Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dilip Kumar Das v. State Of Uttar Pradesh

Allahabad High Court
Jan 9, 1992
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — V.N. Mehrotra, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

Opposite party No. 2, Satnam Singh, filed a criminal complaint in the Magistrate's court alleging that two accused had taken a bus (Bus No. URU 5428) on lease and then dishonestly disposed of it to one Dilip Kumar of Howrah for Rs. 2,50,000/-, and that the registration number was changed to WBR 2732. A search and seizure warrant was issued and the vehicle was seized in West Bengal.

The present applicant claimed to have purchased the bus, obtained financing through Jam Finance Corporation (Calcutta), paid Rs. 1,50,000/- to Automobiles Financing Corporation (Kanpur) by demand draft, and subsequently had the vehicle registered in his name. He applied to the Magistrate for release of the seized bus in his favor. By order dated 18.4.1990 the Magistrate rejected the applicant's release application, observing that the case involved allegations of fraud and that the applicant had not produced a receipt for payment or a sale letter.

The applicant filed this petition under section 482 Cr. P. C. seeking direction for release of the seized bus in his favor. Opposite party No. 2 filed a counter affidavit denying the applicant's asserted sale and alleging fraudulent transfer and manipulation of registration. The applicant filed a rejoinder affidavit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the seized bus should be released in favour of the applicant on the basis that it was registered in his name.
  2. Whether, when disposing of an application under section 451, Cr. P. C., a Magistrate is bound to release a vehicle to the person shown as the registered owner irrespective of other facts.
  3. Whether prima facie allegations of fraud or manipulation in obtaining registration preclude release of a vehicle to the registered owner.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applicant contended that the bus was registered in his name and, therefore, the Magistrate should have released it to him.
  • Relying on precedents (Kalpanath Singh v. Sheo Nath Rai and Smt. Naseem Banu v. State of U.P. & another), the applicant argued that a vehicle should be released to the registered owner when deciding an application under section 451, Cr. P. C.
  • The applicant produced photostat copies of two bank drafts and an affidavit, claiming payment of Rs. 1,50,000/- to the financing firm and asserting transfer formalities had been completed with Jam Finance Corporation as financer; monthly dues were deposited and Jam Finance Corporation later deleted its name from the registration certificate.

Opposite Party No. 2's Arguments

  • Opposite party No. 2 asserted that he was the original owner and registered owner (URU 5428) and that the bus had been financed by the Bank of Baroda and then leased to an accused under a lease dated 28.3.1983.
  • He denied any sale or transfer to the applicant and alleged that the accused fraudulently transferred the bus to the applicant who then wrongfully changed the registration number.
  • He asserted that the applicant produced no sale letter or documentary proof that the opposite party received payment for a sale, and therefore the Magistrate was correct in refusing release.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kalpanath Singh v. Sheo Nath Rai The court observed that the person in whose name a vehicle stands registered is prima facie the owner and entitled to custody; however, where it is shown prima facie that the registrant has sold the vehicle to another who has paid and performed obligations, release can be made in favour of the purchaser even if registration has not been transferred. The court contrasted that case with the present facts: in Kalpanath Singh the purchaser had prima facie shown purchase and payment to the registered owner; in the present case the applicant had not produced comparable evidence of a sale from opposite party No. 2.
Smt. Naseem Banu v. State of U.P. and another (Division Bench decision dated 16.4.1987) The court noted a consensus that release should ordinarily be in favour of the person shown as registered owner; but the Magistrate may take a different view where prima facie the registration is fraudulent, obtained by misrepresentation, or for other cogent reasons manifest on the record. The court relied on this principle to hold that a Magistrate is not bound to release a vehicle to the registered owner where prima facie evidence suggests registration may be invalid or obtained by fraud; thus release to a non-registered person remains open in appropriate cases.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the materials, affidavits and arguments. It accepted as undisputed that opposite party No. 2 originally owned and had registered the vehicle. The applicant asserted that he had purchased the vehicle and produced photostat copies of two bank drafts for Rs. 1,50,000/- purportedly paid to the financing firm; he also asserted that transfer formalities had been completed with the financing corporation and Jam Finance Corporation and that the vehicle was subsequently registered in his name.

