- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
People'S Union For Civil Liberties (Pds Matters) v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The present order is an interlocutory direction issued in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 196 of 2001. In compliance with the Supreme Court’s earlier order dated 17-9-2012 (2013) 2 SCC 682, Justice D.P. Wadhwa submitted a “Final Central Vigilance Committee Report” summarising nationwide and State-specific recommendations to reform the Public Distribution System (PDS). Because counsel for the parties had not yet examined the report, they sought copies or requested that it be uploaded to the Supreme Court’s website. Two additional reports from Commissioner N.C. Saxena were also received, prompting State counsel to ask for time to file objections. The Additional Solicitor General (ASG) informed the Court that the Attorney-General for India would assist on the next date of hearing.
Legal Issues Presented
The opinion addresses a procedural matter and does not frame distinct legal issues.
Arguments of the Parties
Counsel for All Parties
- Requested that the Registry provide physical copies of Justice Wadhwa’s final report or make it accessible online so that they could prepare responses.
Counsel for State Governments
- Sought additional time to file objections to two separate reports received from Commissioner N.C. Saxena.
Additional Solicitor General (Union of India)
- Assured the Court that the Attorney-General would appear and assist at the next hearing.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| 17-9-2012 (2013) 2 SCC 682 | Directed the Central Vigilance Committee to submit a consolidated set of recommendations (national and State-specific) on PDS reforms. | The instant order notes receipt of the final report prepared pursuant to this directive. |
| 27-7-2010 (2010) 11 SCC 719 | Mandated total computerisation of the PDS and required the Union Government to develop common software. | Cited within Justice Wadhwa’s report as background for recommending accelerated computerisation. |
| 29-3-2011 (2011) 14 SCC 393 | Called for creation of a High-Powered Committee to oversee PDS computerisation. | Referenced in the report to explain formation and functioning of the High-Powered Committee. |
| 14-9-2011 (2011) 14 SCC 331 | Issued detailed directions on data digitisation, monitoring, and citizen-centric disclosure in PDS. | Forms the basis of several short-term recommendations on data cleaning and SMS alerts. |
| 3-2-2012 (2012) 12 SCC 357 | Appointed the Secretary, Department of Food & Public Distribution, as chief coordinator for PDS computerisation. | Cited to illustrate continuing coordination problems between Centre and States. |
| 14-5-2011 (2013) 2 SCC 684 | Ordered reservation of five million tonnes of foodgrains for 150 poorest districts and vulnerable groups. | Forms the foundation for the report’s section on additional allocations and community kitchens. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court’s analysis is succinct and procedural. Observing that none of the counsel had yet examined the extensive Wadhwa Committee report, the Bench considered that meaningful responses required prompt access to the document. Accordingly, it balanced administrative feasibility with counsel’s request by directing the Registry either (a) to supply physical copies to all appearing lawyers, or (b) to upload the report on the Supreme Court’s website to facilitate immediate download. To maintain parity, counsel for all concerned State Governments were also instructed to file their responses. The Court further recorded the ASG’s assurance regarding the Attorney-General’s appearance and fixed a specific date (8-2-2013 at 2:00 p.m.) for the next hearing, consolidating related interlocutory applications for efficient management of the matter.
Holding and Implications
ORDER: The Registry is directed to disseminate Justice D.P. Wadhwa’s final report—either by supplying hard copies to counsel or by uploading it on the Supreme Court’s website. State Governments and other parties shall file their responses by the next date of hearing. I.A. No. 98 of 2010 is ordered to be listed, and the matter is posted for further hearing on 8-2-2013 at 2:00 p.m.
Implications: The order facilitates transparency and ensures all parties have equal access to the Committee’s detailed recommendations, enabling informed objections or endorsements. It does not establish new legal precedent but advances procedural efficiency in a long-running public-interest litigation concerning systemic reform of the Public Distribution System.
Order
1. A final report summarising the recommendations of the Committee has been received from Justice D.P Wadhwa, pursuant to our order dated 17-9-2012 (2013) 2 SCC 682. The learned counsel for the parties submit that they did not have the advantage of going through the final report. They pray for issue of the copies to them or at least uploading of the recommendations on the website of the Supreme Court of India to enable each one of them to download a copy of the report and file their response.
2. We accordingly direct the Registry to either prepare copies for delivery to the counsel appearing in these cases or if it is otherwise permissible upload the report on the website of the Supreme Court of India so as to enable each one of the counsel to get a copy of the same for his use. The learned counsel for the State Governments concerned shall also respond to the report and recommendations summarised by Justice Wadhwa.
3. Mr P.P Malhotra, ASG, assures the Court that the learned Attorney General for India, who is not available today will appear and assist the Court on the next date of hearing.
4. Post on 8-2-2013 at 2.00 p.m
5. We are at this stage informed that two reports have been received from the office of Mr N.C Saxena, Commissioner. The learned counsel appearing for the State Governments seek time to file their objections to the said reports. They are free to do so on or before the next date of hearing. Advance copies of the same be furnished to Mr Colin Gonsalves, Senior Advocate, appearing for the petitioner.
