Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Gafoor v. State Of Kerala

Kerala High Court
Sep 30, 1987
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was tried by the Court of Session, Quilon for offences punishable under Sections 489B and 489C of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). He was found guilty on both counts and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for 5 years under Section 489B and 3 years under Section 489C, with both sentences to run concurrently.

The appellant, from Chavakkat, allegedly had contacts in Bombay and offered to procure a No Objection Certificate (N.O.C.) for PW 1 to travel to Libya. PW 1 paid Rs. 4000 but did not receive the N.O.C., leading to a demand for refund. The appellant’s brother-in-law, Ashraf, also planned to go to Libya. The appellant, PW 1, and Ashraf traveled to Bombay for about two weeks but failed to obtain the N.O.C.

The prosecution alleged that the appellant obtained counterfeit U.S. dollar notes in Bombay and attempted to exchange them in his native place. The appellant contended that he received 11 U.S. dollar notes from R.K. Ali, a panshop owner in Bombay, as payment after a dispute over Rs. 8000 related to the N.O.C. arrangement. He claimed he believed the notes were genuine and later entrusted them to another person for exchange. The appellant was arrested by Customs Preventive Officer PW 5 after information was received, and subsequent investigation led to recovery of additional counterfeit notes.

Eleven prosecution witnesses were examined, and all counterfeit notes were marked as exhibits. No defense witnesses were called. The appellant admitted obtaining the notes from Bombay but denied knowledge of their counterfeit nature. The witness R.K. Ali was summoned but not examined due to the appellant’s absence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant committed offences under Sections 489B and 489C of the IPC relating to using and possessing forged or counterfeit currency notes with knowledge or reason to believe them to be counterfeit.
  2. Whether the appellant’s claimed belief that the notes were genuine negates the mens rea required for conviction under these sections.
  3. The appropriate sentence considering the appellant’s circumstances and the nature of the offence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant believed the U.S. dollar notes were genuine, having received them from R.K. Ali as payment.
  • He contended he was duped by R.K. Ali and had no knowledge or reason to believe the notes were counterfeit.
  • Relied on Supreme Court precedents (Mammutty v. State of Karnataka and Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab) to argue that mere possession without knowledge of counterfeit nature is insufficient for conviction.
  • Requested leniency in sentencing due to being a first offender with a family dependent on him.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mammutty v. State of Karnataka (1979 Crl. L.J 1383; (1979) 4 SCC 723; AIR 1979 SC 1705) Presumption of knowledge of counterfeit currency does not arise if accused genuinely did not know the notes were fake. Court considered this precedent but distinguished facts, noting the appellant’s conduct indicated knowledge or reason to believe the notes were counterfeit.
Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1982 Crl. L.J 32) Possession of counterfeit notes without dishonest intention or other incriminating circumstances is insufficient for conviction. Distinguished on facts; the appellant’s clandestine attempts to exchange notes showed intent and knowledge, supporting conviction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the ingredients of Sections 489B and 489C IPC, emphasizing that mere possession of counterfeit currency is not punishable unless the accused has knowledge or reason to believe the notes are forged or counterfeit. The court noted that this knowledge need not be proved directly but can be inferred from circumstances.

The appellant admitted obtaining the notes from R.K. Ali but claimed ignorance of their counterfeit nature. The court found this claim difficult to accept given the appellant’s conduct, including attempts to exchange the notes clandestinely and leaving counterfeit notes in a taxi seat, indicating awareness or reason to believe the notes were fake.

The court also observed that dealing in foreign currency without permission violates the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, adding to the appellant’s culpability. The prosecution satisfactorily proved possession and attempted use or exchange of counterfeit U.S. dollar notes.

Although the appellant was a first offender with a family dependent on him, the court reduced the 5-year sentence under Section 489B to 3 years, while confirming the 3-year sentence under Section 489C. Both sentences were ordered to run concurrently.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed with modification of sentence.

