Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Murat Ram Murat v. State Of U.P.

Allahabad High Court
Jan 5, 1994
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Court Opinion (Palok Basu, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal is by Murat alias Ram Murat against the judgment and order dated 24.1.1979 of the V Additional Sessions Judge, Varanasi, in Sessions Trial No. 109 of 1978. At trial the appellant was convicted under Sections 302/34, 302 (simpliciter) and 307 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to life imprisonment on the murder counts and ten years' rigorous imprisonment for the Section 307 offence, with sentences directed to run concurrently.

The prosecution alleged that on 16.1.1978 at about 5:00 P.M., following an earlier dispute and an FIR lodged by a woman of the informant's family, the appellant Murat (armed with a spear) and his brother Puranmasi (armed with a gun) went to the informant's house. Puranmasi fired at and caused the death of Bachcha Ram Yadav; the appellant allegedly assaulted Smt. Dhiraji (who later died on the way to hospital) with a spear; and injured Rajnath (who survived). Puranmasi died during trial. The prosecution relied on eyewitness testimony (including an injured eyewitness), medical evidence, post-mortem reports, and certain recovery and investigation documents.

The trial Judge convicted the appellant principally on the basis of four eye-witnesses (including the injured witness P.W.7, Rajnath). The appellant appealed; the appeal was heard by Palok Basu, J., with submissions from counsel for the appellant and the State.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Trial Judge was correct in placing implicit reliance on the testimony of the eyewitnesses (including an injured eyewitness) to convict the appellant of the offences charged.
  2. Whether alleged partiality or particular circumstances (e.g., concealment of relationship by P.W.2; alleged affidavit prepared by P.W.8) justified rejecting the eyewitness testimony.
  3. What weight should be given to the dying declarations of the two deceased under Section 32 of the Evidence Act and whether non-compliance with certain U.P. Police Regulations would necessitate excluding those statements.
  4. Whether, even if the dying declarations are excluded for non-compliance with the U.P. Police Regulations, the remaining eyewitness and documentary/medical evidence suffice to uphold the conviction.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • All prosecution witnesses were partisan and had motives to depose falsely against the appellant; reliance on their testimony by the trial Judge was therefore misplaced.
  • P.W.2 (Mahjad) initially tried to conceal his relationship to the informant, indicating partiality.
  • P.W.8 (Dular) had prepared an affidavit to be filed during trial and therefore his in-court testimony was alleged to be not voluntary or impartial.

Respondent / State's Position

  • The opinion does not set out a detailed, separate statement of the State's oral submissions; however, the prosecution case relied on eyewitness testimony (including an injured eyewitness), dying declarations admitted under Section 32 of the Evidence Act, medical evidence, post-mortem reports, FIR and police investigation documents, and recoveries (such as a firearm from Puranmasi).

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the trial record, the prosecution case and the defence criticisms, and explained its reasons for upholding the conviction:

  1. Assessment of eyewitnesses: The trial Judge had placed implicit reliance on the testimony of four eyewitnesses, including P.W.7 (Rajnath), who was an injured witness. The appellate court examined the defence criticisms of individual witnesses and found them insufficient to discredit the testimony taken as a whole.
  2. On P.W.2 (Mahjad): Although this witness initially attempted to conceal his relationship with the informant, he subsequently admitted he was the informant's first cousin. He lived physically between the houses of the parties, his testimony was not otherwise challenged in cross-examination, and therefore there was no basis to discard his evidence.
  3. On P.W.8 (Dular): The defence suggestion that he had prepared an affidavit for filing did not amount to proof that his in-court testimony was untrue. The defence did not produce an oath commissioner, identifying witness, or otherwise prove execution of such a document in accordance with law. The Court also observed that P.W.8 was related to the accused side as well, undermining a presumption that he would depose falsely against the appellant.
  4. On P.W.7 (Rajnath): He was an injured witness whose medical examination was carried out within two hours of the incident. Spear injury to the chest and corroboration in the FIR were present. The immediate motive (the earlier FIR lodged by the informant's sister Smt. Israji, P.W.11) for the attack was established by P.W.11's testimony and the carbon copy of her FIR (Ext. Ka19).
  5. Corroborative documentary and medical evidence: The contents of the FIR, the two post-mortem reports, and the injury report of Rajnath were held to fully corroborate the eyewitness account. Post-mortem reports (Ext. Ka2 and Ka3) detailed the injuries and concluded that the injuries were sufficient to cause death; the cause of death and weapon types were addressed by the doctor (Dr. S. P. Tandon).
  6. Recoveries and investigation: The Investigating Officer's actions (arrest of Puranmasi and recovery of a firearm and cartridges, memorandum Ext. Ka13; arrest of the appellant; preparation of site plan Ext. Ka18; recovery memo Ext. Ka17) were described and corroborated by police witnesses, supporting the prosecution narrative.
  7. Dying declarations and procedural compliance: The Court noted that the statements of the two deceased were proved as dying declarations admissible under Section 32 of the Evidence Act (marked Ext. Ka15 and Ka16). The Court also observed that even if those dying declarations were not relied upon because of non-compliance with some Rules in the U.P. Police Regulations, the eyewitness testimony and attendant circumstances would still be sufficient to sustain conviction.
  8. Overall conclusion on sufficiency of evidence: Having examined the credibility attacks and the supporting documentary and medical evidence, the Court found no error in the trial Judge's approach and concluded that the evidence sufficed to convict the appellant.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is DISMISSED. The appellate court upheld the convictions and sentences awarded by the trial Judge.

Direct consequences: The appellant, who was on bail at the time of the decision, was directed to surrender to his bail bonds to serve the sentences awarded by the trial court.

Broader implications: The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal precedent. The Court expressly stated that even if the dying declarations were excluded for non-compliance with certain U.P. Police Regulations, the remaining eyewitness and corroborative evidence were sufficient to sustain the conviction; thus the case is decided on the facts and established evidentiary material rather than on an expansion of legal principle.

Note: This summary is based exclusively on the contents of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

PALOK BASU, J.

(1) MURAT alias Ram Murat has preferred this appeal against the judgment and order dated 24. 1. 1979 passed by V Addi. Sessions Judge, Varanasi in Sessions Trial No. 109 of 1978 whereby the appellant has been convicted under Section 302/341 I. P. C. and also under Section 302 I. P. C. simplicitor and sentenced to imprisonment for life on both counts and also under Section 307 I. P. C. and sentenced to ten years' RI. (sentences directed to run concurrently). The first charge against the appellant was that on 16. 1. 1978 at 5 P. M. he shared the common intention along with brother Puranmasi to kill Bachcha Ram Yadav and others and in furtherance of the said common intention Puranmasi committed the murder by intentionally shooting at and causing death of Bachcha Ram Yadav and thereby committed an offence punishable under Section 302/34 I. P. C. The second charge against the appellant was that in the said incident the appellant caused the death of Smt. Dhiraji wife of Bachcha Ram Yadav by causing her death by intentionally causing spear injury as a result of which she died on the way to ;the hospital. For this the appellant was charged with the offence punishable under Section 302 I. P. C. simplicitor. The third charge against the appellant was that in the same incident he caused injuries with spear to Rajnath P. W. 7 with intention to cause his death, who survived and thereby committed an offence punishable under Section 307 I. P. C.

