- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of H.P And Others v. Sudesh Kumari
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
Ms. Alpana (writ petitioner in CWP No. 3363 of 2009) challenged an Office Memorandum dated 31.7.2009 (Annexure P3) and an order dated 2.9.2009 (Annexure P4) seeking quashing of those communications. The petitioner's case was that, under the applicable law and rules, female contractual employees were entitled to maternity leave at par with regular employees; earlier instructions had enhanced maternity leave from 84 days to 135 days (Annexure P3). The petitioner, who was working as a Lecturer on contract, had availed maternity leave which had been sanctioned in her favour. Subsequently, Annexure P3 and Annexure P4 were issued to grant only 12 weeks (84 days) maternity leave to female contractual employees and to withdraw earlier instructions (Annexure P2). The petitioner sought writs in the nature of certiorari to quash Annexures P3 and P4 and to direct the State to provide 135 days maternity leave to contractual employees.
The Writ Court quashed the impugned order restraining the State from effecting recovery from the petitioner.
Another writ petitioner, Ms. Sudesh Kumari (in CWP No. 1617 of 2014), filed a petition after noticing the judgment in Ms. Alpana's case, seeking the same reliefs (quash Annexure P1 dated 31.7.2009 and Annexure P4 and a mandamus to extend 135 days maternity leave). That writ petition was also granted in terms of the judgement passed in Alpana's case.
The State challenged both Writ Court judgments by filing Letters Patent Appeals (LPAs), contending that the petitioners were not entitled to maternity leave at par with regular employees and that the Writ Courts' decisions were not legally sustainable.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether female contractual/ad hoc/temporary employees are entitled to maternity leave at par with regular/permanent employees (specifically the 135 days period) under the law and applicable rules.
- Whether the Office Memorandum dated 31.7.2009 and the circular/order dated 2.9.2009, which limited maternity leave for contractual employees to 12 weeks (84 days) and withdrew earlier enhanced instructions, are legally sustainable and liable to be quashed.
- Whether the Writ Courts' orders quashing those communications and restraining recovery are legally sustainable.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- Female contractual employees are entitled, as a matter of law and rules, to maternity leave at par with regular employees — the maternity leave had been enhanced from 84 days to 135 days by earlier instructions (Annexure P3).
- The Office Memorandum and subsequent order/circular (Annexures P3 and P4 / Annexure P1 in the second petition) that limited maternity leave for contractual employees to 84 days and withdrew earlier instructions were unlawful and discriminatory.
- The petitioners sought quashing of the impugned communications by writ of certiorari and, in the second petition, a writ of mandamus directing extension of 135 days maternity leave.
State's Arguments
- The State (through the learned Advocate General) argued that the petitioners were not entitled to maternity leave at par with regular employees and that the administration was justified in distinguishing between regular and contractual/part-time employees.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Female Workers (2000) 3 SCC 224 | Held that provisions providing maternity leave do not limit entitlement only to regular employees; casual/muster-roll/daily-wage women employees engaged in long-term work cannot be denied maternity benefits; constitutional and Directive Principles support maternity relief (Article 42). | The Court relied on the reasoning in this case—quoting multiple paras—to support that women employed on casual/muster-roll/contractual basis cannot be denied maternity benefits and to emphasize constitutional imperatives against discrimination. |
| Hindustan Antibiotics Ltd. v. Workmen, AIR 1967 SC 948 (1967 (1) SCR 652) | Principle that labour in whatever sector should be treated on an equal basis in the relevant region/industry (applied in context of Article 14 and labour laws). | Referenced to reinforce the equality principle under Article 14 vis-à-vis labour and to support treating contractual employees equally for maternity benefits. |
| Ms. Sonika Kohli v. Union of India, 2004 (3) SLJ 54 CAT | Held that denial of maternity leave to female teachers was violative of Articles 14 and 15; the claim for maternity leave is founded on fair play and social justice and Articles 42/43 and Directive Principles inform entitlement. | Quoted to support the proposition that maternity leave claims rest on fair play and social justice and that denial to contract employees amounts to discriminatory treatment contrary to constitutional provisions. |
| Rattan Lal v. State of Haryana, 1985 (3) SLR 548 | Deplored policy denying salary/allowances to 'ad hoc' teachers during vacations by artificial breaks and held that those entitled to maternity or medical leave should be granted such leave in accordance with rules. | Reproduced to buttress the view that ad hoc/'contract' teachers are entitled to maternity/medical leave and related benefits as per rules. |
| Tasneem Firdous v. State, 2006 (II) S.L.J 699 | Held that contractual employees are entitled to maternity leave; considered broader constitutional obligations and international covenants (e.g., CEDAW) in protecting rights of women. | Invoked to support the entitlement of contractual employees to maternity leave and to note the international and constitutional dimensions of the State's obligation to protect women's rights. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by rejecting the State's contention that the petitioners were not entitled to maternity leave at par with regular employees. The reasoning proceeded along the following lines, drawing explicitly from constitutional articles, statutory context, and precedent:
- The Court emphasized that in law there is no relevant difference between a female regular employee and a contractual/ad hoc/temporary employee for the purposes of maternity: biologically and socially a female employee undergoes the same maternity-related conditions and hardships regardless of employment status. Denying equal maternity leave to contractual employees would amount to discrimination under Article 14.
