Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

The State Of Jharkhand v. Alber Oraon Convict

Jharkhand High Court
Nov 22, 2011

D.N. Upadhyay, J.

1. The criminal appeal and the death reference, referred to above, have been preferred against the judgment of conviction and sentence dated 05.10.2010 and 06.10.2010 passed by learned Sessions Judge, Lohardaga in Sessions Trial No.71 of 2009 arising out of Lohardaga P.S. Case No.195 of 2008 corresponding to G.R. Case No.596 of 2008 whereby the sole appellant Alber Oraon has been held guilty and awarded death sentence under Section 302 I.P.C. and rigorous imprisonment for 7 years and to pay a fine of Rs.5000/- under Section 201 I.P.C. In default of making the payment of fine further simple imprisonment for three months has been awarded.

2. The fardbeyan of Sunil Munda recorded on 14.12.2008 at 22.30 hours at village Kutmu, P.S.-Lohardaga unfold the following facts:

Pushpa Devi (sister of informant) along with her two children, Dipika Kumari aged 8 years and Sudarshan Munda aged 6 years (all deceased), was living at village Kutmu after the death of her husband Dilip Kumar Munda in order to provide education to her children. Initially she was living as a tenant in the house of Sukro Oraon (PW-4). Thereafter she purchased a piece of land within the same village and constructed a pukka house on the same plot. The contract for construction of said house was given to appellant Alber Oraon who developed intimacy with Pushpa in course of construction of the house. After completion of the house appellant Alber Oraon started living with Pushpa and her children pretending himself to be her husband. The informant and his aunt had been visiting the house of Pushpa. At one point of time the informant could learn from the neighbours of Pushpa that appellant Alber Oraon is being seen alone in the house and Pushpa and her children are not being seen. The informant with his aunt went to the house of Pushpa to know whereabouts but they did not receive cogent information from appellant and he gave evasive and conflicting replies. Sometime he said that she had gone to her parents house and some times he said that she had gone to meet her maternal grandmother. Under these circumstances suspicion cropped up in the mind of informant and the matter was reported to the police after which the dead bodies of Pushpa and her two children were exhumed from the soak pit situated near the toilet. The dead bodies were decomposed and it were dug out in presence of an Executive Magistrate. On further enquiry the neighbours have reported that Alber was not having cordial relation with Pushpa since last Karma festival and he wanted to get the land and house transferred in his name. The informant has reasons to believe that appellant with the help of his associates has killed Pushpa and her children.

3. On the basis of fardbeyan Lohardaga P.S. Case No.195 of 2008 was registered on 15.12.2008 and accordingly investigation proceeded. At the conclusion of investigation appellant Alber Oraon was chargesheeted u/s 302/34 and 201/34 of the I.P.C. Altogether 12 witnesses have been examined on behalf of prosecution to substantiate the charges framed against the appellant and also exhibited documents and materials. In course of investigation appellant Alber Oraon, who was on police remand in connection with another case, had confessed his guilt and on the basis of said confession incriminating documents had been recovered.

4. The doctor (PW-12) who had conducted autopsy on the dead bodies had found ante mortem injuries caused by hard and blunt substance on the head of the deceased Pushpa.

The facial bones and bones of base of skull were found broken into pieces with laceration of brain matters on the person of Sudarshan Munda.

Dipika Kumari, aged 8 years, was having depressed comminuted fracture.

5. It is not disputed that the prosecution is wholly relying on circumstantial evidence and therefore, it is incumbent upon the Court to consider whether the chain of circumstantial evidence is complete pointing towards guilt of the accused exonerating every hypothesis of his innocence. The circumstances on which the prosecution has relied upon can be categorised on the basis of evidence available on record as mentioned below:

(i) Whether Pushpa was living with her children at village Kutmu in a rented house of Sukru Oraon.

(ii) Whether Pushpa had purchased a piece of land in the same village and constructed a house thereon with the help and participation of accused-appellant Alber Oraon and whether Alber Oraon had developed intimacy with Pushpa in course of construction of said house and started living with her as husband and wife in the same house after it was constructed.