6. As prayed by Mr P.P Malhotra, ASG, list IA No. 98 of 2010 in WP (C) No. 196 of 2001 also on the next date of hearing.
Court Masters
Final Justice Wadhwa Central Vigilance Committee Report
(In pursuance of the order dated 17-9-2012 (2013) 2 SCC 682 of the Hon'ble Supreme Court)
1. Public Distribution System (PDS) is the largest food distribution network of its kind in the world. Yet it has acquired notoriety of being the most corrupt system in the country. There is undoubtedly nexus between the fair price shop (FPS) owners, transporters, bureaucrats and politicians. Diversion of PDS foodgrain occurs, both in the supply chain as well as at FPS. Information technology can be used to curb this menace of foodgrain diversion. Modern technology will help in ensuring that the beneficiary regularly receives his/her entitlement of foodgrains of same quality as has been issued by FCI.
2. The Hon'ble Court by its order dated 17-9-2012 (2013) 2 SCC 682 called upon the Central Vigilance Committee (CVC) to sum up its final recommendations in two streams—(i) those which could be dealt at the national level so as to be applicable to all the States in the country, and (ii) those which would be specific to any region or State. As far as latter part of the directions is concerned, CVC has already submitted separate report for each State giving specific recommendations and applicability thereto. To illustrate, functioning of PDS in tea estates in West Bengal and Assam; law and order problems in Manipur, Jharkhand and Odisha; relating to militancy and inaccessible areas of the States of Jammu and Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand during winter and rainy seasons when certain areas are cut off, are some of the issues on which Committee has made specific recommendation in the relevant reports. The Hon'ble Court has also desired that the recommendations of the Committee could be on short term/immediate measures to be taken by the Central and/or State Governments as also long-term objectives to be pursued by them over the years.
3. The Committee has, therefore, bifurcated recommendations into long term and short term so that these could be implemented in a proper manner. As to long-term objectives two important steps would be: (1) constitution of Civil Supplies Corporation in every State/Union Territory, and (2) computerisation of whole PDS operations. For short-term measures, recommendations could be: (i) identification of beneficiaries/inclusion and exclusion errors, (ii) storage capacity, (iii) transportation of PDS foodgrains, (iv) viability of fair price shop, (v) accountability and monitoring, (vi) allocation of foodgrain on per unit basis, (vii) Vigilance Committee (viii) complaint mechanism, (ix) allotment of FPS, (x) awareness of beneficiaries, (xi) vigilance and enforcement, (xii) functioning of FPS, (xiii) supply of fortified atta, (xiv) elimination of bogus and fake ration cards, (xv) electronic weighment, (xvi) issuance of ration cards, (xvii) implementation of the Hon'ble Supreme Court's orders dated 8-5-2002 and 2-5-2003, (xviii) allocation of PDS foodgrain from the Centre to the States/UTs on the basis of projected population, 2012, (xvii) joint sampling, (xviii) abolition of APL category, and (xix) special measures for the poorest districts in the country.
4. Public Distribution System evolved as a system of management of scarcity and for distribution of foodgrains at affordable prices. Over the years, PDS has become an important part of the Government's policy for management of food economy in the country. There are over five lakh fair price shops in the country which distribute foodgrains under PDS. Currently allocation of foodgrains under TPDS is made by the Government of India to the States/Union Territories for APL and BPL including Antyodaya Anna Yojana (AAY) families.
5. PDS is operated under the joint responsibility of the Central and the State Governments. The Central Government has taken the responsibility for procurement, storage, transportation and bulk allocation of foodgrains, etc. The responsibility for distributing the same to the consumers through the network of fair price shops (FPSs) rests with the State Governments. The operational responsibilities including allocation within the State, identification of families below poverty line, issue of ration cards, supervision and monitoring the functioning of FPSs rests with the State Government. To streamline the system, the Central Government has issued Public Distribution System (Control) Order, 2001. Regrettably, the States are not giving full effect to the Order.
6. PDS has not yielded benefits to the extent intended. This is on account of various reasons viz.:
(i) collusion between persons involved in the PDS supply chain resulting in leakage and large-scale diversion of foodgrains;
(ii) flawed system of appointment of FPS dealers;
(iii) errors of inclusion and exclusion which deny targeted beneficiaries of their entitlement and resulting in faulty identification of target groups;
(iv) virtually non-existent vigilance machinery at the grass-root level;
(v) too many categories for entitlement resulting in dilution of targeting of deserving beneficiaries;
(vi) long-drawn and ineffective procedure for dealing with malpractices that allow the guilty to get away;
(vii) too many functionaries involved in the process resulting in dilution of accountability and fixing of responsibility;
(viii) lack of adequate supervision over PDS operations at the field level and laxity which often does not result in any punishment to persons found negligent at the supervisory and higher levels for negligence in supervision when in the normal course the supervisors should also be held responsible as any diversion results in wastage of public resources;
(ix) undue political interference; and lastly
(x) a corrupt implementing machinery and all in all a sleepy and sloppy programme where there is freedom to play with its great objectives with impunity to derive unlawful pecuniary benefits.
7. Everyone from the Prime Minister down the line is seized of the need for revamping, overhauling or restructuring PDS. To revamp the system drastic steps are required to be taken. Patchwork will not do. Two important steps would be: (1) Constitution of a Civil Supplies Corporation in every State/Union Territory, and (2) Computerisation of the whole PDS operations.
