- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shree Sidhbali Steels Limited And Others v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
This matter arises from a writ petition filed under Article 32 of the Constitution of India.
The petitioner had been granted a development rebate of 33.33% by the U.P. State Electricity Board. It is stated that this rebate was granted in view of a State Government policy aimed at encouraging industrialisation of the hill areas.
Subsequently, the U.P. Electricity Reforms Act, 1999 came into force with effect from 14-1-2000. In an earlier judgment, the Supreme Court in U.P. Power Corpn. Ltd. v. Sant Steels & Alloys (P) Ltd., (2008) 2 SCC 777, held that the rebate concession would be valid only until the 1999 Act came into force, as recorded in paragraph 34 of that decision.
In the present writ petition, the petitioner challenges the correctness of the observation in paragraph 34 of the Sant Steels decision insofar as it states that the writ petitioner is not entitled to the rebate concession after 14-1-2000. The current order is an interlocutory order considering whether this question should be referred to a larger Bench.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the observation in paragraph 34 of U.P. Power Corpn. Ltd. v. Sant Steels & Alloys (P) Ltd., holding that the petitioner is not entitled to rebate concession after 14-1-2000, is legally correct in light of Section 12 of the U.P. Electricity Reforms Act, 1999.
- Specifically, whether the rebate concession granted to the writ petitioner from 1997 to 2002 should continue till 2002 or cease to have effect after 14-1-2000 and thereafter, in view of the 1999 Act and the State Government’s power to issue policy directions.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner, through learned Senior Counsel Shri Shanti Bhushan, contends that the observation in paragraph 34 of the Sant Steels judgment—stating that the writ petitioner is not entitled to rebate concession after 14-1-2000—is legally incorrect.
- It is argued that under Section 12 of the U.P. Electricity Reforms Act, 1999, the State Government is empowered to issue policy directions to the Regulatory Commission.
- The petitioner submits that this power is analogous to the earlier power of the State Government to issue policy directions to the U.P. State Electricity Board under Section 78-A of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948.
- On this basis, the petitioner suggests that the policy underlying the development rebate for industrialisation of hill areas could validly continue to operate even after the 1999 Act came into force, and therefore the rebate should not automatically terminate on 14-1-2000.
The opinion does not summarize arguments from the respondents.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| U.P. Power Corpn. Ltd. v. Sant Steels & Alloys (P) Ltd., (2008) 2 SCC 777 | The Supreme Court held that the rebate concession granted by the U.P. State Electricity Board would be valid only until the U.P. Electricity Reforms Act, 1999 came into force (i.e., until 14-1-2000), as recorded in paragraph 34 of that judgment. | The present Bench notes this earlier holding and the specific observation in paragraph 34 which limits rebate entitlement to the period before 14-1-2000. The petitioner’s challenge to the correctness of this observation is considered an important legal question warranting reference to a larger Bench. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court identifies that the central challenge in the present writ petition is to the correctness of the observation in paragraph 34 of the Sant Steels judgment, which restricts the validity of the rebate concession to the period prior to 14-1-2000.
The Court takes note of the petitioner’s submission that Section 12 of the U.P. Electricity Reforms Act, 1999 confers power on the State Government to issue policy directions to the Regulatory Commission, analogous to its prior power to issue policy directions to the U.P. State Electricity Board under Section 78-A of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948. This submission, if accepted, may have a bearing on whether the development rebate could lawfully continue beyond the date on which the 1999 Act came into force.
The Bench emphasizes that the issue is important because it concerns the industrialisation of the hill areas in the State of Uttaranchal, which the Court explicitly recognizes as being in the public interest.
On this basis, the Court concludes that the argument advanced by Shri Shanti Bhushan raises an important question of law that requires consideration by a larger Bench. The Court does not undertake a detailed merits analysis or resolve the substantive legal question; instead, it confines itself to determining that the issue is sufficiently significant to warrant such reference.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The Court holds that the question—whether the rebate concession granted to the writ petitioner from 1997 to 2002 should continue till 2002 or cease to have effect after 14-1-2000 and thereafter—is an important question of law requiring consideration by a larger Bench. The Court directs that the papers of the case be placed before the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India for appropriate orders on constituting a larger Bench to decide this question.
IMPLICATIONS: The immediate effect of this order is that there is no final determination of the petitioner’s entitlement to the development rebate beyond 14-1-2000. The substantive issue of whether the rebate continues up to 2002 or terminates upon the coming into force of the U.P. Electricity Reforms Act, 1999 is left open for decision by a larger Bench. The order primarily affects the parties by deferring the resolution of their rights until the larger Bench renders its decision, and it does not itself establish a new substantive precedent on the merits of the rebate issue.
Order
1. This writ petition has been filed under Article 32 of the Constitution of India.
2. Heard Shri Shanti Bhushan, learned Senior Counsel for the writ petitioner, Shri Pradeep Mishra, learned counsel for U.P Power Corpn. Ltd. and Shri Shail Kumar Dwivedi for the State of Uttar Pradesh.
3. It appears that the petitioner had been granted the development rebate of 33.33% by the U.P State Electricity Board and it is alleged that this was in view of the policy of the State Government to encourage industrialisation of the hill areas.
4. Subsequently, the U.P Electricity Reforms Act, 1999 came into force with effect from 14-1-2000. This Court by its judgment in U.P Power Corpn. Ltd. v. Sant Steels & Alloys (P) Ltd. (2008) 2 SCC 777 held that the rebate concession would be valid till the Act of 1999 came into force (vide SCC para 34).
5. Shri Shanti Bhushan, learned Senior Counsel submits that the observation in the aforesaid para 34 that the writ petitioner is not entitled to the rebate concession after 14-1-2000 is legally not correct because under Section 12 of the U.P Electricity Reforms Act, 1999, the State Government is entitled to issue policy directions to the Regulatory Commission, just as it earlier had power to issue policy directions to the U.P State Electricity Board under Section 78-A of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948.
6. We are of the opinion that this argument of Shri Shanti Bhushan requires consideration by a larger Bench since it is an important question as there can be no doubt that industrialisation of hill areas in the State of Uttaranchal is in the public interest.
7. In view of this we are of the opinion that this question, as to whether the rebate concession granted to the writ petitioner from 1997 to 2002 should continue till 2002 or will cease to have effect after 14-1-2000 and thereafter, deserves consideration by a larger Bench being an important question of law. Let the papers of this case be put before the Hon'ble the Chief Justice of India for deciding the aforesaid question.
Court Masters
Alert