Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Arbee & Company, Madras v. Govind Dall Mills Rep. By Its Partner, A.N.G Ravindran And Others

Madras High Court
Jun 22, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — C. Nagappan, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal was preferred against the judgment and decree in O.S. No. 1482 of 1981 passed by the IX Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Madras. The plaintiff purchased a consignment of 2,000 bags of "Jumbo Black Matpe (Oorid)" shipped by Thai Agro Export Company, Bangkok to Madras Port aboard the M.V. European Liberty. The first defendant acted as the shipping agents for the vessel (the carrier's local agents); the plaintiff paid US$31,500 for the goods and insured the consignment for Rs. 2,52,000.

The consignment arrived at Madras on or about 23 February 1980. The plaintiff took delivery between 14 March and 19 March 1980 and, on delivery, alleged that 203 bags were short-landed (and a "B" certificate was issued by Madras Port Trust). An independent surveyor (G. R. Newman) reported, on 28 March 1980, that in the remaining 1,797 bags there was a shortage of 7,982 kgs (bags weighed 81,993 kgs against an expected 89,979 kgs). The plaintiff claimed Rs. 46,272.64 (value of 203 bags, shortage in weight and survey fees) from the first defendant (shipping agents) and the second defendant (insurer), who did not satisfy the demand, and filed suit for recovery with interest and costs.

The trial court framed six issues, found that 203 bags were short-landed but that the 7,982 kg shortage was not proved, and decreed Rs. 25,578 in favour of the plaintiff (value of 203 bags) against the defendants with interest at 6% p.a. and proportionate costs. The first defendant appealed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit is maintainable as against the first defendant (the shipping agents) given the contention that they are only the agents of a disclosed principal and that the contract of carriage was with the carrier directly.
  2. Whether the second defendant (the insurer) is liable for the suit claim, in light of the plaintiff's alleged failure to preserve remedies against the carrier and the insurer's rights of subrogation.
  3. Whether there was short-landing of 203 bags of cargo and whether the 'B' certificate issued by the Madras Port Trust is sufficient to prove short-landing.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Assertions

  • The consignment of 2,000 bags was shipped to Madras and delivered to the plaintiff; on delivery the plaintiff discovered 203 bags short-landed and a shortage of 7,982 kgs in the remaining bags as per an independent survey.
  • The loss/shortage occurred while the consignment was in the custody of the ship and the carrier; the first defendant, as shipping agents, is liable to pay the value of the short-landed bags and the shortage.
  • The second defendant (insurer) is also liable to pay the value under the insurance policy.
  • The plaintiff sought Rs. 46,272.64 representing the claimed loss, with interest and costs.

First Defendant's (Appellant's) Arguments

  • The suit is barred by limitation under Article III, Rule 6 of the Carriage of Goods by Sea Act.
  • There is no privity between plaintiff and first defendant; the first defendant is only agent of a disclosed principal (Goldstar Line Limited) and not personally liable under Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act.
  • The vessel discharged the entire bill of lading quantity into the custody of Madras Port Trust; once delivered into Port Trust custody the carrier's liability ended (relying on Section 42(7) of the Major Port Trusts Act).
  • The alleged short-landing and shortage occurred while cargo was in the custody of Madras Port Trust (or due to plaintiff's delay/failure to clear cargo), so the first defendant cannot be held liable.
  • The 'B' certificate and subsequent survey are unreliable or time-barred; the plaintiff delayed clearance beyond free days and delayed applying for survey, rendering the survey not binding on the first defendant.
  • The suit was bad for non-joinder of the Madras Port Trust (a necessary party).

Second Defendant's (Insurer's) Arguments

  • The suit is not maintainable against the insurer because the plaintiff failed to protect rights and to comply with terms and conditions of the insurance contract (failed to submit necessary papers despite reminders), and therefore the insurer closed the file and repudiated liability.
  • The plaintiff's negligence and failure to preserve remedies against the carrier deprived the insurer of its right to be indemnified and subrogated to pursue the carrier.
  • There is no obligation on the insurer to pay interest as claimed by the plaintiff.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. Chinoy Chablani & Company, AIR 1982 Calcutta 365 That the statutory presumption under Section 230 (Clause (3)) of the Indian Contract Act cannot make an agent liable when the principal has entered into the contract directly with the third party; the agent cannot be held liable by legal fiction where the agent did not participate in formation of the contract. The court relied on this decision to support the proposition that when the contract of carriage was entered into with the carrier directly, the agent (first defendant) could not be held liable; the claim against the agent is misconceived.
The Union of India represented by the Regional Director (Food), Southern Region, Madras v. Cheyenna Companies Naviera S.A. represented by its Agent, Pengotis A. Lemas and Associates Ltd., 1974 1 MLJ 1 That when the carrier is liable to make good shortage, the local agent at Madras cannot be made liable. The court referred to this authority as a supporting precedent that an agent of the carrier cannot be held liable when the contract is with the carrier.
E.I.D. Parry (India) Ltd. v. Far Eastern Marine Transport Company Ltd., represented by its Local Agents, Chowgule Bros., 1988 1 LW 320 Reiterated that Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act applies where the agent enters into contract on behalf of the principal; if the contract is entered into directly by the principal/carrier, no liability can be attached to the agent. The court quoted and applied this decision to conclude that the claim against the first defendant (agent) is misconceived because the carriage contract was with the carrier directly.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by addressing the three framed points for determination.

