- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
S.V.S. Dharmarajan v. The District Collector, Virudhunagar District Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, S.V.S. Dharmarajan of Elayirampannai, filed a Writ Petition under Article 226 seeking a writ of mandamus directing the District Collector and the Superintendent of Police, Virudhunagar District (respondents 1 and 2) to take action against respondents 3 and 4 for allegedly ex-communicating him from his caste. The petitioner alleged the action amounted to practicing untouchability punishable under the Protection of Civil Rights Act and violated Article 17, and claimed entitlement to privileges of the Elayirampanni Hindu Nadars' Uravinmurai.
On 21.09.2006 notice for admission was ordered. On 31.03.2010 the Superintendent of Police was directed to enquire and file a status report; a status report dated 03.03.2011 was filed. The status report stated that the petitioner had not filed a criminal complaint for four years, had approached the District Munsif Court in O.S.No.125 of 2009 and filed I.A.No.459 of 2009 (leading to C.M.A.No.7 of 2009 before the Sub Court, Sivakasi). A written complaint was recorded at Elayirampannai Police Station (Community Service Register No.66/06) and an enquiry was conducted by the Sub Inspector. No criminal case was pending and no final settlement had been reached despite a peace committee meeting with revenue and police officials.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the alleged ex-communication of the petitioner by respondents 3 and 4 amounts to the practice of untouchability punishable under the Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 and thus violates Article 17 of the Constitution.
- Whether respondents 1 and 2 are obliged to take action (criminal or otherwise) against respondents 3 and 4 on the basis of the petitioner’s allegations.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The ex-communication constitutes practicing of untouchability punishable under the Protection of Civil Rights Act.
- The ex-communication violates Article 17 of the Constitution.
- The petitioner is entitled to all privileges of the Elayirampanni Hindu Nadars' Uravinmurai and cannot be validly ex-communicated.
Respondents' / State's Position (as per status report)
- No criminal complaint had been filed by the petitioner for approximately four years before the status report.
- The petitioner had instituted civil proceedings in O.S.No.125 of 2009 and related interlocutory and appellate proceedings.
- A written complaint was recorded (Community Service Register No.66/06) and an enquiry was conducted by the Sub Inspector; no criminal case was pending and final settlement between parties had not been achieved despite a peace committee meeting.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Devarajiah v. Padmanna reported in AIR 1961 Madras 35 | That the Protection of Civil Rights Act (formerly Untouchability (Offences) Act) prohibits untouchability arising out of social disabilities imposed by reason of birth in certain castes and does not cover social boycott based upon conduct of other communities. | The Court relied on this principle to conclude that alleged ex-communication among members of the same community (Nadar) does not constitute untouchability under Article 17 or the Protection of Civil Rights Act. |
| FORCE I Guarding Services Pvt. Ltd. vs. The State of Tamil Nadu reported in 2011(5) CTC 728 | Historical account of treatment of the Nadar community and their struggles against untouchability. | The Court referenced this judgment for a brief statement of the historical practice of untouchability against Nadars and their subsequent social progress; it did not alter the legal conclusion regarding applicability of Article 17/PCR Act to the present facts. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court observed that the precise meaning of the petitioner's allegation of "ex-communication" was unclear. It noted that many Uravinmurai operate as registered societies under the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975, and disputes between members can be enforced under that Act or through civil proceedings — remedies the petitioner had already initiated in the District Munsif Court.
The Court analysed Article 17 and the Protection of Civil Rights Act, explaining that untouchability (as prohibited) refers to social disabilities imposed by reason of birth in certain castes (not general social boycotts) and, after the renaming of the Untouchability (Offences) Act as the Protection of Civil Rights Act, its protections relate to castes described as Scheduled Castes under the Presidential Order. Relying on Devarajiah v. Padmanna, the Court held that social boycott arising from conduct between members of the same community does not fall within the statutory/constitutional prohibition of untouchability. Since the petitioner and the contesting respondents belong to the same Nadar community, the Court concluded that the allegations do not amount to untouchability under Article 17 or the Protection of Civil Rights Act.
The Court also considered the status report: no active criminal proceedings, prior civil proceedings instituted by the petitioner, an enquiry conducted by police, and unsuccessful peace committee efforts. In light of these facts and the legal analysis, the Court found no basis to entertain the writ petition.
Holding and Implications
Writ Petition dismissed.