7.1 ON CIVIL SUPPLIES CORPORATION
7.1.1 It is a known fact that FPS is the epicentre of corruption where FPS owner, transporter, corrupt officials and politicians are hand in glove to cheat the public. Statistics show that stand-alone FPS is not viable. The FPS owner has to indulge in diversion of PDS foodgrain into black market and earn illegal gain which he shares with his collaborators. FPS owner is corrupt. Yet the States have made categories of persons whom FPS can be allotted. When there is no profit why should the State invite persons in whatever category, when he is bound to indulge in corruption. The State cannot be seen sponsoring corruption or turn a blind eye to corruption. Diversion of PDS foodgrain in black market deprives the genuine beneficiary to get his allotted quantity of foodgrain. Choice is thus between a corrupt FPS functioning and the State itself taking over the functioning of FPS. For this purpose it becomes essential that a Civil Supplies Corporation in the State is constituted to work as an independent body to distribute PDS foodgrain at FPS level and take over existing FPS.
7.1.2 The constitution of Civil Supplies Corporation in every State which will lift foodgrain from FCI and distribute to FPS, as it is not possible, especially in larger States for FPS dealer to lift foodgrain directly from FCI godowns. The State-level Corporation can also take up intermediate storage before delivery to FPS. Where the States are following the decentralised procurement scheme, the supply can be made directly from State godown to FPS, thus cutting/shortening the supply chain. In 13 States there are corporations but all are not necessarily dealing wholly or partially in PDS.
7.1.3 Ideally FPS should be run by the State-level corporations, Panchayati Raj institutions, cooperatives and registered women self-help groups. FPS should not be run by private individual. Wherever FPS is operated by private individuals, they should be phased out gradually and their place be taken over by the Corporation-run FPSs or cooperatives or women self-help groups. Where the State is having a large size of area, there could be even two corporations, which will also be good for competition. There are other distinct advantages of FPS being operated by the State-level Corporation. FPS will abide by various rules and regulations/directions. There will be less than usual complaints relating to non-opening of FPS on time or opening on a day or so in a week, maintenance of record, weighment (quality and quantity), charging of high price, attitude of salesmen and like. Salesmen will be under the control of the Corporation subject to its rules and regulations. The Corporation could itself have a number of trucks fitted with global positioning system (GPS) which can also serve as mobile FPS at times. Mobile vans can be pressed into service by the Corporation where certain areas are inaccessible. Or in the alternative, it should hire dedicated trucks with appropriate tracking tools like GPS.
7.1.4 The Corporation should be made self-sufficient. The Corporation should be able to absorb the loss, if any suffered by FPS run by it, from its other activities. Commission now payable to the FPS will be payable to the Corporation and it should be appropriately fixed. Attempts however, should be made that no burden be placed on the beneficiaries belonging to BPL/AAY categories. Any loss in the operation of the Corporation should be compensated by the State by making budgetary provisions. Where no infrastructure like shop and godown exists for operating FPS it should be built by the State/Corporation on the lines of Mother Dairy outlet or ATM or post office. The land can be provided to the Corporation by the State or by the Panchayat for the purpose. Not much funds are required to build infrastructure. Panchayats have also sufficient resources to build infrastructure.
7.1.5 The State Government is entrusted with the distribution of foodgrain under PDS and should act only as a regulator and the distribution should be left with the Corporation, an independent body. The Corporation should be headed by a senior IAS officer.
7.1.6 Since diversion of foodgrains occurs in the supply chain it should be shortened. Once the Corporation is established, supply chain would be from FCI to the Corporation to FPS. It will be for the Corporation either to take foodgrain from FCI and make doorstep delivery to FPS or keep the same in its own godown and properly distribute. Once the Corporation is established all intermediaries like wholesalers in some States must be abolished.
7.1.7 Till the Corporation is established, FPS wherever established should be allotted either to multipurpose cooperative or to a registered women self-help group. It is assumed that cooperative would be viable. For women's self-help groups, FPS should be like kiranas/grocery shops, so that it absorb the loss suffered by operating FPS or add to the nominal income it earns from the FPS operation.
7.1.8 It must be understood that FPS is basically for the benefit of beneficiaries. There cannot be hereditary allotment of FPS. FPS licence has to be renewed after verification and at that time FPS can be allotted to cooperative or women-self help group. Wherever it is not possible/practicable it should be taken over by the Corporation or even attached to a neighbouring FPS or even put into operation by mobile vans.
7.2 ON COMPUTERISATION
7.2.1 Modern technology can help checking of diversion of PDS foodgrain.
7.2.2 The Public Distribution System (Control) Order, 2001 provides that the State Government is to ensure monitoring of the functioning of PDS at the fair price shop level through the computerisation network of NIC installed in the NIC centres. The Control Order further provides that for this purpose computerised codes shall be issued to each FPS in the district. No State took notice of these provisions and took no steps towards computerisation of PDS.
7.2.3 The Central Vigilance Committee (CVC) in its report on Delhi submitted in August 2007, pointed to these provisions of the Control Order and recommended for the computerisation of PDS in the State. After visiting some more States CVC submitted a comprehensive report on computerisation in February 2009. The Central Government in 2009 approved a scheme on computerisation of PDS on pilot basis in three districts in each of the four States viz. Andhra Pradesh, Assam, Chhattisgarh and Delhi. There was no positive response from the States.
