Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohan Traders v. A.V.M Cattle & Poultry Feeds Mfg. Industries

Kerala High Court
Oct 10, 1979
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal arises from an order refusing to set aside an ex parte decree passed against the appellants. Although the parties reside in Coimbatore district, Tamil Nadu, the suit was filed in the Sub Court, Trivandrum, on the basis that the cause of action arose within that court's jurisdiction. Summons were sent to the defendants by registered post, which were returned with an endorsement of refusal. The defendants were absent when the case was taken up and were declared ex parte. The suit was decreed on proof by affidavit. Execution proceedings were initiated, and the defendants filed an application to set aside the ex parte decree, claiming they were not served with summons and only became aware of the decree upon receiving execution notice. The trial court dismissed the application, holding that proper service of summons had been effected based on an admission regarding the correctness of the address. This order is challenged in the present appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there has been proper service of summons on the appellants in accordance with the Code of Civil Procedure as amended by Act 104 of 1976.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Daveed Aseervadam v. Govinda Pillai (1970 KLT. 907) Interpretation of Kerala Rule 9(3) and Rule 20A(2) regarding service of summons by registered post and refusal endorsements. The court held that an endorsement of refusal on summons sent by registered post under Rule 9(3) is not sufficient proof of service and that Rule 20A(2) does not apply in such cases, implying no due service if refusal is endorsed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure as amended by Act 104 of 1976, focusing on the proper mode of service of summons. It emphasized that the ordinary mode is personal service by a court officer or an authorized agent or family member, with proper acknowledgment. Service by registered post is permitted only in addition to and simultaneously with personal service, as per Rule 19A introduced by the 1976 amendment. The court noted that the Kerala High Court's Rule 9(3), which allowed service solely by registered post without prior personal service, is inconsistent with the amended Code and thus stands repealed by Section 97(1) of the Amendment Act. The court further relied on precedent to clarify that refusal endorsements on summons sent by registered post under Rule 9(3) do not constitute proper service. Since in the instant case summons were sent only by registered post without prior personal service, and were refused, there was no proper service of summons. Consequently, the trial court erred in refusing to set aside the ex parte decree.

Holding and Implications

Allowed.

The appeal is allowed, the ex parte decree against the appellants is set aside, and the suit is restored to the file for disposal according to law. The appellants are entitled to their costs in the appeal. The case is posted for appearance before the trial court on 3-12-1979. No new precedent is established beyond clarifying the application of service rules under the amended Code of Civil Procedure.

Show all summary ...

Janaki Amma, J.:— The appeal arises from an order refusing to set aside an ex parte decree passed against the appellants.

2. Though the parties to the suit reside in the Coimbatore district of Tamil Nadu, the suit was filed in the Sub Court, Trivandrum apparently on the ground that the cause of action arose within the jurisdiction of that court. The court issued summons to the defendants by registered post returnable by 21-1-78. The postal authorities returned the summons with an endorsement of refusal. On 21-1-78 when the case was taken up, the defendants were absent and were declared ex parte. On the plaint claim being proved by affidavit, the suit was decreed on 28-2-1978. Execution was taken up in due course and notice of execution was served on the defendants through the Sub Court, Erode. The defendants thereupon filed I.A 1723 of 1979 for setting aside the ex parte decree stating that they were not served with summons and that they came to know of the decree only on 23-2-79 when the notice of execution was served on them. Basing on the admission of Pw. 1, the father of defendants 2 and 3, that the address given of the defendants on the cover which purported to contain the summons and the copy of the plaint was correct, the learned Subordinate Judge held that there was proper service of summons. The petition was accordingly dismissed. It is this order that is challenged in this appeal. The point for decision is whether there has been proper service of summons. The law applicable is the Code of Civil Procedure as amended by Act 104 of 1976. This is not disputed. Order V, Rule 21 provides that where the defendant resides within the jurisdiction of a court other than the one which issues the summons, summons may be sent to that court either by one of the officers of the Court issuing the summons or by post. The service of summons on the defendant is to be effected by the Court within whose jurisdiction the defendant resides. The usual mode of service is by delivery or tendering a copy of the summons by an officer of the Court to the defendant, if practicable or to an agent of the defendant who is empowered to accept summons or where he has no agent, to an adult member of his family residing with him. The person who accepts the summons is to sign on the original of the summons in acknowledgment of such acceptance. (See Order V, Rules 10 to 16). Rule 17 of Order V deals with cases of refusal of summons by a defendant to whom it is tendered. In such cases, the serving officer should affix a copy of the summons on the outer door or some other conspicuous part of the house in which the defendant ordinarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain and should return the original to the Court from which it was issued with a report that he has so affixed the copy, the circumstances under which he did so and the name and address of the person (if any) by whom the house was identified and in whose presence the copy was affixed.

