Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Fazal Sheikh Others v. Abdur Rahman Mea Others

Gauhati High Court
Jun 8, 1990
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit arises from competing claims over a jote of land originally held by Raibahadur Biraj Mohan Dutta in village Adabari under the Gauripur Raj Estate. In 1928 the jote was sold to Khosa Sheikh and his three sons. Out of approximately 73 bighas, 50 bighas were further sold by the Sheikhs on or about 30-4-1940 (registered deed dated 10-9-1940) to Maulana Abdul Hamid Khan (referred to as "Maulana"). Maulana had possession through an agent, and 25 bighas of the 50 were later settled with the vendors as adhi (sharecropping). Maulana created a Wakf on 16-10-1943 which included the 50 bighas. After the partition (around 1950) Maulana and his family left for Pakistan; management difficulties and disputes followed, including an S.145 Cr.P.C. proceeding (order dated 6-10-1951) declaring Wakf authority possession over the 25 bighas covered by the house. Adhiars (the defendants/appellants) later denied Maulana/Wakf title, prompting proceedings before Adhi Conciliation Boards which dismissed the adhi eviction case as civil in nature. Plaintiffs (respondents) then filed a civil suit for declaration of title and recovery of possession; the trial Court dismissed the suit on multiple findings (including that the sale was benami and that the Wakf was void for uncertainty). The appellate District Judge reversed the trial Court and declared the suit land to be Wakf property, entitled to khas possession. The defendants appealed to the present Court challenging the appellate judgment on several legal grounds.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sale of the suit land to Maulana was a benami transaction or a genuine sale (as contested in the appellate and second appeal).
  2. Whether the certified copy of the Wakf deed was admissible in evidence (challenge under provisions of S.74(2) of the Evidence Act and related technical requirements).
  3. Whether the Wakf deed was void for vagueness/uncertainty of its object (whether "welfare works permitted by the Shariat" is sufficiently certain).
  4. Whether, under S.3(f) of the Wakf Act, a person or committee managing Wakf property is to be treated as a Mutawalli (and whether the appointment of subsequent Mutawallis was valid).
  5. Whether khatians under Section 105 of the Goalpara Tenancy Act indicate title.
  6. Whether Section 111(g) of the Transfer of Property Act (doctrine of forfeiture / consequences of denying landlord's title) applies to the facts, given the adhiars' renunciation of their tenancy and assertion of title.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The sale of the land to Maulana was benami and therefore the title should not be recognized in Maulana/Wakf.
  • The certified copy of the Wakf deed admitted in evidence is secondary evidence; it should not have been admitted without an explanation of why the original was not produced (relying on Nani Bai v. Gita Bai).
  • The object of the Wakf ("welfare works permitted by the Shariat") is vague and the Wakf deed is void for uncertainty.
  • The appellate Court erred in construing S.3(f) of the Wakf Act to treat a person/committee managing Wakf property as a Mutawalli; such treatment is said to be contrary to law.
  • The khatians under Section 105 of the Goalpara Tenancy Act indicate title (the appellate Court erred in holding they did not).
  • The appellate Court incorrectly applied the doctrine of forfeiture under Section 111(g) of the Transfer of Property Act to the facts of the case.

