Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vani Agro Enterprises v. State Of Gujarat

Gujarat High Court
Jul 2, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Four different criminal complaints (Criminal Case Nos. 3540 to 3543/1999) were filed by respondent no. 2 against the common petitioners in the Court of learned Chief Judicial Magistrate (First Class), Vadodara, for offences under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. The petitioners sought to consolidate all complaints and record common evidence, relying on Section 219 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, arguing that since one common notice dated 20/04/1999 was issued for dishonour of four cheques, there was only one cause of action. The trial court rejected this request by order dated 05/08/2006. Subsequent Criminal Revision Applications filed by the petitioners were also dismissed by the Additional District and Sessions Judge, Vadodara, on 12/03/2007. Aggrieved, the petitioners filed the present Special Criminal Applications under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in a case involving dishonour of multiple cheques where one common notice under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 is issued, it can be held that there is only one offence or one cause of action.
  2. Whether the four criminal cases arising from dishonour of four different cheques can be consolidated and tried together with common evidence under the provisions of Section 219 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • There is only one cause of action since one common notice was issued for the dishonour of four cheques.
  • The four criminal cases should be consolidated and one common evidence recorded, invoking Section 219 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
  • Relied on the decision of the Bombay High Court in Rajendra B. Choudhari vs. State of Maharashtra and Anr (2007 CRI. L. J. 844) to support consolidation and common trial.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Contended that each dishonour of cheque constitutes a distinct offence despite the issuance of a common notice.
  • Relied on the Division Bench decision of this Court in Kershi Pirozsha Bhagvagar vs. State of Gujarat (2007 (2) GLH 403) which held that four dishonoured cheques give rise to four separate offences.
  • Argued that the Bombay High Court decision relied upon by petitioners was inapplicable as it dealt with concurrent sentencing and not with the issue of consolidation on the ground of one cause of action.
  • Requested dismissal of the Special Criminal Applications.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kershi Pirozsha Bhagvagar vs. State of Gujarat (2007 (2) GLH 403) Each dishonour of a cheque under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act constitutes a separate offence; multiple cheques cannot be clubbed as one offence despite issuance of a common notice. The Court relied on this binding Division Bench decision to hold that four dishonoured cheques gave rise to four distinct offences and rejected the petitioners' contention of one cause of action.
Rajendra B. Choudhari vs. State of Maharashtra and Anr (2007 CRI. L. J. 844) Considered the issue of concurrent sentencing for multiple offences under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and discussed Section 219 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The Court found this decision not applicable to the present facts as it dealt with concurrent sentences and not with the issue of consolidation of trials or cause of action; thus, it was not helpful to the petitioners.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined whether issuance of one common notice for dishonour of four cheques could be construed as a single cause of action or offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. It relied primarily on the Division Bench decision in Kershi Pirozsha Bhagvagar, which clarified that each dishonoured cheque constitutes a separate offence under Section 138, and Section 219 of the Code of Criminal Procedure deals with offences, not transactions or acts. The Court rejected the petitioners' argument that a common notice implies a single cause of action. It further distinguished the Bombay High Court decision relied upon by the petitioners, noting that it pertained to concurrent sentencing rather than consolidation of trials or cause of action. The Court concluded that the learned trial courts did not err in refusing to consolidate the four criminal cases or hold a single trial with common evidence, as each cheque dishonour gives rise to distinct offences and causes of action.

Holding and Implications

The Special Criminal Applications are dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is that the four criminal complaints arising from dishonour of four separate cheques must be tried separately, as each constitutes a distinct offence despite issuance of a common notice. The Court directed the learned trial Court to dispose of all the criminal cases expeditiously, by 31/03/2010. No new precedent was established beyond reaffirming the binding nature of the Division Bench decision in Kershi Pirozsha Bhagvagar. The order discharges the rule and vacates any interim relief previously granted in these applications.

Show all summary ...

(1) AS common question of law and facts arise in these group of applications and they are between the same parties challenging the common order, all these Special Criminal Applications are disposed of by this common judgement and order.