The court examined whether, under section 451, Cr. P. C., the Magistrate was obliged to release a seized vehicle to the person appearing as registered owner. The court reviewed the precedents cited by the applicant and explained their scope: while registration is prima facie evidence of ownership and ordinarily entitles the registrant to custody, the court may refuse release to a registrant if prima facie materials on record indicate the registration was fraudulent or obtained by misrepresentation or where other cogent reasons render the registration invalid in law.

Applying these principles to the present record, the court noted critical deficiencies in the applicant's proof: the applicant produced no sale letter, no document showing that opposite party No. 2 received any payment from him, and no executed agreement of sale between opposite party No. 2 and the applicant. When specifically asked, the applicant's counsel asserted the court should direct release on the authority relied upon rather than litigate the factual question. Conversely, opposite party No. 2 alleged in his counter affidavit that the registration number URU 5428 was changed by manipulation and fraud; the applicant's rejoinder did not specifically deny that allegation (para 17 stating para 24 "need no reply").

Given the absence of documents evidencing a sale from opposite party No. 2 to the applicant, the presence of a specific fraud allegation in the counter affidavit that was not affirmatively rebutted, and the fact that the vehicle was originally owned and registered in opposite party No. 2's name, the court concluded that it could not hold that the Magistrate's refusal to release the vehicle amounted to an abuse of process or warranted interference under section 482, Cr. P. C.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is rejected and the application is dismissed; the Magistrate's order refusing release of the vehicle in favour of the applicant is upheld. (The opinion states: "In the circumstances this petition is rejected. Application rejected.")

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the seized bus remains withheld pursuant to the Magistrate's order and is not released to the applicant.
  • The court did not lay down any new legal principle beyond applying existing authorities: it reaffirmed that while registration is prima facie evidence of ownership, a Magistrate is not compelled to release a vehicle to a registered owner where prima facie material indicates the registration may have been obtained fraudulently or by misrepresentation.
  • No broader or novel precedent was announced; the decision rests on the application of established principles to the specific evidentiary record presented.

Source: Opinion authored by V.N. Mehrotra, J., as provided. All content in this summary is drawn exclusively from the supplied opinion.

Show all summary ...

V.N. MEHROTRA, J.

(1) THIS petition has been filed under section 482, Cr. P. C. praying that the bus as detailed in the petition and seized under the orders of the A. C. M. M. T. , Kanpur Nagar, be directed to be released in favor of the applicant.

(2) THE facts of the case, as appear from the material placed on the record, are that opposite party No. 2 Satnam Singh filed a complaint in the court of the Magistrate concerned, naming two persons as accused. He alleged that he was dealing in the business of hire purchase of automobiles. The accused persons approached the complainant on 28. 3. 1983 and requested him to give the vehicle on lease. The terms of lease were settled between the parties and the accused persons were to pay Rs. 12,000/- per month to the complainant and it was also agreed that they will use the vehicle as Bailee and Trustee on behalf of the complainant. A deed was executed between the parties and in accordance with the agreement the complainant entrusted Bus No. URU 5428 to the accused persons. The accused persons, however, stopped paying the monthly hire and dishonestly disposed off the vehicle to one Dilip Kumar, resident of Howrah (West Bengal) for Rs. 2,50,000/ -. It was further asserted that the registration number of the vehicle has also been changed as WBR 2732. The complainant asserted that the accused persons have cheated him and have also miss- appropriated the vehicle. The Magistrate concerned issued a warrant for search and seizure in respect of the vehicle. The vehicle was actually seized by the police in

West Bengal . The present applicant, thereafter, moved an application for release of the vehicle in his favor on the ground that had purchased the vehicle and the registration of the same was in his name. The learned Magistrate by his order dated 18. 4. 1990 rejected the application observing that as the matter relates to the commission of fraud and that the applicant has not produced any receipt about payment of money or any sale letter, the bus cannot be released in his favor merely because he is a registered owner.

