- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Palaniappa Gounder v. Nallamuthu Gounder & Ors.
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner is the judgment-debtor in O.S. 34 of 1970, Sub Court, Erode. On 28 November 1970 Perumal Gounder (husband of the second respondent and father of respondents 3 to 8) obtained a decree in O.S. 34 of 1970 against the petitioner for Rs. 5,000 with interest and costs. Execution was initiated in E.P. No. 40 of 1973 and the decree-holder sought sale of certain properties belonging to the petitioner.
The decree-holder valued the properties at Rs. 3,000 in the sale proclamation while the Amin valued them at Rs. 10,000 subject to an usufructuary mortgage. Because the petitioner remained ex parte initially, the court fixed the upset price at Rs. 10,000. The decree-holder later applied in E.A.750 of 1973 to reduce the upset price; by order dated 23 October 1973 the upset price was reduced to Rs. 7,500. It is common ground in the opinion that notice of that application was not given to the petitioner.
The properties were auctioned on 3 January 1974 and purchased by the first respondent for Rs. 7,505, subject to the encumbrance. The petitioner alleges he became aware of the sale on 5 February 1974 and on 24 April 1974 filed E.A.610 of 1974 (purporting under S.47, C.P.C.) in E.P.40 of 1973 praying that the court sale be declared void on grounds including reduction of the upset price without notice, omission of two wells from the proclamation, lack of tom-tom publicity, gross inadequacy of sale price and alleged fraud/irregularity in publication and conduct of the sale.
The Subordinate Judge (Sub Court, Erode) examined documentary evidence and found no fraud but concluded there was at best an irregularity (notifying the petitioner about the reduction was not done). That court held the defect fell within “publication and conduct of the sale” and therefore the appropriate remedy was under O.21, R.90, C.P.C. Since the petition was filed beyond 30 days of the sale, it was held time-barred and dismissed.
The petitioner appealed (C.M.A. No. 68 of 1976) to the District Court, Coimbatore East at Erode, where the District Judge also rejected the contention that the sale was void for non-service of notice of reduction of the upset price and held the remedy was an application under O.21, R.90 C.P.C. within 30 days; dismissal was maintained. The petitioner challenged that decision in the present civil revision petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the reduction of the upset price (from Rs. 10,000 to Rs. 7,500) effected without notice to the judgment-debtor constitutes a material irregularity that falls within Section 47, C.P.C. and therefore permits setting aside the sale under S.47.
- If the reduction without notice is an irregularity, whether that irregularity is instead governed by Order 21, Rule 90 (and related provisions) of the C.P.C., making the remedy time‑barred unless pursued within 30 days of the sale.
- Whether, on the facts, the petition filed on 24 April 1974 (purporting to be under S.47) is barred by limitation because it was not brought within the 30‑day period required for applications under O.21, R.90, C.P.C.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The sale held on 3 January 1974 is void or vitiated by irregularities and fraud in publication and conduct.
- The upset price was originally fixed at Rs. 10,000 but was reduced to Rs. 7,500 without notice to the petitioner; this reduction is a material alteration of the sale proclamation and therefore an irregularity falling within Section 47, C.P.C.
- The gross inadequacy of the sale price (claimed value of lands much higher than sale price) indicates fraudulent or unfair conduct.
- There was an omission to mention two wells in the sale proclamation (a material irregularity) and there was no tom-tom publication in the village.
- Even though the petitioner remained ex parte initially, that does not prevent the court from examining whether the reduction of the upset price without notice is in order.
Respondents' / Decree-holder's Arguments
- The petitioner was fully aware of the court auction even before the date of sale; the sale was properly conducted and is binding on the petitioner.
- The properties were dry lands sold subject to a mortgage; there was no omission of wells; publicity in the village was adequate.
- The upset price was reduced because there were no bidders, and the properties were sold for a reasonable price.
- The petitioner was served with the sale notice and failed to object, and is therefore estopped from challenging the sale.
- The application is barred by limitation in any event.
Auction Purchaser / First Respondent's Arguments
- The sale on 3 January 1974 was not void and was not affected by any material irregularity; it was effected for a proper price after adequate publicity.
- The petitioner was aware of the reduction proceedings and the application to set aside was filed only to protract proceedings.