Points 1 & 2 — Maintainability against the First Defendant and Liability of the Insurer

The court accepted as undisputed that the consignment was entrusted to the principal carrier at the port of shipment and carried to Madras by the vessel owned by that principal. The plaintiff's claim, however, was pursued only against the first defendant (the local agent) and the second defendant (insurer), not the carrier itself.

Applying the authorities cited, the court reasoned that Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act (and the judicial interpretations cited) operates where the agent himself enters into the contract on behalf of the principal. Where the contract of carriage has been entered into directly with the carrier (the principal), the legal fiction that would create a contract between agent and third party under Section 230 does not apply; hence an agent who did not participate in formation of the contract cannot be made liable simply by statutory presumption. The court relied on three precedents (Union of India v. Chinoy Chablani & Company; Union of India v. Cheyenna Companies Naviera S.A.; and E.I.D. Parry v. Far Eastern Marine Transport Co.) that reached the same conclusion in comparable factual contexts.

On the second defendant (insurer), the court applied the principle of subrogation as stated in the opinion: once an insurer pays the assured, the insurer is entitled to be subrogated to the assured's rights to proceed against the third party (the carrier) to recover its indemnity. If the assured abandons or loses its remedies against the carrier (for example, by failing to sue the carrier), the insurer loses its right of indemnity and may repudiate liability under the policy. The court held that the plaintiff's failure to sue the carrier meant the insurer was deprived of its indemnity remedy and therefore the insurer is not liable for the suit claim.

Point 3 — Whether Short-landing of 203 Bags Was Proved

The court examined documentary material relied on in the trial. The plaintiff produced Ex. A-14 (a "B" certificate dated 27.3.1980 issued by the Port Trust) purportedly certifying short-landing of 203 bags. However, other documents from the Port Trust created evident contradictions:

  • Ex. B-8 (out-turn statement dated 23.2.1980 from the Traffic Manager) stated that 203 bags of the consignment were excess landed and that the contents were filled in 91 gunny bags.
  • Ex. B-4 (a letter dated 4.8.1980 from the first defendant to the Traffic Manager) pointed out that the Port Trust's out-turn statement showed an excess of 154 bags compared to the manifested quantity and requested clarification; no clarification was provided by the Port Trust.
  • Exs. B-6 and B-7 (notice and enclosure dated 15.4.1981 from the Port Trust) again reflected that 203 bags' contents were filled in 91 gunny bags.

The court noted the plaintiff had not made the Madras Port Trust a party to the suit. Given that the Port Trust's own documents indicated excess landing (rather than short-landing) of 203 bags, the court concluded it was unclear how the Port Trust then issued Ex. A-14 certifying short-landing. In those circumstances the court held that the Port Trust's "B" certificate was not sufficient to establish short-landing and thus the short-landing allegation was not proved on the record.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appeal was allowed. The judgment and decree of the trial court were set aside and the suit was dismissed.

Immediate Consequences:

  • The plaintiff's decree against the first defendant (shipping agents) and the second defendant (insurer) was vacated.
  • The court held that the claim against the first defendant was misconceived because the contract of carriage was entered into with the carrier directly and the agent could not be held liable under Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act in those circumstances.
  • The insurer (second defendant) was held not liable because the plaintiff's failure to preserve remedies against the carrier deprived the insurer of its subrogated right of indemnity.
  • The court found that the 'B' certificate was insufficient to prove short-landing given contradictory Port Trust documents; accordingly the alleged short-landing was not proved on the record.

On Wider Legal Implications: The opinion applied existing authority on the limited legal question of agent liability where the carrier contracts directly and reiterated the insurer's subrogation principle as applied to the facts. The judgment does not purport to create new law; no broader or novel precedent was announced beyond applying established principles to the record before the court.