Respondent's Arguments

  • At the hearing the appellant's counsel fairly refrained from pressing the benami objection in view of the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988 and the Supreme Court decision in Mithilesh Kumari v. Prem Behari Khare (AIR 1989 SC 1247) — accepting that the appellate finding that the sale was not benami should be upheld.
  • The certified copy of the Wakf deed was properly admitted because the Wakf deed is a public record kept under the Registration Act (and thus falls within S.74(2) of the Evidence Act); the certified copy was proved in accordance with S.77 and the witness evidence explained why the original was not produced (P.W.7 and P.W.5 evidence).
  • The Wakf deed's object ("welfare works permitted by the Shariat") is lawful and sufficiently certain because it confines permissible uses to those recognised by Shariat.
  • The management provisions and S.3(f) of the Wakf Act allow a person or committee managing Wakf property to be treated as Mutawalli; appointment and succession in accordance with the deed and Anjuman Paigame Islam's resolution are valid.
  • Khatian entries do not constitute evidence of title but, at most, indicate possession.
  • S.111(g) of the Transfer of Property Act is applicable where adhiars renounced their character and claimed title, and the Adhi Conciliation Board dismissed the case as civil in nature; therefore the doctrine of forfeiture applies as held by the appellate Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mithilesh Kumari v. Prem Behari Khare, AIR 1989 SC 1247 Retroactivity and sweep of the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act — past benami transactions are within the Act's scope. The Court accepted the appellant's concession in light of this decision and the Benami Act, upholding the appellate Court's finding that the sale to Maulana was not to be challenged on benami grounds.
Nani Bai v. Gita Bai Kom Rama Gunge, AIR 1958 SC 706 Certified copies of registered documents may be secondary evidence but foundation for reception should ordinarily be laid in the pleadings. The appellant relied on this case to challenge admissibility; the Court considered it but found the Wakf deed to be a public record under S.74(2) and properly proved on the facts (witnesses explaining non-production of original).
Md. Saimuddin Sheikh v. Abejuddin Sheikh, AIR 1979 Gau 14 Authority supporting admission of certified copies of public documents under the Evidence Act. The Court cited this decision to support the admissibility of the certified Wakf deed as a public document proved in the manner required by law.
Vidya Varuthi Thirtha Swamigal v. Baluswami Ayyar, AIR 1922 PC 123 Observations on Mahomedan law distinguishing Wakf manager (Mutawalli) from an English-style trustee; mutawalli is a manager of usufruct, not owner. The Court relied on this authority to conclude that a mutawalli's position is akin to a manager/receiver and does not amount to ownership of Wakf property; supports treating a manager as mutawalli under S.3(f).
Mt. Allah Rakhi v. Shah Mohammad Abdur Rahim, AIR 1934 PC 77 Supportive authority for the managerial nature of the mutawalli under Mahomedan law. The Court cited this Privy Council decision (by quotation approval) to bolster the conclusion about the mutawalli's character as manager and not owner.
Nawab Zain Yar Jung v. Director of Endowments, AIR 1963 SC 985 Supreme Court recognition of the principles relating to mutawalli and Wakf management. The Court referenced this decision to confirm that the mutawalli's role is managerial, supporting the appellate Court's adoption of S.3(f).
Prince Gholam Hosain Shah v. Syed Altaf Hosain, AIR 1934 Cal 328 (38 Cal WN 214) Under Mahomedan law, appointment and succession of mutawalli should follow the deed of endowment; appointment by donor and succession per deed valid. The Court cited this Calcutta High Court decision to support the proposition that appointment of a mutawalli in accordance with the deed is valid and to uphold the appointment made in the present case.
Jawun Doss Sahoo v. Shah Kubeer-ood Deen, (1840) 2 Moo Ind App 390 (PC) Historical authority referenced in discussion of the mutawalli's role (term 'procurator'). Quoted in the discussion of mutawalli's role to illustrate historical doctrinal statements distinguishing mutawalli from a trustee; used to support the managerial characterization.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by addressing each of the principal objections raised by the appellants and examined the evidence and law expressly cited in the record. The step-by-step reasoning as manifested in the opinion is summarised below.

