- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sukhdev Singh v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, appointed as Deputy Director of Training on 13 November 1992, consistently received “Outstanding” or “Very Good” entries in his annual confidential reports (ACRs). For the years 2000-2001 and 2001-2002, however, his grading slipped to “Good.” In February 2002 the Union of India issued an Office Memorandum fixing “Very Good” as the benchmark for promotion and directed Departmental Promotion Committees to consider the preceding five years’ ACRs. The appellant’s downgraded ACRs therefore assumed direct relevance to his promotional prospects, prompting the present litigation.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a downgrading of an officer’s ACR from “Very Good” to “Good” constitutes an “adverse remark” that must be formally communicated to the officer.
- Whether the principle articulated in U.P. Jal Nigam v. Prabhat Chandra Jain (1996) 2 SCC 363—regarding communication of downgraded ACRs—applies universally to all government employees or is confined to the employees of U.P. Jal Nigam.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondents' Arguments
- Through the learned Additional Solicitor General, the respondents relied on Union of India v. Major Bahadur Singh (2006) 1 SCC 368 to contend that U.P. Jal Nigam has no “universal application” and was intended to apply only to U.P. Jal Nigam employees.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| U.P. Jal Nigam v. Prabhat Chandra Jain (1996) 2 SCC 363 | Downgrading from “Very Good” to “Good” is not ordinarily an adverse entry requiring formal communication, yet reasons should be recorded and the officer advised. | Treated as laying down a general proposition of law; Bench considered whether its reach extends beyond U.P. Jal Nigam. |
| T.K. Aryaveer v. Union of India (2003) 1 ATJ 130 | Followed U.P. Jal Nigam to hold that uncommunicated adverse remarks cannot be used to an employee’s detriment. | Cited as an example of High Courts and Tribunals applying U.P. Jal Nigam. |
| A.B. Gupta v. Union of India (2005) 1 ATJ 509 | Same principle: non-communication of adverse remarks vitiates adverse effect. | Cited for consistent application of the principle. |
| Bahadur Singh v. Union of India (2003) 2 SCT 514 | Same principle following U.P. Jal Nigam. | Cited for consistent application of the principle. |
| Union of India v. Major Bahadur Singh (2006) 1 SCC 368 | Held that U.P. Jal Nigam was not of universal application. | Relied upon by respondents; created an apparent conflict prompting reference to larger Bench. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court acknowledged the divergence between U.P. Jal Nigam, which articulated a general rule on downgraded ACRs, and Major Bahadur Singh, which confined that rule to U.P. Jal Nigam employees. Observing that U.P. Jal Nigam laid down a legal proposition that could not be so narrowly restricted, the Bench concluded that an authoritative resolution of the conflict was required. Consequently, it determined that the matter should be placed before a larger Bench for definitive pronouncement.
Holding and Implications
The case is referred to a larger Bench.
Immediate Effect: The records are to be laid before the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India for constitution of an appropriate larger Bench; no final decision on the merits or the appellant’s promotion has been rendered.
Broader Implications: The reference underscores an unresolved conflict within Supreme Court jurisprudence on whether downgraded but positive ACR entries must be communicated. The forthcoming larger-Bench decision will clarify the applicability of U.P. Jal Nigam across the civil services.
Order
1. Leave granted. The appellant herein was appointed as Deputy Director of Training on or about 13-11-1992. He attended a training programme on Computer Applied Technology. He was sent on deputation on various occasions in 1997, 1998 and yet again in 2000. Indisputably, remarks in his annual confidential reports throughout had been “Outstanding” or “Very good”. He, however, in two years i.e 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 obtained only “Good” remark in his annual confidential report. The effect of such a downgrading falls for our consideration.
