Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Seethalakshmi/Ramakrishnananda v. Special Tahsildar (La) Ii

Madras High Court
Aug 3, 1994
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner purchased a parcel of land in S. No. 68/2, Somayampalayam Village, Coimbatore by sale deed dated 29.8.1981. The land was the subject of acquisition proceedings under the Land Acquisition Act. A preliminary notification was published in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette on 2.6.1982. The petitioner was recorded as owner in the acquisition proceedings and the enquiry under Section 5-A, but she states she did not receive information or copies of those proceedings. A declaration under Section 6 was said by the petitioner to have been made on 9.4.1983/27.4.1983; she received a Section 9(3) notice dated 28.4.1984 in May 1984. The petitioner instituted a writ petition claiming the proceedings were conducted without affording her an opportunity to be heard, among other grounds.

In W.M.P. No. 18477 of 1984, a learned Judge on 12.9.1985 made an order making an interim stay absolute as to the petitioner on condition that respondents could proceed and pass an award but could not take possession without prior court orders; the respondents were permitted to note and rectify any infirmities. It was observed that the order did not stay the acquisition proceedings generally; rather it prevented dispossession of the petitioner. It was conceded before the court in the present opinion that an award had not yet been made.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the acquisition proceedings had lapsed under Section 11-A of the Land Acquisition Act because no award was made within the two-year period specified in that section.
  2. Whether the period for making an award under Section 11-A should exclude the time consumed in the instant writ proceedings (on the respondents' contention that the interim order impeded proceedings), even though no stay of the acquisition proceedings was actually made that prevented the making of an award.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The acquisition proceedings were conducted without affording the petitioner an opportunity of being heard.
  • The petitioner also alleged she did not receive information or copies of the proceedings in which she was shown as owner.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The requisitioning authority had not made available the compensation money; until compensation is made available, an award could not be made.
  • The period prescribed under Section 11-A should be calculated after excluding the period consumed in the instant writ proceedings because of the interim order.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined Section 11-A of the Land Acquisition Act, which requires the Collector to make an award within two years from publication of the declaration and provides that failure to do so causes the entire acquisition proceedings to lapse. The section's Explanation excludes from the two-year computation any period during which action or proceedings pursuant to the declaration are stayed by a court order.

The court considered the respondents' explanation that absence of available compensation funds prevented making an award and their submission that time consumed in the writ proceedings should be excluded. The court concluded:

  • The statutory two-year limitation of Section 11-A applied and, on the facts before the court, the acquisition had lapsed by reason of non-compliance with that time limit.
  • The Explanation to Section 11-A operates only when there is an actual court-ordered stay of proceedings; here there was no stay of the acquisition proceedings that impeded the making of an award. The earlier order prevented dispossession of the petitioner but did not stay the acquisition proceedings themselves.
  • Therefore, time could not be excluded on the basis that the writ petition was pending when no stay had been ordered; respondents could not rely on pendency alone to avoid the statutory timetable.
  • The respondents' reliance on non-availability of compensation money did not negate the statutory requirement to make an award within the period prescribed by Section 11-A.

On this analysis the court found the acquisition proceedings under G.O. Ms. No. 694 (Education, Science and Technology) dated 9.4.1983 and published 27.4.1983 to be vitiated by lapse under Section 11-A and therefore quashed those proceedings.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition was allowed and the acquisition proceedings in G.O. Ms. No. 694 dated 9.4.1983 (published 27.4.1983) were quashed on the ground that the acquisition had lapsed under Section 11-A of the Land Acquisition Act.

Consequences for the parties: the attempted acquisition under the specified government order is set aside and the petitioner is protected from dispossession; there was no order as to costs. The opinion does not discuss broader precedent-setting implications; it addresses the direct effect on the parties and the application of the statutory time limit under Section 11-A in the circumstances described.

Show all summary ...

Petitioner is a purchaser for valid consideration of a piece of land in S. No. 68/2 in Somayampalayam Village, Coimbatore, vide sale deed dated 29.8.1981 The said land has been subjected to a proceeding under the Land Acquisition Act and the preliminary notification for the said purpose has been issued and published in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette on 2.6.1982 According to the petitioner, she was shown as the owner of the said property in the proceedings after the preliminary notification including the enquiry under Section 5-A of the Act and she received no information or copies of the proceedings. Later, however, in the proceedings, a declaration under Section 6 of the Act has been made according to the petitioner on 9.4.1983/27.4.1983. She, however, received a notice under Section 9(3) of the Act dated 28.4.1984 in May, 1984. She moved this Court accordingly on the ground that the proceedings have been held without affording to her opportunity of being heard and some other grounds.

2. In W.M.P No. 18477 of 1984, a learned Judge of this Court on 12.9.1985 has passed the following order:

“Government Pleader reports that on verifying the plans, the extent involved in the writ petition is towards the peripheral portion under acquisition. Therefore, as already directed on 29.8.1985, interim stay is made absolute, subject to the condition that the respondents could proceed with the acquisition proceedings and pass an award, but not to take possession without prior orders of this Court, In the course of taking further proceedings, it is entirely left to the discretion of the respondents to take note of the points taken in the writ petition, and if there are any infirmities as claimed, they could even be rectified, and thereafter proceed further with the matter. This order is confirmed only to the petitioner and none else.”

3. It is seen from the said order that this court has not stayed the proceedings and ordered only that the petitioner as a consequence of the acquisition shall not be dispossessed. It is conceded, however, before me that award has not yet been made.

4. Section 11-A of the Land Acquisition Act reads as follows:

“The Collector shall make an award under section 11 within a period of two years from the date of the publication of the declaration and if no award is made within that period, the entire proceedings for the acquisition of the land shall lapse:

Provided that in a case where the said declaration has been published before the commencement of the Land Acquisition (Amendment) Act, 1984, the award shall be made within a period of two years from such commencement.

Explanation:— In computing the period of two years referred to in this section, the period during which any action or proceeding to be taken in pursuance of the said declaration is stayed by an order of a Court shall be excluded.”

4-A. To a query why when this Court has indicated in the above order that proceedings should be completed, care has not been taken to abide by the time schedule as contemplated under the Act itself, learned counsel for the respondents has pointed out that the requisitioning authority has not yet made available the compensation money and until such compensation money is made available by the requisitioning authority, it is not possible to make the award. Be that as it may, this case in my opinion is fully covered by Section 11-A of the Act and the acquisition for the said reason has lapsed. Learned Counsel for the respondents has, however, pointed out that the period stipulated under Section 11-A of the Act has to be calculated after excluding the period consumed in the instant proceedings on account of the interim order aforementioned. There can be no exception to the rule that in case a proceeding is stayed by a competent Court of law, the period of limitation shall run only after the stay is vacated or when the matter is finally adjudited by the Court. In the instant case, however, the above rule is obviously not applicable. There has been no stay ordered by the Court, which acted as an impediment to the proceedings for award. While no petitioner can take advantage of the order of stay on the one hand and the statutory limitation under Section 11-A of the Act on the other hand, the respondents similarly cannot come forward and say that since the petition has been admitted and is pending even though there is no order of stay, it has decided not to proceed in accordance with law.

5. For the reasons aforementioned, I am inclined to interfere with the proceedings of the respondents in G.O.Ms NO. 694, Education, Science and Technology dated 9.4.1983 and published in Tamil Nadu Government Gazette dated 27.4.1983 The same is accordingly quashed. The Writ Petition is allowed. There shall be, however, no order as to costs.

KA/RR/VCS