  1. Benami objection to the sale: The appellant's counsel ultimately did not press the benami objection in light of the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988 and the Supreme Court authority in Mithilesh Kumari v. Prem Behari Khare, which treats past benami transactions within the Act's sweep. Accordingly, the appellate Court's finding that the sale to Maulana was genuine was upheld.
  2. Admissibility of certified Wakf deed: The Court noted that the existence of the Wakf was undisputed and it had been recognised by the Board of Wakf with a Gazette notification. The certified copy of the Wakf deed was a public record kept under the Registration Act and thus falls within clause (2) of S.74 of the Evidence Act. The certified copy was therefore admissible and, on the facts (evidence of P.W.7 and the deed-writer P.W.5 — with the scribe deceased), the foundation for reception was satisfactorily explained. The Court rejected the appellant's reliance on Nani Bai as insufficient to exclude the certified copy in these circumstances and sustained the appellate Court's admission of the document.
  3. Vagueness of the Wakf object: The Court analysed the Wakf deed's object — half the income for Maulana's heirs and the other half to Anjuman Islam for "public welfare works permitted by the Shariat." The Court articulated governing principles of Muslim/Wakf law (objects must be religious, pious or charitable as recognised by Muslim law and must be indicated with reasonable certainty but need not enumerate each object). It held that the rider "permitted by the Shariat" confines permissible uses to those recognised by Shariat, removing the vagueness that might have arisen from a naked reference to "welfare works." The Court concluded that the Wakf object was sufficiently certain and not void for vagueness; incorporation by reference to Shariat was permissible.
  4. Status and appointment of Mutawalli under S.3(f) of the Wakf Act: The Court examined the statutory definition in S.3(f) of the Wakf Act, which includes "any person or Committee for the time being managing or administering any wakf property" as a mutawalli. The Court cited authoritative decisions (including Vidya Varuthi Thirtha Swamigal, Mt. Allah Rakhi, and Nawab Zain Yar Jung) to reaffirm that a mutawalli is akin to a manager of the usufruct and not a trustee in the English technical sense. On the facts, the original mutawalli had resigned (Exhibit-3) and subsequent mutawallis were appointed according to the deed and with approval (Exhibits-4 and 6); the Court found no infirmity in those appointments.
  5. Khatian entries and title under Section 105 of the Goalpara Tenancy Act: The Court reiterated the well-settled principle that khatians are not evidence of title but may indicate possession; it sustained the appellate Court's finding on this point.
  6. Applicability of Section 111(g) of the Transfer of Property Act (forfeiture doctrine): The Court found the admitted fact that when eviction proceedings were initiated the defendants/adhiars renounced their tenancy/adhi character and asserted title. Because the Adhi Conciliation Board treated the dispute as civil in nature and dismissed the adhi eviction proceedings, S.111(g) applied. The appellate Court's application of the doctrine of forfeiture (treating the adhiars as having forfeited tenancy rights by denying the landlord's title) was sustained.
  7. Conclusion on evidence and findings: Having addressed these points, the Court found no merit in the appeal and sustained the appellate Court's conclusions on admissibility of the Wakf deed, validity and certainty of the Wakf, validity of mutawalli appointments, the non-proprietary nature of khatians, and applicability of S.111(g).

Holding and Implications

Holding:

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • The District Judge's appellate judgment (which reversed the trial Court) is sustained by this Court on the principal issues contested on appeal.
  • Concretely, the following consequences flow from the decision as applied to the parties:
    • The sale to Maulana is not successfully attacked on benami grounds in this appeal (the appellate finding is upheld given the Benami Act and relevant authority).
    • The certified copy of the Wakf deed was properly admissible as a public document under S.74(2) of the Evidence Act and supported by witness evidence; the Wakf deed's execution and contents were adequately proved.
    • The Wakf was not void for uncertainty: its object ("welfare works permitted by the Shariat") is sufficiently certain.
    • The appointment and succession of the mutawallis in accordance with the deed and approvals were valid; a manager/committee managing Wakf property can be regarded as a mutawalli under S.3(f) of the Wakf Act.
    • Khatians were correctly treated as indicating possession but not title.
    • Section 111(g) of the Transfer of Property Act applies where tenants/adhiars renounce their tenancy and assert title, and the appellate Court's application of that principle was proper.
  • No new legal principle was formulated by this Court; the decision applies and affirms existing statutory provisions and authorities to the facts of this case. The direct effect is to dismiss the second appeal and thereby sustain the appellate Court's decree in favour of the plaintiffs (as Wakf representatives) for recovery of khas possession as earlier declared by the appellate Court.

