- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ashoka Kumar Thakur v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
Two writ petitions (Civil) Nos. 265 and 269 of 2006 are pending before the Supreme Court of India. On 29-5-2006 the Court had already issued notice in these petitions and “formulated the basic issues” for consideration. The impugned governmental policy under challenge has not yet been implemented, and the Court has made it clear that any future implementation will be subject to the final outcome of these proceedings.
An interlocutory application was subsequently filed by the Resident Doctors’ Association, Maulana Azad Medical College, and the Resident Doctors’ Association, All-India Institute of Medical Sciences. Upon mention, this application was taken on board and notice was issued. The Central Government was granted the same period for filing its response to the application as is available for its response in the main writ petitions.
During the pendency of the writ petitions nationwide protests, strikes and demonstrations were carried out by resident doctors, medical students and others. These actions disrupted medical services and prompted the present order directing that such protests be called off and that medical services be restored immediately.
Legal Issues Presented
The opinion addresses a procedural matter and does not frame distinct legal issues.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Paschim Banga Khet Mazdoor Samity v. State of W.B., (1996) 4 SCC 37 | The right to timely medical treatment is an integral part of Article 21 (Right to Life) of the Constitution. | Invoked to emphasise that patient care cannot be compromised; therefore ongoing strikes must cease and medical services must resume immediately. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
1. The Court noted that protests and strikes are forms of expressing viewpoints, but allowing them to continue while the Court itself is seized of the core issues would have no practical benefit and would primarily inconvenience the general public who rely on medical services.
2. Citing Paschim Banga, the Court reaffirmed that the right to receive medical treatment is inseparable from Article 21. Damage caused to patients through disrupted services can be “irretrievable,” whereas the grievances of striking doctors can be addressed through the ongoing judicial process.
3. To balance the right of expression with the constitutional duty to protect life and health, the Court:
- Directed that all protests, strikes and demonstrations related to the issues in the writ petitions be called off “forthwith.”
- Clarified that any governmental action implementing the challenged policy will remain subject to the final decision in these proceedings.
- Invited any interested individual or group to submit representations to the Central Government or to seek impleadment in the writ petitions.
- Ordered that no punitive action be taken by the Government for past participation in strikes and required the reinstatement of any doctor whose services had been terminated, provided they rejoin within three days.
- Instructed the learned Additional Solicitor General to file a status report the next day and to communicate the order to all States and Union Territories.
Holding and Implications
ORDER: All ongoing protests, strikes and demonstrations by doctors, medical students and others on the issues under adjudication are to be CALLED OFF FORTHWITH, and medical services must be immediately restored throughout the country. Government authorities are directed not to impose punitive measures for earlier participation in such protests and to reinstate any doctor whose services were terminated, subject to the doctor rejoining within three days.
Implications: The immediate effect is the compulsory resumption of medical services nationwide, safeguarding patients’ constitutional right to health. The Government’s policy decision under challenge remains in abeyance, as any implementation will be subject to the eventual judgment in the writ petitions. No new precedent on substantive constitutional issues is set at this interim stage, but the order reinforces the primacy of Article 21 over professional or industrial action in the healthcare sector.
Order
IA No. … of 2006 in Writ Petition (C) No. 265 of 2006
1. Upon mention, the matter is taken on board. An application has been filed by the Resident Doctors Association, Maulana Azad Medical College and Resident Doctors Association, All-India Institute of Medical Sciences. Issue notice.
2. The response to this application shall be filed within the time allowed to the Central Government to respond to the writ petitions.
Writ Petitions (C) Nos. 265 and 269 of 2006
3. While issuing notice on 29-5-2006 (2011) 12 SCC 785, we had formulated the basic issues which arise for consideration. It goes without saying that if any connected or ancillary issue or issues is/are to be examined or require to be examined, that shall be done. If any additional points are necessary to be adjudicated, it is always open to the persons concerned to make application to be impleaded in the writ petitions or file separate petition. It also needs no reiteration that if ultimately the policy, which is yet to be implemented, is in fact implemented, the same shall be subject to the result of the writ petitions.
4. Additionally, we find that the protests, strikes, demonstrations, etc. necessarily relate to expression of view, stand or concern by the doctors concerned, students and others. There cannot be two channels for adjudication. Since the issues are being examined by this Court, if the strikes, etc. are permitted to be continued, they practically yield no result except causing inconvenience to the general public.
5. As was noted by this Court in Paschim Banga Khet Mazdoor Samity v. State of W.B (1996) 4 SCC 37 a person's right to get treated is inseparable from Article 21 of the Constitution of India. Keeping that aspect in view, we had required the persons who were on strike, demonstration, etc. to call them off to avoid inconvenience to the patients. The damage done to a patient is sometimes irretrievable, but the grievances of the persons who are resorting to strikes, etc. can be remedied in appropriate proceedings and the issues are being examined by this Court.
6. In that background, making the position clear that if any action is taken by the Government in respect of the impugned policy, the same shall be subject to the outcome of the present proceedings and/or any proceeding which may be filed relating to the issues, we direct that all protests, strikes and demonstrations or any such form of dissent relating to the issues being examined and/or connected and/or incidental and/or relatable thereto shall be called off forthwith. The medical services shall be restored forthwith. The doctors cannot be insensitive to the plight of patients.
7. Let the learned Additional Solicitor General file a status report by tomorrow, 1-6-2006. These matters shall be listed tomorrow i.e on 1-6-2006.
8. It goes without saying that notwithstanding the pendency of these petitions, it is open to anyone who feels that he has something to suggest about the issues involved, he can make a proper representation to the Central Government, which we are sure, shall be duly considered. It is also open to him to approach this Court to be impleaded in these proceedings or file a separate petition, as noted above.
9. In case, the strikes, etc. are called off, as directed, we are very sure the Government shall appropriately consider the feelings of the doctors or the students and shall not take any punitive action for whatever has been done till the strikes, etc. are called off.
10. If, in the meantime, the services of any doctor have been terminated for participating in the strikes, etc. the Government shall permit them to join forthwith. In these cases, the doctors concerned are granted three days' time to join back. Mr Gopal Subramanium, learned Additional Solicitor General stated that if, within a period of three days, the doctor concerned joins back, the order of termination shall be recalled.
11. Our order shall be communicated by the learned Additional Solicitor General to all the States and Union Territories through the Chief Secretaries concerned so that the same can be given effect to throughout the country.
12. A copy of our order shall be handed over to the learned Additional Solicitor General today.
Court Masters
Alert