- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
R. Manickam v. The Sengunthar Charitable Trust, Rep. By Its Secretary, T.P. Arumugam
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiffs (the revision petitioners) filed a suit in the District Court, Namakkal, registered as S.R. No. 1825 of 2009. The suit prayed for framing a Scheme in respect of the first respondent trust under Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The District Judge returned the Plaint on multiple occasions for defects:
- Return No. I (15.4.2009): Listed five specific defects (value of the suit, court-fees and provision of law under the Court Fees Act, jurisdiction, properties involved, and short cause title). Time one month was granted for compliance. The petitioners rectified the defects and re-presented the Plaint the same day.
- Return No. II (15.5.2009): Stated "Previous return No. 4 complied with is not satisfactory." Time one month granted; petitioners answered and re-presented the Plaint.
- Return No. III (19.6.2009): Requested the value of the suit, correct provision of law under the Court Fees Act and payment of any deficit court-fee. Time one month granted; petitioners re-presented after furnishing details.
- Return No. IV (12.8.2009): Stated that the previous returns dated 15.4.2009, 15.5.2009 and 19.6.2009 were to be correctly complied with and that the compliance should be incorporated in the Plaint wherever applicable. Time one month granted.
Because the Plaint was returned successively (four returns), the plaintiffs filed this Civil Revision Petition seeking a direction that the Lower Court register the Plaint instead of repeatedly returning it on the ground of non-compliance.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the District Court was justified in repeatedly returning the Plaint (on 15.4.2009, 15.5.2009, 19.6.2009 and 12.8.2009) instead of registering it after the petitioners' compliance.
- Whether the High Court should direct the District Judge to register the Plaint forthwith or require the Trial Court to reconsider the returns and compliance on merits.
- What is the proper scope of the Court's scrutiny at the stage of registration of a Plaint and how should defects be recorded and dealt with when a Plaint is returned and re-presented.
Arguments of the Parties
Revision Petitioners' Arguments
- The defects pointed out by the District Judge were promptly rectified and the Plaint was re-presented each time.
- Some particulars sought in the return memo were already furnished in the original Plaint, so returning the Plaint repeatedly showed a lack of application of mind by the Trial Judge.
- The repeated returns were unwarranted and this Court should issue corrective directions to put subordinate courts in order and to direct registration of the Plaint.
- Specifically, counsel relied on the petitioners' compliance reports to argue that all defects were rectified, making the return dated 12.8.2009 unjustified.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any arguments advanced on behalf of the first respondent (the trust) or other parties.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| T. Arivandandam v. T.V. Satyapal, 1977 (4) SCC 467 | Illustrates the Trial Court's jurisdiction under Order 7, Rule 11, CPC to reject a Plaint that is manifestly vexatious or does not disclose a clear right to sue; advocates early screening of bogus litigation. | The court quoted this authority to emphasize that Trial Courts have power to reject meritless or vexatious suits under Order 7, Rule 11, and that proactive judicial action at an early stage is permissible to curb irresponsible litigation. This underpins the distinction between scrutiny at registration and the power to reject later. |
| Shreenath v. Rajesh, 1998 (4) SCC 543 | Describes the hardships and long procedural routes a seeker of justice faces; highlights delay caused by procedural law and hierarchical appeals. | The court relied on this statement to acknowledge the procedural difficulties faced by litigants and to justify a measured approach at the entry point (registration) so as not to unnecessarily delay access to justice. |
| R.N. Jadi & Brothers v. Subhashchandra, 2007 (4) CTC 326 (SC) : 2007 (9) Scale 202 | Affirms that procedural law is subservient to justice — rules of procedure are handmaids of justice and should advance the cause of justice rather than obstruct it. | The court cited this authority to reinforce the principle that procedural prescriptions should aid, not obstruct, justice; this guided the court's view that registration-stage scrutiny should be limited to verifying compliance with essential procedural requirements. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in the following steps, strictly following the text of the opinion:
- Contextual observation: The court noted that civil litigation is procedurally long and that execution and appeals prolong access to relief (paras 9, 15). This establishes the sensitivity to procedural delays when dealing with registration of Plaint.
- Statutory framework: The court observed that Order 7, Rule 1 prescribes particulars to be contained in a Plaint and that certain specified suits (including those under Section 92 CPC relating to public charities) have prescribed procedures. The court reminded that Order 7, Rule 11 permits rejection of a Plaint at any time, even without a written statement by the defendant (para 10).
- Proper scope of scrutiny at registration: The court held that verification at the time of registration should be limited to checking whether the Plaint satisfies the legal requirements set out in the CPC. The Court must ascertain fundamental compliance, but should not use registration to conduct extended merits scrutiny (para 12).