7.2.4 The Central Government in 2008 invited the Union Territory of Chandigarh and the Haryana State to take up computerisation of PDS in their respective areas and even provided funds for the purpose. Accordingly, a scheme on Smart Card based delivery of essential commodities under TPDS was sanctioned during 2008-2009. The administrative approval of this scheme was made on 18-12-2008 with an expenditure of Rs 142.29 crores. Unfortunately nothing appears to have been done towards full computerisation of PDS in Chandigarh and Haryana and there exists only a blame game between NIC and private vendors.
7.2.5 Since all this period no visible initiative was taken and the States did not show any inclination towards computerisation. The Central Government appeared helpless and there was large-scale diversion of PDS foodgrain both at supply chain and at FPS level. The Hon'ble Supreme Court was approached on the basis of the report submitted by CVC for appropriate directions.
7.2.6 In its order date 27-7-2010 (2010) 11 SCC 719, the Hon'ble Supreme Court said that to avoid pilferage and corruption, there must be total computerisation of PDS on top priority basis and that the Union Government “must prepare a software and the same software should be used by all the States”. The Court further observed that the Union Government may consider computerisation in consultation with the specialised agency like Uidai or any other agency. Accordingly, on 9-8-2010 the Union Government set up a Task Force headed by the Director General, National Informatics Centre (NIC). The Task Force was constituted of representative of the Department of Information Technology; representative of the Unique Identification Authority of India (Uidai); representative of the Department of Food and Public Distribution; representative of Food Corporation of India and Secretary of select States [Andhra Pradesh, Assam, Chandigarh (UT), Chhattisgarh, Delhi, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh and Tamil Nadu] as members. The Task Force submitted its report on 1-11-2010.
7.2.7 In its order dated 29-3-2011 (2011) 14 SCC 393, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that the matter was pending for several years but no real progress had been made in computerisation programme and that it was absolutely imperative that computerisation be put in place as expeditiously as possible. Directions were issued to the Central Government to take appropriate steps to have a high-powered committee (HPC) which can take assistance of all concerned to ensure computerisation of PDS. The committee so constituted was to monitor the programme of computerisation on regular basis.
7.2.8 The high-powered committee (HPC) was thereafter constituted with the Chairman, CVC and Director General, NIC; Director General, Uidai; Secretary, Department of Food and Public Distribution, Govt. of India and the Supreme Court Commissioner or his representative, as members. This Committee was formally constituted by the Government Order dated 3-5-2011. HPC submitted its report to the Hon'ble Supreme Court in August 2011. On 14-9-2011 (2011) 14 SCC 331 the Hon'ble Supreme Court passed a detailed order as to the steps to be taken towards computerisation. Thereafter meetings have been held and some States submitted action plans. In its order dated 3-2-2012 (2012) 12 SCC 357 the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that there appears to be no coordination between the Central Government and the State Governments and that “this long-outstanding problem can be sorted out if the Secretary, Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution, Government of India, is made in charge of the computerisation programme in PDS”. The Hon'ble Court nominated Secretary, Department of Food and Public Distribution as the Chief Coordinator of computerisation programme and directed to coordinate with all the Chief Secretaries of the States and the Administrators of the Union Territories.
7.2.9 In spite of all these directions it is apparent that the process of computerisation is distressingly slow and urgency is not being shown by the States. As the things stand, it may take even five years towards computerisation.
7.2.10 Immediate steps are required to be taken by the States. The States should follow the steps on priority basis as directed in the order dated 14-9-2011 (2011) 14 SCC 331. The first and foremost is the collection of digital data. The States must complete the process of digitisation of data within the prescribed time period. It has been reported that 11 States/Union Territories have completed the process of digitisation of data which is yet to be cleaned as it has been done with the help of FPS dealers. Now the data must be cleaned with the help of Uidai or RGI (Registrar General of India) data. The process of computerisation may take time, meanwhile the States should introduce IVR based toll-free number for redressal of complaints, SMS alert system for social audit and information on distribution of foodgrain be uploaded regularly on the national web portal. Chhattisgarh model be put in place to check diversion of foodgrain in supply chain.
SHORT-TERM RECOMMENDATIONS
8. IDENTIFICATION OF BENEFICIARIES/INCLUSION AND EXCLUSION ERRORS
8.1 There is great deal of inclusion and exclusion errors in identification of BPL families. There are no fixed criteria for identification of BPL families under TPDS. For BPL identification some States like Tripura adopted “income” and “expenditure” approach based on the BPL Census, 1992 and 1997 respectively. Other States like Punjab follow “score-based, ranking” criteria based on 13 cardinal indicators as laid down in BPL Census, 2002 while some other States have their own criteria for identifying BPL families. For example in the State of Uttarakhand any family having monthly income more than Rs 750 is not a BPL.
8.2 The first and foremost thing for the Central Government is to lay down criteria for BPL category. Thereafter, steps should be taken for identification of BPL families. In that case, there should be no cap on the number of BPL families. The lists of BPL and AAY families should be reviewed every year for the purpose of deletion and inclusion of families.
9. STORAGE CAPACITY
9.1 There is an acute shortage of covered storage capacity with FCI as well as the State Governments. It is found that the States where procurement is being done do not have sufficient storage space and the foodgrains were lying on the roads. Proper infrastructure must be developed by FCI and the States for storage of foodgrains. In the hills and inaccessible areas, there is need to have storage capacity for storing foodgrains supplies for 3 to 6 months.
