- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Centre For Environmental Law, World Wide Fund-India v. Union Of India And Others (For Intervention)
Factual and Procedural Background
The order records proceedings in multiple interlocutory applications connected with Writ Petition (Civil) No. 337 of 1995 and Writ Petition (Civil) No. 202 of 1995, and also an application in SLPs (C) Nos. 19628-29 of 2009. In the WP (C) No. 202 of 1995 connected IA, the Court took up an application for directions filed by the learned amicus curiae concerning the proposed import and introduction of African cheetahs from Namibia into Palpur Kuno Sanctuary, Madhya Pradesh, alongside the pending issue of re-introduction of lions in Kuno Sanctuary (stated to have been held up for the last two decades). The Court heard the amicus curiae and the learned Additional Solicitor General for the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF), and queried whether the National Board for Wildlife (NBWL) had taken any decision on cheetah introduction.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether any decision/opinion of the National Board for Wildlife (NBWL) exists regarding introduction of African cheetahs from Namibia into Palpur Kuno Sanctuary, and whether such NBWL opinion is a legal requirement for the proposed introduction under Section 5-C of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972.
- Whether MoEF’s proposed import/introduction of cheetahs into Palpur Kuno Sanctuary should be stayed pending the Court’s final decision on re-introduction of lions in Kuno Sanctuary.
Arguments of the Parties
Learned Amicus Curiae's Submissions
- It was stated that the decision to introduce African cheetahs from Namibia into the proposed habitat had not been placed before the Standing Committee of the NBWL, and that only feasibility studies had been undertaken with no deliberations or considered decision of the Board/Standing Committee available in the public domain.
- Relying on Section 5-C of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972, it was submitted that NBWL opinion is a legal requirement for introduction of cheetahs from Namibia into India, and that no such decision had been taken or placed before the Court.
- Scientific material was referenced for the proposition that introduction of an alien species should be considered only if no native species is suitable; that Kuno Sanctuary is not a natural habitat for African cheetah; that limiting factors in the native range should be studied by competent ecologists before introduction; and that issues such as man-animal conflict, prey base sufficiency, and lion-cheetah coexistence require detailed scientific study, with priority to preservation of native species.
MoEF / Additional Solicitor General / MoEF Officer's Position
- On the Court’s specific query, the Joint Director of MoEF present in Court stated that no decision had been taken by NBWL so far on introduction of cheetahs to Palpur Kuno Sanctuary, though the issue had been placed before it.
- In a separate set of IAs (IAs Nos. 3450-51 in IAs Nos. 3297-99 in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995), MoEF’s counsel sought time to obtain instructions.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court perused the amicus curiae’s application, annexures, and other scientific materials, and heard the amicus curiae and the learned Additional Solicitor General for MoEF. It directly inquired whether NBWL had taken any decision on introducing African cheetahs into Palpur Kuno Sanctuary; the MoEF officer stated that no NBWL decision had been taken so far. The Court noted the submission that Section 5-C of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 makes NBWL opinion a legal requirement for such introduction, and recorded scientific concerns raised regarding alien species introduction, suitability of Kuno as habitat, ecological study requirements, potential man-animal conflict, prey base adequacy, and coexistence with lions. In view of these considerations and the pending final decision on re-introduction of lions in Kuno Sanctuary, the Court stayed MoEF’s decision to import cheetahs for introduction into Palpur Kuno Sanctuary and directed MoEF to produce relevant materials and decisions, if any, relating to studies and NBWL deliberations.
Holding and Implications
STAY GRANTED: The Court stayed MoEF’s decision to import African cheetahs from Namibia for introduction into Palpur Kuno Sanctuary until the Court takes a final decision on re-introduction of lions in Kuno Sanctuary.
DIRECTIONS ISSUED: MoEF was directed to produce before the Court relevant materials and decisions, if any, relating to studies undertaken and deliberations made by NBWL. The Court also suo motu impleaded the States of Gujarat and Madhya Pradesh as parties to the application, directed service of the application on their counsel, and ordered listing “after vacation.”