- Procedural uniformity and ministerial role: The court directed that a uniform procedure be followed — a ministerial officer should note deficiencies and the docket should contain all defects pointed out; a reasonable time should be fixed for compliance (para 13).
- Limits on successive returns: After re-presentation, the Court's re-examination should focus on whether the earlier returns were complied with rather than inventing new defects. New defects may be pointed out only in exceptional cases where an omission in the original return is shown (para 13).
- Remedial process when compliance is disputed: If the Court remains unconvinced about compliance after re-presentation, the plaintiff may request that the matter be posted for a maintainability hearing so the Court can hear the plaintiff about the defects and compliance; the Court should hear such requests at the earliest opportunity (para 13).
- Application to the present facts: The court found that while the petitioners appear to have re-presented the Plaint after rectifying earlier defects, the final return dated 12.8.2009 was unclear in stating only that previous returns were "to be correctly complied with." The court held that an order should not leave parties in darkness and must speak for itself (paras 18–19).
- Resulting direction: Because there was nothing on the face of the record indicating why the Trial Court concluded that compliance was not correct, the High Court declined to direct immediate registration. Instead, the court directed an administrative and procedural remedy: petitioners to re-present the Plaint with their remarks on the 12.8.2009 return within two weeks; the District Judge was then directed to consider and dispose of the matter on merits and in accordance with law within one week thereafter (para 21).
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The Civil Revision Petition is disposed of with directions for further procedural steps rather than an order directing immediate registration of the Plaint.
Direct consequences for the parties:
- The revision petitioners are directed to re-present the Plaint with their remarks responding to the return dated 12.8.2009 within two weeks from the receipt of a copy of the High Court's order.
- Upon receipt, the learned District Judge is directed to consider and dispose of the matter on merits and in accordance with law within one week thereafter.
- The connected miscellaneous petition is closed and the court ordered no costs.
Broader implications:
The Court reiterated and applied established principles emphasizing that (a) registration-stage scrutiny should be confined to verifying compliance with procedural prerequisites, (b) successive returns should not be used to invent defects, and (c) Courts should adopt a uniform and transparent ministerial procedure for noting defects and permitting rectification. The opinion did not purport to lay down a novel precedent beyond the application of these existing principles and cited authorities.
Prayer: Civil Revision Petition against the order dated 12.8.2009 in S.R No. 1825 of 2009 on the file of the District Court, Namakkal.
JUDGMENT
1. The plaintiffs, in a Suit filed before the District Court, Namakkal, in S.R No. 1825 of 2009, are the revision petitioners. The prayer is to direct the Lower Court to register the Plaint, instead of returning the matter time and again on the ground of non-compliance of the directions.
2. The Suit vide S.R No. 1825 of 2009 was preferred by the revision petitioners praying for framing a Scheme in respect of the first respondent trust under Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
3. The Plaint was returned on 15.4.2009 pointing out the following defects:
Return No. I
“1. Value of the suit to be furnished.
2. Court fees due for the Suit and provision of law under C.F Act to be mentioned.
3. How this Court has got jurisdiction to entertain the Suit.
4. Properties involved in the Suit if any to be furnished.
5. Short cause title to be furnished correctly.
Retd: Time one month.
Sd/.PDJ Sd/.PDJ
15.4.09 Namakkal
15.4.09”
The defects as indicated by the Court was rectified and it was re-presented on 15.4.2009 itself.
4. The Plaint was once again returned on 15.5.2009 with the following remarks:
Return No. II
“Previous return No. 4 complied with is not satisfactory.
Retd: Time one month.
15.5.09 Sd/.PDJ
Namakkal
15.5.09”
The defect pointed out on 15.5.2009 was answered by the petitioners and the plaint was again re-presented.
5. The re-presented Plaint was returned for the third time on 19.6.2009 with the following remarks:
Return No. III
“Value of the Suit to be mentioned in the Plaint and under correct provision of law under Court Fees Act and deficit Court fee if any to be paid.”
Retd: Time one month.
19.6.09 Sd/.PDJ
Namakkal
19.6.09”
The details sought for by the learned District Judge was furnished and the Plaint was accordingly re-presented.
6. The final return was on 12.8.2009 and it would read thus:
Return No. IV
“The previous returns dated 15.4.2009, 15.5.2009 and 19.6.2009 to be correctly complied with. The returns complied with should be incorporated in the Plaint itself wherever it is applicable.
Returned. Time one month.