The appellant’s conviction under Sections 489B and 489C of the IPC is upheld. The sentence under Section 489B is reduced from 5 years to 3 years, while the 3-year sentence under Section 489C is confirmed, with both sentences running concurrently. The decision directly affects the appellant’s punishment but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond the application of existing principles to the facts.

Show all summary ...

1. The appellant was tried by the Court of Session, Quilon for the offences punishable under S. 489B and 489C of the Indian Penal Code. He has been found guilty on both the counts and was sentenced to undergo rigourous imprisonment for a period of 5 years under S. 459B aad for rigorous imprissnmenet for 3 years under S. 489C I.P.C Both the sentences have been ordered to run concurrently.

2. The case in short is as follows: The appellant is a person hailing from Chavakkat. It is alleged that he bad some contacts with some people in Bombay and he offered to get N.O.C for PW 1 to go to Libiya. PW 1 parted with a sum of Rs. 4000/-. However, PW 1 could not get N.O.C and he waated to get back the amount from the appellant. The appellant's brother-in-law one Ashraf had also some plans to go to Libiya. According to the appellant himself, his brother-in-law and PW 1 went to Bombay and there they met one R.K Ali, who was running a panshop at Bombay. The appellant, PW 1 and Ashraf were at Bombay for about 2 weeks aad they were not successful in getting N.O.C The prosecution case is that the appellant managed to obtain some U.S dollar notes from somebody in Bombay and he returned to the native place end tried to exchange these notes. However, these notes were fake currency notes and the accused was ultimately arrested by the Customs Preventive Officer. The appellant would contend that he was to get some Rs. 8000/- from R.K Ali in connection with the N.O.C arrangement and this R.K Ali refused payment. The appellant and others insisted for immediate payment and therefore R.K Ali gave them 11 U.S dollar notes. The appellant thinking that they were original U.S dollar notes obtained the same and returned to Chavakkad. The appellant would also contend that he later entrusted these notes to one Ummar for exchanging the same. The appellant also contended that he believed that the dollar notes ware genuine notes aad that if they were sot genuine notes he was duped by R.K Ali. The appellant was found in possession of fake U.S dollar notes. PW. 5 got information of the same and he informed the matter to the superior officer at Trichur. P.W 5 arrested the assused. He also informed the Superintendent of Police. Later PW. 8, the A.SI registered a case on the basis of Ext. P1 letter given by P.W 4, the Superintendent of the Customs Office, Trichur. The Sub Inspector of Police, Vadanappally took over tha investigation and conducted search, but he could not find any other incriminating articles. Later the investigation was taken over by P.W 1, the Detective Inspector. About 1½ months after the incident P.W 6 a taxi driver produced two other counterfeit dollar notes. The same were recovered by him from the seat of his car.

3. On the side of the prosecution 11 witnesses ware examined. All the II U.S fake dollar notes were marked as MO 1 series. There was no witness on the defence side.

4. As already pointed out the appellant admitted of having obtained these U.S dollar notes from Bombay. The appellant would contend that he obtained the same from one R.K Ali. R.K Ali was summoned as a witness before the Sessions Court; but he was cot examined on that day, since the appellant was not present. The learned counsel for the appellant contended that the non-examination of R.K Ali is fatal to the prosecution case. But it may be remembered that the witness appeared and was prepared to give evidence. It was because of the fault of the appellant that the witness could not be examined. Whatever be the source of this fake notes it is proved beyond reasonable doubi that the appellant had these dollar notes with him.