- The Court framed the claim for maternity leave as grounded in fair play and social justice, invoking Articles 14 and 15 against discrimination and citing Directive Principles (Articles 41, 42 and 43) that require the State to secure just and humane conditions of work and provide maternity relief. The opinion reproduced Articles 41, 42 and 43 to show the constitutional context underpinning maternity benefits.
- The Court relied on Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Female Workers (2000) 3 SCC 224 to show that the Maternity Benefit Act and related considerations do not confine maternity benefits solely to regular employees. The Municipal Corporation judgment was quoted at length to support the proposition that maternity benefits should extend to women employed on muster-roll/daily-wage/contractual bases, and that denial of such benefits would be inconsistent with the objectives of the Maternity Benefit Act and constitutional principles.
- The Court cited Sonika Kohli (2004 (3) SLJ 54 CAT) to reiterate that claims for maternity leave are founded on social justice and that denial by administration can violate Articles 14 and 15. The Court used this to repudiate distinctions carved out by the State between regular and contractual employees for maternity benefit purposes.
- The Court referred to Rattan Lal v. State of Haryana to show prior authority disapproving policies which denied entitlements (such as salary/allowances or leave) to ad hoc teachers by artificial or fictional devices, emphasizing that those entitled to maternity or medical leave should be granted such leave in accordance with rules.
- The Court also noted the Jammu & Kashmir High Court decision in Tasneem Firdous v. State which held that contractual employees are entitled to maternity leave, drawing attention to the broader constitutional and international law considerations (including reference to international covenants protecting women's rights).
- On the basis of these constitutional principles, statutory context, and precedents, the Court held that the Office Memorandum dated 31.7.2009 and the circular dated 2.9.2009, which limited maternity leave for contractual employees to 84 days and withdrew earlier instructions providing 135 days, were unlawful and were to be quashed. Consequently, all female employees—whether on contract, ad hoc, permanent or temporary—were held to be entitled to maternity leave at par with regular employees.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court quashed the Office Memorandum dated 31.7.2009 and the circular/order dated 2.9.2009, and held that all female employees—whether on contract, ad hoc, permanent or temporary—are entitled to maternity leave at par with regular employees (i.e., the enhanced period referred to in earlier instructions).
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The writ decisions in favour of the petitioners were sustained; recovery proceedings based on the impugned communications were restrained/quashed in respect of the petitioners as per the Writ Court orders, and the LPAs were dismissed.
- The opinion grounds its decision on constitutional equality and social-justice principles, statutory context (including the Maternity Benefit Act jurisprudence), and prior case law cited in the opinion.
- The opinion does not state that it is creating a new legal precedent beyond applying existing constitutional and statutory principles and the authorities it cites; it implements those principles to quash the impugned communications and to extend maternity-leave parity to female contractual/ad hoc/temporary employees.
Note: This summary is confined strictly to matters and reasoning contained in the provided judicial opinion. No facts, arguments, or conclusions not present in the opinion have been added.
Mansoor Ahmad Mir, Chief Justice.
Ms. Alpana writ petitioner in CWP No. 3363 of 2009 had invoked the jurisdiction of this Court for quashing Office Memorandum dated 31.7.2009, Annexure P3 and order dated 2.9.2009 Annexure P4, on the grounds taken in the memo of writ petition.