9.2 In some States like State of Odisha, Assam, West Bengal, etc. there are storage agents, which lift PDS foodgrain from FCI and store it in its own godown and thereafter distribute PDS foodgrain to FPS dealers. These intermediate/storage agents should be eliminated.
9.3 The construction of covered storage capacity by FCI as well as the State Government with a proper boundary wall and parking space for vehicles meant for transportation of PDS foodgrain should be taken up on priority. Some States are facing difficulty in providing land for construction of storage base for foodgrains due to high cost of land. The Rail Land Development Authority has identified about 43,000 hectares of vacant land available with the Railways, which can be utilised for constructing storage for foodgrains by FCI and the States/Corporation which will facilitate moving the foodgrains through rail to the State/Corporation godowns and from godowns to FPS.
10. TRANSPORTATION OF PDS FOODGRAINS
10.1 The Civil Supplies Corporation or the department where Corporation is not formed should lift the stock from the FCI godowns and deliver it to FPS for distribution. The States which have decentralised procurement scheme, supply of foodgrain can be made directly from the State godown to FPS. There should be doorstep delivery at FPS level. As far as possible, there should be no intermediate storage by the Corporation after lifting the stock from the FCI godown. This will help in reducing the cost incurred on multiple handling as well as reduce the pilferage and diversion of PDS foodgrain. Wherever possible, the Corporation can also have their own trucks for carrying of stocks from FCI/State godowns to FPS. The Corporation can also provide mobile vans for distribution of PDS items in the inaccessible areas.
10.2 Further, induction of global positioning system (GPS) technology keep a track on the movement of trucks carrying foodgrains from FCI to fair price shops. This will also enable the authority to fix responsibility on the transporter if the stock does not reach FPS at the scheduled time. Steps should also be taken to make the trucks carrying PDS foodgrain identifiable either by painting them with a specific colour or by putting banners stating that they are carrying PDS commodities.
11. VIABILITY OF FAIR PRICE SHOP
11.1 FPS run by the Corporation can sell other grocery items in addition to the PDS items and can run as a departmental store instead of FPS. This will help in cutting down the losses which are incurred by FPS while selling only PDS items. If at all, FPS incurs loss that loss will be of the Corporation and the direct responsibility of the State. Salesmen appointed by the Corporation will be paid uniform salary and will be under the rules and regulations of the Corporation.
11.2 In some States like Delhi, it was found that State Civil Supplies Corporation is earning profit from distributing/transporting PDS commodities to FPS. The Corporation may make nominal increase in the sale price of PDS commodities to adjust losses suffered due to running of FPS. FPS allotted to the cooperative/multipurpose societies must do other work apart from running FPS, so that the losses, if any, incurred from FPS might be adjusted in the earning of cooperative from other sources.
12. ACCOUNTABILITY AND MONITORING
12.1 The State Government should ensure strict monitoring of PDS. Inspection of fair price shops and godowns should be done regularly/frequently.
12.2 The allocation of PDS foodgrain to the FPS dealer should be made taking into consideration the closing balance of PDS foodgrain stock with FPS in the previous month. It was found by this Committee that 100% allocation is done to FPS without checking utilisation certificate. Hence allocations be made strictly on the basis of closing balance shown in the utilisation certificate.
12.3 It should be ensured that the stock reaches FPS during the first week of the month positively, as it is seen that in most of the States the FPS dealer is receiving the stock in the last week of the month and distribute it within 2-3 days.
12.4 Modern technology should be used for citizen participation in monitoring PDS, like registering of mobile numbers by the citizens on the website of the department so that whenever PDS commodities are dispatched to an FPS from the warehouse, an SMS/email alert service about foodgrains availability at FPS is sent to all the mobile numbers registered for that FPS. For instance in the State of Chhattisgarh, citizens can register their mobile numbers on the website of the department by selecting one or more FPSs. Whenever PDS commodities are dispatched to an FPS from the warehouse/State godown, an SMS is sent to all the mobile numbers registered for that FPS.
12.5 Social audit of FPS functioning, developing a “transparency portal” to provide information and data about PDS, setting up a toll-free call centre to monitor complaints, and digitisation of PDS beneficiary database and putting it in public domain, etc. are some of the measures which the States should introduce immediately.
12.6 The State Government should involve the Gram Panchayat, Gram Sabha, NGOs, resident welfare associations in monitoring distribution of foodgrains under PDS.
13. ALLOCATION SHOULD BE MADE ON UNIT BASIS
13.1 In many States distribution of PDS foodgrain is on the basis of ration card irrespective of the number of units (members) in the family. This appears to be rather incongruous. A single person holding ration card will get 35 kg of foodgrain every month while a family of 7 to 8 persons holding a ration card will also get 35 kg of foodgrain. This system has to be rationalised. Ration should be allotted on the basis of units or members per ration card and not on the basis of family. Generally speaking a family of 3 members is given 21 kg, a family of 6 members be given (35 + 7 kg), 7 members (35 + 7 + 7 kg) and so on.
14. VIGILANCE COMMITTEES
14.1 On paper there are many Vigilance Committees to monitor the distribution of foodgrains. But on ground these committees are non-functional and almost defunct. There is no check on the foodgrains brought by the FPS dealer or supplied to the State by FCI and distribution thereof to the beneficiaries.