(3) IN his petition the petitioner has asserted that the Automobiles Financing Corporation, which is a Financing Corporation of

Kanpur , had financed the bus having registered No. BHZ 28 in the name of opposite party No. 2. The Opposite party No. 2 along with his other family members are partners of the said firm. The applicant was approached by Satnam Singh for selling the vehicle and for this purpose the applicant entered into a hire purchase agreement with one Jam Finance Corporation, Calcutta . During the time when the applicant was negotiating with Satnam Singh for purchase of the Bus, the applicant received a letter from Automobiles Financing Corporation dated 31. 3. 1986 disclosing therein that the Bus sought to be purchased by the applicant was under a hire purchase agreement with it and a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- should be paid to it so that it could issue necessary documents. In pursuance of this letter the applicant obtained a loan from Jam Finance Corporation and paid the amount of Rs. 1,50,000/- by demand draft. The Automobiles Financing Corporation and Satnam Singh issued necessary papers for transfer of the vehicle and it was transferred in the name of the applicant showing Jam Financing Corporation as the Financer. The registered number of the Bus was changed from BHZ 28 to WBR 2732. In terms of the agreement with the Jam Finance Corporation the applicant deposited the monthly dues. Thereafter Jam Finance Corporation issued a letter to the registration authority intimating that they had received the full payment and consequently their name was deleted from the registration certificate. The applicant has further asserted that he is the sole owner of the vehicle which is registered in his name. The complaint filed by the opposite party No. 2, Satnam Singh, was false. The Bus was liable to be released in favor of the complainant. The applicant filed his affidavit and copied of certain documents in support of his allegation. The opposite party No. 2 has filed counter affidavit denying the allegations made by the applicant. He has asserted that there was no agreement between him and the applicant nor the Bus was ever transferred by him to the applicant. He has asserted that the bus in question belongs to him and the same is registered in his name and he is the registered owner of it which has bearing number URU 5428. It was financed by the Bank of Baroda, New Delhi . The entire payment was made by him to the Bank of Baroda. It was thereafter leased to accused Bharat Singh under the lease agreement dated 28. 3. 1983. A true copy of the said agreement has been filed along with the affidavit. The opposite party No. 2 further asserted that in term of the lease agreement the accused persons wrong fully and fraudulently transferred the bus to the applicant who got the registration number of the bus changed. The opposite party No. 2 has also asserted that he was in no way concerned with Automobiles Financing Corporation, Kanpur nor the bus was ever financed by the firm. It was also asserted that the applicant has no right, title or interest in the bus in question and the learned Magistrate was correct in rejecting the application for release of the bus moved by the applicant. The applicant has filed rejoinder affidavit in reply to the counter affidavit by the opposite party No. 2.

(4) I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have perused the material on record. The contention by the learned counsel for the applicant is that as the applicant was the registered owner of the bus in question, the same should be released in his favor. It has also been contended that while disposing of an application under section 451, Cr. P. C. , the learned Magistrate could not enter into the question of ownership of the bus but should have released the same in favor of its registered owner. In reply to the above argument by the learned counsel for the applicant, the learned counsel for opposite party No. 2 has stated that actually opposite party No. 2 Satnam Singh was the registered owner of the bus in question and he had leased the same to the accused against whom the complaint has been filed. It has also been contended that the accused persons were not entitled to transfer the bus but they fraudulently and wrongfully transferred it to the applicant who got the registration number of the bus wrongfully changed in his name. It is contended that merely because the applicant has succeeded in fraud-lently getting the registration changed in his name, the bus should not be released in his favor.

(5) THE learned counsel for the applicant has referred to the ruling in the case Kalpanath Singh v. Sheo Nath Rai and also the decision by a Division Bench of this court dated 16. 4. 1987 in the case Smt. Naseem Banu v. State of U. P. and another in support of his argument that the bus should be released in favor of the registered owner of the same.

(6) IN Kalpanath Singhs case, referred to above, one Shiv Nath Rai was the owner of the motor vehicle in question. It was also registered in his name under the Motor Vehicles Act. Kalpanath Singh lodged a report under section 379, I. P. C. alleging that he had purchased the said bus from Shiv Nath Rai and, on his behalf, he had started paying the remaining installments of the bus to the bank concerned, but Shiv Nath Rai took away the vehicle by force. The police submitted a charge-sheet against Shiv Nath Rai. During the pendency of the case Kalpanath Singh moved an application under section 451, Cr. P. C. for release of the vehicle in his favor. The learned Magistrate held that Kalpanath Singh was entitle to the custody of the bus and accordingly released the same in his favor. Shiv Nath Rai filed a revision against that order and the learned Sessions Judge held that even if Kalpanath Singh had paid any money to Shiv Nath Rai and had also paid installments of the loan to the Bank; he could not become owner of the vehicle because its registration was not transferred in his name under section 31 of the Motor Vehicles Act. He allowed the revision and vacated the order passed by the Magistrate. Kalpanath Singh then filed revision in this court. Though this court observed that the person, in whose name the vehicle stands registered with the registering authority under the Motor Vehicles Act, is prima-facie the owner of a vehicle and is entitled to its custody unless any other person establishes his superior title or claim over it, it still held that as prima-facie it has been shown that Kalpanath Singh had purchased the vehicle from its registered owner, the vehicle should be released in his favor, even though it was not registered in his name.