(iii) Whether live-in-relationship prevailing between Pushpa and Alber Oraon went into rough whether since Karma festival because the appellant had developed evil design in his mind to grab the property belonging to Pushpa.

(iv) Whether the death of Pushpa and her two children was homicidal and the recovery of dead bodies were made from the soak pit situated near the toilet adjacent to the house.

6. On the other hand the appellant had taken a plea that the chain of circumstantial evidence is incomplete and there are missing link to lead a conclusion towards the guilt of accused-appellant. The prosecution has failed to bring on record any circumstantial evidence to indicate that it was the appellant who killed Pushpa and her children and to screen himself from legal punishment concealed the dead bodies in the soak pit. Pushpa was not having cordial relation with her in-laws after the death of her husband and she had left her matrimonial home under that circumstance. The possibility that her inlaws with an intention to grab the landed property had eliminated Pushpa and her children is available.

7. The appellant was lodged in jail in connection with another case prior to the date of recovery of dead bodies from the place. No witness has come forward to say that it was the appellant who had concealed the dead bodies at the place mentioned.

8. Now it is time to discuss the evidence available on record in the above perspective of prosecution and defence version. To begin with PW-1 Suguni Devi, PW-2 Lalit Munda, PW-3 Sunil Munda (Informant), PW-4 Sukru Oraon, PW-5 Ranjeet Bhagat and PW-6 Bipin Dubey have clearly stated in their deposition that Pushpa with her children was living in the house of Sukru Oran on rent. The evidence of Sukru Oraon is very much relevant because he was the land lord in whose house Pushpa with her two children was living on rent to provide education to her children. There is no evidence on record to disbelieve the version of aforesaid witnesses.

9. So far the second circumstance is concerned, aforesaid six witnesses have again corroborated this fact that Pushpa had purchased a piece of land at village Kutmu and a pukka house was constructed thereon. It has come in the evidence of aforesaid witnesses that appellant Alber initially joined the construction work in the capacity of a mason but later undertook the contract and helped Pushpa in the construction of the house. The witnesses have further gone to say that in course of construction of the house appellant Alber Oraon developed intimacy with Pushpa and after completion of the house he had been living with them in the very same house.

10. With regard to circumstance No.3, evidence of PW-1 Suguni Devi and PW-3 Sunil Munda (informant) appear to be relevant. Suguni Devi in her deposition in para-5 has stated that in the year 2008 on the eve of karma festival she had been to the house of Pushpa and on that occasion she had disclosed that Alber had assaulted her by means of brick but she did not disclose the reason of assault. The fact that Alber had assaulted Pushpa on karma festival has also come in the evidence of PW-3 in para-6. Suguni Devi has further stated that on 29.11.2008 when she had been to the house of Pushpa, instead of Pushpa and her children appellant Alber was only present in the house. When she asked the whereabouts of Pushpa and her children from appellant Alber, he replied that she had gone to Ranchi to meet her friend but the information was incorrect. She again came back to the house of Pushpa and noticed that potato crops grown within the campus had been grazed by cattle. On 14.12.2008 PW-1 Suguni Devi along with PW-3 Sunil Munda had come to the house and in course of tilling potato crops few ladies from the neighbourhood appeared at the place and they also asked about Pushpa and her children from these witnesses. The aforesaid ladies had further disclosed the fact that a recently dug ditch was there but now it appears to be filled. After receiving such information a suspicion arose in the mind of these two witnesses that Pushpa and her children might have been killed and concealed within that ditch. After having such thought in their mind, the matter was reported to police and after arrival of the police the soil up to the depth of 6 feet over the soak pit was removed. After removal of the earth a layer of brick soling was noticed and after removal of bricks dead bodies of Pushpa and her children wrapped in a cloth and a blanket had been recovered. The dead bodies were decomposed but identified as of Pushpa and her daughter Depika and son Sudarshan. At the place of recovery of dead body the fardbeyan of PW-3 was recorded at the relevant point of time. It is necessary to mention here evidence of PW-11 Pranab Kr. Pal, Executive Magistrate, who was then posted as C.O. at Lohardaga. He has stated that after receiving information from the Officer-in-charge of Lohardaga Police Station he had gone to the place of occurrence and the dead bodies were exhumed in his presence and the inquest reports were prepared on the following morning.