Appeal dismissed with costs as recorded in the opinion.

Show all summary ...

1. This is an appeal against the judgment and decree dated 16-11-70 of the District Judge, Goalpara at Dhubri in Title Appeal No.11 of 1975 reversing the judgment and decree dated 24-1-73 passed by the Munsiff No.1, Dhubri in Title Suit No.383 of 1965.

2. The circumstances which have given rise to the action may be briefly summarised. One Raibahadur Biraj Mohan Dutta held a jote of about 73 Bighas of land in village Adabari under the Gauripur Raj Estate. The said jote was sold to one Khosa Sk and his three sons - Sitap, Kitap and Ainulla Sk. by a registered deed of sale dated 4-5-1928. Out of this 73 bighas, 50 bighas of land was sold by the Sheikhs on 30-4-1940 to Maulana Abdul Hamid Khan also known as Maulana Bhasani (hereinafter referred to as 'Maulana') by registered sale deed dated 10-9-1940. Maulana lived at Hamidabad, previously known as Ghagmari. Delivery of possession of the land in pursuance of the sale deed was made by vendors to one Manikuddin Sarkar, who acted on behalf of Maulana. Out of total 50 bighas so purchased, 25 bighas of land comprising two plots, was settled with the vendors themselves on Adhi. On the remaining 25 bighas Maulana constructed his dwelling house and excavated a tank. The representative of Maulana, Kumed Ali lived in the house and also cultivated the land. Maulana's family also occasionally visited the place.

3. On 16-10-1943. Maulana created a Wakf of about 732 bighas of land situated in different mouzas, which included the 50 bighas of land purchased vide deed dated 30-9-1940 as stated above. The registered deed of Wakf provided that half of the income of the property shall be spent for the maintenance of Maulana's heirs and the income of the other half would go to Anjuman Islam, a local religious institution, to be spent on public welfare works permitted by the Shariat. One Ijadur Rahman Choudhury was appointed the first Mutawalli. The Wakf deed also laid down a scheme for appointment of subsequent Mutawallis.

4. After partition of the country, around the year 1950, Maulana and his family left for Pakistan. The Mutawalli Ijadur Rahman Choudhury also left for Pakistan after resigning from the Mutawalli. For sometime the management of the Wakf property was in a quandary. One Mvi. Abu Taher was put in charge of the property in the absence of the first Mutawalli. Taking advantage of the situation, the adhiars of the 25 bighas of jote land stopped delivering the adhi share of paddy to the Wakf authority and also threatened possession from the other part of the land. This gave rise to a proceeding under S.145 of the Code of Criminal Procedure in which the Additional District Magistrate of Dhubri by order dated 6-10-51 declared possession of the Wakf authority over the 25 bighas of land covered by the house etc. The defendants (appellants herein) were found in possession of the 25 bighas as adhiars. That order was not challenged by the adhiras. They, however, did not deliver the adhi share of crop to the Multawalli of the Wakf. The then Mutawalli, therefore, filed a case before the Revenue Court for eviction of the adhiras. In the meantime Adhi Conciliation Boards were constituted and the case was transferred to the Gauripur Adhi Conciliation Board. At this stage, for the first time, the defendants set up adverse title against Maulana and the Mutawalli of the Wakf before the said Board and contended that the suit land was not sold to Maulana by the vendors; and that the sale was benami and as such, the vendors were never adhiars under Maulana or the Mutawalli of the Wakf. In view of the aforesaid stand taken by the adhiars, who were the vendors of Maulana, the Adhi Conciliation Board dismissed the case with a comment that the dispute between the parties was of a civil nature and should be decided by a Civil Court. The Adhi case was instituted on 6-7-1955 and was disposed of on 10-1-1961. In the meantime, it is alleged that the defendants (appellants herein) forcibly cut and removed the paddy and also dispossessed the plaintiffs from the other 25 bighas of land.