- The auction-purchaser adopted the decree-holder's counter and additionally argued that the petition should have been under O.21, R.90, C.P.C. within 30 days of the sale; the petitioner cannot bypass the limitation by labelling the application as under S.47, C.P.C.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Gnanambaranam Pillai v. Rathinam Pillai | The opinion notes that this decision pointed out that any irregularity or fraud in the settlement of the proclamation which precedes its publication or the conduct of the sale is not attracted by O.21, R.90, C.P.C. | The court records this earlier view but explains that a later Full Bench decision considered and disagreed with this aspect; therefore that aspect cannot be treated as good law for present purposes. |
| Esakki Das v. Chelliah (and another) | The provided opinion records that this decision was relied upon by the petitioner, but does not state in the text the specific rule or principle taken from it. | The opinion acknowledges reliance but does not extract or apply a specific principle from this case in the reasoning as set out in the text. |
| S.N. Shamsuddin v. N.K. Poyyamani (also cited as Shamsuddin v. M.K. Poyyamani) | The court cites an interpretation that once the upset price is fixed and forms part of the sale proclamation settled after notice to the judgment-debtor, no material alteration in that sale proclamation can be made subsequently without notice to the judgment-debtor. | The opinion relies on that interpretation to hold that after the Tamil Nadu amendment (introducing O.21, R.66(d)(i) and amendment in R.196), the court cannot reduce an upset price already fixed without giving notice to the judgment-debtor. |
| Takkasheela Pedda Subba Reddi v. Pujari Padmavathamma and others | The opinion notes that this Supreme Court decision was relied upon by the petitioner; the text does not state the precise rule or principle extracted from it. | The opinion records the reliance but does not set out an express application of a specific rule from this decision in the court's reasoning as reproduced in the text. |
| A.P.V. Rajendran v. S.A. Sundararajan and others (Full Bench) | The Full Bench held that defects relating to alteration or reduction of an upset price relate to matters covered by the sale proclamation and therefore fall within O.21, R.66 and O.21, R.90, C.P.C. | The court follows and applies the Full Bench's conclusion to hold that omission to notify the judgment-debtor of the application to reduce the upset price is an irregularity within the scope of O.21, R.90 (publication and conduct of the sale) and not S.47, C.P.C. |
| K. Krishnaswami Pillai v. The Kumbakonam City Union Bank Ltd. and others | The respondent relied on this decision to argue that non-service of notice in the application for reduction of upset price cannot be ground for setting aside the sale when the judgment-debtor remained ex parte. | The opinion records that this decision was relied upon by the respondent in support of that contention; the court considered the broader line of authority (including Full Bench decisions) in reaching its conclusion. |
| Dhirendranath Dorai and Sahal Chandra Shay v. Sudhir Chandra Gosh | The Full Bench referred to this Supreme Court decision in its reasoning; the specific rule from the decision is not elaborated in detail in the provided opinion extract. | The opinion notes that the Full Bench invoked this Supreme Court decision in support of its conclusion that defects in proclamation are covered under O.21, R.90, thereby influencing the court to treat earlier contrary decisions as not good law. |
| Ramalingam v. Sankara Iyer | The earlier decisions (including this case) were cited as supporting the proposition that defects in the settlement of the proclamation precede publication and thus are not covered by O.21, R.90. | The opinion records that the Full Bench considered and disagreed with the principle ascribed to this earlier decision; the present court follows the Full Bench in rejecting that narrower view. |
| Nataraja v. Chandmul Amarchand | This decision was among earlier cases considered by the Full Bench that had held defects in proclamation were not within O.21, R.90; the opinion does not set out a separate principle beyond that contextual note. | The Full Bench treated such earlier holdings as not good law in the respect that they denied application of O.21, R.90 to proclamation defects; the present court follows that Full Bench conclusion. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in a stepwise legal analysis strictly from the materials and authorities referenced in the opinion:
- The court accepted as a fact (not disputed) that the petitioner was not served with notice of the decree-holder's application to reduce the upset price (E.A.750 of 1973).
- The court examined the statutory position before and after the 1972 Tamil Nadu amendment. Prior to the amendment, the court observed, there was no statutory obligation to fix an upset price; thus the court earlier had discretion and was not bound to give notice when fixing or altering an upset price.
