- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jamna Datwani v. Anand Datwani
Factual and Procedural Background
The opinion concerns two applications filed by plaintiffs Smt. Jamna Datwani and Mr. Janak Datwani under Order 39 Rules 1, 2, and 3 CPC in separate suits. Both plaintiffs are related to defendant No. 1, Mr. Anand Datwani, with Smt. Jamna Datwani being his mother and Mr. Janak Datwani his brother. They claimed to be shareholders of M/s C. N. A. Exports Private Limited and contested Mr. Anand Datwani's claim of holding 99% shares, alleging that his claim was based on forged documents.
C. N. A. Exports Private Limited owned immovable properties including a plot in Gurgaon and a 38% share in property at New Friends Colony, New Delhi. The plaintiffs sought to restrain defendants and their agents from creating third-party rights over these properties. Prior to the suits, the company had entered into a Memorandum of Understanding for development of the Gurgaon property with a third party.
The defendants contended that the plaintiffs were not shareholders, asserting that shares were transferred to Mr. Anand Datwani through valid gift deeds and share transfer forms signed by Smt. Jamna Datwani in 1998. The plaintiffs denied executing these documents and alleged forgery.
There was no dispute until 2004, when directors Mr. Heera Datwani and Mr. Anand Datwani sought to develop the Gurgaon property, leading to multiple litigations within the family. Documentary evidence showed that share transfers and a gift deed occurred in 1998, with board meetings and resolutions supporting the defendants' position. The defendants also relied on a family settlement wherein Mr. Anand Datwani exchanged his shares in other properties for shares in the company.
The plaintiffs challenged the timing and authenticity of the gift deed and share transfers, and raised issues regarding the filing of annual returns with the Registrar of Companies. The defendants countered these allegations with documentary evidence, including minutes of meetings and power of attorney documents.
Ultimately, the court found the defendants' evidence more credible and dismissed the plaintiffs' applications.
Additionally, an application under Order 40 Rule 1 CPC by the plaintiffs for appointment of a Receiver was dismissed as infructuous following the dismissal of the earlier applications.
The suits were scheduled for further proceedings including completion of pleadings and framing of issues.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the plaintiffs were the rightful shareholders of M/s C. N. A. Exports Private Limited or whether the defendants' claim of 99% shareholding by Mr. Anand Datwani was valid.
- Whether the share transfer forms and gift deed executed in 1998 were genuine or forged documents.
- Whether the defendants should be restrained from creating third-party rights over the company’s immovable properties.
- The validity and effect of the family settlement concerning shareholding arrangements within the family.
- The propriety of filing annual returns with the Registrar of Companies reflecting the shareholding changes.
- The appropriateness of appointing a Receiver under Order 40 Rule 1 CPC in the context of the ongoing dispute.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiffs' Arguments
- The plaintiffs claimed to be shareholders of the company, denying Mr. Anand Datwani’s claim of 99% shares.
- They alleged that the share transfer forms and gift deed executed in 1998 were forged documents fabricated by Mr. Anand Datwani.
- They argued that the gift deed dated 10th January 1998 could not be genuine since the shares were transferred to Smt. Jamna Datwani only on 23rd March 1998.
- The plaintiffs contended that the filing of annual returns for multiple years together in 2005 was an attempt to manipulate shareholding records.
Defendants' Arguments
- The defendants asserted that the plaintiffs were not shareholders and that all shares had been validly transferred to Mr. Anand Datwani through proper gift deeds and share transfer forms.
- They claimed a family settlement was reached prior to 10th January 1998 whereby Mr. Anand Datwani gave up his shares in other properties in exchange for shares in the company.
- The defendants argued that the gift deed and share transfer forms were genuine and that the sequence of dates supported the validity of the documents.
- They emphasized that the plaintiffs, particularly Smt. Jamna Datwani, were actively involved in managing the company and could not now claim ignorance or fraud regarding shareholding.
