Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Lml Limited v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 22, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner made a reference under Section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (the “1985 Act”) on 8-9-2006, which was registered by the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) on 15-9-2006. Around September 2006, Respondent 3 filed a claim before the Industries Facilitation Council, Kanpur under Section 6 of the Interest on Delayed Payments to Small Scale and Ancillary Industrial Undertakings Act, 1993 (the “1993 Act”) for recovery of Rs 17,37,994.40 with interest for unpaid supplies. During the pendency of those proceedings, the 1993 Act was replaced by the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 (the “2006 Act”).

After registration of the BIFR reference, BIFR passed an order on 8-5-2007 directing secured/unsecured creditors not to file or pursue suits already filed, with a caveat that non-compliance by the petitioner could lead BIFR to reconsider its decision. Subsequently, on 22-12-2008, the Council made an award in favour of Respondent 3 directing payment of Rs 28,44,711.55 and compound interest on the principal.

The petitioner challenged the award under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (the “1996 Act”) before the District Judge, Kanpur Nagar. On 12-5-2011, the District Judge directed the petitioner to deposit 75% of the awarded amount within a month, stating that failure would render the Section 34 petition defective and liable to dismissal as not maintainable. The petitioner challenged that order before the Allahabad High Court; a Single Judge dismissed the writ petition on 30-8-2011. The special leave petition challenged the High Court’s order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner's failure to make the 75% deposit directed by the District Judge (in the Section 34 challenge to the Council award) should result in dismissal of the Section 34 petition as not maintainable, in the context of pending BIFR proceedings under the 1985 Act.
  2. Whether the court needed to decide the question of law: whether “pre-deposit” under Section 19 of the 2006 Act is covered by “execution, distress or the like” under Section 22(1) of the 1985 Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner submitted that finalisation of a scheme under Section 18 of the 1985 Act was at an advanced stage before BIFR.

Respondent 3's Arguments/Concessions

  • Respondent 3 conceded that so long as proceedings remain pending before BIFR under the 1985 Act, the award dated 22-12-2008 cannot be enforced in light of this Court’s decisions in Jay Engg. Works Ltd. v. Industry Facilitation Council (2006) 8 SCC 677 and Morgan Securities & Credit (P) Ltd. v. Modi Rubber Ltd. (2006) 12 SCC 642.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jay Engg. Works Ltd. v. Industry Facilitation Council (2006) 8 SCC 677 That, while proceedings are pending before BIFR under the 1985 Act, the award cannot be enforced. Noted via Respondent 3’s concession to support the position that enforcement of the award is barred while BIFR proceedings continue.
Morgan Securities & Credit (P) Ltd. v. Modi Rubber Ltd. (2006) 12 SCC 642 That, while proceedings are pending before BIFR under the 1985 Act, the award cannot be enforced. Relied on (through Respondent 3’s concession) as part of the basis for the Court to avoid deciding the broader statutory interpretation question and to mould relief regarding the deposit condition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted, but declined to decide, the legal question whether “pre-deposit” under Section 19 of the 2006 Act falls within “execution, distress or the like” under Section 22(1) of the 1985 Act. Instead, the Court proceeded on the basis of the position accepted before it: Respondent 3 conceded that, while BIFR proceedings under the 1985 Act remain pending, the award dated 22-12-2008 cannot be enforced, relying on the Court’s earlier decisions.

Having regard to that position, the Court held it unnecessary to enter into the framed question of law. It considered that the “interest of justice” would be met by protecting the petitioner’s Section 34 challenge from being dismissed solely due to non-compliance with the District Judge’s direction to deposit 75% of the award amount. The Court further directed that the Section 34 petition may remain pending with the District Judge until BIFR finalises the scheme under Section 18 of the 1985 Act.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF: The special leave petition was disposed of with directions that failure to deposit the amount as directed by the District Judge on 12-5-2011 shall not result in dismissal of the petitioner’s Section 34 arbitration petition challenging the award dated 22-12-2008, and that the Section 34 petition may remain pending until finalisation of the scheme by BIFR under Section 18 of the 1985 Act.

