Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sitaram Poddar v. Bhagirath Choudhary

Calcutta High Court
Mar 31, 2011
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal from a judgment and decree dated 4 September 2006 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Second Court at Alipore in Money Suit No. 16 of 2004, which dismissed the suit ex parte.

The plaintiff instituted the suit seeking recovery of Rs. 2,37,690 and pendente lite interest and interest on judgment. The plaint alleged that on or about 17 September 2002 the plaintiff advanced Rs. 98,000 to the defendants (neighbours) at the plaintiff's residence-cum-office. The defendant No. 1 allegedly agreed to transfer specified agricultural/bastu land to the plaintiff's mother as repayment; alternatively the defendants agreed to pay interest at 18% per annum if the land was not transferred. The defendants were said to have taken two years' time, and despite repeated demands the money was not repaid; the plaintiff's mother was allegedly insulted and threatened when she sought repayment in person.

Defendant No. 1 appeared but ultimately did not contest the suit; defendant Nos. 2 and 3 did not contest despite service of summons. The trial Judge dismissed the suit ex parte on two grounds: (1) the plaintiff did not possess any licence for money-lending business, and (2) there was no one-month notice to the defendants from the plaintiff's advocate demanding repayment. The plaintiff appealed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the learned Trial Judge was justified in dismissing the suit for recovery of money lent and advanced on the ground that the lender had no registration and licence as a money-lender under the Bengal Money-Lenders Act, 1940.
  2. Whether, before instituting a suit for recovery of money lent and advanced, it was necessary for the lender to issue a notice through his advocate giving the borrower one month's time to repay.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bhutnath v. Nilkantha, AIR 1949 Patna 400 Business of money-lending imports system, repetition and continuity; occasional loans do not make one a professional money-lender. Used to support the proposition that occasional or isolated loans (such as the single loan in this case) do not convert the lender into a professional money-lender subject to licensing requirements.
Sanwarmal Agarwalla v. Benoy Krishna Mukherjee, AIR 1970 Patna 167 Similar emphasis on continuity and repetition as markers of money-lending business. Cited alongside Patna decisions to reinforce that more than occasional loans are required to establish a money-lending business under comparable enactments.
Gaurishanker v. Magharam, AIR 1974 Rajasthan 238 Element of continuity and habit is essential to constitute exercise of profession/business of money-lending; professional not casual money-lender is contemplated by the Act. Relied on to bolster the interpretation that the statutory scheme targets professional money-lenders and not isolated transactions.
Parmanand Jain v. Firm Babulal Rajendra Kumar Jain, AIR 1976 Madhya Pradesh 187 Money-lender means a person who in the regular course of business advances loans — "regular course" implies system and continuity. Applied to show that advancing a single loan does not amount to carrying on money-lending as a regular business requiring registration/licence.
Binapani Roja v. Rabindranath Sarkar, AIR 1959 Calcutta 213 The word "loans" in section 2(14) (Bengal Money-Lenders Act) is plural; thus, more than one lending occasion is necessary to establish a business of money-lending. Used to interpret the Bengal Act's language and conclude that the plaintiff's single advance was insufficient to attract the Act's licensing and account-statement requirements.
Satyanarayan Kamal Kumar v. Birendra Pro Singh, AIR 1979 Calcutta 197 Under the Bengal Money-Lenders Act, a money-lender is one who carries on money-lending as a regular business; mere lender is not a money-lender. Cited to distinguish between a mere lender (the plaintiff's pleaded position) and a professional money-lender who would require licensing.
Gajanan v. Seth Brindaban, AIR 1970 SC 2007 Under C.P. & Berar Money-Lenders Act, money-lender means a person who in the regular course of business advances loans; isolated transactions are excluded. Invoked as Supreme Court authority supporting the proposition that isolated lending transactions do not attract money-lenders' regulatory provisions.
Ka Icilda Wallang v. U. Lokendra Suiam, AIR 1987 SC 2047 Few disconnected and isolated transactions would not make a person regularly engaged in money-lending business. Referred to for the principle that sporadic lending does not amount to carrying on the business of money-lending.
P. Vaikunta Shenoy & Company v. V.P. Had Sharma, AIR 2008 SC 416 Purpose of money-lenders Acts is to prevent malpractice and oppression by money-lenders; purposive interpretation is necessary; in money-lending business the object is to earn interest. Used to emphasize the purposive interpretation of money-lenders legislation and to underline that the Acts target professional lenders whose object is interest-earning rather than isolated accommodation loans.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by examining statutory definitions under the Bengal Money-Lenders Act, 1940 (sections 2(9), 2(13) and 2(14)) which distinguish a "lender" and a "money-lender" and define "money-lending business" as advancing loans in a business-like manner (plural lending). The court reviewed authority from various High Courts and the Supreme Court holding that the defining feature of a money-lending business is system, repetition and continuity — professional, repeat lending — and that isolated or occasional loans do not suffice to characterise a lender as a professional money-lender.