- Defendants placed reliance on board meeting minutes, power of attorney documents, and other evidences to support their position.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court carefully examined the documentary evidence including share transfer forms, gift deeds, board meeting minutes, and power of attorney documents. It noted that the gift deed was dated prior to the share transfer forms, reducing the likelihood of forgery. The court accepted the defendants' explanation that the family settlement preceded the formal documentation and that gift of movable assets like shares need not be contemporaneous with formal transfer certificates.
The court found the plaintiffs’ argument about forged documents to be unconvincing and regarded the allegations of fraud as afterthoughts motivated by the increased value of the properties. It also held that the plaintiffs, being involved in the company’s management, could not blame the defendants for the delay in filing annual returns.
The court concluded that the gift of shares to Mr. Anand Datwani was a bona fide family arrangement and that the plaintiffs failed to establish any prima facie case to restrain the defendants from dealing with the properties.
Consequently, the court dismissed the plaintiffs' applications under Order 39 and the subsequent application for appointment of a Receiver under Order 40 Rule 1 CPC was dismissed as infructuous.
Holding and Implications
The court dismissed the plaintiffs' applications under Order 39 Rules 1, 2, and 3 CPC, and the subsequent application for appointment of a Receiver under Order 40 Rule 1 CPC was dismissed as infructuous.
The direct effect of this decision is that the defendants are not restrained from dealing with the immovable properties of the company, and the plaintiffs’ claims of forged documents and wrongful shareholding were rejected. The court explicitly stated that nothing in its order affects the merits of the underlying suits. No new precedent was established by this decision.
( 1 ) THE above two applications, one under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC and the other under Order 39 Rule 1 and 3, have been filed by the plaintiffs in the above two suits. Both the plaintiffs are related to defendant No. 1. While Smt. Jamna Datwani is the mother of defendant No. 1, Mr. Janak Datwani is the brother of Mr. Anand Datwani. Both the plaintiffs viz Smt. Jamna Datwani and Mr. Janak datwani have claimed that they were the shareholders of M/s C. N. A. Exports private Limited and denied the claim of Mr. Anand Datwani that he was having 99% shares in C. N. A. Exports Private Limited being baseless, based on forged documents.
( 2 ) C. N. A. Exports Private Limited had immovable property bearing plot No. 4 sector 18, Gurgaon measuring 24200 sq yards and it also has 38% shares in the land and building at 6, New Friends Colony, New Delhi. Smt. Jamna Datwani claims that she was having 22. 7% shares in C. N. A. Exports and Mr. Janak Datwani claimed that he was having 13. 33% shares. There are various litigation going on between the family members. A final decree in a suit for partition of the property situated at New Friends Colony has already been passed and in the partition, the company got 38% shares. In the subject applications in the above suits, a prayer is made that the defendants, their directors and agents be restrained from creating any third party right in any manner in the land and building of Plot no. 4, Sector 18, Gurgaon or in respect of share of company in New Friends Colony property.
( 3 ) M/s. C. N. A. Export before filing of these suits had already entered into an MOU for development of Gurgaon property with a third party/company. The claim of the defendant No. 2 is that Smt. Jamna Datwani and Mr. Janak Datwani were not the shareholders of the company. The shares of Mr. Janak Datwani and others were transferred in favour of Mrs. Jamuna Datwani and Mrs. Jamna Datwani further transferred all her shares in favour of Mr. Anand Datwani. A valid gift deed was executed by Smt. Jamna Datwani and she also signed share transfer form on 23rd March 1998. With the transfer of these shares in favour of Mr. Anand datwani, Mr. Anand Datwani became the owner of 99% shares in the company.
( 4 ) THE plaintiffs' contention is that the share transfer plea was a false plea based on forged documents and Smt. Jamna Datwani had not executed any share transfer form or gift deed and Mr. Anand Datwani being son of Smt. Jamna Datwani took benefit of the relationship and fabricated the documents.