2. The Union of India issued an Office Memorandum on 8-2-2002 wherein the benchmark for promotion was directed to be “Very Good” in terms of Clause 3.2 thereof. It is also not in dispute that guidelines for the Departmental Promotion Committees had been issued by the Union of India wherein, inter alia, it was directed as follows:
“… 6.2.1 (b) The DPC should assess the suitability of the employees for promotion on the basis of their service records and with particular reference to the CRs for five preceding years irrespective of the qualifying service prescribed in the Service/Recruitment Rules. The ‘preceding five years’ for the aforesaid purpose shall be decided as per the guidelines contained in the DoP&T OM No. 22011/9/98-Estt. (D) dated 8-9-1998, which prescribe the model calendar for DPC read with OM of even number, dated 16-6-2000. (If more than one CR have been written for a particular year, all the CRs for the relevant years shall be considered together as the CR for one year.)”
3. The question as to whether such a downgradation of annual confidential report would amount to adverse remark and thus it would be required to be communicated or not fell for consideration before this Court in U.P Jal Nigam v. Prabhat Chandra Jain (1996) 2 SCC 363, (1996) 33 ATC 217 in the following terms:
“3. We need to explain these observations of the High Court. The Nigam has rules, whereunder an adverse entry is required to be communicated to the employee concerned, but not downgrading of an entry. It has been urged on behalf of the Nigam that when the nature of the entry does not reflect any adverseness that is not required to be communicated. As we view it the extreme illustration given by the High Court may reflect an adverse element compulsorily communicable, but if the graded entry is of going a step down, like falling from ‘very good’ to ‘good’ that may not ordinarily be an adverse entry since both are a positive grading. All that is required by the authority recording confidentials in the situation is to record reasons for such downgrading on the personal file of the officer concerned, and inform him of the change in the form of an advice. If the variation warranted be not permissible, then the very purpose of writing annual confidential reports would be frustrated. Having achieved an optimum level the employee on his part may slacken in his work, relaxing secure by his one-time achievement. This would be an undesirable situation. All the same the sting of adverseness must, in all events, not be reflected in such variations, as otherwise they shall be communicated as such. It may be emphasised that even a positive confidential entry in a given case can perilously be adverse and to say that an adverse entry should always be qualitatively damaging may not be true. In the instant case we have seen the service record of the first respondent. No reason for the change is mentioned. The downgrading is reflected by comparison. This cannot sustain. Having explained in this manner the case of the first respondent and the system that should prevail in the Jal Nigam, we do not find any difficulty in accepting the ultimate result arrived at by the High Court.”
4. Several High Courts as also the Central Administrative Tribunal in their various judgments followed the decision of this Court in U.P Jal Nigam (1996) 2 SCC 363, (1996) 33 ATC 217, inter alia, to hold that in the event the said adverse remarks are not communicated causing deprivation to the employee to make an effective representation thereagainst, thus should be ignored. Reference may be made to T.K Aryaveer v. Union of India (2003) 1 ATJ 130, A.B Gupta v. Union of India (2005) 1 ATJ 509 and Bahadur Singh v. Union of India (2003) 2 SCT 514.
5. Our attention, however, has been drawn by the learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the respondents to a recent decision of this Court in Union of India v. Major Bahadur Singh (2006) 1 SCC 368 wherein a Division Bench of this Court sought to distinguish U.P Jal Nigam (1996) 2 SCC 363, (1996) 33 ATC 217 stating as follows:
“8. As has been rightly submitted by the learned counsel for the appellants U.P Jal Nigam case (1996) 2 SCC 363, (1996) 33 ATC 217 has no universal application. The judgment itself shows that it was intended to be meant only for the employees of U.P Jal Nigam only.”
6. With utmost respect, we are of the opinion that the judgment in U.P Jal Nigam (1996) 2 SCC 363, (1996) 33 ATC 217 cannot be held to be applicable only to its own employees. It has laid down a proposition of law. Its applicability may depend upon the rules entirely in the field but it cannot be said that no law has been laid down therein. We, therefore, are of the opinion that the matter should be heard by a larger Bench. Let the records of the matter be placed before the Hon'ble the Chief Justice of India for passing appropriate orders.
Court Masters
Alert