Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sekhara Pillai v. Government Of Tamil Nadu

Madras High Court
May 19, 1992
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Second Appeal concerning Minority Status of Arumana High School

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed O.S. No. 463 of 1978 in the Principal District Munsif, Kuzhithurai, seeking a declaration that the plaintiff's high school (High School Arumana) is a minority institution entitled to protection under Articles 29 and 30 of the Constitution of India, and consequential injunction restraining defendants from enforcing certain Sections and Rules of the Tamil Nadu Recognised Private Schools (Regulation) Act, 1973 and Rules framed thereunder.

The school was started by the plaintiff's father in 1941, upgraded to high school status in 1948. The plaintiff alleges the school was started to promote Malayalam (the language of the Nair community, which the plaintiff contends is a linguistic minority in Kanyakumari District). After the merger of Kanyakumari District with Tamil Nadu (by the States Reorganisation Act), Tamil-medium divisions were opened.

The Chief Educational Officer issued a communication dated 26.6.1973 directing compliance with the 1973 Act; the plaintiff challenged that direction by W.P. 4945/75 which was dismissed on 4.10.1976 but the court gave opportunity to file a suit for declaration within 11 weeks. The present suit followed.

The defendants resisted, arguing inter alia that the school was not established with the intention to promote Malayalam and pointing to the numeric predominance of Tamil-medium students; therefore it was not a minority institution and must follow the 1973 Act. After trial the District Munsif dismissed the suit. The plaintiff's first appeal (A.S. 178/79) was dismissed by the Subordinate Judge, confirming the trial court. The plaintiff filed this second appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the courts below were correct in holding that the High School, Arumanai, managed by the appellant is not entitled to protection under Articles 29 and 30 of the Constitution of India.
  2. When 'minority school' in Act 29 of 1974 is defined as a private school "established and administered, or administered, by such minority" (whether based on religion or language) having the right under Clause (1) of Article 30 of the Constitution, whether the courts below were correct in saying that the private school has to be established by the minority (i.e., whether establishment at a time when the founders were not a minority precludes protection if the community later becomes a minority).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Mr. G.S. Thambi)

  • The school was started by the plaintiff's father with the object of promoting Malayalam language.
  • The plaintiff belongs to the Nair community whose mother tongue is Malayalam and thus is part of a linguistic minority in Tamil Nadu.
  • The school was established and administered as a minority institution; consequently the plaintiff is entitled to the declaration and injunction under Articles 29 and 30.
  • Reliance was placed on decisions (including N. Parameswara Kurup v. State) holding that institutions established in areas later merged into Tamil Nadu may be entitled to Article 30 protection where the relevant community becomes a minority after reorganisation.

Respondent's Arguments (Mr. B. Mani, Government Advocate)

  • The school is not a minority institution and hence is not entitled to protection under Articles 29 and 30 of the Constitution.
  • Evidence shows only one Malayalam section in each standard and a larger number of Tamil-medium students (132 Malayalam v. 622 Tamil), undermining the claim that the school was established to promote Malayalam.
  • The management must therefore follow provisions of the Tamil Nadu Recognised Private Schools (Regulation) Act, 1973.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Azeez Basha v. Union of India, AIR 1968 SC 662 The words "established and administered" in Article 30 must be read conjointly; an institution established by central legislation was not held to have been established by a religious minority even if later administered by one. The lower appellate court relied on this ruling to conclude that because the school was established when it lay in the erstwhile Trivancore-Cochin State (where Malayalam was official) it was not established by a minority; the present Court considered that precedent but found distinguishing features and other applicable authority.
N. Parameswara Kurup v. State (High Court decision cited in the judgment) Held that where institutions were established in the erstwhile Travancore-Cochin State and later, after transfer of territory by Central Act 37 of 1956, became part of Tamil Nadu, a liberal and sympathetic construction of Article 30(1) entitled such institutions to protection if they had been established and were managed for the benefit of the linguistic community that became a minority after reorganisation. The Court found the facts of the present case similar to those in N. Parameswara Kurup and applied the same reasoning: since the school was established to benefit Malayalis and is managed by those who established it, it is entitled to Article 30(1) protection despite territorial reorganisation.
State of Kerala, Etc. v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial, Etc., AIR 1970 SC 2079 It is irrelevant to minority-protection under Article 30 that persons from other (including majority) communities attend the minority institution; their presence does not defeat minority rights. The Court relied on this principle to hold that the numerical predominance of Tamil-medium students in the school is not germane to the question of minority status; attendance by non-minority students does not defeat the school's claim to protection.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through the following analytical steps, grounded in the evidence and authority cited in the record:

  1. Examination of evidence: The Court reviewed the plaintiff's evidence (P.W.1) that the school was started by his father in 1941 as a Middle School, upgraded in 1947–48, and was conducted for promoting Malayalam; that Malayalam was the only medium before the 1956 merger and Tamil classes were introduced only after the merger.
  2. Consideration of lower courts' conclusions: The trial and first appellate courts had held that the institution was not a minority school and that the plaintiff was not administering it for promotion of Malayalam (finding instead that the school was run to promote private interest). The appellate court had relied on Azeez Basha to emphasize the conjunctive reading of "established and administered."
  3. Assessment of comparable authority: The Court considered a High Court decision in N. Parameswara Kurup where institutions established in Travancore-Cochin and later incorporated into Tamil Nadu by the States Reorganisation Act were held entitled to Article 30 protection. The reasoning in that decision emphasised a generous, liberal and sympathetic approach to construing Article 30(1), particularly where plaintiffs had established and continued to manage the institutions for the benefit of the linguistic community that became a minority after reorganisation.
  4. Application to present facts: Finding the present facts similar to N. Parameswara Kurup (school established to benefit Malayalis, managed by the founders), the Court concluded that the school falls within the protective ambit of Article 30(1) even though it was established at a time when the founders were not a minority in the erstwhile state.
  5. On the relevance of student composition: The Court addressed the defendants' emphasis on the larger number of Tamil-medium students but held that numerical predominance of non-minority students is not decisive. Relying on State of Kerala v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial, the Court observed that attendance by other communities is irrelevant to the grant of Article 30 protection.
  6. Statutory definition: The Court noted that under Act 29 of 1974 a "minority school" is defined to include schools "established and administered or administered by a minority." The Court held the plaintiff's case fits within this statutory definition (i.e., an institution administered by a minority) and therefore statutory language supports granting relief.
  7. Conclusion of analysis: Taken together — plaintiff's evidence about original purpose, the High Court precedent permitting protection where reorganisation caused minority status, the irrelevance of student composition, and the statutory definition — led the Court to conclude the plaintiff is entitled to declaration and injunction under Articles 29 and 30.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The second appeal is allowed; the judgments of the courts below are set aside; the suit is decreed and the plaintiff is entitled to the declaration and injunction sought that the High School Arumana is a minority educational institution entitled to protection under Articles 29 and 30 of the Constitution of India.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The plaintiff obtains the declaratory relief that the school is a minority institution and the consequential injunction (restraining enforcement of the challenged provisions of the Tamil Nadu Recognised Private Schools (Regulation) Act, 1973, as applied to this institution).
  • The judgments of the trial court and the first appellate court are set aside.
  • Each party is to bear their respective costs throughout.

The Court applied and relied upon existing precedent (including State and High Court decisions) and statutory definition; the judgment applies those authorities to the facts and does not purport to create a new legal principle beyond that application.

(End of summary.)

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

The plaintiff in O.S 463 of 1978 on the file of Principal District Munsif, Kuzhithurai, has filed this second appeal against the Judgment in A.S 178 of 1979 on the file of Additional Subordinate Judge, Kuzhithurai, in which the learned Subordinate Judge has confirmed the judgment in O.S No. 463 of 1978.