Direct effect: the petition is dismissed and no costs were awarded. The Court's decision was confined to the facts and statutory/constitutional interpretation in the opinion; no new legal precedent was announced beyond applying existing principles (including Devarajiah v. Padmanna) to these facts.
(Prayer: Writ Petition is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying for the issue of a Writ of Mandamus, directing the first and second respondents to take action against third and fourth respondents for having ex-communicated the petitioner from his caste.)
1. The petitioner is one S.V.S.Dharmarajan, S/o.Sankaralinga Nadar residing at Elayirampannai, Sattur Taluk, Virudhunagar District. In this Writ Petition, he has come forward to seek for a direction to respondents 1 and 2, viz., the District Collector and the Superintendent of Police, Virudhunagar District to take action against respondents 3 and 4 for having ex-communicated the petitioner from his caste. The petitioner in the grounds raised in the affidavit in para-6.1 had stated that the action of respondents 3 and 4 amounts to practicing of untouchability punishable under the Protection of Civil Rights Act. It is also violative of Article 17 of the Constitution of India. It is also stated that he is entitled for all privileges available to Elayirampanni Hindu Nadars' Uravinmurai and there is no right to ex-communicate the petitioner from Uravinmurai.
2. When the matter came up on 21.09.2006, notice for admission was ordered and subsequently, on 31.03.2010, the second respondent, the Superintendent of Police was directed to enquire the matter in issue and file a status report. Accordingly, the Superintendent of Police has filed a status report dated 03.03.2011. In that report, he has stated that till date (even after four years), no complaint has been given by the petitioner and already the petitioner has approached the District Munsif Court at Sattur in O.S.No.125 of 2009 and also filed an interim application in I.A.No.459 of 2009. The said interim application led to filing of an appeal before the Sub Court, Sivakasi in C.M.A.No.7 of 2009. He further submitted that the written complaint was received by Elayirampannai Police Station and a Community Service Register No.66/06 was given and proper enquiry was conducted by the Sub Inspector of Police. As on date, there is no criminal case pending against the petitioner or the contesting respondents and final settlement could not be arrived at between the rival groups, even though peace committee meeting was convened in the presence of revenue and police officials.
3. It is not clear as to what the petitioner mean by his ex-communication. It is needless to state that most of Uravinmurai though earlier functioned as unregistered bodies, they have subsequently registered themselves as Societies under the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975 and if there are any grievances between the members, the petitioner can enforce the provisions of the Act or establish his civil right before the appropriate civil forum, which he has already done by moving the District Munsif Court. Even assuming, if there was any removal or ex-communication within Uravinmurai, it is not clear as to how that will result in either violation of the Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 or infringement of Article 17 of the Constitution of India. Under Article 17 of the Constitution of India, untouchability is abolished and its practice in any form is forbidden and the enforcement of any disability arising out of untouchability shall be an offence punishable in accordance with law. Though the Constitution does not define as to what is meant by "untouchability", the subsequent enactment of the Parliament, viz., rechristening of The Untouchability (Offences) Act, 1955 into one of the Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 clearly prohibits untouchability in any form which arises out of social disabilities imposed by certain classes of persons by reason of their birth in certain castes and does not cover social boycott based upon conduct of other communities, as held by this Court in Devarajiah v. Padmanna reported in AIR 1961 Madras 35. Therefore, after rechristening of The Untouchability (Offences) Act, 1955 as the Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955, read with Article 17 of the Constitution of India, it only refer to the castes which are described as scheduled castes, as per the list of castes included under the Presidential Order. The petitioner calling his ex-communication into one of practice of untouchability either under Article 17 or under the Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 is only a misnomer. In the present case, the petitioner and the contesting respondents belong to the same Nadar community. Therefore, the question of practicing untouchability amongst them will not arise.
4. It is no doubt true, around 100 years ago, the members of Nadar community were treated as untouchables by the caste Hindus and were denied entry into temples meant for the Hindus. Series of legal battles as well as direct agitations were conducted by them. Thereafter, not only they were guaranteed entries into Hindu temples controlled by caste Hindus but also at present, in number of temples in southern districts, they are holding positions as trustees. History of the practice of untouchability against them and the fight of the community to establishing their self-respect were briefly set out by this Court in the judgment in FORCE I Guarding Services Pvt. Ltd. vs. The State of Tamil Nadu reported in 2011(5) CTC 728.
5. Under the said circumstances and in the light of the status report filed by the second respondent, the Superintendent of Police, there is no case made out to entertain the present Writ Petition. Hence, the Writ Petition stands dismissed. No costs.
Alert