3. From the above provisions, it is clear that the ordinary mode of service that the law contemplates is service through an officer of the Court. Service of summons by post was provided by Rule 20A which was inserted by Central Act 66 of 1956. Such service by post was in lieu of or in addition to service through officer of Court in cases the original summons was returned unserved. Rule 20A(2) dealt with refusal of summons sent by registered post. S. 20A, however, stands deleted by the Amendment Act of 1976. At present, service by post is provided in Rule 19A which is added by the Amendment Act of 1976. The rule reads:

“Simultaneous issue of summons for service by post in addition to personal service-(1). The Court shall, in addition to and simultaneously with, the issue of summons for service in the manner provided in rules 9 to 19 (both inclusive), also direct the summons to be served by registered post, acknowledgment due, addressed to the defendant, or his agent empowered to accept the service, at the place where the defendant, or his agent, actually and voluntarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain:

Provided that nothing in this sub-rule shall require the Court to issue a summons for service by registered post, where, in the circumstances of the case, the Court considers it unnecessary.”

4. Thus even though service by registered post is permissible, it has to be done in addition to and simulaneously with the issue of summons for service in the manner provided in Rules 9 to 19. In other words, the statute does not contemplate service of summons through registered post in cases where summons through Court has not been taken. Rule 9(3) framed by the Kerala High Court, no doubt, deviates from the above provision and permits service of summons by post even without a prior attempt through court. The sub-rule reads:

“Where the defendant resides in India whether within the jurisdiction of the Court in which the suit is instituied or not, the Court may direct the proper officer to cause a summons under this order to be addressed to the defendant at the place where be ordinarily resides or carries on business or works for gain and sent to him by registered post prepaid for acknowledgment. An acknowledgment purporting to be signed by the defendant shall be deemed to be sufficient proof of service of such summons.”

5. The rule does not provide for cases of refusal of summons issued through registered post.

6. Kerala Rule 9(3) and Rule 20A(2) came up for interpretation before a Division Bench of this Court in Daveed Aseervadam v. Govinda Pillai (1970 KLT. 907). The court held that since Rule 9(3) says nothing about an endorsement of refusal, the implication is clear that an endorsement of refusal is not to be deemed to be sufficient proof of service. In such cases, sub-rule (2) of Rule 20A has no application and when a summons issued under Rule 9(3) is returned with an endorsement by the postman that it was refused, there is no due service of the summons.

7. Reference may in this connection be made to S. 97(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1976. Under the said provision any amendment made or any provision inserted in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 by a State Legislature or a High Court before the commencement of the said Amendment Act, shall except in so far as such amendment or provision is consistent with the provisions of the said Code stand repealed. Evidently, Rule 9(3) added in Kerala in so far as it provides for issue of summons by registered post otherwise than as provided in Rule 19A is inconsistent with the provisions of the Amendment Act, 104 of 1976. The result is that Rule 9(3) added in Kerala stands repealed by virtue of S. 97(1) of the Amendment Act.

8. It follows that under the law as it stands now, service of summons through registered post is permitted only in addition to and simultaneously with the issue of summons for service in the manner provided in Rules 9 to 19. An endorsement of refusal can be acted upon only if the procedure in Order V, Rule 19A has been followed.

9. In the instant case, there is no case for the respondent that summons to the appellants had been taken through court and as such, there has not been proper service of summons. The court below has, therefore, gone wrong in refusing to set aside the decree passed against the appellants. The appeal is accordingly allowed. The ex parte decree against the appellants will stand set aside and the suit will be restored to file and disposed of according to law. The appellants will be entitled to their costs in the appeal. The case will stand posted for appearance of parties before the trial court to 3-12-1979.

10. Allowed.