Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Aruna Rodrigues (2) And Others v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
May 8, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Union of India filed three interim applications (IAs Nos. 4, 14 and 15) seeking modification of this Court’s earlier order dated 22-9-2006 (reported at 2011 12 SCC 477). That earlier order had directed the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) to “withhold approvals” for genetically-modified (GM) crops until further instructions. According to the Union of India, the continued operation of that order prevented GEAC from acting on numerous pending applications for field trials of GM plant varieties, even though 91 field tests and 24 approvals (granted between 2-5-2006 and 22-9-2006) were already in progress. The present order resolves the modification request and sets conditions for ongoing and future trials and for the possible commercial release of certain Bt cotton varieties.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Court’s order dated 22-9-2006 should be modified to allow GEAC to process and grant approvals for pending field-trial applications of GM crops.
  2. What safeguards, if any, should accompany such approvals to prevent contamination of neighbouring crops.
  3. Whether GEAC may grant commercial approval for four specified events of Bt cotton and, if so, under what conditions.

Arguments of the Parties

Union of India / GEAC (represented by the learned ASG)

  • Because of the earlier order, GEAC cannot act on numerous field-trial applications, creating a regulatory standstill.
  • Twenty-four approvals were granted between 2-5-2006 and 22-9-2006, and 91 field tests are already underway; continued suspension hampers scientific progress.

Petitioner (represented by Mr. Prashant Bhushan)

  • Existing and proposed field trials lack adequate biosafety measures.
  • There is a serious risk of pollen-flow contamination to neighbouring fields cultivating related plant species.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Order dated 22-9-2006
(2011 12 SCC 477)
Directed GEAC to withhold all approvals for GM crop trials pending further instructions. The Court considered whether and how to modify this prior injunction in the light of current applications and ongoing field trials.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court acknowledged that GEAC had been unable to process pending applications because of the earlier blanket prohibition. Balancing the Union of India’s request for regulatory continuity with the petitioner’s concerns about environmental safety, the Court crafted a conditional relaxation of its prior order. Its analysis focused on biosafety safeguards:

  • GEAC must ensure field trials do not contaminate neighbouring crops; a minimum isolation distance of 200 metres from fields growing the same species is mandated.
  • Each trial must designate a responsible scientist, and the details of such personnel must be reported to GEAC, which must conduct regular supervision.
  • Before any genetically modified (GM) material leaves a greenhouse for open-field trials, the institution must supply a validated, event-specific testing protocol capable of detecting contamination at a limit of detection (LOD) of at least 0.01%.
  • Regarding Bt cotton, GEAC has already approved four events (Cry 1 Ac MON 531, Cry 1 Ac + Cry 2 Ab MON, GFM Cry 1 A, and Cry 1 Ac Event 1) for commercial use. The Court permits GEAC to grant commercial approvals for these events, subject to its “usual conditions” and additional verification that:
    • no further genetic modification has created new events,
    • commercial use will not introduce toxicity or allergenicity, and
    • any test data addressing these concerns are made available to the Court.

Holding and Implications

The interim applications are disposed of, and the order of 22-9-2006 is modified. GEAC may now process pending field-trial applications and grant commercial approval for the specified Bt cotton events, provided that it implements the detailed biosafety safeguards outlined above. The matter is listed for further consideration in August 2007.

Implications: The decision lifts the blanket moratorium imposed in 2006, enabling continued research and limited commercialisation of certain genetically engineered crops under stringent oversight. The ruling is case-specific and does not establish a new general precedent beyond the immediate regulatory framework for GEAC.

Show all summary ...

Order

IAs Nos. 4, 14 and 15

1. The Union of India is seeking modification of the order passed by this Court on 22-9-2006 (2011) 12 SCC 477. By the said order, this Court had directed the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) to withhold approvals till further instructions to be issued by this Court on hearing of all concerned.

2. The learned ASG submits that in view of the order passed by this Court, GEAC is not in a position to grant approval to various applications which are pending with the said authority. All these applications are for conducting field trials on various varieties of plants. GEAC, during the period 2-5-2006 to 22-9-2006, granted approvals in respect of 24 items in respect of Bt cotton, Bt cauliflower, Bt brinjal, Bt rice, transgenic rice, Bt castor, groundnut, transgenic tomato, potato, and other items. The field trials are going on in respect of these items and this Court in the said order also noticed that 91 field testings have been going on.

3. Mr Prashant Bhushan, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that as regards these field trials sufficient precautions are not being taken and it is likely that there would be serious pollen flow contamination to the plants of similar species of the neighbouring fields.

4. GEAC shall take sufficient precautions to see that these trials are not causing any contamination to the cultivation of neighbouring fields. There should be at least 200 m distance from the trial fields from the neighbouring field having same type of cultivations. All the trials which are being conducted, the name of the scientist and other details who will be responsible for all aspects of the trials should be reported to GEAC and there should be regular supervision by them. Prior to bringing out the GM material from the greenhouse for conduct of open field trials, the approved institution should submit a validated event specific test protocol at an LOD of at least 0.01% to detect and confirm that there has been no contamination.

5. As regards Bt cotton, we are told that GEAC has already granted approval for commercial use of Bt cotton Cry 1 Ac MON 531, Cry 1 Ac and Cry 2 Ab MON, GFM Cry 1 A gene and Cry 1 Ac gene (Event 1). Several applicants sought for permission to use Bt cotton commercially. The applications are pending with GEAC. As regards these four species of Bt cotton varieties, GEAC may give permission for commercial use, subject to the usual conditions imposed. GEAC should also satisfy itself that these events are not further genetically modified so that no further species are created by such modification. GEAC should also verify whether these species by commercial use create any toxicity or allergenicity to any of the users in organic conducted with these varieties of Bt cotton. If any such test has been conducted, the data should be made available to this Court.

6. The IAs are disposed of accordingly. Post the matter in August 2007.

Court Masters