- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mohanambal v. Director, Land And Survey Department, Kancheepuram
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This Writ Petition under Article 226 challenges the Second Respondent's order dated 7.11.2008 rejecting the Petitioner's request for compassionate appointment.
The Petitioner's father, Arjunan, was employed as a Surveyor at Uthiramerur in the Land and Survey Department and died in harness on 10.2.1986, leaving the Petitioner and her mother. The mother applied for compassionate appointment in 1986 but was rejected for not having the minimum qualification of 8th standard.
The Petitioner passed Plus Two (+2) and submitted an application in 2001 (she was then 18 and unmarried). That application remained pending for seven years because of a government ban in G.O.Ms No. 212, P & AR Department dated 29.11.2001. During the pendency, the Petitioner married on 2.2.2004. After the ban was lifted on 21.2.2006, the Petitioner submitted documents on 20.6.2007 asserting she was the only eligible legal heir, but the department rejected the request on 24.8.2007 stating she was a married woman and thus not entitled to compassionate appointment.
The Petitioner challenged the 24.8.2007 order in W.P. No. 19581 of 2008. That petition was disposed of on 4.9.2008 setting aside the earlier rejection and directing consideration of her request without reference to her marriage, within four weeks (relying on U. Arulmozhi v. Director Of School Education, 2006 (2) LW 324). The order was not complied with; a Contempt Petition No. 465 of 2010 was filed but closed, granting liberty to challenge the matter in a separate writ petition, which led to the present petition.
When the present writ petition was taken up, the Government Advocate appeared on behalf of the Respondents, the petition was heard on admission and by consent it was taken up for final disposal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Second Respondent was justified in rejecting the Petitioner's claim for compassionate appointment on the new ground that the Petitioner's application was made beyond three years from the date of the death of her father, when the earlier rejection had been made solely on the ground that the Petitioner had married during the pendency of the application.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The Petitioner's mother had applied for compassionate appointment immediately after the death of the father; that application was rejected only for lack of minimum qualification (8th standard).
- The Petitioner, being the only other legal heir, filed an application after obtaining required educational qualifications; the earlier departmental rejection had been solely on the ground of the Petitioner's marriage.
- The Respondents are not justified in taking a new ground (delay beyond three years) in the impugned order when that ground was not taken earlier.
- The Petitioner produced an Income Certificate dated 23.11.2010 showing the Petitioner's husband is employed as a cooli earning Rs. 2,000 per month, relevant to assessing present financial hardship.
Respondents' Arguments (as recorded)
- The Second Respondent relied in the impugned order on the ground that the Petitioner's application was not submitted within three years from the date of death of her father.
- The learned Government Advocate cited precedents including Sanjay Kumar v. State of Bihar, 2000 (7) SCC 192, Punjab National Bank v. Ashwini Kumar Taneja, 2004 (7) SCC 265, and Santosh Kumar Dubey v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 2009 (6) SCC 481, to support the Respondent position (as recorded by the Court).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| U. Arulmozhi v. Director Of School Education, 2006 (2) LW 324 | Relied upon in an earlier disposal of W.P. No. 19581 of 2008 directing consideration of the Petitioner's request without reference to her marriage. | The Court noted that the earlier petition was disposed of relying on this decision and that the earlier direction to consider the petitioner's claim without reference to marriage had not been complied with. |
| Syed Khadim Hussain v. State of Bihar, 2006 (9) SCC 195 | Where a dependent applied in time (widow applied) and was rejected without reasons, the other legal heir may be considered for appointment even after a long lapse of time; authorities should consider the application of other heirs in appropriate cases. | The Court applied this decision to the facts of the present case and held it supported consideration of the Petitioner's claim even though much time had passed, directing reassessment in light of the Petitioner's present financial situation. |
| Sanjay Kumar v. State of Bihar, 2000 (7) SCC 192 | Cited by the learned Government Advocate (case involved a claimant applying for compassionate appointment after eight years). | The Court observed that this decision had no application to the facts of the present case because the claimant in that case applied for the first time after eight years. |
| Punjab National Bank v. Ashwini Kumar Taneja, 2004 (7) SCC 265 | Decision upholding rejection of compassionate appointment claim on the ground of non-existence of financial hardship. | The Court recorded that this authority was cited by the learned Government Advocate but did not treat it as determinative for the present facts. |