( 5 ) IT is an undisputed fact that till 1998, the shareholding of the company was among 8 persons namely Mrs. Jamna Datwani, Mr. Kishin Datwani, Mr. Janak Datwani, Ms. Nitya Datwani, Mrs. Sushma Ravidass, Mr. Tikamdass K. Moolchandani, Mr. Anand Datwani and M/s JB Overseas (Sales) Pvt. Ltd. It is the case of Mrs. Jamna Datwani and Mr. Janak Datwani that C. N. A. Export was a shell company and it was doing no business at all from the years 1998 to 2004 A perusal of undisputed documents show that Mrs. Jamna Datwani remained its director till 2004 and on 2nd February 2004, she resigned from the directorship and stated that she was not in a position to continue as director due to her pre-occupation in personal affairs. She asked the Board of Directors to accept her resignation and file necessary forms with Registrar of Companies. Mrs. Jamna datwani is a business woman and had been actively involved in business for most of her life. On 2nd February 2004, a meeting of the Board of Directors of the company had taken place wherein she was present in the meeting along with Mr. Anand Datwani, the other director. One Mr. Hira Datwani was called by invitation. In the same meeting, Mr. Anand Datwani was elected as chairman of the meeting and Smt. Jamna Datwani put forth her resignation which was accepted by the Board with immediate effect and Mr. Heera Datwani was appointed as director of the company with immediate effect.
( 6 ) IT seems till 2004, there was no dispute between the parties. After 2004, when Mr. Heera Datwani and Mr. Anand Datwani became directors, they thought of developing the property at Gurgaon and gave up export business and tried to create wealth out of the reality business, then started a flood of litigation between other family members and Mr. Anand Datwani and the company. The plea taken by the plaintiffs Smt. Jamna Datwani and Mr. Janak Datwani that they were the shareholders of the company is prima facie belied from the documents executed by Smt. Jamna Datwani and Mr. Janak Datwani and other shareholders/family members. Smt. Jamna Datwani in 1998 was the director of the company. She had 2555 shares in CNA Export. Ms. Nitya Datwani, Kishin Datwani and Janak Datwani transferred their 2500, 1500 and 1500 shares respectively in her favour by executing share transfer forms. Mrs. Jamna Datwani who became the owner of 8055 shares, transferred all her shares in favour of Mr. Anand Datwani on the same day and signed the share transfer forms. All share transfer forms were signed on the same day. On the face of it, the forms seems to be genuine having signatures of Mrs. Jamna Datwani and the signatures are the same as found on the other admitted documents. There is no reason to believe that these forms are forged forms. She had also executed a gift deed on 10th January 1998 gifting all her shares to Mr. Anand Datwani. The arguments raised by counsel for the plaintiffs is that she could not have gifted these shares on 10th January 1998 since the shares were transferred in her name on only 23. 3. 1998 by other persons. Therefore, the gift deed allegedly executed on 10th January 1998 was a forged document.
( 7 ) IT is the stand of the defendants that a family settlement was arrived at between the parties in respect of the various properties of the family and in terms of that family settlement, defendant Mr. Anand Datwani had given up his shares in some of the other properties and in turn the defendant was to receive all the shares in CNA Export Private Limited which, at that time, was doing no business and was having only a plot of property. It is submitted that this family settlement was arrived at prior to 10th January 1998 itself. Since the shares are movable assets, the gift can be done even by transferring the possession. The formalities of share transfer certificate etc were to be done later on and under this arrangement while Mrs. Jamna Datwani executed the gift deed on 10th January 1998, soon after the family settlement was arrived at, the share transfer forms were signed on 23rd March, 1998.