(7) IN Smt. Naseem Banus case this court concerned a number of decisions of this court and deserved that the consensus of opinion appears to have been that release should ordinarily be made in favor of the person in whose name the registration of the vehicle appears to be. The learned counsel for the applicant has, on the basis of this observation, argues that as the vehicle was registered in the name of the applicant, it should be released in his favor. I am, however, unable to agree with the argument that under section 451, Cr. P. C. the Magistrate concerned is bound to release the vehicle in favor of the registered owner irrespective of the facts and circumstances of the case. Consider a case where the vehicle belonging to a person, and registered in his name, is stolen by somebody and the thief subsequently manages to get it registered in his name under the Motor Vehicles Act. Can it be said that even in such a case the court is bound to release the vehicle in his favor? This aspect of the matter was actually considered in Smt. Naseem Banus case where it was observed that the release should normally be in favor of the person shown to be registered owner of the vehicle but, depending on the facts and circumstances of the case, it remains open to the court to take a different view where the facts warrant an inference that the registration could not be given effect to. It was further observed that in a case, for instance, where it is shown prima-facie that the registration was fraudulent or obtained by misrepresentation or that for other cogent reason manifest on the record, it could not be treated as valid. In the eye of law, the powers of the court are not foreclosed for the purpose of directing release even to the person who is not the registered owner. Thus in case it prima-facie appears that the registration was fraudulent or obtained by miss-representation or if, for other cogent reasons, it could not be treated as valid in the eye of law, the Magistrate could release the vehicle n favor of a person who is not the registered owner of the same.

(8) IN the present case the vehicle was owned by opposite party No. 2 Satnam Singh. It is also not disputed that it was originally registered in his name. The contention by the applicant is that he purchased this vehicle and subsequently it was registered in his name. According to him the vehicle was financed by Automobiles Financing Corporation and he paid the amount due to that Corporation and after that its registration was changed in his name. The applicant has filed photostat copies of two bank drafts to support his contention about payment of the amount of Rs. 1,50,000/- t. v the firm. He has, however, not filed a single document to show that opposite party No. 2 had received any amount from him or he had entered into any agreement with him regarding the sale of the vehicle. When I put a query to the learned counsel for the applicant as to whether any sale letter was issued by the opposite party No. 2 or any document was executed by him in favor of the applicant, the learned counsel for the petitioner replied that this court cannot go into this question but should direct the release of the vehicle in favor of the applicant on the basis of the rulings relied upon by him. In view of this fact it can be, at this stage, accepted that opposite party No. 2, who was the registered owner of the vehicle, neither issued any sale letter in favor of the applicant nor any document was executed about the alleged sale of the vehicle between him and the applicant. Thus the applicant has at this stage not been able to show that he had entered into any agreement with the opposite party No. 2 regarding the sale of the vehicle in question. He has in fact not produced any document even to show that there was any agreement of sale between him and the accused persons who had executed an agreement of lease in favor of the opposite party No. 2. Except for the fact that the applicant had got the vehicle registered in his favor at a subsequent stage, there is no document or material on record to show as to how he became the owner of the vehicle which was admittedly owned by the opposite party No. 2 earlier.

(9) IN these circumstances it cannot be said that merely because the applicant has been able to get the vehicle registered in his name, the same should be released in his favor. The opposite party No. 2 has in para 24 of his counter affidavit alleged that URU 5428 was got changed by manipulation fraudulently, thereby asserting that the registration number of the bus in question was got changed by the applicant by manipulation and fraud. The applicant has in para 17 of his rejoinder affidavit mentioned that T1the content of para 24 of the counter affidavit need no reply. Thus even this specific assertion about fraud and manipulation made in the counter affidavit has not been specifically denied by the applicant.

(10) CONSIDERING all these facts and circumstances, it cannot be said that the order by the learned Magistrate refusing to release the vehicle in favor of the applicant amounted to abuse of the process of the court or that it would be in the interest of justice for this court to interfere with the impugned order by the learned Magistrate. In the circumstances this petition is rejected. Application rejected.