- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Maharashtra v. Pappu Alia Suresh Budharmal Kalani .
Order of the Supreme Court
1. Taken on board. Exemption from filing certified copy of the impugned order and OT is allowed. Issue notice, returnable on 15-4-2014.
2. Mr Ravindra Keshavrao Adsure, learned counsel, accepts notice on behalf of the sole respondent.
3. If the respondent-accused, Pappu alias Suresh Budharmal Kalani, is not being released pursuant to the impugned order of the High Court till this date, there shall be stay of the said order.
4. List the matter on returnable date.
Court Masters
Impugned Order of the High Court
(Before Naresh H. Patil and Smt Anuja Prabhudessai, JJ.)
5. Heard the learned counsel for the parties. The applicant was convicted and sentenced by the trial court for the offences punishable under Section 120-B read with Section 302 IPC in Sessions Case No. 218 of 1999. The applicant herein along with other accused persons was framed on 2-11-2002. The trial court framed charge for offences punishable under Sections 120-B and 109 IPC read with Section 302 IPC.
6. The learned counsel appearing for the applicant submitted that there is absolutely no evidence against the applicant in respect of hatching of conspiracy to kill deceased Inder Bhatija. The applicant was acquitted by the trial court for an offence punishable under Section 109 IPC. The learned counsel specifically referred to the evidence of PWs 4, 9, 11, 12, 26A, 27 and 29. PW 9 driver, PW 11 and PW 29 were declared hostile. It is submitted that the applicant was convicted and sentenced merely based on surmises and conjectures. The applicant was arrested in March 1993 in connection with the subject crime. Initially, the provisions under the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (“TADA”, for short) were made applicable. The said provisions were later on removed. The applicant was released on bail in September 2001. During the trial the applicant was on bail. After pronouncement of the judgment and order the applicant was taken into custody on 3-12-2013.
7. The learned Special Public Prosecutor appearing for the State submitted that it requires to be considered as to why witnesses turned hostile. The applicant is politically heavy weight in the area and due to his terror and pressure, witnesses were not coming forward to depose against him. This is clear from the fact that even the wife of the deceased turned hostile including the father of the deceased. The learned Prosecutor further submitted that inference needs to be drawn as to what extent terror was created by the applicant in the minds of the prosecution witnesses. The learned counsel referred to the relevant portion of the evidence of some of the witnesses in support of his submissions. Reliance was placed on the judgment of the Sikkim High Court in Pem Dorjee Bhutia v. State of Sikkim 2002 Cri LJ 4641 (Sikk). The learned counsel appearing for the complainant was also granted permission to address the Court.
8. We have perused the depositions of the witnesses. Prima facie we have noticed that material witnesses like wife and father of the deceased and PW 9 driver turned hostile. Perusal of the evidence on record shows that none of the witnesses have made reference to the role played by the applicant in hatching the conspiracy to kill deceased Inder Bhatija. Merely because some of the witnesses have turned hostile, it would not be appropriate to refuse bail to the applicant. The prosecution case is that original Accused 3, 6 and 7 had entered into the office of Inder Bhatija who was fired at with a firearm. The witnesses even during the course of cross-examination did not explain the reasons for their turning hostile. The prosecution has not elicited from them the reasons for turning hostile. The learned counsel for the petitioner applicant submitted that during the course of the trial the applicant was on bail and he did not interfere in whatsoever nature in the smooth conduct of the trial.
9. Considering the evidence brought on record and the submissions advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the respective parties, we are of the view that the applicant could be enlarged on bail. Hence, the application is allowed in the following terms:
Order
(i) The order of substantive sentence passed by the trial court against the applicant stands suspended.
(ii) The applicant shall be released on bail in the sum of Rs 1,00,000 with two sureties in the like amount.
(iii) The applicant shall not enter Ulhasnagar for a period of three months save and except attendance in other court cases.
(iv) The applicant shall intimate his place of residence to the nearest police station. He shall report to Kalyan City Police Station once in a fortnight, for a period of three months from today.
10. At this stage the learned Special Public Prosecutor prayed for stay of operation of this order for four weeks. The learned counsel for the applicant objects to the same. We are not convinced to stay operation of this order. The prayer is rejected.
Alert