11. Evidence of PW-8 Umesh Kr. Thakur, who had conducted the investigation appears desirable to discuss at this juncture. This witness has stated that on 14.12.2008 he was posted as Officer-incharge at Lohardaga Police Station and after receiving information he had gone to the place of occurrence and the dead bodies of Pushpa and her children were recovered in his presence as well as in the presence of the then Circle Officer, Lohardaga namely Pranab Kr. Pal. After taking charge of investigation he had inspected the place of occurrence which has been described by him in para-5, 6 and 7. the pertinent part of deposition of this witness is that appellant Alber Oraon who was remanded to jail custody in connection with a kidnapping case, was taken on police remand in connection with that very case and he was available at the Police Station on the date on which instant case was reported. Therefore, the appellant was interrogated by the police and he had admitted his guilt and gave a disclosure statement on the basis of which some documents indicating marriage agreement held between Pushpa and the appellant and the documents indicating inheritance of the property had been recovered from the house of PW-10 Vikas Kumar Gupta. The marriage agreement paper was affixed with photograph of deceased Pushpa and appellant Alber and the photographs were attested after being signed by the deceased and appellant which finds support from the evidence of PW-9 Motilal Agrawal, Notary Public. These documents have been marked as material exhibit-1 series. Since the documents were recovered at the instance of appellant from the house of Vikas Kumar Gupta a production -cum-seizure list was also prepared which has been marked exhibit-3. PW-10 Vikas Kumar Gupta has corroborated this fact in his deposition in paragraph-1 and 2. This witness is purely an independent witness and he has also corroborated this fact that appellant was living with Pushpa in her house and the appellant was present at the time of production of those documents. Therefore, a very cogent circumstance unfolding the motive behind the agreement has come up in the evidence after recovery of material exhibit-1, 1/1 and 1/2 . From the evidence of PW-8 and PW-10 it is clear that the property was standing in the name of Pushpa and appellant Alber Oraon had created primary documents to acquire the property after the death of Pushpa and her legal heirs.

In view of the discussions made above, the motive behind the crime, which was designed by the appellant, has been proved.

12. Now coming to the last circumstance, the evidence of doctor is very much clear that all the three deceased were having fracture injuries on their skull bone which was caused by hard and blunt substance and the cause of death was due to those ante mortem injuries. The autopsy on the dead bodies was done on 16.12.2008 and according to opinion given by the doctor the death was within 3 to 6 weeks prior to the date of post mortem examination. The death of Pushpa and her children was homicidal, has clearly been proved by the evidence of doctor who conducted autopsy on the dead bodies. The post mortem reports have been marked exhibit-6, 6/1 and 6/2 which bears details of injuries which the doctor had noticed during post mortem examination.

13. Before discussing the points raised by the appellant, we feel it necessary to have a look on the answers given by the appellant while he was examined u/s 313 Cr.P.C. It is evident that the appellant has almost denied all the questions framed on the basis of evidence available on record , put to him. He has gone to the extent of saying that Pushpa was not known to him and he did not have live-in-relationship with her.

14. In the foregoing paragraphs we have discussed the evidence of PW1 to PW-6 and PW-10. All these witnesses have clearly stated that the appellant was living with Pushpa at village Kutmu in the house constructed by her. We would also have to keep in mind that the ghastly triple murder of a lady and her two minor children had taken place within four-wall of a house which was under the occupation of the deceased and the accused-appellant and therefore, in such type of crime availability of direct evidence is always remote and therefore, the circumstances appearing play an important role to find out the truth. The appellant had denied that the deceased and her children were known to him but the documentary evidence available on record forcefully disprove this assertion of appellant. PW-9 Motilal Agrawal is an advocate vested with power of notary. He has stated that photographs of Alber and Pushpa were attested by him and both of them were present together at the time of attestation of the said document. The attested photographs stuck with document have been recovered from the house of PW-10 Vikas Kumar Gupta who deals in real estate. The evidence of PW-10 has already been discussed in the foregoing paragraphs in which PW-10 has stated that those documents material exhibit-1 series were given to him by the appellant. Thus, it is clear that the appellant, in order to save him from legal punishment has tried to conceal the fact. Furthermore, the livein- relationship prevailing between the deceased Pushpa and appellant had gone into rough weather because the appellant had started extorting money from her to fulful his need. He had developed an evil design in his mind after which the incident took place. The facts appearing in the case at hand almost tally with the facts appearing in the case of (2011) 7 SCC 125 (Sudam Vrs. State of Maharashtra). In that case too the accused was living with the deceased and her children and in order to grab the property he killed them. The circumstances discussed by the trial Court that the appellant had motive to commit crime and that the deceased were last seen in the company of the accused and that the accused had given extra judicial confession admitting his guilt after recovery of the dead bodies and failure to explain the circumstances under which all the deceased met homicidal death were taken into consideration to hold the appellant guilty of the charges and the aforesaid findings of the trial Court was upheld by the Apex Court and the death punishment awarded to accused was also confirmed.