| Santosh Kumar Dubey v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 2009 (6) SCC 481 | Denial of relief where a person was not traceable for seven years and even thereafter no claim for compassionate appointment was made within five years. | The Court noted the citation but did not apply it as the facts before it differed (the mother had applied in time and the petitioner pursued the matter). |
| Indirani Ammal v. Chief Engineer, TNEB, W.A No. 3050 of 2003 dated 8.3.2005 (confirmed by Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 2039 of 2006 dated 30.3.2010) | Granting relief to a legal heir in a compassionate appointment context (Tamil Nadu Electricity Board employee case). | The Court noted this Division Bench decision and its confirmation by the Supreme Court as supporting the approach taken in favour of the petitioner in similar circumstances. |
| W.A No. 42 of 2007 dated 2.7.2009 (confirmed by Supreme Court in S.L.P(C) No. 8305 of 2010 dated 6.7.2010) | Another Division Bench decision taking the same view as Indirani Ammal, later confirmed by the Supreme Court. | The Court referenced these decisions as consistent with the line of authority favouring consideration of claims where initial applicants applied in time. |
| Civil Appeal Nos. 2858-2859 of 2010 (arising from SLP (C) Nos. 5068-5069/2009) | Supreme Court set aside a Division Bench judgment that had reversed a Single Judge's direction for compassionate appointment; the Supreme Court restored the Single Judge's view that a minor who became major should have been granted appointment where the mother had applied in time. | The Court reproduced the Supreme Court's order and relied on it as persuasive authority supporting the proposition that where the mother/initial applicant applied in time, another heir may be considered subsequently. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court identified the central point for consideration: whether the Second Respondent could justify rejection of the Petitioner's claim on the new ground that the application was made beyond three years from the father's death, when the earlier departmental rejection had been made solely because the Petitioner got married during the pendency of the application.
The Court reasoned that the Second Respondent had not taken the present ground (delay beyond three years) when rejecting the earlier claim. Because that ground was not relied upon earlier, the Court held that the reason stated in the impugned order — that the Petitioner had not submitted the application within three years from the father's death — could not be sustained as a fresh basis for rejection.
To assess the present necessity for relief, the Court directed production of a current Income Certificate to verify the family's financial status. The Petitioner produced an Income Certificate dated 23.11.2010 from the Tahsildar, Ambattur showing the Petitioner's husband is a cooli earning Rs. 2,000 per month. The Court treated this income evidence as relevant to consideration of financial hardship.
The Court relied on Supreme Court precedent in Syed Khadim Hussain v. State of Bihar (2006 (9) SCC 195), which considered a case where an initial applicant (the widow) applied in time but was rejected, and the Court directed consideration of another heir's application even after a long lapse. The Court quoted paragraphs 5 and 6 of that decision which support consideration of other legal heirs where the initial applicant had applied within the prescribed period and the authorities had not given proper reasons for rejection.
The learned Government Advocate's reliance on other Supreme Court decisions (Sanjay Kumar; Punjab National Bank v. Taneja; Santosh Kumar Dubey) was recorded; the Court distinguished Sanjay Kumar as inapplicable because the claimant there applied for the first time after eight years. The Court also referred to a series of Tamil Nadu High Court decisions (Indirani Ammal and others) and noted confirmations or interventions by the Supreme Court in those matters, treating those authorities as supportive of the approach to be adopted in the present matter.
Applying these authorities to the facts before it — in particular that the mother had applied within one year after the father's death and was denied appointment for lack of qualification, and that the Petitioner had consistently pursued the matter — the Court concluded that the impugned order could not stand and that the claim should be reconsidered in light of the income evidence now produced.
Holding and Implications
The impugned order dated 7.11.2008 is set aside.
Consequences and directions given by the Court:
- The matter is remitted to the Second Respondent to consider the Petitioner's claim afresh in the light of the Income Certificate dated 23.11.2010 issued by the Tahsildar, Ambattur.
- The Second Respondent is directed to pass revised orders within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
- The Writ Petition is disposed of in accordance with the above directions; no costs were awarded and connected Miscellaneous Petitions were closed.
Implications beyond the parties: The opinion applies existing Supreme Court and High Court authority to the present facts and directs reconsideration; the Court did not purport to lay down a new legal principle or override the cited precedents. The decision's immediate effect is to require the Second Respondent to reconsider the Petitioner's claim and pass fresh orders within the specified time.
End of summary (based exclusively on the provided opinion).