2. Short facts leading to this appeal are:

The plaintiff has filed the suit for declaration that the plaintiff's high school is a minority institution entitled to protection under Articles 29 and 30 of the Constitution of India and consequential injunction restraining the defendants from enforcing certain Sections and Rules in Tamil Nadu Recognised Private Schools (Regulation) Act, 1973 and Rules framed thereunder on the following grounds:

The plaintiff is the owner and Manager of Educational Institution called High School Arumana which was started by the plaintiff's father in 1941. It was upgraded as a High School in 1948. It was started with the object of promoting Malayalam Language which is the language of the Nair Community which constitute a linguistic minority in Kanyakumari District. After the merger of Kanyakumari District with the state of Tamil Nadu, more divisions were opened in the school for imparting knowledge of Tamil. The Tamil Nadu Government passed Tamil Nadu Recognised Private Schools (Regulations) Act, 1973. It had virtually taken the right of management and had vested it in a school committee. This Act of the Government violates the fundamental rights guaranteed to the minorities under Article 29 and 30 of the Constitution. The Chief Educational Officer of Kanyakumari District required the plaintiff by his communication dated 26.6.73 to comply with the provisions of the said Act. Aggrieved by this direction, the plaintiff filed W.P 4945/75. It was resisted by the defendants who questioned the character of the minority institution. The writ petition was dismissed on 4.10.76 giving opportunity to the plaintiff to file a suit within 11 weeks from the date of order for a declaration that the school is a minority institution entitled to protection under Articles 29 and 30 of the Constitution of India. Hence the suit.

3. The defendants resisted the suit on the following grounds:

The school was not opened with an intention to promote Malayalam language. It is having one Malayalam section in each standard. The total number of students in Malayalam Section is 132 whereas the total number of students in Tamil Section is 622. The claim that intention of starting the school has to promote Malayalam language is baseless. Since the school is not a minority institution, the management is expected to follow the provisions contained in the Tamil Nadu Recognised Private Schools (Regulation) Act, 1973. the plaintiff is not entitled to protection under Article 29 and 30 of the Constitution of India. Hence dismissal of the suit is prayed for.

4. After elaborate trial, the learned District Munsif had that plaintiff's school is not a minority school, entitled to protection under Articles 29 and 30 of the Constitution and that the plaintiff is not entitled to declaration and injunction prayed for by him and has dismissed the suit. Aggrieved by the same, the plaintiff A.S 178/79 on the file of Subordinate Judge, Kuzhithurai. The learned subordinate Judge, after hearing the parties has dismissed the appeal and thereby confirmed the judgment of the trial court. Aggrieved by the same, the plaintiff has come forward with this second appeal.

5. The substantial questions of law that arose in this second appeal are:

1. Whether the courts below were correct in holding that the High School, Arumanai, managed by the appellant is not entitled to protection of Article of the Constitution of India?

2) When ‘minority school’ in Act 29 of 1974 is defined as a private school or its choice established and administered, or administered, by such minority, whether based on religion or language as has the right to do so under Clause (1) of Article 30 of the Constitution of India, are the courts below correct in saying that the private school has to be established by the minority?

6. Mr. G.S Thambi, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that the school was started by the plaintiff's father with the object of promoting Malayalam language that plaintiff belongs to Nair community whose mother tongue is Malayalam and hence is a linguistic minority in Tamil Nadu and the school was established and administered as a minority institution and hence plaintiff is entitled to declaration and injunction, as prayed for by him. Per contra, Mr. B. Mani, the learned Government Advocate, appearing for the respondents, submitted that the school is not a minority institution hence is not entitled to protection of Articles 29 and 30 of the Constitution of India.

7. The plaintiff figured as P.W 1, He has stated that his father started the school in 1941 as a Middle School and later it was upgraded as High School in 1947-1948 and the school is conducted in promoting Malayalam language. He has further stated that he belongs to Nair community and Malayalam is his mother-tongue and Nair community is a minority community. He has further stated that Malayalam was the only medium of instruction in his school before merger in 1956 of this part of the country with Tamil Nadu and after merger, Tamil classes were opened and this school is a minority institution based on language. Though in cross-examination, he has stated that he do not know for what purpose the school was started, lie has stated that the aim of starting the school is to benefit the Malayalis. The lower appellate court had held that at the time when the school was started, it was in the Trivancore-Cochin State and only later it was merged with Tamil Nadu and has become part and parcel of Kanyakumari District where Malayalam is a language of linguistic minority and that enable a person to get the protection of Article 30 of the Constitution, the institution must have been established and administered by the minorities and in the instant case, it was not established by a minority based on language in as much as at the time of starting of the school, this school was situated in erstwhile Trivancore-Cochin State where Malayalam is the official language. The lower appellate court had relied upon the ruling of the apex court in Azeez Basha v. Union of India AIR 1968 SC 662. In that case, the contention of the petitioner was that Aligarh University is a minority institution, The said University was established by Central Legislation by Aligarh Muslim University Act, 1920. So it was held that it was not established by a religious minority but was later administered by a religious minority and that to claim the benefit of Article 30 of the Constitution it must have been established and administered by the religious minority and the words ‘established and administered’ must be read conjointly. Mr. G.S Thambi, would submit that in a case having identical facts, this High Court has decided that such a school which was established in a erstwhile Trivancore-Cochin State which later became part of Kanyakumari District is a school entitled to protection of 30 of the Constitution of India. In N. Parameswara Kurup v. State, the school concerned in those cases were originally situated in the erstwhile Travancore-Cochin State. But later, those portions of Travancore-Cochin State had merged with the State of Tamil Nadu by Central Act, 37 of 1956. The plaintiff who had established those schools would contend that after merger with Tamil Nadu, the schools which were intended for the benefit of students of Nair community and for the benefit of Malayalis in the State of Tamil Nadu and so they are entitled to protection guaranteed under Article 30(1) of the Constitution. Article 30(1) of the Constitution of India reads as follows:

“30 (1) All minorities, whether based on religion or language, shall have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice.”

It was submitted in the above case for the appellants that Kanyakumari District has been transferred to State of Tamil Nadu by States Reorganisation Act (Central Act 37 of 1956) that these linguistic classes have been reduced to minority and therefore, they are entitled to protection guaranteed under Article 30(1) of the Constitution of India. It was their further submission that the plaintiffs, who established those institutions are managing the same and that therefore there can be no impediment to hold that the institutions are minority schools within the purview of Article 30(1) of the Constitution of India. On that submission, Justice Maheswaran, had held as follows:

“The right conferred by Art. 30(1) of the Constitution of India is not an illusion and such a right cannot be allowed to whittle down. In this case, there is no dispute that the plaintiffs have established the institutions and are in management of the same. A generous liberal and sympathetic approach should weigh with the court in construing Art. 30(1) of the Constitution of India. The safeguarding of interest of the minorities amongst affluent population is very important. Such a generous and sympathetic approach is reflected in the Constitution so as to preserve the right of the minorities in so far as their educational institutions are concerned. When such is the case, the plaintiffs should not be deprived of their protection guaranteed under Art. 30(1) of the Constitution of India, merely, because the plaintiffs who established the in situations were not minority at the time when the institutions we re established, but later become minority in view of the fact that Kanyakumari district was transferred to the State of Tamil Nadu, by virtue of the provisions of the Central Act 37 of 1956. In this view of the matter. I am of opinion that the plaintiffs will be entitled to the declaration prayed for.”

The facts of the case before me are similar to the facts on which the above ruling was given by this Court. The plaintiff's evidence which I have referred to supra would show that the aim of starting of the school was to benefit Malayalis and for promoting Malayalam language. So the plaintiff is entitled to the protection of Article 30(1) of the Constitution of India.

8. The courts below have held that the plaintiff is not administering the institution as a minority for the purpose of promotion of Malayalam language and that he is conducting the private school to promote his own interest. The admitted evidence is that there are Malayalam classes separately in each standard. According to P.W 1 Malayalam was the only medium of instruction in this School before merger in 1956 with Tamil Nadu and thereafter, Tamil classes were also started. It is in evidence that students in classes in Tamil medium out number the number of students studying in Malayalam medium. But that is not, germane. In State Of Kerala, Etc. v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial, Etc AIR 1970 SC 2079, the apex court has laid as follows:

“It is equally irrelevant that in addition to the minority community others from other minority communities or even from the majority community can take advantage of these institutions. Such other communities bring in income and do not have to be turned away to enjoy the protection.”

9. Further more, as per Act 29 of 1974, the minority school is one which is established and administered or administered by a minority. The plaintiff's case comes within the ambit of this definition also and hence is entitled to the reliefs prayed for.

10. In view of the above, the plaintiff will have to necessarily succeed and get a declaration and injunction prayed for by him.

11. In the result, the second appeal is allowed, setting aside the judgments of the courts below and consequently the suit is decreed. In the circumstances of the case, parties shall bear their respective costs throughout.

RR/KA/VCS