- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. L.N Tamuly And Others
P.K Deb, J.:— This appeal under section 30(1)(aa) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, has been directed against the judgment and award dated 19.6.1989 passed by the learned Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Kamrup, Guwahati in W.C No. 2 of 1988.
2. The crux of dispute as canvassed in this appeal is whether the insurance company, the appellant, is liable to pay interest and penalty as contemplated under section 4-A of Workmen's Compensation Act along with the statutory compensation as per section 4 of the same Act. The facts of the case are very simple. The truck No. AMU 2783 belonged to the owner Balen Chandra Kallta met with a disastrous accident while the wooden bridge over the river Khorkhari broke down when the loaded truck was passing over the same and in the said accident Pradip Kumar Talukdar who was serving as handyman in the truck died in the accident which occurred on 7.3.1986 When the owner and the insurance company did not settle the claim of compensation of Binapani Talukdar, she preferred W.C No. 2 of 1988 and the learned Commissioner (the Addl. Deputy Commissioner), Kamrup, Guwahati, after hearing both the parties passed the impugned order granting statutory compensation along with simple interest at the rate of 6 per cent per annum and penalty of 25 per cent on the principal amount which amounted to Rs. 62,494.79. Admittedly the insurance company, appellant in the present case, had deposited the statutory compensation amount by a cheque on 2.6.1989 It has been ordered by the learned Commissioner that the balance amount of the awarded compensation should be paid by the insurance company within seven days.
3. On the basis of the judgment and award dated 19.6.1989 the insurance company deposited whole of the amount awarded but raised objection by way of filing appeal before this court to the effect that legally it was not liable to pay penalty and interest as contemplated under section 4-A of Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 (hereinafter to be referred as ‘the Act’).
4. Mr. S.K Barkotoki appearing on behalf of the insurance company has relied on the decision of this court passed in the Division Bench as referred to in (1992) 2 GLR 260 wherein it has been held that the liability of the insurer shall be to indemnify the default of the employer in payment of the compensation but the insurance company cannot be saddled with liability to pay interest and penalty on the analogy that sub-section 3 of section 4-A of the Act specifically mentions that the penalty and interest can be imposed upon the employer only on default of payment of compensation within one month from the date it fell due and as such interest and penalty can never be an integral part of the compensation which can be imposed upon the insurer who is to indemnify the employer. On the other hand, Mr. B.K Jain, appearing for the claimants-respondents supported the impugned judgment and order on the ground that the insurance company cannot dis-shoulder its liability regarding interest and penalty when they had also not settled the claim within the period and in the absence of insurance policy being filed it cannot be said that their liability is only to the extent of the statutory compensation and not beyond that. He has also referred to the decision of our High Court as reported in (1987) 1 GLR 271 where it has been held that the Commissioner under the Workmen's Compensation Act can directly impose on the insurance company to pay the claim determined under the Act and also on the provisions of section 95(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act when the liability of the insurance company is much above the amount awarded by the Commissioner.
5. To appreciate the submissions of the learned counsel for both the parties following admitted facts gathered from the records of the lower court require to be considered. The accident occurred on 7.3.1986 and in that year itself the insurance surveyor, A.K Purkayastha, verified the documents required for settling the claim. On 13.1.1987 the employer informed the insurance company by way of Workmen's Compensation claim with relevant facts and copy of documents required for settling the claim. When no claim was settled even after the claim preferred by the claimant on 1.11.1987, the claimant filed this Workmen's Compensation case before the Commissioner and the insurance company received the notice of the case on 24.2.1988 On 30.12.1988 insurance company filed written statement. On 23.5.1989 the employer also filed written statement. Then only on 2.6.1989 the insurance company deposited the statutory claim by a cheque.
6. In the impugned order, the learned Commissioner appreciated the gesture of the insurance company in depositing the statutory claim on 2.6.1989 but imposed the penalty and interest on the principal amount of compensation holding that there was delay in settling the claim of the claimant although that has not been specifically or elaborately mentioned in the impugned judgment.
7. It is true that the interest and penalty is not an integral part of the compensation and the same can be imposed only if the employer fails to settle the claim within one month when it is falling due. Insurer is also to indemnify the insured as per the contract and agreement between the insurer and the insured. In that sense insured's failure to settle the claim within the time limit makes him liable for penalty and interest and by the agreement the insurer is to indemnify the insured unless there is any specific bar in the terms and agreement of the insurance policy. In the present case insurance policy has not been filed and there is no scope for this court to scrutinize the same to find out whether there is any specific bar to that effect or not. Any insurer is to indemnify the insured in respect of the claim arising out of the accident of death or bodily injury for all purpose as a whole. Moreover, as per section 95(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act, the award made for compensation is well below the limit prescribed. It is now well settled after the decision of the Apex Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jugal Kishore, 1988 ACJ 270 (SC), that it is the liability of the insurer to gather the higher risk when it fails to show specifically by filing insurance policy that he is not liable to do so.
8. In the present case, just after the incident, insurance company was in the know of the incident and on 13.1.1987 employer specifically preferred the claim of settlement for the workman. But the insurance company kept silent and slept over the same even after receipt of the notice of the Workmen's Compensation case on 24.2.1988 and did not settle the claim. It deposited the statutory amount only on 2.6.1989 and hence on the ratio of the decisions of our High Court in the above two decisions it is found and held that there was delay as contemplated under section 4-A of the Act on the part of the insurance company and hence the appellant is liable to pay the penalty and interest with the award.
9. In the result, the appeal is dismissed but no order as to costs. As per direction given by this court while admitting this appeal on 15.9.1989 shall now be complied with. The balance amount kept in deposit with the bank with interest shall be paid to the claimant.
10. Appeal dismissed.
Alert