- After the Tamil Nadu amendment introducing O.21, R.66(d)(i) and the consequent amendment in R.196 of the Civil Rules of Practice, the court's power to fix the upset price and the related procedure were formalized. The court relied on the interpretation in S.N. Shamsuddin v. N.K. Poyyamani that, when upset price is fixed and becomes part of a proclamation settled after notice to the judgment-debtor, no material alteration can be made subsequently without notice to the judgment-debtor.
- The court concluded that after the amendments it is not open to the court to reduce an upset price already fixed without notice to the judgment-debtor. The court nevertheless recognized that the aggrieved judgment-debtor is not without remedy: if the judgment-debtor can establish that the property did not fetch a proper price and sustained substantial injury as a result of the material irregularity (the reduction without notice), he can apply to set aside the sale.
- The court then addressed the crucial classification issue: whether the irregularity of reduction of the upset price without notice falls under Section 47, C.P.C. (a general provision enabling the court to set aside a sale if it appears that the property has not been duly sold) or under Order 21, Rule 90 (which governs setting aside sales on the ground of irregularities in publication and conduct of the sale and carries a 30‑day limitation). The court reviewed earlier decisions (including Gnanambaranam Pillai and Ramalingam v. Sankara Iyer) which had suggested proclamation-stage defects were outside O.21, R.90, but then explained that a Full Bench in A.P.V. Rajendran v. S.A. Sundararajan had considered those earlier decisions and held that defects relating to the settlement or alteration of the proclamation—including reduction of the upset price—are matters covered by the sale proclamation and thus fall within O.21, R.66 and O.21, R.90.
- Applying the Full Bench's pronouncement, the court placed the omission to notify the judgment-debtor of the application to reduce the upset price on a par with an irregularity in the publication and conduct of the sale, thereby concluding that the defect is one falling squarely under O.21, R.90 (and not S.47).
- Finally, the court applied this classification to the facts: the sale took place on 3 January 1974, but the petitioner’s application (E.A.610 of 1974) was filed on 24 April 1974, not within 30 days of the sale. Because the petition was presented beyond the 30‑day period applicable to O.21, R.90, it was time‑barred. The courts below were therefore justified in declining to entertain the petition.
Holding and Implications
Holding: THE CIVIL REVISION PETITION IS DISMISSED. The court held that the omission to give notice of the application to reduce the upset price was an irregularity that falls within the scope of Order 21, Rule 90, C.P.C., and consequently the petition filed on 24 April 1974 (outside the 30‑day period from the sale date of 3 January 1974) was barred by limitation.
Direct implications for the parties:
- The application by the petitioner seeking to declare the sale of 3 January 1974 void is dismissed as time‑barred.
- The orders of the Subordinate Judge and the District Judge dismissing the petitioner’s application were upheld; the petitioner was ordered to pay costs.
- The auction sale stands unreversed by this proceeding (the civil revision fails).
Broader legal implications reflected in the opinion:
- The court follows the Full Bench view that defects or irregularities relating to the settlement or subsequent alteration of the sale proclamation (including reduction of the upset price without notice) are matters connected with the publication and conduct of the sale and thus fall under Order 21, Rule 90, C.P.C., rather than being remedied solely under Section 47, C.P.C.
- After the Tamil Nadu amendment to O.21, R.66(d)(i) and the amendment in R.196, a court cannot reduce an upset price already fixed without giving notice to the judgment‑debtor; nevertheless, the appropriate procedural route for challenging such irregularity is the remedy provided by O.21, R.90 (subject to its limitation period).