12.8.09 Sd/.PDJ
Namakkal
12.8.09”
7. The return of Plaint successively for the fourth time made the petitioners to file the Revision Petition.
8. The learned counsel for the revision petitioners would submit that the defects as pointed out by the learned District Judge was promptly rectified and the Plaint was re-presented. However time and again the learned Judge was returning the Plaint by pointing out reasons one after another. Some of the particulars sought in the return memo were already furnished in the original Plaint itself and as such there was total non-application of mind, which alone resulted in returning the Plaint on numerous occasions. According to the learned counsel this Court has to take corrective measures to put the Subordinate Courts in order.
9. The Civil Procedure Code contains provisions regarding institution of Suits. The journey between presenting a Plaint and obtaining a decree is too long and rather difficult on account of ordained procedures. It is not easy to obtain a decree in a Civil litigation within a short span of time. Even after obtaining decree from the Court of original jurisdiction, the decree holder has to wait long for the purpose of enjoying the fruits of the decree, on account of First Appeals and Second Appeals, which would invariably be taken advantage of by the unsuccessful opponents. The decree confirmed ultimately by the Apex Court in the hierarchy would again be challenged in execution on various grounds. Even though the Executing Court was not expected to go behind the decree, the fact remains that execution of decree is resisted many a time successfully for years together.
10. The litigants would be put to difficulties in case the Court of original jurisdiction drag them from pillar to post, even before registering the Plaint. The attempt of the Court before registering the Plaint should be to ascertain as to whether the procedural requirement for filing such a Suit has been complied with by the plaintiff. The statutory provisions as contained under Order 7, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure prescribes the particulars to be contained in the Plaint. In addition to the institution of the Suit of general nature, there are Suits in particular cases like the Suit by or against the Government or public officers in their official capacity, inter-pleader Suits, Suits relating to public nuisance or other wrongful acts affecting the public at large as well as Suits relating to public charities within the meaning of Section 92 of the Civil Procedure Code. There is a prescribed procedure contemplated for institution of such specified Suits. The Court was obliged to examine as to whether the plaintiff has complied with such fundamental procedures, and in case of such compliance, the Court has no other alternative than to register the Plaint. The Court was not powerless even after registering the Plaint. The statutory provision as per Order 7, Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure enables the Court to reject the Plaint at any point of time. It is not necessary to file written statement by the defendant for the purpose of exercising the jurisdiction to reject the Plaint.
11. It would be appropriate to quote the observation of Mr. Justice V.R Krishna Iyer in T. Arivandandam v. T.V Satyapal, 1977 (4) SCC 467, with respect to the jurisdiction of the Trial Court to reject the Plaint, which reads thus:
“5. … The learned Munsif must remember that if on a meaningful - not formal - reading of the Plaint it is manifestly vexatious, and meritless, in the sense of not disclosing a clear right to sue, he should exercise his power under Order 7, Rule 11, C.P.C, taking care to see that the ground mentioned therein is fulfilled. And, if clever drafting has created the illusion of a cause of action, nip it in the bud at the first hearing by examining the party searchingly under Order 10, CPC. An activist Judge is the answer to irresponsible law Suits. The Trial Courts would insist imperatively on examining the party at the first hearing so that bogus litigation can be shot down at the earliest stage. The Penal Code is also resourceful enough to meet such men, (Cr. XI) and must be triggered against them. In this case, the learned Judge to his cost realised what George Bernard Shaw remarked on the assassination of Mahatma Gandhi:
“It is dangerous to be too good.”
6. The Trial Court in this case will remind itself of Section 35-A, C.P.C and take deterrent action if it is satisfied that the litigation was inspired by vexatious motives and altogether groundless. In any view, that Suit has no survival value and should be disposed of forthwith after giving an immediate hearing to the parties concerned.”
12. When there is an in-built procedure in the Civil Procedure Code itself to consider the maintainability of the Suit at a later point of time, the verification of the Plaint at the time of registration should only be for the purpose of ascertaining as to whether the Plaint satisfies the legal requirements as provided under the Civil Procedure Code.
13. There should be a uniform procedure in the matter of consideration of Plaint and Petitions for the purpose of registration. Whenever a Plaint is filed, it has to be verified by the Ministerial Officer of the Court entrusted with the duty to examine the Plaint. Such officer has to note down all the deficiencies in the Plaint for the purpose of compliance. The defects pointed out by the Court in its entirety should be noted in the docket and the plaintiff should be directed to rectify those defects within a reasonable time fixed by the Court. The Plaint duly re-presented after compliance should be examined again not for the purpose of inventing further defects for return, but for the purpose of ascertaining as to whether the initial returns were duly complied with. This does not mean that it was not permissible to indicate defects afresh which were not mentioned in the original return. In exceptional cases, when it was made out that a particular defect was omitted to be mentioned in the original return, the Court would be at liberty to indicate such defects subsequently. However such cases should be exceptional. In the normal circumstances, all the defects should be pointed out during the initial return itself. Even after complying with the defects pointed out earlier by way of first or second return, the Court was not convinced of the compliance reported by the plaintiff, it would be open to the plaintiff to request the Court to post the matter for maintainability, so as to enable the Court to hear the plaintiff with respect to the defects pointed out and the compliance made in respect of those defects. When a request for such hearing is made, it should be the endeavour of the Court to hear the plaintiff's counsel at the earliest point of time. It would enable both the Court as well as the counsel to understand the fundamental defects in the Plaint and the steps to taken to rectify those defects.
