Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Paras Ram Gupta By Lrs. v. Ram Asrey .

Supreme Court Of India
Oct 19, 2000
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The matter arises from a dispute concerning Booth No. 164, Sector 35-C, Chandigarh. Ram Asrey (son of Aschraj Lal) entered into an agreement for sale in favour of Paras Ram Gupta on 23-10-1972 and executed a power of attorney in Paras Ram Gupta's favour the same day. On 24-5-1984, Ram Asrey revoked that power of attorney. Paras Ram Gupta then filed a suit seeking a declaration that the general power of attorney executed and registered by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff was valid and enforceable, and also sought a permanent injunction restraining the defendant from interfering with his possession and enjoyment of the booth.

During the pendency of the suit, Paras Ram Gupta died on 30-4-1989. His heirs applied for substitution under Order 22 Rules 1-4 CPC; the trial court allowed substitution. The defendant challenged that order by revision under Section 115 CPC. The High Court allowed the revision, holding that upon the death of the power-of-attorney holder, the right to sue did not survive to his legal representatives, and set aside the trial court's substitution order. The legal representatives then appealed against the High Court's judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the legal representatives of a deceased plaintiff (Paras Ram Gupta) were entitled to be substituted in the pending suit, particularly in light of the agreement for sale and the dispute concerning the power of attorney.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court focused on the existence of the agreement for sale in favour of Paras Ram Gupta and the fact that he died during the pendency of the suit. It reasoned that, on accepting these facts, the legal representatives of Paras Ram Gupta were entitled to seek protection of possession (injunction) by virtue of the agreement for sale.

The court expressly declined to decide the broader question of whether the right to sue survives to heirs upon the death of a power-of-attorney holder. Instead, it held that substitution was justified on the independent footing that the agreement for sale supported survival of the cause of action to the heirs and legal representatives. On that basis, the appeal was found to deserve allowance.

Holding and Implications

ALLOWED: The judgment under appeal (the High Court's order setting aside substitution) was set aside, and the appeal was allowed. No order as to costs was made.

The direct effect is that the legal representatives of Paras Ram Gupta are entitled to be substituted in the suit on the strength of the agreement for sale, allowing the litigation (including the claim for injunctive protection of possession) to proceed in their names. The opinion does not indicate that any new precedent was set beyond this case-specific determination.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. This is the plaintiff's appeal. One Ram Asrey, son of Aschraj Lal entered into an agreement for sale of Booth No. 164, Sector 35-C, Chandigarh on 23-10-1972 in favour of Paras Ram Gupta. On the same day, Ram Asrey executed a power of attorney in favour of Paras Ram Gupta. On 24-5-1984, Ram Asrey revoked the power of attorney executed in favour of Paras Ram Gupta. Paras Ram Gupta thereupon filed a suit for declaration that the general power of attorney executed and registered by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff on 25-9-1972 is valid and enforceable. It was also prayed that the decree for permanent injunction restraining the defendant from interfering with the possession and enjoyment of Booth No. 164 be also passed in favour of the plaintiff-appellant and against the defendant. While the suit was pending, Paras Ram Gupta died on 30-4-1989. The heirs of Paras Ram Gupta filed an application under Order 22 Rule 1-4 for their substitution in place of the deceased plaintiff Paras Ram Gupta. The trial court allowed the application for substitution. The defendant-respondent thereafter preferred a revision under Section 115 CPC. The High Court was of the view that since the power-of-attorney holder has died, the right to sue does not survive to the legal representatives of the deceased power-of-attorney holder. Consequently, the revision was allowed and the order passed by the trial court was set aside. It is against the said judgment, the legal representatives of Paras Ram Gupta are in appeal before us.

2. We have heard counsel for the parties and are of the view that once it is accepted that Ram Asrey entered into an agreement for sale in favour of Paras Ram Gupta and Paras Ram Gupta had died during the pendency of the suit, the legal representatives of deceased Paras Ram Gupta were entitled to seek injunction in regard to their possession by virtue of the agreement for sale. Without going into the question whether the right to sue survives to heirs on the death of the power-of-attorney holder, we hold that the legal representatives of Paras Ram Gupta were entitled to be substituted on the strength of the agreement for sale entered into in favour of Paras Ram Gupta. Since right to sue survives to heirs and legal representatives of the deceased Paras Ram Gupta, this appeal deserves to be allowed.

3. For the aforesaid reasons, the judgment under appeal is set aside. The appeal is allowed accordingly. There shall be no order as to costs.