- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Munna Kumar v. State Of Bihar .
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, Munna Kumar, was convicted by the Xth Additional Sessions Judge, Patna for an offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC. He appealed to the High Court of Judicature at Patna, which confirmed the conviction and sentence.
As per the prosecution, on 1-6-1994 at about 2:00 p.m., Munna Kumar and his friend Dilip Kumar took the deceased, Ashok Kumar, from his house on the pretext of playing football. When Ashok did not return by evening, his father searched for him and near the Damodar Valley Corporation office allegedly saw Ashok in the presence of the accused, raising alarm and trying to escape. The prosecution case was that Munna Kumar fired a shot at Ashok Kumar, causing a head injury; Ashok was taken to Patna Medical College Hospital and later died.
The investigating officer visited the hospital and the place of incident, conducted investigation, and the body was subjected to post-mortem examination (though the manner of proof of that report later became significant). The Sessions Court and the High Court relied on eyewitness testimony (PWs 1 to 3).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in the absence of proper proof of the post-mortem report, the prosecution proved the cause of death sufficiently to sustain a conviction for murder under Section 302 IPC.
- Whether the proved act of firing a shot at the deceased’s head warranted conviction for an alternative offence (Section 307 IPC) instead of Section 302 IPC.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The post-mortem examination report was not proved in accordance with the prescribed procedure because it was not proved by the doctor who prepared it nor by any person acquainted with the doctor’s handwriting.
- As a result, the prosecution failed to establish the cause of death of Ashok Kumar, and therefore failed to prove the offence of murder against the appellant.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court noted that both the Sessions Judge and the High Court relied upon the evidence of PWs 1 to 3 as eyewitnesses, and it found no infirmity in the High Court’s acceptance of their testimony.
A central deficiency identified by the court was the proof of the post-mortem report. The prosecution did not examine the doctor who prepared the report, nor any person acquainted with the doctor’s handwriting. Instead, an advocate’s clerk was examined, who admitted he had no acquaintance with the doctor and no familiarity with the doctor’s handwriting. The court concluded that the post-mortem report was not proved as per the prescribed procedure, and that the prosecution failed to adduce the “best evidence” to prove it. On that basis, the court held that the appellant was entitled to the benefit of doubt regarding the cause of death.
Although there was evidence that Munna Kumar fired a shot at the head of Ashok Kumar, and the inquest report indicated an injury on the head, the court found there was no satisfactory evidence proving the cause of death. In the court’s view, this made it difficult to sustain a conviction for murder under Section 302 IPC. However, the court held that the evidence established beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant fired at the deceased’s head, bringing the conduct within Section 307 IPC.
Holding and Implications
ALLOWED; CONVICTION UNDER SECTION 302 SET ASIDE; CONVICTION ALTERED TO SECTION 307 WITH 8 YEARS’ IMPRISONMENT.
The appellant’s conviction and sentence for the offence punishable under Section 302 (read with Section 34) IPC were set aside. He was found guilty under Section 307 IPC and sentenced to 8 years’ imprisonment, with set-off for the period already undergone; if he had already completed 8 years, he was directed to be released forthwith. The co-accused Dilip Kumar had not appealed; the court noted he would be entitled to the benefit of this decision if he approached the court in appeal. The opinion does not indicate that it laid down any new precedent; its direct effect was to modify the appellant’s conviction and sentence based on evidentiary shortcomings regarding proof of cause of death.
Order
1. The appellant Munna Kumar was found guilty by the Xth Additional Sessions Judge, Patna for the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC. He challenged his conviction and sentence in the appeal preferred before the High Court of Judicature at Patna. The High Court confirmed the conviction and sentence. The prosecution case is that the appellant Munna Kumar and his friend Dilip Kumar went to the house of the deceased Ashok Kumar on 1-6-1994 at about 2.00 p.m and took him away from his house on the pretext of playing football. As Ashok Kumar did not return home in the evening, his father got suspicious and went in search of him. When he reached near the office of Damodar Valley Corporation he saw his son Ashok Kumar in the presence of these appellants. Ashok Kumar was raising alarm and was trying to escape from the appellants. The case of the prosecution is that the appellant fired a shot at deceased Ashok Kumar and he sustained injury on his head. In the injured condition he was taken to Patna Medical College Hospital but his life could not be saved.
2. The investigating officer came to know of the incident and he went to the Patna Medical College Hospital and thereafter he visited the place of incident and conducted further investigation. The body of the deceased Ashok Kumar was subject to post-mortem examination and it was found that there was a bullet injury on his head. The Sessions Judge as well as the High Court relied on the evidence of PWs 1 to 3 who were eyewitnesses. The High Court accepted the evidence of these three witnesses and we do not find any infirmity in this and the evidence of these witnesses were rightly accepted by the High Court.
3. One significant aspect of this case is that the post-mortem examination produced by the prosecution was neither proved by the examining doctor who prepared it nor any person who had any acquaintance with the handwriting of the doctor was examined on the side of the prosecution. An advocate's clerk was examined to prove the post-mortem examination. He candidly admitted in the cross-examination that he had no acquaintance with the doctor who prepared the post-mortem examination and that he had no familiarity with the handwriting of the doctor. Therefore, it is clear that the post-mortem report was not proved as per the prescribed procedure. On this basis, counsel for the appellant contended that the prosecution evidence would not show the cause of death of Ashok Kumar and it is submitted that the prosecution failed to prove the offence of murder against the appellant. We find some force in this contention. The prosecution should have produced the best evidence by proving the post-mortem certificate. It should have examined any person who had some acquaintance with the handwriting of the doctor who prepared the post-mortem report, either one of his colleagues or anybody who had been working in the hospital where the doctor worked. The prosecution failed to produce the best evidence and the appellant is certainly entitled to the benefit of doubt arising out of this.
4. However, there is evidence to the effect that the appellant Munna Kumar fired a shot at the head of the deceased Ashok Kumar. The inquest report also would show that Ashok Kumar sustained an injury on his head but there is no satisfactory evidence to prove the cause of death of Ashok Kumar. In the absence of any satisfactory evidence it is difficult to convict the appellant for the offence of murder punishable under Section 302. However, there is satisfactory evidence beyond all reasonable doubt to show that the appellant Munna Kumar fired a shot at the head of deceased Ashok Kumar. The offence would certainly come within the purview of Section 307 IPC.
5. In the result, we set aside the conviction and sentence of the appellant for the offence punishable under Section 302 and find him guilty and sentence him to undergo imprisonment for a period of 8 years under Section 307 IPC. We are told that the appellant has already undergone a long period in jail and he is entitled to set off for the period already undergone and if he has already completed 8 years, he be released forthwith. Dilip Kumar, the co-accused, who had been convicted along with Munna Kumar has not filed any appeal in this Court. He would be entitled to the benefit of this, in case he comes before this Court in appeal. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed.
Alert