S.B.S.R/V.C.S
1. The judgment debtor in O.S 34 of 1970, Sub Court, Erode is the petitioner in this civil revision petition, which is directed against the order of the courts below, dismissing an application filed by the petitioner herein to declare the court auction sale held on 3rd January, 1974, as void. On 28th November, 1970, one Perumal Gounder, the husband of the second respondent and father of respondents 3 to 8 herein, obtained a decree in O.S 34 of 1970, against the petitioner for the recovery of a sum of Rs. 5,000, with interest at 6-1/4 percent per annum from 25th November, 1967 till 28th November, 1970 and thereafter at 6 per cent per annum till the date of realisation and costs. This decree was put into execution in E.P No. 40 of 1973 in O.S 34 of 1970 and the decree holder prayed for the realisation of the amounts due under the decree by the sale of certain properties belonging to the petitioners. In the course of those proceedings, the petitioner, though served with notice, did not appear but remained ex parte. In the sale proclamation, the value of fhe properties sought to be proceeded against was given by the decree holder as Rs. 3,000, while the Amin had valued it at Rs. 10,000 subject to an usufructuary mortage and since the petitioner had remained ex parte initially, the court fixed theupset price at Rs. 10,000. Later, on an application filed by the decree holder in E.A 750 of 1973 in E.P.40 of 1973, the upset price originally fixed at Rs. 10,000 was reduced by order dated 23rd October, J 973, to Rs. 7,500. It is now common ground that notice of this application was not given to the petitioner. Thereafter, the properties were sold on 3rd January, 1974, and purchased by the auction purchaser first respondent herein for Rs 7,505, subject to the encumbrance referred to earlier. On 24th April, 1974, the petitioner filed E.A 610 of 1974 in E.P.40 of 1973 in O.S 34 of 1970, Sub Court, Erode, praying that the court sale held on 3rd January, 1974, should be declared void. According to the petitioner, he became aware only on 5th February 1974, about the sale of his properties in court auction on 3rd January, 1974, and the sale in favour of the first respondent herein is void and affected by irregularities and fraud in the publication and conduct of the same. The properties sold according to the petitioner, are first class nanja lands of the value of Rs. 10,000 per acre and that properties worth Rs. 35,000 had been sold only for Rs. 7,505, and the gross inadequacy of the price of the properties sold would indicate the fraudulent nature of the sale. The petitioner also complained of an omission to mention two wells in the sale proclamation which, according to him, constituted a material irregularity. No publication of the proposed sale by tom-tom was made in the village, according to the petitioner. The petitioner further stated that though originally the upset price was fixed at Rs. 10,000, subsequently that had been reduced to Rs. 7,500 without notice to the petitioner and that such reduction in the upset price is a material alteration in the sale proclamation without notice to the petitioner and the same would be a material irregularity, which would vitiate the entire sale. The petitioner claimed that these irregularities would fall within the scope of S. 47, C.P.C and prayed that the sale held on 3rd January, 1974 should be declared void.
5. This application was resisted by the decree holder on the ground that the petitioner was fully aware of the Court auction sale even before the date of sale and that the sale was perfectly valid and binding on the petitioner. The proceedings and the sale had been properly conducted as required by law, according to the decree holder, that there was no irregularity or fraud in the conduct of the sale as claimed by the petitioner and that the properties were only dry lands and they have been sold subject to a mortgage. The decree-holder stated that though originally the upset price was fixed at Rs. 10,000 subsequently it was reduced to Rs. 7,500 as there were no bidders and thereafter, the properties were sold for a very reasonable price. There were no wells in the lands, according to the decree-holder, and wide publicity about the sale was given in the village. The decree-holder also raised a plea that the sale notice was served on the petitioner and that he had kept quiet and therefore, the petitioner would be estopped from challenging the sale of the properties. Even after the reduction of the upset price, according to the decree-holder, the petitioner was given notice of the proclamation and even then the petitioner did not raise any objection and that therefore, there is no material irregularity, which would vitiate the same. An objection that the application is barred by time was also raised. The auction purchaser first respondent herein contended that the sale held on 3rd January, 1974, was not void nor was it affected by any material irregularity and that the sale had been effected for a proper price. Adequate publicity of the sale was given in the village concerned and it was only thereafter the sale was held. The petitioner, according to the auction purchaser, was fully aware of the proceedings relating to the reduction of the upset price and that the application to declare the sale void was filed only with a view to protract the proceedings. In other respects, the auction purchaser adopted the counter filed by the decree-holder. In an additional counter filed by the auction-purchaser, he raised a plea that the application should have been filed under O. 21, R. 90, C.P.C within 30 days from the date of the sale and merely by calling it as an application which would fall under S. 47, C.P.C, the petitioner cannot get over the bar of limitation. The petitioner filed a rejoinder statement to the effect that since he did not receive any notice in the application to reduce the upset price, the defect would amount to a material defect in the sale proclamation and therefore, the sale held on 3rd January, 1974, would be void. The petitioner also claimed that the failure to issue a notice in the petition to reduce the upset price is only an irregularity and illegality and renders the sale void and therefore, the application would be in time.
