- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Union Of India v. Vimal Bhai And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The order concerns the operationalisation of regional benches of the National Green Tribunal (NGT) and issues arising from unauthorised occupation of government residences. On 16-7-2013 the Secretariat of the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet approved the appointment of two Judicial Members and expressed willingness to operate a reserved panel. During the hearing the Additional Solicitor General informed the Court that infrastructure, including residential accommodation, was ready for a Pune Bench of the NGT. Counsel for the State of West Bengal requested time to secure premises and housing for the Kolkata Bench. The matter also touches on implementation of this Court’s earlier judgment in S.D Bandi v. Karnataka SRTC concerning eviction of unauthorised occupants of government accommodation, and on the specific grievance of Lieutenant General S.S. Dahiya regarding his eviction.
Legal Issues Presented
The opinion addresses a procedural matter and does not frame distinct legal issues.
Arguments of the Parties
Submissions of the Union of India
- Placed on record the 16-7-2013 letter approving appointment of two Judicial Members and operation of the reserved panel.
- Asserted that all infrastructure and residential accommodation required for the Pune Bench is complete and ready.
Submissions of the State of West Bengal
- Reported ongoing efforts to secure office space and residential premises for the Kolkata Bench of the NGT.
- Sought two weeks’ time to finalise arrangements and requested that the Bench not be shifted from Kolkata to Gauhati or Ranchi.
Grievance of Lieutenant General S.S. Dahiya
- Alleged forcible eviction and imposition of penal damages based on notices issued by the Court regarding unauthorised occupation.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| S.D Bandi v. Karnataka SRTC, (2013) 12 SCC 631; (2013) 8 Scale 88 | Guidelines for eviction of unauthorised occupants of government accommodation (para 33 of the judgment). | The Court discharged its earlier eviction notice but directed the Government and concerned agencies to act strictly in accordance with para 33 of the judgment. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court relied primarily on factual representations made by counsel and on the binding principles set forth in S.D Bandi. 1. Accepting the Union’s assurance that infrastructure was complete, the Court found no impediment to declaring the Pune Bench operational from 1-8-2013. 2. Considering the State of West Bengal’s efforts and request, the Court balanced administrative feasibility with the need for timely access to environmental justice, granting a two-week extension rather than ordering relocation of the Bench. 3. With respect to government accommodation, the Court harmonised the need for orderly enforcement with fairness by withdrawing its own notice yet emphasising adherence to para 33 of S.D Bandi. 4. To address Lieutenant General Dahiya’s specific grievance, the Court crafted a remedial mechanism: the officer would submit a representation to the Additional Solicitor General, who must facilitate prompt departmental action.
Holding and Implications
ORDER:
- The Ministry of Environment and Forests must, within seven days, act on the 16-7-2013 letter approving appointment of two Judicial Members.
- The Pune Bench of the NGT shall become functional with effect from 1-8-2013.
- The Government of West Bengal is granted two weeks to provide office and residential accommodation for the Kolkata Bench; relocation of the Bench is deferred.
- The earlier Court notice regarding eviction of unauthorised occupants is discharged, but the Government must proceed strictly in line with para 33 of S.D Bandi.
- Lieutenant General S.S. Dahiya may submit a letter to the Additional Solicitor General, who must ensure expeditious redress of his grievance.
- The matter is listed next on 2-8-2013.
Implications: The order ensures immediate operational capacity for the Pune NGT Bench and sets a short timetable for the Kolkata Bench, thereby facilitating environmental adjudication. It also clarifies the procedure for eviction of unauthorised occupants without issuing new legal principles, and provides an ad-hoc remedy for an individual grievance. No new precedent is established beyond enforcement of existing directives.
Order
1. Shri P.P Malhotra, learned Additional Solicitor General placed before the Court Letter dated 16-7-2013 sent by the Secretariat of Appointment Committee of the Cabinet to the Ministry of Environment and Forests conveying approval of the Appointment Committee of the Cabinet to the appointment of two Judicial Members. The letter also indicates the willingness of the Government of India to operate the reserved panel. The letter is taken on record and the Ministry of Environment and Forests is directed to take action within 7 days in accordance with Para 3 of the Letter dated 16-7-2013. Shri Malhotra also gave out that infrastructure is ready for making the Pune Bench of the National Green Tribunal (NGT) operational. He submitted that residential accommodation for Judicial and Expert Members of the Pune Bench has also been made available.
2. In view of the statement made by the learned Additional Solicitor General, we direct that the Pune Bench of the National Green Tribunal shall become functional w.e.f 1-8-2013.
3. Shri Rohatgi, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the State of West Bengal gave out that serious efforts are being made to make available the accommodation for the Kolkata Bench of the Tribunal as also residential accommodation for Judicial and Expert Members. He submitted that two weeks' time may be allowed to the State Government to take necessary steps and the Court may not direct shifting of the Bench from Kolkata to Gauhati or Ranchi.
4. The request made by Shri Rohatgi is accepted and two weeks' time is granted to the Government of West Bengal to provide adequate space for making the Kolkata Bench of the Tribunal functional. In addition, suitable residential accommodation for Judicial and Expert Members must also be made available within this period.
5. In view of the judgment of this Hon'ble Court in S.D Bandi v. Karnataka SRTC (2013) 12 SCC 631, (2013) 8 Scale 88, notice ordered by this Court for vacating the government accommodation from those who are unauthorisedly occupying the same is discharged with the direction that the Government and the agencies concerned must take action strictly in accordance with para 33 of the judgment in S.D Bandi case (2013) 12 SCC 631, (2013) 8 Scale 88.
6. Lieutenant General S.S Dahiya, complained that on the strength of the notice issued by this Court he was forcibly evicted from the accommodation and was made to pay penal damages. Shri Rakesh Khanna, learned Additional Solicitor General gave out that he will instruct the department concerned to look into the grievance of Lieutenant General Dahiya.
7. With a view to enable the department to redress the grievance of Lieutenant General Dahiya, we direct him to hand over a letter to the learned Additional Solicitor General who will ensure that necessary action is taken in the matter at the earliest.
8. Put up on 2-8-2013.
Court Masters
Alert