2. The case of the writ petitioner is that as per law and the Rules occupying the field, all the female contractual employees are entitled to maternity leave at par with the regular employees and that is why their maternity leaves were enhanced from 84 days to 135 days in terms of Annexure P3. The petitioner while working as Lecturer, on contract basis, had availed maternity leave. The leave availed by her was duly sanctioned in her favour. Subsequently, vide Office Memorandum Annexure P3, appended with the writ petition as also letter dated 2nd September, 2009 Annexure P4, it was decided to grant only 12 weeks (84 days) maternity leave to the female employees working on contract basis and earlier instructions Annexure P2 were withdrawn by the respondent. Thus, the petitioner had sought writ of certiorari for quashing Annexures P3 and P4 commanding the respondents-State to provide all the female contractual employees 135 days materiality leave to which regular employees are entitled to. It is apt to reproduce reliefs claimed in the writ petitions filed by Ms. Alpana herein:
“(a) That the order dated 2.9.2009 (Annexure P-4) effecting recovery of alleged over payment made to the petitioner on account of availing Maternity leave of 135 days may kindly be quashed by way of issuance of writ in the nature of certiorari.
(b) That the office Memorandum dated 31.7.2009 (Annexure P-3) may also be quashed.”
3. The Writ Court, after considering the case of the petitioner, quashed the impugned order restraining the State from effecting recovery from the petitioner.
4. Ms. Sudesh Kumari, writ petitioner in another writ petition, after noticing the judgment, also filed CWP No. 1617 of 2014 for the grant of same reliefs.
5. It is also apt to reproduce reliefs claimed by writ petitioner Sudesh Kumar in the writ petition herein:
“1. That the writ of certiorari to quash Annexure P1 dated 31st July, 2009 (office memorandum) and specially annexure P-4 by which Annexure P-3 office order of dated 10.3.2009 vide which the maternity leave to the contractual employees was enhanced from 85 days to 135 days on the ground that there cannot be any discrimination between the regular and contractual employees, has been withdrawn.
2. Issue a writ of mandamus directing the respondent's authorities to extend the Maternity leave to present petitioner for 135 days.”
6. The said writ petition was also granted in favour of the petitioner, in terms of the judgment passed in Alpana's case in CWP No. 3363/2009, supra.
7. The State has questioned both these judgments by the medium of these LPAs, on the grounds that the petitioners were not entitled to maternity leave at par with the regular employees and the judgments made by the Writ Courts are not legally sustainable. The argument advanced by the learned Advocate General is not tenable for the following reasons.
8. In law, there is no difference between a female regular employee and a contractual employee/ad hoc employee because a female employee whether regular, temporary or ad hoc, is a female for all intents and purposes and she has a matrimonial home, matrimonial life, and after conception, she has to undergo the entire maternity period, same treatment, pains and other difficulties which a regular employee has to undergo. Thus, there is no occasion for making discrimination and if, less period of maternity leave is granted to a contractual employee, it will amount to discrimination, in terms of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
9. The claim of maternity leave is founded on the grounds of fair play and social justice. There cannot be discrimination and if any discrimination is made, it is in breach of Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution. Articles 41, 42, and 43 deals with the subject and we deem it appropriate to reproduce the said Articles herein:
“41. Right to work, to education and to public assistance in certain cases.- The State shall, within the limits of its economic capacity and development, make effective provision for securing the right to work, to education and to public assistance in cases of unemployment, old age, sickness and disablement, and in other cases of undeserved want.
42. Provision for just and humane conditions of work and maternity relief.- The State shall make provision for securing just and humane conditions of work and for maternity relief.
43. Living wage, etc., for workers.- The State shall endeavour to secure, by suitable legislation or economic organization or in any other way, to all workers, agricultural, industrial or otherwise, work, a living wage, conditions of work ensuring a decent standard of life and full enjoyment of leisure and social and cultural opportunities and, in particular, the State shall endeavour to promote cottage
industries on an individual or co-operative basis in rural areas.”