5. Situated thus, the plaintiffs (principal respondents before this Court) filed the suit for declaration of title and recovery of possession of both the plots of land - the plot of 25 bighas settled with the defendants on adhi as well as other plot of 25 bighas of khas land wherefrom it was claimed that the Wakf Estate or the Mutawalli had been dispossessed. It was contended that the principal defendants had forfeited their rights as adhiars by denying the title of the Maulana and the Wakf Estate.

6. A number of issues were framed before the trial Court, including issues, whether the plaintiff were interested in the suit property, whether the Wakfnama was void for uncertainty and indefiniteness, whether the original Mutawalli resigned his post and if not, whether the appointment of subsequent Mutawalli was legal and valid. The learned trial Court held that the sale executed by the vendors to Maulana by registered deed of sale dated 30-9-40 was benami. It also held the Wakf created by Maulana to be void for uncertainty. It observed that the plaintiffs failed to prove that the first Mutawalli had resigned and, as such, it was held that the appointment of the subsequent Mutawalli was illegal. It was further observed that in view of his finding that the creation of the Wakf estate and the sale of the suit property by the defendants to Maulana had not been proved, the question of settlement of the land with the defendants by the plaintiffs on adhi did not arise. The trial Court held it to be a case of adverse possession. In view of the aforesaid findings, the suit was dismissed by the trial Court.

7. On appeal, the learned District Judge reversed the findings of the trial Court. It was observed that no issue had even been framed as to whether the alleged sale of the suit land in favour of Maulana was a benami transaction or not. The appellate Court, on consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case, did not approve the finding of the trial Court that the transaction was benami. It was held that the transaction of sale by the defendants to Maulana was not benami but a genuine one. Regarding validity of the Wakf, it was observed that it could not have been the subject of decision in the suit in question. However, in view of the findings arrived at by the trial Court, the appellate Court examined the same and arrived at a finding that the Wakf executed by Maulana was not void for uncertainty. The objection to admissibility of certified copy of the Wakf deed, on the facts and circumstances of the case, was held to be not tenable. The appointment of the subsequent Mutawalli was also held to be valid and legal. The appellate Court also held that the defendants, who are adhiars, became trespassers the moment they denied the title of the landlord and that the civil suit filed by the plaintiffs for their eviction was maintainable. In view of the aforesaid findings, the judgment and decree of the trial Court were set aside. It was declared that the suit land was the property of the wakf created by Maulana and that the plaintiffs were entitled to recover khas possession thereof.

8. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment, the defendants have preferred the present second appeal before this Court. The order of the appellate Court has been challenged mainly on the following grounds. The finding that the sale of the land to the Maulana was genuine and not benami was not tenable; the certified copy of the Wakf deed had been admitted in evidence in violation of the provisions of S.74(2) of the Evidence Act without complying with the technical requirements prescribed for the purpose; the finding that the object of the Wakf was not vague and the Wakf deed not void on that count is errouneous; the observation that under S.3(f) of the Wakf Act a person who manages a Wakf property is to be treated as Mutawalli is contrary to law. The other two grounds are that the appellate Court was not correct in holding that the khatians never indicated any title under the provisions of S.105 of the Goalpara Tenancy Act and that the appellate Court was not correct in applying the doctrine of forefeiture under S.111 (g) of the Transfer of Property Act to the facts and circumstances of the case.