Applying those principles to the facts, the court observed that:

  • The plaint alleged a single occasion of lending (Rs. 98,000 on one date) and contained no averment that the plaintiff carried on a money-lending business or had lent on other occasions.
  • No written statement was filed by the defendants, but the material on record showed only a single transaction; therefore statutory requirements applicable to professional money-lenders (licence, registration, statement of account) were not attracted.
  • The Trial Judge's first ground for dismissal (absence of a money-lenders licence) was unsustainable because the plaintiff had not been shown to be a professional money-lender under the Act and case law.

On the second ground (absence of a one-month notice through the plaintiff's advocate before suing), the court examined whether such notice is a condition precedent to instituting suit. The court found:

  • There was no contractual term between the parties requiring a one-month notice by the lender's advocate before instituting proceedings.
  • The plaint did allege that demands had been made for repayment without success.
  • The court rejected the Trial Judge's conclusion that, absent a contractual stipulation, a borrower is entitled to a one-month advocate's notice as a precondition to suit; such a requirement would be an unreasonable procedural burden on a lender who had advanced an accommodation/occasional loan.

Finally, the court considered the plaintiff's claims for special damages and compensation for harassment and mental agony (valued at Rs. 1,00,000). On available materials, the court held the plaintiff had not established those heads of claim and was unwilling to grant relief on those scores.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The impugned judgment and decree of the learned Trial Judge were set aside. Money Suit No. 16 of 2004 was decreed in part for Rs. 1,37,690 (Rupees one lakh thirty seven thousand six hundred ninety). The plaintiff is entitled to interest at 12% per annum from the date of institution of the suit until recovery. The defendants are directed to pay the decretal sum within one month; in default the plaintiff may initiate execution proceedings.

The court also held that the plaintiff's claims for special damages and compensation for harassment and mental agony were not established and were therefore not granted.

Implications: The decision directly reverses the trial court's ex parte dismissal and grants a part-decree to the plaintiff with interest and a schedule for payment and execution. The court applied existing precedent to clarify that the Bengal Money-Lenders Act's licensing and related procedural requirements apply to professional, repeat money-lenders; isolated single loans are not enough to invoke those statutory obligations. The opinion does not announce a novel legal principle; it applies existing authorities to the facts and resolves the appeal in favour of the plaintiff in part.


Prepared from the text of the provided opinion by Subhro Kamal Mukherjee, J., with concurrence by Tarun Kumar Gupta, J. No information beyond the text of the opinion has been added.

Show all summary ...

Subhro Kamal Mukherjee, J.:— This is an appeal against judgement and decree dated September 4, 2006 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Second Court at Alipore, District South-24 Parganas in Money Suit No. 16 of 2004. The learned Judge by the impugned judgement and decree dismissed the said suit ex parte.

2. The plaintiff instituted this suit for recovery of Rs. 2, 37,690/- (Rupees two lakh thirty-seven thousand six hundred ninety) only and for recovery of pendente lite interest and interest on judgement.