Prayer: This Writ Petition is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, praying this Court to issue a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus calling for the records in connection with the proceedings on the file of the Second Respondent in N.K.A.1/10105/2008 dated 7.11.2008 passed by the Second Respondent and quash the same and direct the Respondents to appoint the Petitioner on compassionate ground.
JUDGMENT
1. This Writ Petition is filed challenging the order of the Second Respondent dated 7.11.2008 rejecting the request of the Petitioner seeking compassionate appointment and for a direction to the Respondents to appoint the Petitioner on compassionate ground.
2. The case of the Petitioner is that Petitioner's father Arjunan was employed as Surveyor at Uthiramerur in the Land and Survey Department and on 10.2.1986 he died in harness, leaving behind the Petitioner and her mother (wife of the deceased employee). According to the Petitioner, her father was the sole bread-winner of the family. The Petitioner belongs to Scheduled Caste community and immediately after the death of Arjunan, Petitioner's mother submitted an Application seeking compassionate appointment to her in the year 1986, which was rejected on the ground that she was not having minimum qualification of 8th standard.
3. On passing Plus Two (+2) examinations, Petitioner submitted an Application in the year 2001 along with all relevant certificates and at that time the Petitioner had completed 18 years of age and was not married. The said Application was kept pending for seven years due to the ban order issued by the Government in G.O.Ms No. 212, P & AR Department, dated 29.11.2001 and during pendency of the said Application, on 2.2.2004 Petitioner married one Ramesh, who is also not employed. The Second Respondent informed the Petitioner that her claim for appointment on compassionate ground was forwarded to the Government, the ban order issued by the Government in the year 2001, the same was not considered. On 21.2.2006 the Government lifted the ban order and on 20.6.2007 Petitioner submitted the relevant documents and also stated that she is the only eligible legal heir of the deceased employee (Arjunan), entitled to be appointed on compassionate ground. However, the said request was rejected by the department on 24.8.2007 stating that the Petitioner is a married woman and therefore, she is not entitled to get appointment on compassionate grounds.
4. The above said order was challenged by the Petitioner in W.P No. 19581 of 2008. Placing reliance in the Division Bench decision reported in U. Arulmozhi v. Director Of School Education, 2006 (2) LW 324, the said W.P No. 19581 of 2008 was disposed of on 4.9.2008 by setting aside the said order and directing the Respondents to consider the request of the Petitioner without reference to her marriage, within four weeks. The said order having not been complied with, Petitioner filed Contempt Petition No. 465 of 2010 and during the hearing of the Contempt Petition, noticing the order passed already, the Contempt Petition was closed granting liberty to the Petitioner to challenge the order in a separate Writ Petition. Pursuant to the above liberty, this Writ Petition is filed on the ground that the Respondents having not raised the present objection in the earlier order of rejection, which was passed solely on the ground that the Petitioner is a married woman and therefore, they are not justified in finding out a new ground to reject the claim of the Petitioner.
5. When the Writ Petition was posted for admission on 3.11.2010 the learned Government Advocate took notice on behalf of the Respondents.
6. Heard the learned Counsel for the Petitioner as well as the learned Government Advocate and by consent of both parties the Writ Petition itself is taken up for final disposal.
7. The point arises for consideration in this Writ Petition is whether the Second Respondent is justified in rejecting the claim of the Petitioner, seeking compassionate appointment, on the ground that the Application was made beyond three years from the date of death of Petitioner's father, when the request was earlier rejected only on the ground that the Petitioner got married during pendency of the Application.
8. The Petitioner's mother immediately applied for compassionate appointment after the death of Petitioner's father. The Second Respondent having not taken the ground, which is now taken in the impugned order, for rejecting the earlier claim made by the Petitioner, I am of the view that the reason stated in the impugned order viz., Petitioner has not submitted the Application within three years from the date of death of her father, cannot be sustained. This Court directed the Petitioner to produce an Income Certificate of the Petitioner's family recently obtained, to verify the financial status of the family as on today. The learned Counsel for the Petitioner produced an Income Certificate dated 23.11.2010 issued by the Tahsildar, Ambattur, wherein it is stated that the Petitioner's husband is doing cooli work and earning Rs. 2,000/- per month.