Respondent 3 was granted liberty to apply to BIFR to be heard before finalisation of the scheme, and the Court directed that if such an application is made, BIFR shall hear Respondent 3 before finalisation of the scheme or before any order terminating proceedings under the 1985 Act. The order primarily affects the parties’ procedural positions (non-dismissal for non-deposit and continued pendency of the Section 34 petition pending BIFR action); the Court expressly avoided deciding the broader statutory interpretation question and therefore did not set out any new legal rule on that issue.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. We have heard Mr M.L Lahoty, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr Manoj Goel, learned counsel for Respondent 3.

2. We do not think that in the present case, it is necessary to deal with the question of law, whether the expression “pre-deposit” used in Section 19 of the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 (for short “the 2006 Act”) is covered within the expression “execution, distress or the like” in Section 22(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (for short “the 1985 Act”).

3. Bereft of unnecessary details, suffice it to say that the petitioner made a reference under Section 15(1) of the 1985 Act on 8-9-2006. The Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) registered the reference on 15-9-2006. Somewhere in September 2006, Respondent 3 filed a claim petition before the Industries Facilitation Council, Kanpur (for short “the Council”) under Section 6 of the Interest on Delayed Payments to Small Scale and Ancillary Industrial Undertakings Act, 1993 (for short “the 1993 Act”) to recover the amount of Rs 17,37,994.40 along with interest for the supply of parts made to the petitioner Company payment of which was not made.

4. The 1993 Act was replaced by the 2006 Act during the pendency of the proceedings. After the reference was registered, on 8-5-2007, BIFR passed an order, inter alia, directing the secured/unsecured creditors not to file or pursue the suits already filed. It was further made clear that if the directions/guidelines are not complied with by the petitioner Company within the given time-frame, BIFR would reconsider its decision.

5. Subsequent to the above order of 8-5-2007, on 22-12-2008, the Council passed an award in favour of Respondent 3. It was held that the petitioner would pay a sum of Rs 28,44,711.55 and compound interest on the principal amount to Respondent 3. The award has been challenged by the petitioner under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short “the 1996 Act”) before the District Judge, Kanpur Nagar.

6. On 12-5-2011 the District Judge directed the petitioner to deposit 75% of the amount awarded by the Council within a month. It was further directed that failure to deposit the amount would render the petition defective and was liable to be dismissed as not maintainable. This order was challenged by the petitioner before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad. The Single Judge of that Court has dismissed Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 31008 of 2011 the writ petition with certain observations on 30-8-2011. It is this order which is under challenge in the special leave petition.

7. Mr M.L Lahoty, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that as the matter stands today, the finalisation of scheme under Section 18 of the 1985 Act is at advanced stage before BIFR.

8. Mr Manoj Goel, learned counsel for Respondent 3 has conceded before us that so long as the proceedings remain pending before BIFR under the 1985 Act, the award dated 22-12-2008 cannot be enforced by Respondent 3 in light of this Court's decisions in Jay Engg. Works Ltd. v. Industry Facilitation Council (2006) 8 SCC 677 and Morgan Securities & Credit (P) Ltd. v. Modi Rubber Ltd. (2006) 12 SCC 642

9. Having regard to the above position, we are satisfied that this is not a case where we should go into the legal question noted by us in the beginning of our order. We are satisfied that interest of justice shall be subserved if it is directed that failure to deposit the amount as directed by the District Judge, Kanpur Nagar in its order dated 12-5-2011 would not result in dismissal of the arbitration petition filed by the petitioner under Section 34 of the 1996 Act challenging the award dated 22-12-2008. The said arbitration petition may remain pending with the District Judge until the finalisation of scheme by BIFR under Section 18 of the 1985 Act. We order accordingly.

10. The special leave petition is disposed of as above. Respondent 3 is granted liberty to apply to BIFR to hear it before finalisation of the scheme. We observe that if such an application is made, BIFR shall hear Respondent 3 before finalisation of the scheme or any other order that may be passed by BIFR terminating the proceedings under 1985 Act.

Court Masters