5. The question that would arise for consideration is whether the appellant had committed offences punishable under S. 489B and C of I.P.C S. 489B, deals with the offence relating to the using of forged or counterfeit coins as genuine and the offence under. S. 489C is in respect of possession of forged or counterfeit notes. Mere possession or use of counterfeit currency nctes is not punishable; the accosed must have knowledge or reason to believe that the notes were counterfeits or forged. The prosecution shall prove those ingredients. But this proof need not be necessarily by direct eviderce. The various circumstances leading to the seizure of forged cotes, the manner in which the accused came into possession of these nctes are important circumstances. Under S. 489B it is necessary that the accused who sells or buys or receives or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine, any forged or counterfeit currency notes and bank notes must have knowledge or reason to believe that the same to be forged or counterfeit, and the ingredients of S. 489C wculd also go to show that the accused should have been in possession of the forged or counterfeit currency notes or bank notes knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit note and intending to use the same as genuine.

6. It was contended on behalf of the appellant that the appellant believed that these notes were real end genuine U.S dollar notes issued by R.K Ali and at no point of time the appellant thought it to be fake or counterfeit currency notes and therefore he cannot be convicted for the offence under S. 489B or C of I.P.C The appellant also relied on two decisions of the Supreme Court reported in Mammutty v. State of Karnataka (1979 Crl. L.J 1383 : (1979) 4 SCC 723 : A.I.R 1979 S.C 1705), and Bachan Singh v. State af Punjab (1982 Crl. L.J 32). In the first mentioned case a rustic villager sold 3 quintals of tamarind fruits to a person whom he did not know and that person gave him a sum of Rs. 390. The accused contended that he did not know that these currency notes were counterfeit and be came to know of it for the first time when he was interrogated by the police. So, under that circumstance the Supreme Court held that there could not be any presumption that the accused knew that the notes in his possession were counterfeit.

7. The other decision is by a single Bench of Punjab and Haryana High Court. That was also a case where the accused was an illiterate lady who was found in possession of a made-up to rupee note. When she tendered the note to a shop-keeper for change the shop-keeper replied that the note was not genuine. The Court held that the tendering alone of such a note to the shopkeeper was not sufficient and the prosecution should have proved that it was with dishonest intention so as to cause wrongful loss to him and that there was no collateral circumstance to prove that she had palmed off such notes before, or that she was in possession of such notes in such large numbers and her possession for any other purpose was inexplicable.

8. The circumstances proved in this case are clearly different. Even according to the appellant he obtained the U.S dollar notes from one R.K Ali of Bombay. The appellant would say that R.K Ali had received Rs. 8000/- under the pretext of arranging N.O.C for two persons. The appellant obtained 11 cotes of hundred dollar denomination from R.K Ali. It is difficult te believe that the appellant was under the impression that these notes were genuine notes and therefore he accepted the same. If the appellant really wanted the amount from R.K Ali he should have insisted for payment in Indian currency. Dealing in foreign currency like U.S dollar notes without valid permission is itself violative of the provisions of the Forein Exchange Regulation Act. The subsequent conduct of the appellant also clearly shows that he wanted to exchange these dollar notes in & clandestine manner. At first he gave 4 notes to P.W 7 and these notes later turned out to be fake notes. Few days thereafter P.W 2, P.W 3 and the appellant travelled in a taxi car and it is evident that the appellant left two dollar notes beneath the seat of the car and the same were subsequently produced by the taxi driver. This also would go to show that the appellant was aware or had reason to believe that these notes were not genuine and he somehow wanted to convert them into Indian currency by cheating. The cfferce therefore would squarely come within S. 489B and C of I.P.C The prosecution has satisfactorily proved that the appellant was in possession of counterfeit U.S dollar notes and that he had sold or attempted to sell or exchange some of these counterfeit notes to others. Therefore the appellant has been lightly cocvicted utder S. 489B and 489C, I.P.C The appellant has been sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of 5 years under S. 489B, I.P.C The appellant seems to be a first offender. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the appellant has a family consisting of 5 children and a wife and the long incarceration in the jail would only put the members of the family in extreme poverty. So, taking a lenient view, I reduce the sentence of imprisonment for 5 years under S. 489B to a period of 3 years. The cotviction and sentence under S. 489C for a period of 3 years is confirmed. Both the sentences are ordered to run concurrently.

9. With the above modification in the sentence the appeal is dismissed.