3. Before the Sub-court, Erode, the petitioner marked Ex.A1 while the auction-purchaser filed Exs.B1 to B3. On a consideration of the documentary evidence, the learned Subordinate Judge, Erode, found that the court sale held on 3rd January, 1974, is not vitiated by any fraud, but would only be at best vitiated by an irregularity in that publication for the reduction of the upset price was given to the petitioner. It was also further found that such an irregularity would fall within the scope of the ‘publication and conduct of the sale’ and as such, the petition would fall under O. 21, R. 90, C.P.C, and since the petitioner had filed the petition to set aside the sale beyond 30 days from 3rd January, 1974, the application would be barred by limitation. In this view, the petition was dismissed.
4. Aggrieved by this, the petitioner preferred an appeal in C.M.A No. 68 of 1976, District Court, Coimbatore East at Erode. Before the learned District Judge, the only point urged was that the petitioner was not served with any notice in the application for reduction of the upset price and that the sale held without such notice to the petitioner was void. The learned District Judge was disinclined to accept this and ultimately found that even though no notice was served on the petitioner for the reduction of the upset price, yet, the sale held on 3rd January, 1974, cannot be set aside at the instance of the petitioner, as the remedy of the petitioner was only to file an application under O. 21, R. 90, C.P.C within 30 days from the date of the sale and that such an application not having been so filed the petitioner is not entitled to any relief. On this conclusion, the dismissal of the application by the court below was maintained and the appeal was dismissed. It is the correctness of this order that is challenged in this civil revision petition.
5. The main point urged by the learned counsel for the petitioner in the civil revision petition is that the reduction of the upset price earlier fixed without notice to the petitioner would amount to an irregularity, which would relate to the publication and conduct of the sale and which would fall within the scope of S. 47, C.P.C, and therefore, the court sale held on 3rd January, 1974, should be declared void. Elaborating this, the learned counsel for the petitioner stated that the alteration of the upset price originally fixed in the sale proclamation without notice to the petitioner would result in the issue of a fresh proclamation consequent to the reduction of the upset price without the knowledge of the petitioner and that amounts to the alteration of the proclamation already settled to the prejudice of the judgment-debtor and would thus constitute an irregularity within the meaning ot S. 47, C.P.C
6. Reliance in this connection was placed by the learned counsel for the petitioner upon the decision in Gnanambaranam Pillai v. Rathinam Pillai,1 Esakki Das v. Chelliah and another,2 and Shamsuddin v. M.K Poyyamani.3 It was also further submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the circumstance that the petitioner remained ex parte is not a ground which would preclude the court from considering whether the reduction of the upset price without notice is in order. Reliance was also placed by the learned counsel for the petitioner upon the decision of the Supreme Court reported in Takkasheela Pedda Subba Reddi v. Pujari Padmavathamma and others.4
7. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent submitted that even on the footing that notice of the application for the reduction of the upset price should have been given to the judfiment-debtor and that there was a failure to do so, that would at best, even according to the learned counsel for the petitioner, constitute only an illegality or irregularity, which would vitiate the sale. Even in such a case, according to the learned counsel, the proper remedy of the petitioner would only be an appplication under O. 21, R. 90, C.P.C, and not under S. 47, C.P.C The learned counsel for the respondent in this connection relied upon the decision of the Full Bench in A.P.V Rajendran v. S A. Sundararajan and others,5 in support of his contention that the irregularity complained of in the instant case could only be an irregularity in the publishing or the conduct of the sale within the meaning of O. 21, R. 90, C.P.C, and therefore, S. 47, C.P.C, cannot be invoked and consequently, the application filed by the petitioner not having been filed within 30 days from the date of the sale, “would be out of time. The learned counsel for the respondent also relied upon the decision in K. Krishnaswami Pillai v. The Kumbakonam City Union Bank Ltd., and others,6 to contend that the non-service of the notice in the application for the reduction of the upset price cannot be taken as a ground for setting aside the sale especially when the petitioner had remained ex parte throughout till the date of sale