(2) FOUR different criminal complaints, being Criminal Case Nos. 3540 to 3543/1999, are filed by respondent no. 2 against the respective common petitioners in the Court of learned Chief Judicial Magistrate (First Class), Vadodara for the offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. In the aforesaid complaints, applications came to be submitted by the respective common petitioners to consolidate all the complaints and to record only one common evidence. It appears that the respective petitioners made the aforesaid request in light of the provisions of Section 219 of the Code of Criminal Procedure submitting that for dishonour of four cheques, one common notice has been issued dated 20/04/1999 and, therefore, there would be only one cause of action and all the complaints are required to be consolidated and one common evidence is required to be recorded. The learned 4th Additional Senior Civil Judge and Judicial Magistrate First Class, Vadodara vide order dated 05/08/2006 dismissed all the aforesaid applications below Exh. 28 and rejected the request of the respective petitioners to consolidate all the aforesaid criminal cases and to record one common evidence. Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the order passed by the learned trial Court in rejecting the aforesaid applications, respective petitioners preferred Criminal Revision Application Nos. 211/2006, 213/2006, 212/2006 and 214/2006, which came to be rejected by the learned Additional District and Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court No. 5, Vadodara dated 12/03/2007. Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned order passed by the learned trial Court dismissing the applications submitted by the respective petitioners to consolidate the aforesaid criminal cases and to record one common evidence, the respective petitioners have preferred the present Special Criminal Applications under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

(3) SHRI Hriday Buch, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the respective petitioners does not press the prayer to consolidate the respective criminal cases and the trial in exercise of powers under Article 219 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. However, he has submitted that in view of the fact there are four different dishonour of cheques and there was only one common notice issued under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, it can be said that there would be only one cause of action for all the four criminal cases and, therefore, all the four criminal cases are required to be consolidated and common evidence is to be recorded.

(4) SHRI Hriday Buch, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the respective petitioners has heavily relied upon the decision of the division Bench of the Bombay High Court in the case of RAJENDRA B. CHOUDHARI Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANR reported in 2007 CRI. L. J. 844 in support of his above submission. By making the above submission and relying upon the aforesaid decision, it is requested to allow the present Special Criminal Application.

(5) ALL the Special Criminal Applications are opposed by Ms. Krina Calla, learned AGP appearing on behalf of respondent no. 1 and Shri Nandish Chudgar, learned advocate appearing on behalf of respondent no. 2-original complainant. It is submitted by Shri Nandish Chudgar, learned advocate appearing on behalf of respondent no. 2-original complainant that the controversy in question is now not res integra in view of the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in the case of KERSHI PIROZSHA BHAGVAGAR Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT reported in 2007 (2) GLH 403. It is submitted that the Division Bench of this Court in the aforesaid decision has observed and held that four different dishonour of cheques would constitute four distinct offences, for which may be one common notice might have been issued. It is further submitted that as such the decision of the Bombay High Court relied upon by the learned advocate appearing on behalf of the respective petitioners would not be applicable at all. Before the Bombay High court, the controversy was with respect to running the sentence of imprisonment concurrently and in a case where more than one cheques are dishonoured. It is submitted that even otherwise, the decision of the Bombay High Court would be helpful to respondent no. 2-original complainant and, therefore, it is requested to dismiss the present Special Criminal Application.

(6) HEARD the learned advocates appearing on behalf of the respective parties. The short question, which is posed for consideration of this Court, is; whether in a case where more than one cheques are dishonoured and one common notice under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 is issued, can it be said that it will constitute only one offence and/or there would be only one cause of action?

(7) IN the present case, four different cheques came to be dishonoured, however, one common notice 20/04/1999 was issued for dishonour of cheques and thereafter under different criminal cases, complaints have been filed by the original complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. In view of the fact that only one common notice was issued for dishonour of different cheques it is sought to be contented on behalf of the respective common petitioners-original accused that it can be said that there is only one cause of action and, therefore, all the complaints are required to be consolidated.