15. The appellant has tried to create doubt saying that strained relation prevailed between the deceased Pushpa and her in-laws after the death of her husband, but no material is available on record to support this fact. On the contrary the evidence available on record is that Pushpa had left her matrimonial home some times after the death of her husband and to provide education to her children she came to village Kutmu and took a house on rent where she had spent about two years before shifting to her own house constructed in the same village. The brothers and other relatives of Pushpa who have been examined in this case have clearly deposed that no in-laws of Pushpa had been in visiting term and they had almost squeezed their relationship. The cumulative effect of the evidence available on record roaringly and consistently proved this fact that Pushpa with her children was living on rent in the house of Sukru Oraon and she had spent about two years at that very house. Thereafater, she had purchased a piece of land over which she constructed a pukka house. In course of construction of the house appellant came in her contact and developed intimacy and finally started living with her as husband and wife in the newly constructed house. When Pushpa refused to oblige him in future, the appellant formed a motive in his mind to grab the land after eliminating Pushpa and her children. When Pushpa and her children went missing from the house, suspicion arose in the mind of the informant and other relatives of Pushpa and the matter was reported to police after which the investigation proceeded. In course of investigation incriminating documents pointing towards the motive and other evidence conclusively pointing towards the guilt of the accused have been collected. The prosecution witnesses and the documents marked as exhibit unerringly speak that the appellant had committed the ghastly crime. The learned Sessions Judge has elaborately discussed all the relevant points referring applicable rulings to the facts and therefore, we do not find any merit in this appeal and the same stands dismissed.

16. The next question arises whether the deat sentence passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Lohardaga can be confirmed and the case comes within the ambit of rarest of rare case? It is true that no clear cut guideline have been given for passing death sentence but the Apex Court has expressed views in cases like Machhi Singh Vrs. State (1983) 3 SCC 470, BechanSingh Vrs. State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 684 and Sushil Murmu Vrs. State of Jharkhand (2004) 2 SCC 338. Learned Sessions Judge, after hearing the parties on the point of sentence has followed the guidelines given by the Apex Court in the judgments referred to above and he has considered all the aggravating and mitigating circumstances appearing in favour of theappellant. Here in the instant case a helpless lady and her two minor children were done to death in an extremely brutal, grotesque and diabolical manner. The motive behind the crime was to grab the property after eliminating them. Not only that the appellant has won the trust of a widow lady and the deceased had made them dependant on the appellant for their future life. The murder of such helpless lady and her children is also an example of betrayal of trust and therefore, collective conscience of the community has shaken. The appellant who is also having criminal antecedent has committed ghastly crime in a very planned manner and after committing the murder he had concealed the dead bodies very intelligently applying his skill of mason which also indicates the possession of cruel mind. Mostly on the same facts the death sentence in the case reported in (2011) 7 SCC 125 (Sadam Vrs. State of Maharashtra was confirmed by the Apex Court.

17. In view of the judgments cited above and also considering facts and circumstances of the present case and the reasons discussed above, we consider the case under the rarest of rare category and no sentence except death punishment will meet the ends of justice and therefore, the death sentence awarded to the appellant under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code stands confirmed. The sentence passed for the offence under Section 201 of the Indian Penal Code also need no interference and the same is confirmed.