8. In the instant case, it is not in dispute that the petitioner was not served with notice in the application for the reduction of the upset price filed by the decree-holder in E.A.760 of 1978. Prior to the introduction in 1972 of the Tamil Nadu Amendment in O. 21, R. 66 (d) (i), C.P.C, the Court was under no obligation, under the statute, to fix the upset price and therefore, when the court proceeded to fix or modify the upset price originally fixed, such an act cannot be said to have been (sic) made pursuant to any obligation imposed upon the court under the terms of O. 21, R. 66, C.P.C Therefore, with reference to the provisions of O. 21, R. 66, C.P.C, as they stood prior to the amendment in 1972, whenever the court either fixed the upset price or altered it, it was under no obligation to give notice to the judgment debtor. After the introduction of O. 21, R. 66 (d) (i) in C.P.C, by Tamil Nadu Amendment, R. 196 of the Civil Rules of Practice was also amended, and thereafter, the court was specifically empowered to fix the upset price of the property, which the courts have been doing even earlier, as well as the lots, if any, in which the property shall be sold. Interpreting that Rule in S.N Shamsud’ din v. N. K. Poyyamani, Ismail, J., (as he then was), held that once the upset price is so fixed and forms part of the sale proclamation and the sale proclamation has been settled after notice to the judgment-debtor, no material alteration in the said sale proclamation can be made subsequently without notice to the judgment-debtor. It is therefore, quite evident that after the introduction of Tamil Nadu Amendment in O. 21, R. 66 (d) (i) and the amendment effected in R. 196 of the Civil Rules of Practice, it is not open to the court to reduce the upset price already fixed without notice to the judgment-debtor. Even in such cases, it is not as if the aggrieved person is without any - remedy. Notwithstanding the reduction of the upset price without notice, if the judgment-debtor is able to establish that the property sold had not fetched a proper price, then he can make an application to set aside the sale and fsucceed therein, if he can establish substantial injury arising out of the inadequacy of the price as a result of the material irregularity owing to the reduction of the upset price without notice to him.
9. Even according to the learned counsel for the petitioner the reduction of the upset price without notice to the judgment-debtor would constitute a material irregularity but that it would justify the setting aside of the sale itself. Even if that be so, the question arises as to whether such an irregularity would be one which would fall under the provisions of O. 21, R. 90, C.P.C, or under S. 47, C.P.C It is in this connection that the learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the decision in Gnanabaranam Pillai v. Rathinam Pillai. Therein it has been pointed out that any irregularity or fraud in the settlement of proclamation which precedes its publication or conduct of the sale, is not attracted by O. 21, R. 90, C.P.C This conclusion was based on the earlier decision in Ramalingam v. Sankara Iyer. But, these decisions, viz., Gnanabaranam Pillai v, Rathinam Pillai, and Ramalingam v. Sankara Iyer, were considered by the Full Bench in A.P.V Rajendran v. S.A Soundararajan and others. In that case, one of thegrounds on which the court sale was impugned was the improper reduction of the upset price for lot 1. Even so, it was held by the Full Bench that the defect related to matters covered by the sale proclamation and which in turn would be covered by O. 21, R. 66 and O. 21, R. 90, C.P.C In so holding, the Full Bench stated that in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in Dhirendranath Dorai and Sahal Chandra Shay v. Sudhir Chandra Gosh, the earlier decisions of this Court in Ramalingam Pillai v. Sankara Iyer, (died) and others Nataraja v. Chandmul Amarchand and Gnanabaranam Pillai v. Rathinam Pillai (relied on by the leared counsel for the petitioner) in so far as they held that a defect or an irregularity in the sale proclamation would not fall under O. 21, R. 90, C.P.C as that irregularity precedes the stage of publication and conduct of the sale, cannot be held to be good law.
10. In this case, the omission to issue a notice to the judgmentdebtor in the application for the reduction of the upset price relates to one of the steps taken in the matter of publishing and conducting the sale and has therefore to be placed on a par with an irregularity in the publication itself. In view of the pronouncement of the Full Bench referred to above, an irregularity of the type as in the present case would be clearly one which would fall within the scope of R. 90, C. P. C. and not under S. 47 C. P. C. In the present case, the court, auction sale was held on 3rd January, 1974, and the petition in E. A. 610 of 1974 purporting to be under S. 47, C. P. C. had been filed by the petitioner only on 24th April, 1974 (and not on 6th February, 1974 as has been stated by the courts below). Obviously, there fore, the application had not been presented within 30 days from the date of the sale and the application filed was clearly out of time. The courts below were quite justified in declining to entertain the application filed by the petitioner. Consequently, the civil revision petition fails and is dismissed with costs.
S.B.S.R/V.C.S
Alert