- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Arvind Kumar v. Union Of India
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, Mr. Arvind Kumar, filed a petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 (Suit No. 1837-A/84) against the Union of India for appointment of an arbitrator to resolve disputes between the parties. The respondent initially appointed Smt. R. Lakshmanan as arbitrator, who accepted but subsequently resigned. The respondent failed to appoint a replacement arbitrator despite the petitioner’s request. The petitioner then filed an interlocutory application (I.A. No. 1048/87) under Sub-sections (4) and (5) of Section 20 of the Arbitration Act, seeking appointment of an arbitrator.
The respondent contended that the petitioner had withdrawn his claim for interest via a letter dated 1st April 1987 and that the disputes were resolved, negating the need for an arbitrator. The petitioner claimed that the withdrawal letter was obtained under coercion and threat, thereby reviving the dispute.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the letter dated 1st April 1987, withdrawing the claim for interest and stating that the dispute was resolved, constituted a full and final settlement of the claims between the parties.
- Whether the petitioner’s allegation that the withdrawal letter was procured under coercion raised a dispute requiring adjudication by an arbitrator.
- Whether the respondent was obligated to appoint an arbitrator under the arbitration agreement and Section 20 of the Arbitration Act, 1940, despite the respondent’s assertion that the dispute was resolved.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- The letter dated 1st April 1987, withdrawing the claim for interest, was obtained under coercion and threat by the respondent.
- Therefore, the dispute was not resolved and required adjudication by an arbitrator as per the arbitration agreement.
- The petitioner’s claims included damages, interest, and costs, which constituted disputes arising out of or in connection with the contract.
Respondent’s Arguments
- The petitioner had withdrawn his claim for interest by the letter dated 1st April 1987.
- Accordingly, the disputes and differences between the parties stood resolved, negating the need for appointment of an arbitrator.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Damoder Vally v. K. K. Kar | The question whether there had been a full and final settlement of a claim under a contract is itself a dispute arising "upon" or "in relation to" or "in connection with" the contract. | The Court applied this principle to hold that the dispute regarding whether the withdrawal letter constituted a full and final settlement was a matter for arbitration under the arbitration agreement. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the letter dated 1st April 1987, which indicated that the petitioner withdrew his claim for interest because the respondent had instructed payment of dues. However, the petitioner’s assertion that the letter was procured under coercion revived the dispute over whether the letter operated as a full and final settlement. The Court identified this as a substantive dispute arising from the contract, which fell within the scope of the arbitration clause.
The Court relied on the precedent of Damoder Vally v. K. K. Kar, which established that disputes regarding full and final settlement under a contract are arbitrable. The Court further noted that claims for damages and interest were disputes connected with the contract, reinforcing the need for arbitration.
Accordingly, the Court concluded that the respondent was obligated to appoint an arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes as per the arbitration agreement and Section 20 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.
Holding and Implications
The petition is accepted.
The respondent is directed to appoint an arbitrator within two months from the date of the order to adjudicate the disputes and differences referred to in the petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act, 1940. There is no order as to costs.
This decision compels the respondent to comply with the arbitration agreement and ensures that the substantive disputes between the parties are resolved through arbitration. No broader precedent beyond the application of the cited authority was established.
JAGDISH DHANDRA, J.
(1) PETITION under Section 20 Arbitration Act, 1940 being Suit No. 1837-A/84 was filed by the petitioner Mr. Arvind Kumar against the Union of India, respondent, through the Director General of Supplies and Disposals, for appointment of an arbitrator to adjudicate upon the disputes and differences which had arisen between the parties. That petition was accepted and consequently the respondent vide letter dated 15th July, 1985 appointed Smt. R. Lakshmanan, Additional Legal Advisor, Ministry of law, as an arbitrator. She accepted the reference on 8th August, 1985 but resigned as an arbitrator on 9th September, 1985. Thereafter no arbitrator was appointed by the respondent. The petitioner vide notice dated 2nd July, 1986 called upon the respondent to appoint another arbitrator in view of resignation of Smt. R. Lakshmanan. The respondent failed to appoint the second arbitrator.
(2) THEREAFTER the petitioner has put up this petition (being I. A. No. 1048/ 87) under Sub-sections (4) and (5) of Section 20 of Arbitrator Act, 1940, praying for the appointment of arbitrator to adjudicate upon the disputes and differences between the parties.
(3) IN reply, the respondent. Union of India has asserted that the petitioner vide his letter dated 1st April, 1987 had withdrawn his claim for interest and that the disputes and differences stood resolved between the parties for which reason there was no warrant for the appointment of any arbitrator.
(4) IN the rejoinder the petitioner while admitting the letter dated 1st April, 1987 as having been written by him to the respondent, asserted that this letter had been taken from him under coercion by the respondent, who had threatened that otherwise no, payment would be made to him.
(5) THE letter dated 1st April, 1987 written by the petitioner to the respondent reads as follows.
"since you have given necessary instructions for payment of our dues, to the Pay and Accounts Officer, we are withdrawing our claim for the interest. The dispute may be treated as resolved and settled against this contract. This is to confirm that offer given against tender was signed by me on behalf of the firm as a proprietor. SD/- For Arvind Kumar and Co.
(6) A perusal of this letter goes to show that in view of the fact that the respondent had given necessary instructions to its Pay and Accounts Officer for the payment of dues of the petitioner, the petitioner in return withdrew his claim regarding interest and thus it was stated in this letter that the disputes between the parties stood resolved and settled as far as this contract was concerned. When now it is asserted that this letter was procured from the petitioner under threat and coercion that otherwise no dues would be paid to him, the dispute has again arisen between the parties whether this letter operates as full and final settlement of the claim of the petitioner or not and whether this letter had been written by the petitioner under threat and coercion as alleged by him. This obviously is a dispute which has to be settled by the Arbitrator as per the arbitration agreement between the parties. Damoder Vally v. K. K. Kar1, is an authority which covers this matter and according to this authority the question whether there had been a full and final settlement of the claim under the contract was a dispute arising between the parties upon or in relation to or in connection with the contract.
(7) IT is pointed out by the counsel for the petitioner that in main petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act, 1940. the petitioner's claim was to-wards damages, interest and costs. According to the authority cited above, a claim for damages was a dispute or difference which arose between the parties and was 'upon' or' in relation to' or 'in connection with' the contract, and the reference to the Arbitrator by the respondent was not barred. The facts of that authority were that the tender entered into a contract with the Damodar Vally Corporation to supply coal but as it failed to do so in accordance with the terms of contract, the D. V. Corporation unilaterally repudiated the contract and ultimately paid to the tender for the supply of coal ; and it was the case of D. V. Corporation that those payments, including the return of the deposit amount, finally settled the claims of the tender. After receiving those payments, the tenderer claimed fram D. V. Corpn. damages for repudiation of the contract When D. V. Corporation did not agree, the tender served a notice of his intention to refer the matter to the arbitration under the arbitration clause contained in the contract. The Court held as follows.
"held that the question whether there had been a full and final settlement of a claim under the contract was itself a dispute arising 'upon' or "in relation to' or 'in connection with' the contract. A claim for damages was a dispute or difference which arose between the respondent and the appellant and was 'upon' or 'in relation to' or 'in connection with' the contract, and the reference to the arbitrator by the respondent was not barred. "
(8) IN view of the aforesaid discussion this petition is accepted and the respondent is directed to appoint an arbitrator in accordance with the arbitration agreement within two months from today and the disputes and differences between the parties as referred to in the main petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 be referred to him for decision. There shall be no order as to costs.
Alert