- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Prabhu Narain And Others v. State Of U.P And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners, former work-charged employees of the respondent State authorities, filed a writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution seeking a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to grant them pensionary and other retiral benefits upon attaining the age of superannuation. They relied on this Court’s earlier decision in Raj Narain Prasad v. State of U.P., (1998) 8 SCC 473, contending that the judgment entitled them to regularisation of service and, consequently, to pension. The respondents filed a detailed counter-affidavit asserting that although more than 5000 work-charged employees had been regularised between 1997 and 2000 pursuant to the said judgment, work-charged employees are governed by separate financial rules that do not grant pension, though gratuity is paid on superannuation. After considering the pleadings and oral submissions, the Court delivered the present order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioners, as work-charged employees whose services were never regularised, were entitled to pensionary benefits under any existing rule or scheme.
- Whether the failure or delay of the respondents to regularise the petitioners’ services, allegedly in violation of Raj Narain Prasad, entitled the petitioners to pension as a consequential relief.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The judgment in Raj Narain Prasad mandated regularisation of similarly situated work-charged employees; the petitioners fulfilled all criteria of the approved scheme.
- Because the respondents “slept over” or delayed regularisation, the petitioners were unjustly denied pension despite long years of service.
- The principle of “last come, first go” was ignored—juniors were allegedly regularised ahead of the petitioners, amounting to discrimination.
Respondents' Arguments
- The writ petition does not identify any breached fundamental right or specific rule entitling the petitioners to pension.
- Work-charged employees are governed by paragraphs 458-463 and 667-669 of the Financial Handbook, Volume VI, read with Articles 361 and 370 of the Civil Services Regulations, which exclude pension but allow gratuity.
- Pursuant to Raj Narain Prasad, more than 5000 work-charged employees have been duly regularised; the petitioners failed to show any instance where juniors were preferred over them.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Raj Narain Prasad v. State of U.P., (1998) 8 SCC 473 | Regularisation of work-charged employees who satisfy the scheme’s criteria. | The Court observed that this case dealt solely with regularisation and did not confer an automatic right to pension; it served only as a possible ground for seeking regularisation, which the petitioners had not specifically pursued. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court distinguished between two separate claims: (a) regularisation of service and (b) entitlement to pension. It noted that:
- Raj Narain Prasad addressed only the issue of regularisation; pension entitlement was not part of that judgment.
- The petitioners supplied no rule, regulation or scheme that conferred pensionary rights on work-charged employees. Despite the respondents’ explicit challenge on this point, the petitioners failed to identify any legal basis in their rejoinder.
- Entitlement to pension presupposes either regularisation or an express statutory provision. As the petitioners’ services remained unregularised, and no pension-conferring rule applied to work-charged staff, the claim lacked foundational merit.
- If the petitioners felt aggrieved by non-regularisation, they could have sought relief limited to that issue, with supporting particulars such as the identity of juniors allegedly regularised ahead of them. No such particulars were pleaded.
- Given these deficiencies, the Court saw no legal basis to grant the mandamus sought.
Holding and Implications
WRIT PETITION DISMISSED.
Immediate Effect: The petitioners receive no pensionary benefits; costs are not awarded. Broader Implications: The order reaffirms that work-charged employees cannot claim pension absent regularisation or an explicit statutory provision, and that Raj Narain Prasad does not, by itself, create a right to pension.
Order
1. In this writ petition filed under Article 32 of the Constitution the petitioners have sought for issuance of an appropriate writ, direction and order in the nature of mandamus inter alia commanding the respondents to grant the petitioners all the pensionary/retiral benefits consequent upon attaining the age of superannuation and for any other appropriate direction as considered suitable in the given circumstances of the case. The petitioners claim that they had been the work-charged employees of the respondents; they had put in a very long service and attained the age of superannuation. In the light of earlier judgment of this Court in the case of Raj Narain Prasad v. State of U.P (1998) 8 SCC 473 the petitioners claim that they were entitled to be regularised in service as they have satisfied all the requirements to come within the scheme approved by this Court. They contend that because the respondents failed to implement the judgment and order aforementioned in letter and spirit, their services were not regularised. Had the respondents followed the directions given in the said judgment, they could have been regularised and consequently, they would have been entitled to grant of pension by taking their length of service into consideration. The respondents have filed a detailed counter-affidavit resisting the claim made by the petitioners in the writ petition. In the counter-affidavit it is pointed out that about 7744 employees were work-charged employees and 5516 muster roll employees; pursuant to the direction given by this Court and in terms of the schemes, the services of more than 5000 work-charged employees have been regularised since the years 1997 to 2000. In paragraph (D) of the counter-affidavit in regard to the pensionary benefits, it is stated thus:
“(D) As regards the pensionary benefits, the work-charged employees are not entitled to the same because their services are different from the services of the regular employees. The services of work-charged employees are governed by provisions of para 669 of the Financial Handbook read with Articles 361 and 370 of the Civil Services Regulations and as such the work-charged employees are not entitled to the pensionary benefits. The petitioners are not entitled to any pensionary benefits. From a perusal of the abovementioned provisions it is evident that the petitioners are not entitled to any pensionary benefits and in these circumstances, no relief can be granted to the petitioners as regards pensionary benefits. It may be pointed out that the provisions of the Financial Handbook and Civil Services Regulations have not been challenged by the petitioners in these writ petitions.