10. In case titled Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Female Workers (2000) 3 SCC 224, it has been held as under:
“27. The provisions of the Act which have been set out above would indicate that they are wholly in consonance with the Directive Principles of State Policy, as set out in Article 39 and in other Articles, specially Article 42. A woman employee, at the time of advanced pregnancy cannot be compelled to undertake hard labour as it would be detrimental to her health and also to the health of the foetus. It is for this reason that it is provided in the Act that she would be entitled to maternity leave for certain periods prior to and after delivery. We have scanned the different provisions of the Act, but we do not find anything contained in the Act which entitles only regular women employees to the benefit of maternity leave and not to those who are engaged on casual basis or on muster roll on daily wage basis.
28. The Industrial Tribunal, which has given an award in favour of the respondents, has noticed that women employees have been engaged by the Corporation on muster roll, that is to say, on daily wage basis for doing various kinds of works in projects like construction of buildings, digging of trenches, making of roads, etc., but have been denied the benefit of maternity leave. The Tribunal has found that though the women employees were on muster roll and had been working for the Corporation for more than 10 years, they were not regularized. The Tribunal, however, came to the conclusion that the provisions of the Maternity Benefit Act had not been applied to the Corporation and, therefore, it felt that there was a lacuna in the Act. It further felt that having regard to the activities of the Corporation, which had employed more than a thousand women employees, it should have been brought within the purview of the Act so that the maternity benefits contemplated by the Act could be extended to the women employees of the Corporation. It felt that this lacuna could be removed by the State Govt. by issuing the necessary notification under the Proviso to Section 2 of the Maternity Act. This Proviso lays down as under:
“Provided that the State Government may, with the approval of the Central Government, after giving not less than two month's notice of its intention of so doing, by notification in the Official Gazette, declare that all or any of the provisions of this Act shall apply also to any other establishment or class of establishments, industrial, commercial, agricultural or otherwise.”
29……
30. We appreciate the efforts of the Industrial Tribunal in issuing the above directions so as to provide the benefit of the Act to the muster roll women employees of the Corporation. This direction is fully in consonance with the reference made to the Industrial Tribunal. The question referred for adjudication has already been reproduced in the earlier part of the judgment. It falls in two parts as under:
(i) Whether the female workers working on muster roll should be given any maternity benefit?
(ii) If so, what directions are necessary in this regard.
31-32……..
33. A just social order can be achieved only when inequalities are obliterated and everyone is provided what is legally due. Women who constitute almost half of the segment of our society have to be honoured and treated with dignity at places where they work to earn their livelihood. Whatever be the nature of their duties, their avocation and the place where they work; they must be provided all the facilities to which they are entitled. To become a mother is the most natural phenomena in the life of a woman. Whatever is needed to facilitate the birth of child to a woman who is in service, the employer has to be considerate and sympathetic towards her and must realise the physical difficulties which a working woman would face in performing her duties at the work place while carrying a baby in the womb or while rearing up the child after birth. The Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 aims to provide all these facilities to a working woman in a dignified manner so that she may overcome the state of motherhood honourably, peaceably, undeterred by the fear of being victimised for forced absence during the pre or post-natal period.”
11. In Ms. Sonika Kohli v. Union of India reported in 2004 (3) SLJ 54 CAT, it has been held in paras 12 and 13, the relevant portion of which is quoted as under:
“12. An almost a new point of controversy has been raised with regard to the admissibility of maternity leave to female teachers. In some of the O.As it has been prayed that the benefit of maternity leave, which has hitherto been denied by the respondent-Administration, be directed to be extended in accordance with the rules. Mr. R.P Bali, learned Counsel for some of the applicants urged that the action of the respondents in denying the benefit of maternity leave like other regular employees is violative of the principles enshrined in Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution of India as it denies the benefit of beneficial provisions of law to a female teacher. Mr. N.K Bhardwaj, learned Counsel for the Administration urged that maternity leave is not admissible to contract employees as they are not covered by the Punjab CSR Vol.1, Part-1. According to him, the benefit of maternity leave with pay is payable to permanent/regular female employees and that the Administration is justified in carving out a distinction between the regular female teachers and the teachers appointed on part time or contract basis, as is in the present case. Let us examine the respective contentions of the parties.