(8) IN case of KERSHI PIROZSHA BHAGVAGAR (Supra) in paragraph 22 the Division Bench has observed and held as under;

"22. The essential requirements of section 138 of the n. i. act are that (1) there should be a cheque drawn by a person on an account maintained by him with a banker for payment of any amount of money to another person in discharge of any debt or liability, in whole or in part, (2) the cheque should be presented to the banker, (3) it should be dishonoured, i. e. returned by the bank unpaid, either because of the amount of money standing to the credit of that account being insufficient to honour them or for the reason that it exceeds the amount arranged to be paid from that account. In case of dishonour, a notice in writing is issued to the drawer of the cheque within a stipulated period and if the drawer of that cheque fails to make the payment of the amount of money within the period stipulated from the receipt of the notice, the drawer of the cheque shall be deemed to have committed an offence punishable under section 138 of the n. i. act with imprisonment for a term which may extend to two years under the N. I. Act. The ingredients of Section 138 make it amply clear that every cheque that is dishonoured gives rise to the commission of an alleged offence for which there is a specified punishment. In the instant petition, four cheques were dishonoured, giving rise to four alleged offences. Since Section 219 deals with "offences" and not with "acts" or "transactions", the only conclusion that is possible is that dishonour of four cheques constitutes four distinct offences. The fact that two complaints have been filed in respect of four cheques that have been dishonoured cannot reduce the number of offences alleged to have been committed merely by clubbing two alleged offences in one complaint. The argument that all the four cheques were given as part of the same transaction cannot bring the case of the petitioner within the ambit of the provisions of Section 219 of the Code and to do so would be a clear violation of the provisions of that Section. "

(9) THE Division Bench has specifically observed that ingredients of Section 138 make it amply clear that every cheque that is dishonoured gives rise to the commission of an alleged offence for which there is a specified punishment. The Division Bench has further observed that as four cheques were dishonoured, it gives rise to four alleged offences and, therefore, the contention on behalf of the respective petitioners-original accused that as only one composite notice has been given there would be only one cause of action and/or there would be only one offence cannot be accepted.

(10) NOW so far as the decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of RAJENDRA B. CHOUDHARI (Supra) relied upon by the learned advocate appearing on behalf of the respective petitioners-original accused is concerned, apart from the fact that in view of binding decision of the Division Bench of this Court referred to hereinabove, the said decision would not be of any assistance to the respective petitioners-original accused, even otherwise, considering the controversy/dispute raised in the said decision, the said decision would not be of any assistance to the petitioners-original accused. Before the Bombay High Court, in the said decision, the accused came to be convicted for the offences under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 for four criminal cases tried separately and the learned Magistrate imposed separate sentence of imprisonment and fine in each of the cases and being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the same, the accused approached the Bombay High Court for a direction that all the sentences shall run concurrently and submitted that considering Section 219 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the learned trial Court committed an error in not combining and/or in holding single trial and, therefore, on the facts the said decision would not be of any assistance to the petitioners. Considering the facts of the cases on hand and the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in the case of KERSHI PIROZSHA BHAGVAGAR (Supra), more particularly paragraph 22, the prayer of the respective petitioners for consolidation of all the four cases and for joint one trial and to record only one common evidence cannot be accepted on the ground that there will be only one cause of action. Dishonour of cheques constitute different offences and different cause of action. Merely because common notice was issued, it cannot be said that there is only one cause of action. Each dishonour of cheque has different cause of action for different individual offences. Under the circumstances, it cannot be said that both the Courts below have committed any error in rejecting the prayer of the respective petitioners-original accused to consolidate all the criminal cases and to try it by one trial and recording common evidence.

(11) FOR the reasons stated hereinabove, there is no substance in the Special Criminal Applications and the same deserves to be dismissed and are accordingly dismissed. Rule is discharged in each of the Special Criminal Applications. Ad-interim relief granted earlier stands vacated forthwith in each of the Special Criminal Applications.

(12) CONSIDERING the fact that the criminal cases/complaints are of the year 1999, which are for the offences under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 and considering the object and purpose of Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, the learned trial Court is directed to decide and dispose of all the aforesaid criminal cases/complaints at the earliest but not later than 31/03/2010.

(13) REGISTRY is directed to send the writ of this order to the learned trial Court immediately.