( 8 ) I think that the arguments of learned counsel for the defendant has force. It is not necessary for gifting movable assets that a gift deed be executed. It seems, as abundant caution, gift deed was prepared on 10th January 2004 after family settlement was arrived at. Had the gift deed been forged by mr. Anand Datwani to maneuver the gift of shares in his favour, he would have taken care that the date on gift deed was after the date of share transfer certificates. The fact that the gift deed is dated 10th January 1998 and the share transfer certificates are dated 23. 03. 1998 shows there was least possibility of document being forged.
( 9 ) LEARNED counsel for plaintiffs Mrs. Jamna Datwani and Mr. Janak Datwani also raised the issue that all annual returns of the company were filed together in 2005 with ROC showing changed position of shareholding and no annual return was filed prior to 2004 It is pleaded that the filing of the annual returns for the years 1998 to 2004 together, only shows manipulating of the shareholding. I think this argument must go against the plaintiffs. Plaintiff Mrs. Jamna Datwani was the director of the company till 2004 She was in fact managing the entire show. According to her own pleadings, she was looking after the business herself. If she had not filed annual returns of the company from 1998 to 2004 and had not taken care to reflect the true state of affairs, she cannot put the blame on defendants. Defendant Mr. Anand Datwani has placed on record the share transfer forms and gift deed in respect of other shareholders, who also transferred the shares in his favour. He also placed on record the minutes of meeting dated 23rd March 1998 wherein it was recorded by the Board of Directors, in which Mrs. Jamna Datwani was present and signed the minutes that Mrs. Jamna datwani intends to transfer/gift her shares including shares transferred to her by Ms. Nitya Datwani, Janak Datwani. She informed the Board that Mr. Janak datwani and other (including she) had sent share transfer forms and certificates for transfer of shares. Board passed a resolution for making endorsement on shares and effecting transfer in the members Register. She was a party to this resolution.
( 10 ) THE documents show that on 17th March 2000, Mr. Anand Datwani had given power of attorney to Ms. Jamna Datwani for sale of 10/71 Golf Link property. Mr. Anand Datwani was having 1/4th undivided shares in the Golf Link property. He authorized her mother to collect the entire sale proceeds out of the sale of the Golf Link Properties. It is also seen that Mr. Anand Datwani had executed a gift deed in May 2001 in favour of Ms. Nitya Bharne (Datwani) and her husband Mr. Mahesh Bharne whereby he gifted his 1/4th share in 10/71 Golf Link to these two persons. Defendants has also placed on record a note written by smt. Jamna Datwani which shows that Mr. Janak Datwani was given the family business being run in Paris. He was given 100% ownership of the Paris business.
( 11 ) FROM the material placed on record by defendants, prima facie it is apparent that this gift of the shares of CNA Export made in favour of the defendant Mr. Anand Datwani could not have been a fraud, but it was a family arrangement. Mr. Anand Datwani apparently had given up his equivalent shares in the properties and business in lieu of the shares of the company. The plea taken by the plaintiffs on the face of it does not inspire confidence. All allegations in respect of fraud seems to be an afterthought. Plaintiffs have been very well aware of the affairs of the company and the fact of transfer of shares but later on, looking that the value of properties in National Capital Region have gone up and the defendant has been able to exploit his shares in the properties in a better manner, they seems to be out to create hinderence in the work of defendants.
( 12 ) IN view of my foregoings discussion, I find no force in these applications. The applications are hereby dismissed. Nothing stated herein shall have effect on merits of the case. IA No. 3734/2008 in CS (OS) No. 556 of 2008
1. This is an application under Order 40 Rule 1 CPC on behalf of the plaintiffs for appointment of a Receiver. 2. Since this Court has decided the applications under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC and Under 39 Rule 1 and 3 CPC against the plaintiffs, for the reasons stated in the order, the application has become infructuous and is hereby dismissed as such.
CS (OS) No. 1113/2007 and CS (OS) No. 556/2008 list on 30th July 2008 before the Joint Registrar for completion of pleadings and admission/denial and before the Court for framing of issues on 24th October 2008.
Alert