A true and correct copy of relevant paras of the U.P Financial Handbook is annexed and marked as Annexure R-2.
The gratuity amount is being paid on completing superannuation age by work-charged employees.”
2. In the said paragraph it is also stated that work-charged employees are entitled to gratuity and the same is being paid to them on their attaining the age of superannuation. It is again pointed out in paragraph 11 of the counter-affidavit that the services of work-charged employees are somewhat different from the services of the regular employees. The services of the work-charged employees are governed by the Financial Handbook, Vol. VI, paras 458 to 463 and 667 to 669, read with Articles 361 and 370 of the Civil Services Regulations. In their reply, the stand of the respondents is that the petitioners are not entitled to any pensionary benefits.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioners strongly contended that having regard to the judgment of this Court in Raj Narain case (1998) 8 SCC 473 aforementioned, the petitioners were certainly entitled to regularisation of their services having regard to the length of their services and taking note that they had satisfied the requirement of the scheme; merely because the respondent slept over or delayed regularisation of their services, they cannot be denied the pensionary benefits. He further urged that the principle of “last come must first go” should have been considered by the respondents. In the case of the petitioners the respondents have discriminated in not regularising their services.
4. In opposition, the learned counsel for the respondents pointed out to the averments made in the writ petition that it is not shown as to what fundamental right or rules were breached by the respondents in relation to the petitioners; it is also not shown under what rules the petitioners are entitled to pension. The learned counsel added that the respondents have, pursuant to the directions given and observations made in Raj Narain case (1998) 8 SCC 473 taken steps and services of more than 5000 work-charged employees have been regularised in that regard; it is not shown by any specific instance if the services of juniors to the petitioners have been regularised ignoring their claims. Under the circumstances, without showing any foundation for the claim for pension no relief can be granted to the petitioners.
5. We have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties. It is clear from the averments made in the writ petition that the petitioners have not shown as to what is the basis for their claim of pension. There are two things: one is the claim for the regularisation of their services and the other is the claim for grant of pension. The earlier judgment of this Court in the case of Raj Narain (1998) 8 SCC 473 aforementioned relates only to regularisation of services. If the petitioners had any grievance regarding regularisation of their services and if their services were not regularised early or ignoring their claim services of any juniors were considered, it was open to them to seek appropriate relief based on the judgment of this Court claiming regularisation of their services from a particular date. That is not the claim made in the writ petition. No details or particulars are given as to who are those juniors whose services were regularised in preference to the services of the petitioners. No doubt pension is not a bounty, it is a valuable right given to an employee, but, in the first place it must be shown that the employee is entitled to pension under a particular rule or the scheme, as the case may be. In spite of the fact that in the counter-affidavit it is stated that no rule is quoted by the petitioners to say that under a particular rule they are entitled to grant of pension. In the rejoinder filed the petitioners have also not stated as to under what rules they are entitled to pension. Some of the petitioners, as we are told, have already attained the age of superannuation. We do not have material before us to say that under what scheme the respondents could consider the petitioners for regularisation of their services and if so, from what date. It is stated that more than 5000 work-charged employees have already been regularised. If the petitioners had any grievance of non-regularisation of their services, as already observed, it was/is open for them to claim the appropriate relief, but, one thing is clear that unless the petitioners' services are regularised in the first place, we find it difficult as to how they can claim pension.
6. Under these circumstances, from any angle we do not find any merit in this writ petition, as a result the writ petition is dismissed with no order as to costs.
Alert