14.2 Urgent action may be taken by the State authorities concerned to reactivate or reconstitute FPS-level Vigilance Committees. The process of selection and appointment of members of such committees should be transparent and should involve ration card-holders, particularly, the household women in the area. The non-political persons should be appointed in the committee. The Deputy Commissioner/Collector of a district concerned should be responsible for conducting the meeting of Vigilance Committees regularly. The Vigilance Committee should meet at least once in two months at the Collectorate on a fixed day and time. The date of such meetings should be notified for information of general public. The minutes of meeting of the committee should be prepared and a copy of the same along with the action-taken report should be sent to the department and put into public domain. To ensure that the members of the Vigilance Committees regularly attend the meetings, a token fee or remuneration should be paid to them for participation in the meeting. If the Vigilance Committees receive any complaint from beneficiaries, the same shall be forwarded/reported to the department and follow up the action taken on the complaints received.
15. COMPLAINT MECHANISM
15.1 Lok Adalat
15.1.1 In view of the large number of complaints received by the general public, a separate Lok Adalat on lines of Telephone/Electricity Lok Adalats should be established for PDS issues for every district of the country. The Collector/Additional Collector of district concerned should conduct the Lok Adalat to be associated with the officer heading the District or Taluk level Legal Services Authority. The matters raised in the Lok Adalats must be decided in a time-bound manner.
15.2 Ombudsman/Regulator
15.2.1 A post of Ombudsman/Regulator should be set up to regulate the working of PDS at Central level. They may be authorised to issue directions suo motu or on complaints for improvement of PDS. At the Central level the Regulator can call for the reports from the States on various issues brought to the notice of the Ombudsman/Regulator. The State Government may also create such type of institutions as Regulator to oversee the functioning of PDS in the State.
15.3 Toll-free complaint number
15.3.1 A toll-free number based on IVR and a separate call centre should be established to register the complaints and redressal thereof to the beneficiary.
16. ALLOTMENT OF FAIR PRICE SHOP
16.1 State Civil Supplies Corporation should open and operate the fair price shop. The advantage of FPS being run by the State-level Corporation is that they have to abide by various rules and directions issued by the department from time to time. FPS will open and close on time, maintain proper record, charging the correct price, etc. As salesman is an employee of the Corporation, he has to abide by the rules and regulations of the Corporation.
16.2 FPS may also be allotted to cooperative societies, registered women self-help group and Upbhokta Bhandar/kirana/grocery shop subject to the financial viability of such units. The necessary condition is that the cooperative must be doing other work apart from running FPS. Wherever a shop is given to a cooperative, it should be under the control of two departments viz. Civil Supplies Department and the Cooperative Department Role of both the departments should be clearly specified. The Cooperative Department should regularly audit, inspect, maintain the records of society, etc.
17. AWARENESS OF BENEFICIARIES
17.1 To create awareness among the people at the lowest level following steps can be taken:
(i) A press release, in vernacular, should be issued at the beginning of the month indicating the quantity of PDS items released to the various FPS dealers in the district also indicating entitlement of various categories along with the price/rate of the commodities which the FPS dealer is to charge from the beneficiaries.
(ii) Local TV channels may also be requested to show the details as mentioned at (a) above on their scroll to create the awareness among the people.
(iii) Hoardings be displayed at prominent places and pamphlets may be distributed in the schools/colleges and in general public giving the above information to make people aware of their entitlement.
(iv) The monthly entitlement of the beneficiary along with the rates of the commodities must also be stamped/printed on the ration cards so that the beneficiaries are not cheated by the FPS dealers.
(v) Toll-free complaint/enquiry number along with the address of Ombudsman should be stamped on each ration card.
18. VIGILANCE AND ENFORCEMENT
18.1 There should be zero tolerance approach in the matter of enforcement of various provisions of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955; the Public Distribution System (Control) Order, 2001 and the Prevention of Blackmarketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980. There are certain areas in the country where residents depend exclusively on PDS foodgrain. It is therefore essential that proper supply of PDS foodgrain is maintained. The provisions of these: the Prevention of Blackmarketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980 be invoked whenever there is any threat to disrupt supply of PDS foodgrain. The District Magistrate/Collector has to be made responsible for maintaining regular supply of PDS foodgrain. The cases of diversion or blackmarketing of PDS foodgrains either by FPS or by transporter or by the officials of the department should be tried under these Acts. The Fast Track Courts should be set up to try offences under these Acts.
18.2 There is need to strengthen the prosecution machinery. Often it was observed that once FIR is lodged then department never follows the same. They just appear in court if court summons for witness. In many cases when officers get transferred or retired other officers hardly know about the matter and the file is just kept as a record. In every district there should be some designated department officer who should be responsible to follow the prosecution matters. Special squads be set up by the State consisting of persons from the administration and the police and should be placed directly under the District Magistrate/Collector. These squads should carry out surprise checks and be responsible for launching criminal prosecution against officials of the department, FPSs, etc.