9. At the time of hearing, the learned counsel for the appellant Mr. J.N. Sharma fairly submitted that he did not like to press his objection to the genuineness of the sale deed dated 30-9-1940 which was based on the ground of benami in view of the provisions of the Benami Transaction (Prohibition) Act (45 of 1988) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Mithilesh Kumari v. Prem Behari Khare reported in AIR 1989 SC 1247 wherein it had been held that the said law envisages in its sweep past benami transactions also in its retroactivity and the nullification of defences available to the real owner in recovering the benami property from the benamidar shall apply irrespective of the time of the benami transactions. In that view of the matter, the finding of the appellate Court that the sale of land by the vendors to Maulana was not benami but genuine is upheld. The other questions, therefore, shall be examined in that context.

10. Now, I may turn to the other objections of the appellant. The first grievance is in regard to the admissibility of the certified copy of the deed of Wakf. Before dealing with the same, it may be pertinent to mention that the existence of the Wakf itself is not disputed by the parties. The Wakf was recognised by the Board of Wakf in terms of the provisions of the wakf act and a notification to that effect was also published in the Official Gazette dated 8-1-1958. The Wakf was not only in respect of the suit land but in respect of 732 bighas of land including the suit land. The certified copy of the Wakf deed was filed in the Court and proved. The grievance of the appellant is that the certified copy of the Wakf deed being a secondary evidence should not have been admitted in evidence as there was no explanation as to why the original had not been produced. In support of his contention Mr. Sarma relies on the decision of Supreme Court in Nani Bai v. Gita Bai Kom Rama Gunge., AIR 1958 SC 706. In that case, the Supreme Court had held that though certified copies of registered documents could be adduced as secondary evidence, the foundation for reception of such evidence has to be laid in the pleadings. Mr. S.K.Sen, learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, submitted that the certified copy of the Wakf deed was duly proved and the reason for producing the certified copy in place of the original had already been explained to the Court. In this connection, the learned counsel pointed out to the evidence of P.W. 7, the Mutawalli, who stated that the original deed was not traceable and, as such, the certified copy had been filed. The deed-writer had also been examined as P.W.5. The scribe having been dead, could not be examined. According to Mr. Sen, the certified copy of the Wakf deed was a public document within the meaning of S.74(2) of the Evidence Act and that the same had been duly proved in the manner laid down in S.77 of the said Act. He relies on the decision of this Court in Md. Saimuddin Sheikh v. Abejuddin Sheikh, AIR 1979 Gau 14. I have carefully considered the rival submissions. Section 74 of the Evidence Act defines what are knwon as public documents. This section, so far as relevant, reads :

" 74. The following documents are public documents-

(1) xxx xxx xxx

(2) Public records kept in any State of private documents."

This clause evidently refers to records kept under the Registration Act. Public record of a Wakf deed which is a private document kept in the office of the Sub-Registrar is a public document as defined in clause (2) of S.74 of the Evidence Act and certified copy thereof is admissible in evidence.

11. In the light of the facts and circumstances of the case, and law on the subject, I am of the opinion that the certified copy of the Wakf deed had been rightly admitted in evidence. The execution and the contents of the Wakf deed had also been duly proved by the P.W.5. Under the circumstances, no fault can be found with the finding of the learned appellate Court in that regard. The same is, therefore, sustained.