3. The plaintiff in his plaint contended that the defendants were the next door neighbour of the mother of the plaintiff and as such they were known to the plaintiffs. The defendants approached the plaintiff for loan for the marriage of the youngest daughter of the defendant No. 1. The defendant Nos. 2 and 3 were the sons of the defendant No. 1. The plaintiff, at the instance of his mother, lent Rs. 98,000/- (Rupees ninety-eight thousand) only to the defendants on or about September 17, 2002 at the residence-cum-office of the plaintiff at 64, Sarat Bose Road, Kolkata. The defendant No. 1 undertook to transfer some bastu land in front of the dwelling house of the plaintiff in his native village or to transfer two bighas of agricultural land in favour of the mother of the plaintiff towards the repayment of the loan. The defendants agreed to pay interest at the rate of 18 (eighteen) per centum annually in case of their failure to transfer the land in favour of the mother of the plaintiff. The defendants took two years time to keep their commitment. The plaintiff and his mother, on several occasions, asked the defendants either to repay the money with interest or to transfer the land as agreed, but the defendants did not pay any heed to their requests. Lastly, the mother of the plaintiff went to the house of the defendants asking for repayment, but she was insulted and threatened with dire consequences.

4. The defendant No. 1 appeared in the suit, but ultimately did not contest the suit. The defendant Nos. 2 and 3 in spite of service of the summons of the suit did not, also, contest the suit.

5. The learned Judge, however, dismissed the suit ex parte on two grounds. Firstly, the plaintiff did not possess any licence for money-lending business. Secondly, there was no notice for one month to the defendants by the learned Advocate for the plaintiff demanding repayment.

6. Being aggrieved the plaintiff has come before this Court in appeal.

7. The short point in this appeal is whether the learned Trial Judge was justified in dismissing a suit for recovery of money lent and advanced on the ground that the lender had no registration and licence as money-lender and that before institution of the suit no notice was issued to the defendants giving notice for one month?

8. Section 2(9) of the Bengal Money-Lenders Act, 1940, defines a lender as a person, who advances a loan and includes a money-lender. Section 2(13) of the said Act defines a money-lender. Money-lender means a person, who carries on business of money-lending in West Bengal or who has a place of such business in West Bengal, and includes a pawnee as defined in section 172 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Under section 2(14) of the said Act, money-lending business and business of money lending mean the business of advancing loans either solely or in conjunction with any other business.

9. The Patna High Court while interpreting the provisions of section 4 of the Bihar Money-Lenders (Regulation and Transaction) Act, 1939 holds that the business of money-lending imports a notion of system, repetition and continuity, and that is a test of determining whether the plaintiff is a professional money-lender. Occasional loans to relatives, friends or acquaintances do not make the lender a professional money-lender. There must be more than occasional and disconnected loans to justify a finding that the plaintiff is a professional money-lender (Bhutnath v. Nilkantha*, reported in AIR 1949 Patna 400 and Sanwarmal Agarwalla v. Benoy Krishna Mukherjee, reported in AIR 1970 Patna 167).

10. The Rajasthan High Court in Gaurishanker v. Magharam, reported in AIR 1974 Rajasthan 238 while interpreting section 2(10) of the Rajasthan Money-Lenders Act, 1964, holds that an element of continuity and habit is essential to constitute the exercise of a profession or business. It is the professional money-lender and not the casual money-lender, who alone is contemplated by section 2(10) of the said Act.

11. The Madhya Pradesh High Court in Parmanand Jain v. Firm Babulal Rajendra Kumar Jain, reported in AIR 1976 Madhya Pradesh 187 holds that money-lender means a person, who in the regular course of business advances a loan. The words “in the regular course of business” signify a certain degree of system and continuity of transactions. Every person, who has advanced a loan, therefore, is not a money-lender.

12. In Binapani Roja v. Rabindranath Sarkar, reported in AIR 1959 Calcutta 213, this Court holds that the word ‘loans’ in section 2(14) of the Bengal Money-lenders Act, is in plural. Therefore, in order to establish that the plaintiff is carrying on business of money-lending, it must be proved that he has lent money on more than one occasion.

13. While interpreting the provisions of sub-sections (9), (13) and (14) of the Bengal Money-Lenders Act, 1940, this Court in Satyanarayan Kamal Kumar v. Birendra Pro Singh, reported in AIR 1979 Calcutta 197 holds that money-lender is a person, who carries on business of money-lending in a regular course of business, but mere lender is not so.