14. The institution of large number of Civil Suits shows the trust reposed by the litigants in our justice delivery system. In the event of delaying the matter at the entry point itself it would prompt the litigants to take steps to redress their grievance otherwise than in due process of law.
15. The difficulties normally faced by the seekers of justice was indicated by the Supreme Court in Shreenath v. Rajesh, 1998 (4) SCC 543, at page 545, thus:
“The seeker of justice many a time has to take long circuitous routes, both on account of hierarchy of Courts and the procedural law. Such persons are and can be dragged till the last ladder of the said hierarchy for receiving justice but even here he only breathes fear of receiving the fruits of that justice for which he has been aspiring to receive. The reach this stage is in itself an achievement and satisfaction as he, by then has passed through a long arduous journey of the procedural law with many hurdles replica of mountain terrain with ridges and furrows. When he is ready to take the bite of that fruit, he has to pass through the same terrain of the procedural law in the execution proceedings the morose is writ large on his face. What looked inevitable to him to receive it at his hands distance is deluded back into the horizon. The creation of the hierarchy of Courts was for a reasonable objective for conferring greater satisfaction to the parties that errors, if any, by any of the Lower Courts under the scrutiny of a higher Court be rectified and long procedural laws also with good intention to exclude and filter out all unwanted who may be the cause of obstruction to such seeker in his journey to justice. But this obviously is one of the causes of delay in justice. Of course, under this pattern the party wrongfully gaining within permissible limits also stretches the litigation as much as possible. Thus this has been the cause of anxiety and concern of various authorities, legislators and Courts. How to eliminate such a long consuming justice ? We must confess that we have still to go a long way before true satisfaction in this regard is received. Even after one reaches the stage of final decree, he has to undergo a long distance by passing through the ordained procedure in the execution proceedings before he receives the bowl of justice.
16. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in R.N Jadi & Brothers v. Subhashchandra, 2007 (4) CTC 326 (SC): 2007 (9) Scale 202, observed that the procedural law is always sub-servient and is in aid to justice. It reads thus:
“9. All the rules of procedure are the handmaid of justice. The language employed by the draftsman of processual law may be liberal or stringent, but the fact remains that the object of prescribing procedure is to advance the cause of justice. In an adversarial system, no party should ordinarily be denied the opportunity of participating in the process of justice dispensation. Unless compelled by express and specific language of the Statute, the provisions of the CPC or any other procedural enactment ought not to be construed in a manner which would leave the Court helpless to meet extraordinary situations in the ends of justice.
13. Processual law is not to be a tyrant but a servant, not an obstruction but an aid to justice. Procedural prescriptions are the handmaid and not the mistress, a lubricant, not a resistant in the administration of justice.”
17. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the revision petitioners would submit that the entire returns as communicated by orders dated 15.4.2009, 15.5.2009 and 19.6.2009 were already complied with by the revision petitioners and as such, the learned Trial Judge was not justified in returning the Plaint again on 12.8.2009
18. The petitioners appear to have re-presented the Plaint after rectifying the defects pointed out by the learned District Judge as per order dated 15.4.2009, 15.5.2009 and 19.6.1009
19. I have gone through the last return dated 12.8.2009 It was not clear from the said return as to what was meant by “to be correctly complied with”. The Court was not expected to put the parties in darkness. The order should speak for itself.
20. The learned counsel for the petitioners by placing reliance on the compliance report submitted that all the defects were rectified and as such the return made on 12.8.2009 was unwarranted and accordingly prayed for a direction to the learned District Judge to register the Plaint forthwith. However, I am of the view that the Trial Court should be directed to consider the matter on merits as there was nothing to indicate as to why the Court has come to the conclusion that the compliance was not correct.
21. Accordingly, the revision petitioners are directed to re-present the Plaint with their remarks in respect of the return dated 12.8.2009 within two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and on such receipt, the learned District Judge is directed to consider and dispose of the matter on merits and as per law within one week thereafter.
22. The Civil Revision Petition is disposed of with the above direction. Consequently the connected M.P is closed. No costs.
Alert