19. FUNCTIONING OF FAIR PRICE SHOP (FPS)
19.1 PDS foodgrain should reach FPS in the first week in a month and FPS should be open daily. FPS opening and closing timings should be fixed and followed by FPS dealer. The provisions of the PDS (Control) Order, 2001 should be strictly followed in the State. Sale centres/fair price shop must display information regarding number of APL, BPL and AAY ration cards attached with FPS, scale of foodgrains for the month, rate list, stock received during the month, opening/closing balance on each day, time of opening and closing of sale centre/FPS and the authority for redressal of grievances or lodging of complaints, etc. The FPS dealer should also maintain the stock register, issue register, list of BPL/AAY beneficiaries, toll-free number/name and telephone number of designated officer for lodging the complaint by the public, display sample of foodgrain, etc.
20. SUPPLY OF FORTIFIED ATTA (WHEAT FLOUR)
20.1 In order to check the diversion of PDS wheat, fortified wheat flour be supplied under PDS instead of wheat. Since the shelf-life of wheat flour is limited to 45-60 days only, safeguards should be taken to maintain the quality of wheat flour. Opposition to supply of wheat flour instead of wheat comes from FPS only. In many States visited by the Committee, beneficiaries want wheat flour and not wheat due to non-availability of atta chakkis in the neighbourhood and also saving of time on getting wheat grinded from the chakkis. The distribution of atta under TPDS also keeps a check on inflationary trend in the market. Various brands of atta in the market are sold at the rate of Rs 18-20 per kg. Many States like the State of Himachal Pradesh, Rajasthan, West Bengal, etc. are issuing wheat flour under PDS to the beneficiaries at the rate Rs 9-10 per kg. The States/UTs have to ensure that modern dedicated mills should be engaged for grinding wheat into fortified atta. The dedicated mills and the atta produced should have the Agmark [Agricultural Produce (Grading and Marking) Act, 1937]. Atta should be packed in small packs of 5 kg or 10 kg poly to poly bag. The details like date of packing, expiry, etc. should be clearly printed on the atta bags. It should always be consumed within 45 days of manufacture.
20.2 The provisions of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act and the Packaging and Measurement Act should be strictly observed. It must be understood that an adulterator can cause great harm to the health of the public and the responsibility in the case will have to be fixed.
21. ELIMINATION OF BOGUS AND FAKE RATION CARDS
21.1 Bogus/fake/ghost ration cards are in circulation in almost every State and it is a major source of diversion of precious PDS foodgrain. This fact is well known to the FPS owner and the officials of the department. A strong drive has to be undertaken to weed out such cards. To check this menace, an amnesty scheme may be adopted. Under this scheme, one month's time will be given for surrender of bogus/fake ration cards. After this period, a door-to-door verification should be conducted by utilising the services of the Legal Aid Services Authority. Any bogus card found during survey should be cancelled and punitive action be taken including filing of FIR against the card-holder, FPS dealer and the ration card issuing authority/official of the department concerned. Record of FPS will be checked and in case it is found that any particular ration card has not been used, it may stand cancelled. Any application received for restoration of ration cards will be considered by a committee of lawyers appointed by the Legal Aid Services Authority of tehsil or district. If it is found that absence of card-holders to draw ration was on bona fide ground, the card may be restored.
22. ELECTRONIC WEIGHMENT
22.1 There must be an electronic weighment system connected to the online computerised system at every FCI and block godown of the State. At the FPS level the same may be integrated to the point of sale device as suggested in the separate report on computerisation. Only computer generated weight check memos and truck chit should be issued.
23. ISSUANCE OF RATION CARDS
23.1 In many districts the ration cards had been issued more than 10 years ago and are in extremely poor and unusable conditions. This gives the FPS dealer an excuse to avoid making entries in the card. At many places the Committee found that the ration cards of the beneficiaries had been deposited at the tehsil office/FPS for renewal but had not been issued to the beneficiaries for months. The beneficiaries are left without cards for months together and cannot claim their PDS entitlement. The drive to issue fresh ration cards should be accelerated. Ration cards should be renewed regularly after due verifications. Any addition/deletion or any alteration in the ration card should be done in a time-bound manner.
24. IMPLEMENTATION OF THE SUPREME COURT ORDERS
24.1 The Hon'ble Supreme Court has issued various orders pertaining to transparency and proper functioning of the Public Distribution System. These orders should be properly implemented in the country.
25. ALLOCATION OF PDS FOODGRAIN FROM CENTRE TO STATES/UTs SHOULD BE DONE ON THE BASIS OF PROJECTED POPULATION, 2012
25.1 Under TPDS, the Central Government is allocating foodgrain to the States/UTs on the basis of projected population of 2000. In the year 2000 the projected population of India was 99 crores. In 2012, the population of India is estimated as 122 crores. The Government of India claims that it provides additional/ad hoc allocation from time to time which covers this population gap. But the reality is this additional/ad hoc foodgrain seldom reaches the beneficiaries. No advertisement is given for this additional/ad hoc foodgrain and most of the time this additional/ad hoc foodgrain is diverted into the black market with the nexus of the FPS dealers and corrupt officials. Allocation of PDS foodgrain from the Centre to the States/UTs should be done on the basis of 2012 projected population. Additional/ad hoc foodgrain under TPDS should be stopped.
26. JOINT SAMPLING
26.1 The system of supply of sealed sample packets by FCI to the State godowns and thereafter to FPS should be rigorously followed to ensure that PDS foodgrain is not substituted by inferior quality foodgrains.