12. The next submission of the learned counsel for the appellant is that the Wakf deed is void on the ground of vagueness of the object of the Wakf. I have perused the object. In terms of the provisions contained in the Wakf deed half of the income of the property is to be spent for the maintenance of Maulana's heirs and the other half is to be spent in public welfare works permitted by Shariat. In the absence of any heir of Maulana the entire income of the property is to be spent on such welfare works. A local religious body Anjuman Paygame Ismai is entrusted to receive half of the income or the entire income in case there is no heir of Maulana and to spend the same on such welfare works. According to the counsel for the appellant the object of the Wakf namely 'welfare works permitted by the Shariat" is a very wide and vague expression and the deed of Wakf is void on that account. I have carefully considered the submissions. I have gone through the recognised text on Muslim law as well as various decisions of the Courts on the subject. The principles that emerge may be briefly stated thus: "Wakf" as defined in the Wakf Act means a permanent dedication by a person professing the Mussalman faith of any property for any purpose recognised by the Mussalman law as religious, pious or charitable. The object of the Wakf must be one recognised by the Muslim law as 'religious, pious or charitable'. A Wakf may also be created in favour of the settlor's family, children and descendants. Objects prohibited by Islam are, however, not valid objects of a Wakf. Objects of the Wakf must be indicated with reasonable certainty, but it is not necessary that each object should be named. A Wakf for charity or for good objects permitted by Islam is valid and legal. These are the basic principles. The question that falls for consideration in the present case is whether "welfare works permitted by the Shariat' can be termed to be vague or uncertain object of a Wakf. As earlier indicated, what is necessary for a valid Wakf is that the purpose of the Wakf must be one recognised by Mahomedan law as 'religious, pious and charitable'. A person who dedicates his property by way of Wakf, may, instead of ef enumerating the objects for which the income of Wakf may be used, provide that it may be used for any welfare works permitted by the Shariat, that is, the Mahomedan law. Such provision, in my opinion, is absolutely clear and there is no vagueness or uncertainty in it. The only difference is that instead of restricting the use of the income of the Wakf to some of the specified objects, the Wakf has allowed it to be used for any of the objects which are recognised by Shariat to be welfare works. No exception can be taken to such declaration. If the object would have been described as " welfare works" without the rider "permitted by Shariat", it could have been contended that "welfare works" as commonly understood might even include the works which are prohibited by Islam and in that event the object could have been challenged as vague. But that possibility has been ruled out in the instant case by use of the rider 'permitted by Shariat'. The income of the Wakf, in the instant case, can be used only for such public works which are permitted by Shariat. In my opinion, if a Wakf, instead of enumerating the various purposes for which the income of the Wakf can be used, makes a general declaration and dedicates it to be used for any purpose of public welfare recognised by Shariat it cannot be said that the Wakf is void for vagueness of the object. This is in fact incorporation of object by reference. I do not find anything wrong in such incorporation by reference. I am, therefore, of the clear opinion that the object of the Wakf in question is quite clear and certain and no infirmity can be found with the Wakf deed on that count.

13. The next contention relates to the findings of the learned appellate Court that under S.3(f) of the Wakf Act, a person who manages a Wakf property is to be treated as a Mutawalli. I have perused the relevant provision. Under S.3(f) of the Wakf Act, 1954, Mutawalli has been defined to mean :

" any person appointed either verbally or under any deed or instrument by whcih a Wakf has been created or by a competent authority to be the mutawalli of a wakf and includes any naib-mutawalli, khadim, jejawar, sajjadanishin, amin, or other person appointed by a mutawalli to perform the duties of a mutawalli and save as otherwise provided in this Act, any person or Committee for the time being managing or administering any wakf property as such:"
.....

From a bare reading of the definition, it is clear that save as otherwise provided in the said Act, a person or Committee for the time being managing or administering any wakf property as such is also a Mutawalli. This position is also well settled by a number of decisions of the Courts. A Mutawalli is like a manager rather than a trustee. So far as the wakf property is concerned, he has to see that the beneficiaries get the advantage of the usufruct. In this connection, I may refer to the following observations of Ameer Ali, J. in Vidya Varuthi Thirtha Swamigal v. Baluswami Ayyar, AIR 1922 PC 123 :

" But the Mahomedan law relating to trusts differs fundamentally from the English law. It owes its origin to a rule laid down by the Prophet of Islam; and means the tying up of property in the ownership of God the Almighty and the donation of the profits for the benefit of human beings'. When once it is declared that a particular property is wakf, or any such expression is used as implied wakf, or the tenor of the document shows that a dedication to pious or charitable purposes is meant, the right of the wakf is extinguished and the ownership is transferred to the Almighty. The donor may name any meritorious object as the recipient of the benefit. The manager of the wakf is the mutawalli, the governor, superintendent, or curator. In Jawun Doss Sahoo v Shah Kubeer-ood Deen, ( 1840) 2 Moo Ind App 390 (PC) the Judicial Committee call him 'procurator'. ...... But neither the Sajjadanashin nor the mutawalli has any right in the property belonging to the wakf; the property is not vested in him and he is not a 'trustee' in the technical sense"
.