(2) THE prosecution case, in brief, was that informant P. W. 1. Deonath and the appellant Murat are residents of the same village Dhudhuwa, police-station-Chaubepur, district-Varanasi. The other accused Puranmasi is the real brother of the appellant. Purnmasi died during the trial. The house of P. W. 2. Mehlad is practicularly adjoining. The deceased Bachcha Ram Yadav is the real brother of the informant. The other deceased Smt. Dhiraji is the wife of this deceased Bachcharam Yadav. Similarly, P. W. 7, Rajnath, the injured witness, is also brother of the informant and the deceased Bachcha Ram Yadav. The prosecution case further is that enmity existed between the families of the appellant and that of the informant and some litigation had already taken place between them. On the fateful day, i. e. on 16. 1. 1978 the ladies of the house of the accused had abused and beaten the sister of the informant Smt. Israji, P. W. 11. About this incident Smt. Israji lodged an F. I. R. at the police-station Chaubepur on the same day at 2. 45 P. M. because she was a victim and had received injuries. Lodging of this F. I. R. caused sufficient annoyance to the two accused and around 5 P. M. on 16. 1. 1978 the appellant armed with a spear and co-accused Puranmasi (dead during the trial) armed with his gun came to the house of the informant where the informant, his another brother Rajnath, his brother Bachcha Ram deceased, his sister-in-law (Bhabhi) Smt. Dhiraji, the other deceased, were working at their door. Puranmasi and Murat started hurling abuses which was resisted by the deceased Puranmasi. Immediately thereupon the co-accused Puranmasi fired from his gun which hit Bachcha Ram Yadav who fell down. At this the informant Rajnath and Smt. Dhiraji rushed to apprehend the accused at which the appellant Murat assaulted Rajnath and Smt. Dhiraji with his spear and when the other persons, namely, Ram Swarup Dular P. W. 8 and Mehlad, P. W. 2. and several other villagers tried to apprehend the accused they threatened them to kill if they dared to come near. Thereafter both the accused fled away.

(3) ACCORDING to the prosecution, an F. I. R. was lodged by Deonath, P. W. I at the police-station Chaubepur on 16. 1. 1978 at 6. 45 P. M. It is said that all three victims were carried to the policestation. P. W. 12 Sriram, S. H. O. was present at the police-station when this F. I. R. was lodged. He immediately interrogated all the three injured as also informant. The statements of the two deceased Bachcha Ram Yadav and his wife Smt. Dhiraji was proved during the trial as dying declaration of the two deceased being admissible under Section 32 of the Evidence Act, marked Ext. and Ka. 15 and Ka. 16. The Investigating officer made arrangements for sending the three victims to the hospital but in the meantime the two deceased died. However, Rajnath was medically examined by Dr. Anil Kumar, P. W. 5. on 16. 1. 1978 at 8. 45 P. M. is S. S. P. G. hospital, Varanasi. He found one incised would, 1 cm x 1/2 cm. x depth not probed on the right side of chest at 3 OClock position, 7 cm, medial to right nipple. The said injury was kept under observation. According to the statement P. W. 7, Rajnath was remained hospitalised for about a week.

(4) TO complete the chronology of the prosecution case it may be mentioned here that P. W. 12 Sriram Singh, sub-Inspector immediately proceeded to the place of the occurrence. He got an information that co-accused Puranmasi was likely to be arrested if immediately his tubewell was raided. Consequently he proceeded to the tubewell of Puranmasi where he was successfully arrested. From his possession, his gun and cartridges were recovered about which memorandum was prepared which has been marked Ext. Ka. 13. It may be mentioned here that P. W. 9 Rajaram had accompanied P. W. 12 Shri Ram at the time of arrest and in his testimony the said P. W. 9 Rajaram has fully corroborated the prosecution case about the arrest of Puranmasi and recovery of the fire-arm and cartridges from his possession. Thereafter on 17. 1. 1978 the appellant Murat was also arrested by the Investigating Officer. It may be mentioned here that the Investigating officer prepared the site plan after inspecting the spot which was marked Ext. Ka. 18. He also look plain and blood stained earth from the place of occurrence and -prepared the recovery memo Ext. Ka. 17. While interrogating P. W. 11 Smt. Israji who had sustained injuries in the incident which happened in the afternoon, who had handed over the carbon copy of the F. I. R. which she had lodged. This carbon copy of the F. I. R. has been proved as Ext: Ka. 19.