27. ABOLITION OF APL CATEGORY
27.1 Many APL families do not lift their PDS ration from FPS. This foodgrain is diverted into black market. The Government of India heavily subsidises the cost of foodgrains issued to APL families. Allocations are made to APL families at subsidised rates of Rs 6.10 per kg and Rs 8.30 per kg for wheat and rice respectively. It involves subsidy of more than Rs 9 per kg on wheat and Rs 12 per kg on rice.
27.2 The Committee has recommended in its various reports that APL category should be abolished as it is a source of diversion of foodgrains into the black market. While suggesting abolition of APL category, the Committee also mentioned that if the Court was of the view that it may not be possible or desirable to abolish the APL category altogether, it may consider limiting the APL category to households whose annual income is Rs one lakh. This category may be called “marginally above poverty line (MAPL)”. During the course of hearing of this petition it was suggested that this figure of rupees one lakh could be considered to be enhanced to rupees two to three lakhs. On the recommendation of the Committee, a notice was issued to the Central Government on abolition of APL to which the Central Government filed an affidavit through Ms Alka Sirohi, the then Secretary, Department of Food and Public Distribution, Government of India. It is apparent from the affidavit of the Central Government that “allocation for APL category may be continued till the finalisation of the proposed law on food security”.
28. SPECIAL MEASURES FOR THE POOREST DISTRICTS AND VULNERABLE SECTIONS OF THE SOCIETY IN THE COUNTRY
28.1 Additional ad hoc allocation
28.1.1 The Hon'ble Supreme Court by the order dated 14-5-2011 (2013) 2 SCC 684 while considering various problems affecting the distribution of PDS foodgrains directed the Central Government to reserve 5 million tonnes of foodgrains for distribution to 150 poorest districts and vulnerable sections of the society in the country. This task was given to the Central Vigilance Committee. This 5 million tonnes of foodgrains was to be distributed to 150 poorest districts or small pockets in our country where majority of people of that district live in penury on the recommendation of the Committee.
28.1.2 In order to comply with the directions of the Hon'ble Court, the Committee requested Planning Commission to provide list of 150 poorest districts in the country. The Planning Commission provided two lists viz. a list of 150 most backward districts identified for implementation of the National Food for Work Programme and another list of 147 districts for launching Rashtriya Sam Vikas Yojana. The Committee combined both the lists and identified 174 poorest districts. Thereafter requests were received from some States to include some more districts as the poorest districts in their respective States. Accordingly, 205 districts were identified as the poorest. Allocation of foodgrains was to be made to these districts out of 5 million tonnes foodgrain placed at the disposal of the Committee.
28.1.3 Parameters for allotment were arrived at a meeting with the officers of the Central Government and representatives of the petitioner. Out of 50 lakh tonnes, 43.11 lakh tonnes of foodgrain has so far been allocated to these 205 districts during 2011-2012 and 2012-2013. The period of this additional allocation shall be extended keeping in view the lifting position and request received from the States/UTs.
28.2 Community kitchen/Dal Bhat Kendra
28.2.1 Considering the need of vulnerable sections of the society who do not have enough money even to buy subsidised foodgrains or are too weak to get the allotment and to buy foodgrains, the Committee has devised a scheme for providing cooked food to the poorer segments of our society at nominal cost or free in the backward districts of the country with the help of corporates/PSUs working in those areas under the Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Programme. The Scheme envisages that community kitchens would be run at selected areas, both urban and rural, in the district headquarters like Collectorates, city hospitals, bus-stops or provide cooked food through vans which will take cooked food to pockets inhabited by poor and vulnerable people. The Scheme is being implemented with the active participation of the District Magistrates.
28.2.2 To begin with, the Community Kitchen have been set up under CSR in the States of Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Himachal Pradesh, Odisha and Uttarakhand near district hospitals for providing cooked food on nominal cost or free to the attendants of the poor patients admitted in these hospitals. These attendants accompany the poor patients from distant places with scarce resources to fend themselves against hunger.
28.2.3 While the District Administration will create necessary infrastructure for these kitchens, the Government will provide foodgrains on highly subsidised rates. However, to meet the administrative expenditure for running these kitchens like expenditure on vegetables, pulses, fuel, etc. financial help of PSUs in various States may be sought. It can be run with the help of NGO working in the area with proven track record. The District Magistrate/Collector of the district concerned should be made in charge for running these kitchens smoothly and effectively.
28.3 Free food coupons
28.3.1 During visits to the poorest districts in various States, the Committee found that there are many families who are living in penury. For the persons who hold cards under the AAY Scheme but are unable to purchase foodgrains even at subsidised rates; or those persons who do not fall under AAY Scheme/Annapurna Anna Yojna Scheme or any similar scheme implemented by the State Government but are living in state of penury and are unable to obtain foodgrains by their own means, 10 food cards/coupons should be given to each Gram Panchayat in all the poorest and backward districts to meet any emergency situation. In an emergent situation, the Gram Panchayat/Tahsildar/SDM may issue food cards/coupons to such affected persons entitling them to receive 10 kg foodgrains per card/coupon per month free of cost on presenting/tendering of card or coupon, as the case may be, to the FPS dealer. At the end of the month, number of cards/coupons distributed by the Gram Panchayat/Tahsildar/SDM will be replenished and the FPS dealer shall be provided additional foodgrains accordingly.
Alert