Result on Costs: The appeal was allowed. The suit was dismissed with costs. The court expressly recorded: "There shall be no order as to costs in this appeal."

Note: This summary is strictly confined to the statements, findings and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not introduce facts or legal propositions not present in the opinion text.

Show all summary ...

C. Nagappan, J.:— This appeal is preferred against the judgment and decree in O.S No. 1482 of 1981 passed by the IX Assistant Judge, City CiviL Court, Madras.

2. The first defendant is the appellant herein.

3. The plaint averments can be summarised as follows:

Two thousand bags of Jumbo Black Matpe (Oorid) packed in new jute bags with 50 kgs. per bag and of the aggregate value of 1,00,000 kgs. net was booked by Thai Agro Export Company, Bangkok to Madras Port and was shipped via., European Liberty, a ship of which the first defendant are the shipping agents. M.V European Liberty was classified as a Class I vessel. The plaintiff purchased the goods paying a price of 31500 U.S Dollars and it was insured for Rs. 2,52,000. The consignment reached Madras on or about 23rd of February, 1980. The plaintiff took delivery of the consignment from the Madras Port between 14.3.1980 and 19.3.1980 At the time of taking delivery, it was found that out of the 2000 bags shipped, 203 bags were short landed and ‘B’ certificate was issued by the Madras Port Trust. Further on the survey of the remaining 1797 bags, G.R Newman, Insurance Surveyor on 28.3.1980, found that there was a shortage of 7982 Kgs. of Oorid in the said 1797 bags. The bags are surveyed at Central Berth, Madras Port Trust and found to weight only 81993 kgs. as against the actual weight of 89979 kgs. The steamer Agents representative was not available at the time of survey but surveyed the bags and went away as per the Independent Surveyor's Report. The plaintiff preferred a claim to the first defendant claiming the value of 203 bags short landed and the value of 7982 kgs. being the shortage assessed by the Independent Surveyor with regard to the 1797 bags. The shortage in weight and the short landing of 203 bags had occurred while the consignment was in the custody of the ship and the first defendant, as the shipping agents, is liable to pay the plaintiff the value of it. The first defendant has negatived the claim of the plaintiff on the ground of delay in holding the survey. The consignment reached the Madras Port in a defective condition and the first defendant is liable for that. The second defendant, as insurer, is also liable to pay the plaintiff the value of it. The plaintiff has claimed in all a sum of Rs. 46,272.64 representing the value of 203 bags short landed and 7982 kgs. being the shortage in weight and the survey fees with the defendants. The defendants received the notice, but have not complied with the demand. Hence the plaintiff has filed the suit for recovery of a sum of Rs. 46,272.64 representing the amount due towards shortage and short landing and the survey from the defendants with interest and costs.

4. The first defendant in its written statement contended that the suit has not been filed within the statutory period of one year and the suit is barred under Article III, Rule 6 of the Carriage of Goods by Sea Act. There is no privity of contract between the plaintiff and the first defendant. The first defendant is only the agent of a disclosed principal namely Goldstar Line Limited and hence under Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act, the first defendant is not personally liable and no decree can be passed against it. The first defendant has further stated that a consignment allegedly consisting of 2000 bags of Jumbo Black Matpe (URAD) was entrusted to the principals of the first defendant at the Port of Bangkok for the carriage by Sea Jo the Port of Madras through the vessel M.V European Liberty, owned by the principal of the first defendant. The vessel carried the cargo with due care and diligence and arrived at the Port of Madras. The entire Bill of Lading quantity was discharged by the vessel into the custody of Madras Port Trust. There was no short landing of 203 bags of Cargo as contended by the plaintiff. The alleged loss of cargo must have been due to the loss in the custody of the Madras Port Trust for which the first defendant cannot be held liable. The ‘B’ certificate issued by the Port Trust was done without proper verification of records and it is not binding on the first defendant. The plaintiff is put to strict proof of the quality, weight, order and condition of the consignment prior to loading at the Port of Shipment. The Bill of Lading was issued based on a declaration made by the consignor and the first defendant was not aware of the quantity, quality and other details. Under Section 42(7) of the Major Port Trusts Act, once the cargo is landed by the carrier and delivered into the custody of the Madras Port Trust, the liability of the carrier comes to an end. The plaintiffs must seek its remedy from the Port Trust of Madras or the second defendant. The plaintiff delayed the clearance of the cargo from the Madras Port Trust well beyond the free days period. Hence the first defendant cannot be held liable for any short-landing or shortage of the cargo. Though the vessel completed the discharge of the cargo on 7.3.1980 itself, the plaintiff obtained the Delivery Order for the cargo only on 12.3.1980 which is only after the expiry of free days period. The plaintiff cleared only a part of the cargo from the Port Trust and wrongfully refused to clear the balance inspite of the first defendant's request to do so. The plaintiff applied for survey of the cargo only on 13.3.1980 and the survey was granted as time barred. Hence the survey is not binding on the first defendant. The survey conducted by the second defendant's surveyors is not binding on the first defendant. The alleged loss occurred only when the cargo was in the custody of the Madras Port Trust due to bad handling, pilferage etc. and due to the negligence of the plaintiff in not clearing the cargo immediately on discharge. The first defendant denies the averment that the cargo arrived at the Madras Port was in a defective condition resulting in short landing and shortage of weight. The suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary party, namely, Port Trust of Madras. The first defendant is not liable to pay the suit claim. The second defendant in its written statement contended that the suit is not maintainable as against the second defendant, as the plaintiff has no cause of action to file the suit against it. The plaintiff has grossly failed in its duty to protect the rights and claim of recovery as stipulated and required under the terms and conditions of the contract of Insurance. Thus, the plaintiff had the only option to claim for the alleged loss against the first defendant alone and the suit is liable to be dismissed as against the second defendant in limine. The plaintiff had not submitted the necessary papers relating to the claim to the second defendant inspite of reminders and the second defendant had necessarily to close the file pertaining to the claim after due notice to the plaintiff. The plaintiff was negligent and careless right from the arrival of the ship at Madras Port Trust and deliberately failed to discharge their obligation as per contract of Insurance. There is no contract or obligation on the part of the second defendant to pay interest as claimed by the plaintiff. The second defendant is not liable for the suit claim.