9. Similar issue was considered by the Supreme Court in the decision reported in Syed Khadim Hussain v. State of Bihar, 2006 (9) SCC 195, wherein also the Supreme Court considered the fact that the wife of the deceased, having applied for compassionate appointment in time and as she was found not eligible, the Application submitted by the other legal heir was directed to be considered even after the lapse of eleven years. In paragraphs 5 and 6 of the said decision the Supreme Court held thus,—
“5. We are unable to accept the contention of the Counsel for the State. In the instant case, the widow had applied for appointment within the prescribed period and without assigning any reasons the same was rejected. When the Appellant submitted the Application he was 13 years' old and the Application was rejected after a period of six years and that too without giving any reason and the reason given by the authorities was incorrect as at the time of rejection of the Application he must have crossed 18 years and he could have been very well considered for appointment. Of course, in the rules framed by the State there is no specific provision as to what should be done in case the dependents are minors and there would be any relaxation of age in case they did not attain majority within the prescribed period for submitting Application.
6. As the widow had submitted the Application in time the authorities should have considered her Application. As eleven years have passed she would not be in a position to join the Government service. In our opinion, this is a fit case where the Appellant should have been considered in her place for appointment. Counsel for the State could not point out any other circumstance for which the Appellant would be disentitled to be considered for appointment. In the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case, we direct the Respondent-Authorities to consider the Application of the Appellant and give him appropriate appointment within a reasonable time at least within a period of three months. The Appeal is disposed of in the above terms. No costs.”
10. The learned Government Advocate cited the decision reported in Sanjay Kumar v. State of Bihar, 2000 (7) SCC 192, which has no application to the facts in this case, as the claimant in the cited case applied for compassionate appointment for the first time after eight years. Similar claim of compassionate ground appointment was rejected in the decision reported in Punjab National Bank v. Ashwini Kumar Taneja, 2004 (7) SCC 265, on the ground of non-existence of financial hardship. Relief was denied to a person in the decision reported in Santosh Kumar Dubey v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 2009 (6) SCC 481, on the ground that even though a person was not found traceable for seven years even thereafter within five years, no claim for compassionate appointment was made by the legal heir.
11. Similar claim of the deceased Tamil Nadu Electricity Board Employee was considered and relief granted by the Division Bench of this Court in Indirani Ammal v. Chief Engineer, TNEB, W.A No. 3050 of 2003 dated 8.3.2005 (P. Sathasivam, J. (as he then was) and S.K.K, J.). The said decision was confirmed by the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 2039 of 2006 dated 30.3.2010 Another Division Bench of this Court in W.A No. 42 of 2007 dated 2.7.2009 also took the same view, which was also confirmed by the Supreme Court in S.L.P(C) No. 8305 of 2010 dated 6.7.2010 The contra view taken by another Division Bench of this Court was set aside by the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 2858-2859 of 2010 dated 30.3.2010 The said order reads as follows:
“Civil Appeal Nos. 2858-2859 of 2010 (arising from SLP (C) Nos. 5068-5069/2009)
Leave granted.
Heard learned Counsel for the parties.
These Appeals have been filed against the impugned judgment of the High Court of Madras dated 29the September, 2006 and subsequent order dated 25.8.2008 passed in the Review Application.
The Division Bench of the High Court has reversed the judgment of the learned Single Judge only on the ground of delay who directed compassionate appointment to the Appellant. The Appellant was a minor at the time of the death of his father and since the mother of the Appellant applied within time, we are of the opinion that the Appellant after becoming major should have been granted compassionate appointment.
Accordingly, we allow these Appeals, set aside the impugned judgment of the Division Bench and restore the judgment of the learned Single Judge. No costs.”
12. Here in this case, the Petitioner's mother applied for compassionate appointment within one year and she was not given appointment due to want of minimum qualification of 8th Standard and the Petitioner being the only other legal heir, pursuing the matter and agitating her right for all these years. In the light of the present financial status of the Petitioner, the decision reported in Syed Khadim Hussain v. State of Bihar, 2006 (9) SCC 195 (cited supra) applies to the facts of this case.
13. In view of the above findings, applying the above cited judgments to the facts of this case, the impugned order dated 7.11.2008 is set aside and the matter is remitted back to the Second Respondent to consider the claim of the Petitioner in the light of the Income Certificate produced from the Tahsildar, Ambattur, dated 23.11.2010 and pass a revised orders within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
The Writ Petition is disposed of with the above directions. No costs. Connected Miscellaneous Petitions are closed.
RVS
Alert