This view was quoted with approval by the Privy Council in Mt. Allah Rakhi v. Shah Mohammad Abdur Rahim, AIR 1934 PC 77 and by the Supreme Court in Nawab Zain Yar Jung v. Director of Endowments, AIR 1963 SC 985 (989). In view of the aforesaid decisions, I am of the clear opinion that the position of a mutawalli is more analogous to that of a manager or a receiver. His position is distinguishable from that of a trustee. The wakf property itself never gets transferred to the mutawalli. He has control over the usufruct alone and he has to see that it is used for the objects of the wakf in accordance with the desire of the wakif. In that view of the matter, the learned appellate Court, in my opinion, was correct in holding that a person who manages the wakf property is to be treated as a mutawalli.

14. The next point pertains to resignation of original mutawalli and appointment of new mutawalli in his place. It may be pertinent to mention at this stage that there is enough evidence on record to show that the original Mutawalli had resigned. His letter of resignation is Exhibit-3. He left for Pakistan. Thereafter in terms of the deed of wakf the next Mutawalli was appointed by Anjuman Paigame Islam and his appointment was approved by the Board of Wakf. The resolution of the Anjuman Paigame Islam appointing the next Mutawalli is Exhibit-4 and the letter from the Secretary of the Board of Wakf declaring the appointment is Exhibit-6. On the resignation of this Mutawalli another Mutawalli was appointed by Anjuman Paigame Islam. I do not find any infirmity either in the resignation of first Mutawalli or in the appointment of subsequent Mutawalli. In fact, the whole scheme of appointment of subsequent Mutawalli is contained in the wakf deed itself. Resignation of a Mutawalli under the wakf deed is not a pre-condition for appointment of other Mutawallis. Even if a Mutawalli is not available due to his long absence another Mutawalli can be appointed.

15. The learned counsel for the appellant made a faint attempt to challenge the appointment of subsequent Mutawalli on the ground that the appointment of a Mutawalli by a Committee is unknown to Mahomedan law. In fact, that was the view taken by the trial Court. The appellate Court rightly turned down the contention which is not tenable in view of the clear provisions to that effect contained in Section 3(f) of the Wakf Act.

There are also decisions to that effect. In this connection a decision of the Calcutta High Court in Prince Gholam Hosain Shah v. Syed Altaf Hosain, reported in 38 Cal WN 214 : (AIR 1934 Cal 328) may be referred wherein it was observed that under the Mahomedan Law, the appointment of a Mutawalli can be made by the donor and the succession to the appointment must be in accordance with the provisions of the deed of endowment, if there is any. In view of the aforesaid discussion, in my opinion, the appointment of present Mutawalli in the instant case, was strictly in accordance with law.

16. The next contention of the appellant is whether the khatian under the provisions of Section 105 of the Goalpara Tenancy Act indicate the title over the land. It is well settled that khatians are not evidence of title. They may at the most indicate possession. The findings of the learned appellate Court on this score, therefore, is sustained.

17. The last contention relates to applicability of Section 111 (g) of the Transfer of Property Act to the facts and circumstances of the present case. The admitted position in this case is that when a proceeding was initiated for eviction of the defendants from the suit land as Adhiars, they renounced their character as tenant or Adhiar and claimed title for themselves. It was on the basis of such a stand taken by them that the Adhi Conciliation Board dismissed the cases commenting that it was a suit of civil nature. In that view of the matter, Section 111 (g) clearly applies. The findings of the learned appellate Court in this regard cannot be interferred with.

18. In view of the aforesaid discussion, I do not find any merit in the appeal and the same is dismissed with cost.

Appeal dismissed.