts and circumstances of the case, waived to raise the plea of non-joinder. However if they are necessary parties, it will be different aspect of the case. But the question whether or not they are necessary parties cannot be decided in this application and, therefore, the question is left open.
9. Order 6, Rule 17, CPC runs:
“The Court may at any stage of the proceedings allow either party to alter or amend his pleadings in such manner and on such terms as may be just, and all such amendments shall be made as may be necessary for the purpose of determining the real questions in controversy between the parties.”
10. Under Order 6, Rule 17, one of the conditions for allowing amendment is that the amendment is necessary for the purpose of determining the real question in controversy between the parties. In the present case, the defendant has already-waived to raise the objection as to non-joinder, or misjoinder of parties, if the Government of Assam, the Director and the Board are proper parties. The case of the plaintiff is that they have nothing to do with the correction of the age but they may be made as pro forma defendants, viz for the sake of form. The trial Court has not given any finding that they are necessary parties or proper parties. In such a situation, there is no question to be determined between the parties. Therefore, the learned Munsiff has exercised his jurisdiction illegally or with material irregularity and as such the order allowing, amendment cannot be sustained.
11. The learned counsel for the plaintiff-respondent has referred me to a decision of this Court in SA 21 of 1979, Prabin Chandra Phukan v. Gauhati University decided on 23.3.82 I have perused the judgment. The decision does not help the-plaintiff as regards the amendment of the plaint. For the foregoing reasons, the petition is allowed. The amendment application is dismissed However, considering the facts and circumstances of the case, if the trial Court finds that the Government of Assam, the Director and the-Board are necessary parties, it should not immediately proceed to dismiss the suit without giving the plaintiff an opportunity to add necessary parties having due regard to section 80, CPC.
12. With the said observation and direction, the petition is allowed. No costs.
Alert