FURTHER LISTINGS / DISPOSAL IN OTHER MATTERS: In IA No. 100 in WP (C) No. 337 of 1995, arguments were inconclusive and the matter was listed on 2-7-2012. In IAs Nos. 3450-51 (connected with WP (C) No. 202 of 1995), MoEF’s counsel sought instructions and the matter was posted on 2-7-2012. In SLPs (C) Nos. 19628-29 of 2009, the application was DISPOSED OF, leaving the State to act in accordance with law.
The direct effect of the stay is to halt the cheetah import/introduction into Palpur Kuno Sanctuary pending the Court’s final decision on lion re-introduction in Kuno and pending production of relevant NBWL-related materials; the order does not indicate that it sets any new precedent.
Order
301. Part-heard
IA No. 100 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 337 of 1995
1. Arguments remained inconclusive. List on 2-7-2012.
IA No. … in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995
2. Taken on Board. Perused the application for directions filed by the learned amicus curiae and also gone through Annexures A-1 to A-4 and other scientific materials placed before us.
3. We have heard the learned amicus curiae as well as the learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF).
4. The learned amicus curiae has drawn our attention to Para 3 of the application which reads as follows:
“It is reliably learnt that the decision to introduce African cheetahs from Namibia into the same proposed habitat chosen for re-introduction of lions from Gir has not been either placed before the Standing Committee of the National Board for Wildlife, nor has a considered decision been taken in this regard. Only feasibility studies have been undertaken, no deliberations conducted and no decision taken by the Board or its Standing Committee is available on the public domain.”
5. We have put a specific question to Mr P.P Malhotra, learned Additional Solicitor General in the presence of the officer of MoEF as to whether any decision has been taken by the National Board for Wildlife on the question of introduction of African cheetahs from Namibia to Palpur Kuno Sanctuary in the State of Madhya Pradesh. The Joint Director of MoEF who is present in the Court submitted that no decision has been taken by NBWL on the issue of introduction of cheetahs to Palpur Kuno Sanctuary so far, though placed before it.
6. The learned amicus has drawn our attention to Section 5-C of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972, according to which, for introduction of cheetahs from Namibia into India, opinion of the National Board for Wildlife is a legal requirement. No such decision has been taken so far, nor placed before the Court. Scientific study reveals that introduction of an alien species be considered only if no native specie is considered suitable for the purpose for which the introduction is being made. Kuno Sanctuary is not a natural habitat for African cheetah. Experts say, no species be considered for introduction to a new habitat until the factors which limit its distribution and abundance in the native range have been studied and understood by competent ecologists. Further, we have also to examine whether there will be man-animal conflict in Kuno on cheetah introduction? Again question may arise, whether there is sufficient prey base for all the species to survive? Whether both lions and cheetahs can co-exist is a matter which requires detailed scientific study. Priority has to be given for preservation of our own species.
7. We are, therefore, constrained to stay the decision of MoEF to import cheetahs from Namibia into India for introducing them to Palpur Kuno Sanctuary till we take a final decision on the question of re-introduction of lions in Kuno Sanctuary, a project which has been held for the last two decades. We direct MoEF to produce before the Court relevant materials and decisions, if any, relating to studies undertaken and deliberations made by the National Board for Wildlife on this matter.
8. We suo motu implead the State of Gujarat as well as the State of Madhya Pradesh as parties to this application. The applicant is directed to serve a copy of the application on the counsel representing the State of Gujarat and the State of Madhya Pradesh. List after vacation.
302. IAs Nos. 3450-51 in IAs Nos. 3297-99 in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995
9. The learned counsel appearing for MoEF wants to seek instructions. Post on 2-7-2012.
303. IAs Nos. … in SLPs (C) Nos. 19628-29 of 2009
10. The application is disposed of leaving the State to take action in accordance with law.
Court Masters
Alert