(5) IT may be mentioned here that P. W. 6. Rama Shanker Misra was posted as Station Officer at police-station Kotwali. On receiving information about the dead-body at S. S. P. G. Hospital, he was deputed to prepare the inquest reports on the dead-bodies of Bachcha Ram Yadav and Smt. Dhiraji. Similarly, the said Station officer also prepared the photonash, challan nash and the letters addressed to the Medical Officer for getting post mortem conducted on the said dead bodies. All these documents have been proved by this P. W. 6 R. S. Misra as Exts. Ka 5 to Ka 12 respectively. Ultimately the post-mortem on the dead bodies of Bachcha Ram and Smt. Dhiraji was conducted by Dr. S. P. Tandon P. W. 3, Senior Physician, S. S. P. G. Hospital, Varanasi on 17. 1. 1978 at 3. 45 P. M. at 4. 30 P. M. respectively. According to his statement and the post mortem report Ext. Ka-2, the age of the deceased Bachcha Ram was about 38 years and his death had taken place about half to one day ago. His body was of average built. Rigor mortis was present. The following ante-mortem injuries were found on the body of Bachcha Ram:

(1) Six gun shot wounds of entry 1 cm. x 1 cm. inside with inverted margin on the abdomen. (a) Two on the pubic sum physis. (b) Two on left side of abdomen 1 cm. apart 6 cm. outer and 4 cm. below umbilicus. (c) Two on right side of abdomen 6 cm. away on unbilicus and 6 cm. apart.

There was no blackening, charring or tattoo-ing around the wounds. There are 4 wounds of exit, two on the rectum on the outer side of left buttock and one 8 cm. above it. These wounds had everted margins and are cm. x 1/4 cm. in size. On internal examination inferior venacava and disc ending aorta was pierced through and through by the pellets, the abdomenal cavity containing 500 c. c. blood and it contained 50 c. c. semidagested food and the small and large intestines contained four holes and the right kidney pierced through and through by the pellet and contains 1 pound of blood on it.

(6) IN the opinion of the doctor, the death of Bachcha Ram was caused due to shock and haemorrhage resulting from the injuries suffered by him during his life.

(7) ACCORDING to the statement of Dr. S. P. Tandon and the postmortem report of Smt. Dhiraji Ext. Ka 3, the age of the deceased was about 32 years and her death had taken place about half to one day ago. Her body was of average built. Rigor mortis was present. The following ante-mortem injuries were found on her body:

1. Incised wound 3 cm. x 1 cm. on the front of left chest4 cm. above and inner to left nipple. The injury cuts through the inter castle muscles and 2nd and 3rd ribs and cuts the plura and lung in downward direction and medially cutting pericardium and left ventricle. Pericardinal cavity has 200 c. c. blood in it. 2. Incised wound with tailing 3 cm. x 2 cm. on the back of right chest 6 cm. below inferior angle of scapula. It transverses through the muscles and pleura and lungs 1000 c. c. blood lide fluid present in the right pleural cavity. 3. Incised wounds 3 cm. x 2 cm. x 1 cm. below injury No. 2. It has the same course as injury number two. 4. Contusion 8 cm. x 8 cm. on the front of right chest 6 cm. below the nipple.

On internal examination the doctor has found 150 C. c. semi digested food in the abdomen. According to Dr. S. P. Tandon, the death of Mst. Dhiraji was caused due to shock and haemorrhage resulting from the injuries stated above. It has further been stated by Dr. S. P. Tandon that the injuries of Bachcha Ram could be caused by firearm and the injuries Nos. 1 to 3 of Mst. Dhiraji could be caused by sharp edged weapon such as Ballam and her injury No. 4 could be caused either by falling on the ground or by the handle of the spear. It has further been stated by him that the death of the deceased could have taken place on 16. 1. 1972 at about 8 or 8. 30 P. M. and the injuries found on their bodies were sufficient, in the ordinary course of nature to cause their death. After completing the investigation a charge-sheet was filed against the appellant by Sri Ram, P. W. 12, the Investigating officer.