5. The trial Court framed six issues and on a consideration of the matter, came to the conclusion that there was short-landing of 203 bags and the shortage in weight of 7982 kgs. was not proved and the first defendant, as agent and the second defendant, as insurer are liable to pay a sum of Rs. 25,578 being the value of 203 bags and granted a decree for the above sum to the plaintiff against the defendants with subsequent interest at 6% per annum and proportionate costs. Aggrieved by the same, the first defendant has preferred the present appeal against the plaintiff and the second defendant. For the sake of convenience, in this judgment, the parties are described as arrayed in the suit.

6. The points for determination in this appeal are:

(1) Whether the suit is maintainable as against the first defendant?

(2) Whether the second defendant is liable for the suit claim?

(3) Whether there was short-landing of 203 bags of cargo and whether the ‘B’ certificate issued by the Port Trust is sufficient to prove it?

8. Points 1 and 2: The undisputed facts are that the consignment consisting of 2000 bags of Jumbo Black Matpe was entrusted to the principal of the first defendant at the Port of Bangkok for carriage by Sea to the Port of Madras by the Ship M.V European Liberty, owned by the principal of the first defendant and the consignment was sent to the plaintiff herein. According to the plaintiff, the vessel short landed 203 bags of cargo out of 2000 bags and there was also a shortage of 7982 kgs. of cargo in the remaining bags and the plaintiff has filed the present suit against the agent of the principal and the insurer. The first defendant mainly contends that it is only the agent of the disclosed principal Goldstar Line Limited and hence under Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act, it is not personally liable and the suit is not maintainable.

7. The learned counsel for the appellant/first defendant contends that the first defendant is the local agent of the carrier and in the plaint, it has not been explained by the plaintiff as to how the first defendant is liable for the suit claim and the contract of carriage by Sea has been entered into with the principal directly by the plaintiff and in such case, no liability can be attached to the agent and he relies on some decisions in this regard. The first division relied on in Union of India v. Chinoy Chablani & Company . AIR 1982 Calcutta 365. in which it is held as follows:

“The statutory presumption of a contract between the agent and the third party by legal fiction cannot be extended to cover a case where the principal has entered into the contract directly. In Clause (3) the word “principal” has been used in relation to the agent and not otherwise. The expression “though disclosed” have reference to the agent's act, Section 230, Clause (3) does not cover a case where the principal has entered into the contract himself and not through the agent. If the principal would enter into the contract directly with the third party there could not be any question of the principal being required to be disclosed as a principal. In such event, the agent could not possibly come into the picture at all, and, as such, the agent could not be made liable by creating a legal fiction whereby a contract would be presumed to exist by and between the agent and the third party. If the agent has not done anything in the formation of the contract he could not be made liable without his knowledge and consent by statutory fiction contained in Clause (3). In such a case, the Legislature could not be said to have exonerated a principal who has himself entered into the contract by foisting his contractual liability on to the agent without his knowledge and consent by means of statutory presumption that a contract existed by and between the agent and the third party simply because the principal contracting party could not be sued.”