13. The claim for maternity leave is founded on grounds of fair play and social justice. Before the advent of the Constitution and for a sufficiently long time, thereafter it was customary or say traditional for women to stick to their homes but now they seek various jobs so as to attain economic independence by utilizing their talent, education, industry etc. Sometimes the jobs are taken up by them to overcome economic hardship. For a woman to become a mother is most natural phenomenon in her life. Whatever is needed to facilitate the birth of a child to a women who is in service, the employer has to be considerate and sympathetic towards her and must realize the physical difficulties which a working women would face in performing her duties at work place while carrying a baby in the womb or while bearing a child after birth. Our constitution which, in its preamble, promises social and economic justice, enshrines certain radical provisions in the form of Articles 42 and 43 which deal with the just and humane conditions of work and maternity relief as well as living wage conditions of work ensuring a decent standard of life, and full enjoyment of leisure and social and cultural opportunities. These principles are required to be followed by the State as enjoined by Article 39. In the background of these Articles, the Parliament has enacted Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 (Act No. 53 of 1961) with a view to regulate the employment of women in certain establishments for certain periods before and after child birth and to provide for maternity benefit and certain other benefits…………………….”
12. It is also apt to reproduce para 3 of the judgment delivered in Rattan Lal v. State of Haryana reported in 1985 (3) SLR 548.
“3. We strongly deprecate the policy of the State Government under which ‘ad hoc’ teachers are denied the salary and allowances for the period of the summer vacation by resorting to the fictional breaks of the type referred to above. These ‘ad hoc’ teachers shall be paid salary and allowances for the period of summer vacation as long as they hold the office under this order. Those who are entitled to maternity or medical leave shall also be granted such leave in accordance with the rules.”
13. The Jammu and Kashmir High Court in case titled Tasneem Firdous v. State reported in 2006 (II) S.L.J 699, held that the employees working on contractual basis are also entitled to maternity leave. The relevant portion of para 6 of the judgment is reproduced as under:
“6. In subjective context the matter assumes a larger dimensions because it overflows the contours of an individual case or a singular instance and almost borders on the rights of women and obligation of the State to protect and preserve them, to which, besides statutory constitutional considerations, the international covenants also bind the government. Reference in this behalf may be made to “Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination against Women” adopted by Community of nations on 18.12.1979 to which government of India too is a signatory…………”
14. In paras 6 and 37 of the judgment in Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Female Workers (2000) 3 SCC 224, supra, while considering the constitutional contours of the matter, the Hon'ble apex Court observed as under:
“6……….. It is in this background that we have to look to our Constitution which, in its Preamble, promises social and economic justice. We may first look at the Fundamental Rights contained in Chapter III of the Constitution. Article 14 provides that the State shall not deny to any person equality before law or the equal protection of the laws within the territory of India. Dealing with this Article vis-a-vis the Labour Laws, this Court in Hindustan Antibiotics Ltd. v. Workmen, AIR 1967 SC 948: 1967 (1) SCR 652, has held that labour to whichever sector it may belong in a particular region and in a particular industry will be treated on equal basis. Article 15 provides that the State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth or any of them. Clause (3) of this Article provides as under:-
“(3) Nothing in this article shall prevent the State from making any special provision for women and children”.
7-36……….
37…………..“2. In order to prevent discrimination against women on the grounds of marriage or maternity and to ensure their effective right to work, States Parties shall take appropriate measures:
(a) To prohibit, subject to the imposition of sanctions, dismissal on the grounds of pregnancy or of maternity leave and discrimination in dismissals on the basis of marital status;
(b) To introduce maternity leave with pay or with comparable social benefits without loss of former employment, seniority or social allowances;
(c) To encourage the provision of the necessary supporting social services to enable parents to combine family obligations with work responsibilities and participation in public life, in particular through promoting the establishment and development of a network of child-care facilities;
(d) To provide special protection to women during pregnancy in types of work proved to be harmful to them.
3. Protective legislation relating to matters covered in this article shall be reviewed periodically in the light of scientific and technological knowledge and shall be revised, repealed or extended as necessary.”
15. Having said so, the office memorandum dated 31.7.2009 and circular dated 2.9.2009, made by the State are quashed and all female employees whether on contract, ad hoc, permanent and temporary are held entitled to materiality leave at par with the regular employees.
16. For the reasons discussed herein above, the LPAs are dismissed along with pending applications, if any.
Alert