(8) THE learned trial Judge placed implicit reliance on the testimony of four eye-witnesses who included P. W. 7, Rajnath, an injured one and then convicted and sentenced the appellant as noted above. Aggrieved, this appeal has been preferred.

(9) SRI S. N. S. Yadav, learned counsel for the appellants has been heard in support of this appeal at length. Sri S. P. Tewari, learned Govt. Advocate has spoused the cause of the State and the entire record has been thoroughly scrutinised.

(10) THE first criticism of Sri Yadav against the prosecution witnesses was that all of them are partisan and had reason to falsely depose against the appellant and, therefore, the learned trial Judge has wrongly placed reliance on their testimony. In support of this argument reliance was placed on the two facts: Firstly, that so far as P. W. 2, Mahjad is concerned he admittedly tried to conceal his relationship though when searching cross-examination was directed, he admitted that he is the cousin f the informant. Secondly, that so far as Dular, P. W. 8 is concerned he had prepared an affidavit for being filed during the trial and had put his signature and, therefore he was not voluntarily making a statement in the court when his deposition was recorded.

(11) SO far as the first criticism against P. W. 2. Mahjad is concerned it may be mentioned here that by an urge that his deposition should appear more independent perhaps the witness had initially tried to conceal his relationship with the informant. The fact, however, remains that he has himself said that he is the first cousin of the informant. This witness is living only about 100 paces from the house of the informant. Infact his house lies in between the two houses, i. e. on one side that of the appellant and on the other that of the deceased. His testimony, apart from the aforesaid criticism, has not been challenged at all during the cross-examination. Therefore, there is no reason that this witness should be discarded. Similarly, the statement of P. W. 8, Dular can and should not be discarded because there was a suggestion thrown to him that he had prepared an affidavit for being filed during the trial. Discarding such a witness is not possible as no effort has been made by the defence to prove that the affidavit was infact executed by the said witness. Neither any Oath Commissioner has been produced nor any Identifying witness has been produced nor for document was proved in accordance with law. Consequently, the learned trial Judge was rightly placed reliance on the testimony of the aforesaid witness and has discarded the said argument which was raised in the identical terms before him also during the trial. Another interesting aspect with regard to P. W. 8 is that he happened to be closely related to the accused side also. Consequently it is impossible to expect that a relative-witness would be deposing falsely against the appellant. His house is also practically adjacent to that of the appellant. There is, therefore, absolutely no reason that this witness would be deposing falsely against the accused-appellant. P. W. 7 Rajnath was a victim of the assault perpetrated by the appellant. His medical examination was done within two hours of the incident along with a Mazrubi Chitti. Spear injury was said to have been caused to him on the chest and a mention about this fact is found in the F. I. R. There is no reason on earth for disbelieving this injured witness. The immediate motive for assault stands established by the testimony of P. W. 11 Smt. Israji Devi who sustained injuries at the hands of Maltiya, daughter of Puranmasi and Phulia, sister of the appellant. Copy of the F. I. R. (Ext. Kal 9) fully established the truth of the incident which was the immediate motive for the appellant and the deceased accused torush to avenge the fact of lodging of the F. I. R. against the ladies of their families.

(12) IT may be further pointed out that the contents of the F. I. R. and the two post-mortem reports and the injury report of Rajnath fully corroborates the eye-witness account.

(13) IN view of the aforesaid discussion there is no error in the judgment and the order of the trial Judge in convicting and sentencing the appellant as noted above.

(14) EVEN if the two statements said to have been recorded by the Investigating officer which have been treated as dying declarations of the two deceased namely, Bachcha Ram Yadav and Smt. Dhiraji are not taken note of for non-compliance of some of the Rules mentioned in U. P. Police Regulations the aforesaid eye-witness account and the attending circumstances are more than sufficient Jo up-hold the conviction and sentence awarded to the appellant. In view of the aforesaid discussion this appeal fails and is hereby dismissed. The appellant is on bail. He will surrender to his bail bonds to serve out the sentences awarded to him by the trial Judge. Appeal dismissed.