14. Supreme Court of India in Gajanan v. Seth Brindaban*, reported in AIR 1970 SC 2007 while interpreting the provisions of C.P and Berar Money-Lenders Act, 1934, holds that money-lender means a person, who in the regular course of business advances a loan and excludes isolated transactions of money-lending.

15. Supreme Court of India in Ka Icilda Wallang v. U. Lokendra Suiam, reported in AIR 1987 SC 2047 while interpreting the provisions of Assam Money-Lenders Act, 1934, holds that few disconnected and isolated transactions would not make the plaintiff a person engaged regularly in money-lending business.

16. Supreme Court of India in P. Vaikunta Shenoy & company v. V.P Had Sharma, reported in AIR 2008 SC 416, while interpreting the provisions of Karnataka Money-Lenders Act, 1962, holds that the purpose of the Act was to prevent the malpractice of oppression by money-lenders to take advantage of people's poverty. In the money-lending business, the object of money-lender is to earn interest of the loan he has advanced. Therefore, a purposive interpretation has to be given to the definition of money-lenders.

17. Therefore, one or two isolated or occasional acts of lending money will not constitute a money-lending business; instances of occasional lending of money even at a remunerative rate of interest are not sufficient to constitute business of money-lending. Every loan is a debt, but every debt is not loan. Thus, by laying stress on the business trait of the lending, the Bengal Money-Lenders Act, 1940 contemplates a professional money-lender and it is in relation to such a professional money-lender that the provisions as to a licensee and registrations are applicable.

18. In this case, no written statement was filed. In the plaint, the plaintiffs contended that the plaintiff advanced loan to the defendants. There is no case in the plaint that the plaintiffs are engaged in money-lending business or business of money-lending or there was any indication either in the pleading or in the evidence that the plaintiffs advanced loan to any other person.

19. In the instant case, the evidence was that the original plaintiff lent money on a single occasion. Therefore, it was not necessary that the plaintiff should have taken out a licence under the Bengal Money-Lenders Act, nor it was necessary to send a statement of account to the defendant as required by that Act.

20. The learned Trial Judge held that the plaintiff failed to issue any notice through his Advocates to the defendants asking them refund the loan amount. Therefore; in the opinion of the learned Judge, in the absence of notice for one month, the suit for recovery of money should fail.

21. The question, therefore, is whether the borrower is entitled to get a notice or a demand for refund of money lent and advanced before a suit can be instituted.

22. In this case, there was no contract between the parties for giving a notice for one month through the learned Advocate for the lender before institution of a suit. In the plaint, it was stated that demands were made for refund of money, but in vain.

23. A demand for refund of money lent and advanced by issuing a notice through the learned Advocate of the lender is not a condition precedent to a suit. To call upon a lender, who had advanced an accommodation loan, in every such case, to make a demand for refund by issuing a notice before instituting a costly and time-consuming suit would be a tax on his generosity. We are not prepared to accept the findings of the learned Judge that, in the absence of any contract, a borrower is entitled to a notice for one month asking him to pay back the loan amount with interest.

24. The plaintiff has, also, claimed for special damage and compensation for harassment, humiliation and mental agony and the plaintiff valued such claims at Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only. We have considered the materials-on-record; we are of the opinion that plaintiff could not establish such claims for special damage and compensation. We are not inclined to grant a decree to the plaintiff on those scores.

25. Therefore, the impugned judgement and decree passed by the learned Trial Judge are set aside. Money Suit No. 16 of 2004 is decreed in part for Rs. 1,37,690/- (Rupees one lakh thirty seven thousand six hundred ninety) only. The plaintiff shall, also, be entitled to interest at the rate of 12 (twelve) per centum per annum from the date of institution of the suit till recovery from the defendants.

26. The defendants are directed to pay the decreetal sum within a month from this date. In default, however, it will be open to the plaintiff to initiate execution proceedings for recovery of the decreetal sum in accordance with law.

27. Urgent xerox certified copy of the judgement and decree, if applied for, are to be supplied to the learned Advocates for the parties, upon compliance of all formalities.

Tarun Kumar Gupta, J.:— I agree.

B.D