8. The second decision relied on is The Union of India represented by the Regional Director (Food), Southern Region, Madras v. Cheyenna Companies Naviera S.A represented by its Agent, Pengotis A. Lemas and Associates Ltd. . 1974 1 MLJ 1., in which, a learned Judge of this Court held that the carrier would be liable to make good the shortage and agent of the carrier at Madras cannot be made liable.

9. The next decision is E.I.D Parry (India) Ltd. having its registered office at Dare House, Madras-1 v. Far Eastern Marine Transport Company Ltd., represented by its Local Agents, Chowgule Bros. . 1988 1 LW 320., in which, S.A Kader, J. held as follows:

“16. Issue No. 4—The second defendant-partnership firm is the local agent of the first defendant carrier. Neither in the plaint nor in the argument advanced by the learned counsel for the plaintiff has it been explained as to how the second defendant is liable for the suit claim. This contract of carriage by Sea has been entered into with the first defendant directly and in such a case, no liability can be attached to the agent. Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act comes into play only where the contract is entered into by the agent on behalf of the principal. The claim against the second defendant is therefore misconceived as rightly contended by its learned counsel. This issue is also found against the plaintiff.”

10. In the above dedsions, the Calcutta High Court as well as this Court have held that when the contract of carriage by Sea entered with the carrier directly, no liability can be attached to the agent and the claim against the agent is misconceived. In the present case also, the contract of carriage by Sea has been entered into by the plaintiff with the carrier directly and the suit has not been filed against the carrier, but only against the agent and in such circumstance, the claim against the first defendant agent is misconceived.

11. The second defendant is the insurer and its contention is that the plaintiff had grossly failed in its duty to protect the rights and the claim of recovery as stipulated and required under the terms and conditions of the contract of insurance and it is not liable for the suit claim. Under the law of Insurance, the right of the Insurer on payment of the loss to the assured is to be subrogated to the rights of the assured so as to enable the insurer to proceed against the third party and indemnity itself. The assured has to keep alive his remedies against the carrier and any default committed by the assured by abandoning his rights against the carrier will deprive the insurer of its remedies against the carrier. In such case, it is open to the insurer to repudiate its liability under the policy. In the instant case, the plaintiff by its failure to institute the suit against the carrier, has lost its remedy against the carrier and consequently, the second defendant—insurer is deprived of its right of indemnity against the carrier and in such circumstances, the second defendant is also not liable for the suit claim.

12. Point No. 3: The learned counsel for the appellant/first defendant contends that there was no short-landing of 203 bags of cargo as contended by the plaintiff and the ‘B’ certificate issued by the Port Trust to the plaintiff is doubtful and it is not sufficient to prove the short-landing and relies on some circumstances in this regard. Ex. A-14 is the ‘B’ certificate dated 27.3.1980 given by the Port Trust to the plainltiff. Ex. B-4 is the letter dated 4.8.1980 written by the first defendant to the Traffic Manager of Madras Port Trust. In the above letter, the first defendant has informed the Port Trust that the outturn statement of the Port Trust showed short landing of 203 bags, whereas as per the tally of the Port Trust, it is found that an excess quantity of 154 bags than the manifested quantity landed and the first defendant mentioned the details of tally in the letter and it wanted the Port Trust to clarify. There is no clarification by the Port Trust in this regard.

13. Exs. B-6 and B-7 are the notice and enclosure respectively dated 15.4.1981 sent by the Port Trust to the first defendant with regard to the suit consignment. In the enclosure in Ex. B-7, it is mentioned that 203 bags contents were filled in 91 gunny bags. Ex. B-8 dated 23.2.1980 is the out-turn statement issued by the Traffic Manager of the Port Trust, in which, it is stated that 203 bags of suit consignment were excess landed and the contents were filled in 91 gunny bags. The plaintiff had not added the Port Trust as a party in the suit. The very documents of the Port Trust reveal excess landing of 203 bags of the suit consignment. It is not known as to how the Port Trust has issued Ex. A-14, B certificate dated 27.3.1980 certifying the short-landing of 203 bags of cargo when its own documents reveal otherwise. The B certificate issued by the Port Trust in this case is not sufficient to prove the short-landing and the short-landing of cargo is not proved and the suit must, therefore, fail. In the result, the appeal is allowed and the judgment and decree of the trial Court are set aside and the suit is dismissed with costs. There shall be no order as to costs in this appeal.

14. Appeal allowed.