- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramasamy Gounder v. Lakshmi & Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondents (decree-holders) obtained a decree in O.S. No. 376 of 1983 for recovery of Rs. 25,365 with future interest and costs. They filed an execution petition (E.P. No. 80 of 1985) seeking attachment of the petition-mentioned property under Order 21, Rule 54, C.P.C., and sale after sale proclamation under Order 21, Rule 66, C.P.C., for recovery of Rs. 29,730.15. The judgment-debtor (revision petitioner) resisted the execution petition, alleging that the decree-holders had undervalued the property (they valued it at Rs. 35,000) whereas the property was irrigated canal land and worth much more; the Amin fixed the value at Rs. 3 lakhs. The Subordinate Judge fixed the upset price at Rs. 3 lakhs and directed that the property be proclaimed and sold (sale date noted as 17-9-1987), after recording the values given by the decree-holders, the Amin and the judgment-debtor. The judgment-debtor filed this revision against that order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in execution under Order 21, Rule 64, C.P.C., the court should order sale of the entire undivided share brought to sale or only such portion of the property as is necessary to satisfy the decree.
- Whether acceptance of a low valuation by the decree-holder in the sale proclamation (and the court's acceptance thereof) can vitiate the sale and require interference with the court's order fixing the upset price and ordering sale.
- Whether the court is obliged, under the relevant provisions, to fix its own valuation for the sale proclamation when values are supplied by the decree-holder, the judgment-debtor and the Amin.
Arguments of the Parties
Revision Petitioner (Judgment-debtor)
- The property (even at the upset price fixed at Rs. 3 lakhs by the court below) should not be entirely sold for recovery of Rs. 29,730.15; instead, only such portion as would satisfy the decree should be sold, as contemplated by Order 21, Rule 64, C.P.C.
- The court ought not to direct sale of the undivided half (2.5 acres) of the property; a smaller portion sufficient to meet the debt could be sold.
- The low value given by the decree-holder (Rs. 35,000) will create confusion among prospective purchasers regarding the true value of the property and cause loss to the judgment-debtor.
Respondents (Decree-holders)
- The revision petitioner's objections were not properly raised before the executing court and the only real objection relates to the value to be notified.
- The court below correctly noted the values given by the decree-holders, the judgment-debtor and the Amin, and correctly fixed the upset price at Rs. 3 lakhs as estimated by the Amin; no interference with that order was called for.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Takkaseela Pedda Subba Reddi v. Pujari Padmavathamm a and others | Where the amount specified in the proclamation of sale is realised by sale of certain items, sale of further items should be stopped; the words “necessary to satisfy the decree” indicate that where a sale fetches a price sufficient to satisfy the decree no further sale should be held; non-compliance with O.21, R.64 can vitiate the sale. | The court relied on this authority to support the proposition that the executing court should limit the sale to the portion necessary to satisfy the decree and, applying that principle, directed that only a 1/4th share of the property be proclaimed and sold instead of the undivided half. |
| Jyotish Chandra v. Parbati Bala | Acceptance of a grossly low value by the court (value many times less than real value) can amount to fraud on the court or carelessness by the court and render the sale liable to be set aside (headnote concerning O.21 R.66 and sale proclamation). | The court treated this case as authority for the proposition that a sale can be vitiated where the court accepted an inadequately low valuation; however, it distinguished the present case because the proclamation here contained values from the judgment-debtor, the decree-holder and the Amin. |
| Sisir Kumar Mukherjee and others v. Kanayaal Jhewar and others | Similar effect as Jyotish Chandra — acceptance of grossly inadequate valuation and carelessness of court can set aside sale. | Referred to as supporting authority for the proposition that acceptance of grossly inadequate valuation may vitiate a sale; not treated as directly applicable because multiple valuations were recorded in the present proclamation. |
| Nagendra Iyer v. Varadaraja | Where proclamation contained only the valuation given by the decree-holder and that valuation was grossly inadequate, an intention to conceal true valuation can be inferred and the sale may be vitiated. | Used as an example of a case where sale was set aside for inadequate proclamation valuation; the court distinguished that situation from the present facts where values of decree-holder, judgment-debtor and Amin were all mentioned. |
| Srinivasan v. Andhra Bank Ltd. | Where the proclamation contained the value of the property as stated by the decree-holder and the judgment-debtor, there was no duty on the court under clause (e) of O.21, R.66(2), C.P.C. to fix its own valuation and insert it in the proclamation of sale. | The court relied on this authority to support the view that the presence of values from the parties in the proclamation does not impose upon the court a duty to fix an independent valuation; this distinction weighed against the revision petitioner’s contention that the low valuation alone required setting aside the order. |
| Gurusami Nadar v. Prabakaran (unreported) | After considering decisions, relying on Takkaseela Pedda Subba Reddi, the lower court is not correct in ordering the entire property for sale where sale of a fraction would suffice under O.21, R.64, C.P.C. | The court cited this unreported decision to support the practical conclusion that the executing court could order sale of a fraction of the property (rather than the entire share) where a fraction would be sufficient to realise the decretal amount. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began from Order 21, Rule 64, C.P.C., which allows the executing court, after notice, to order sale of such portion of attached property as may seem necessary to satisfy the decree. It reviewed authorities (notably Takkaseela Pedda Subba Reddi) establishing that once the amount specified in the sale proclamation is realised by sale of certain items, further sale should be stopped; non-compliance with O.21, R.64 goes to jurisdiction and can vitiate a sale.
The court also considered decisions where sales were set aside because the court accepted grossly inadequate valuations given by decree-holders (Jyotish Chandra; Sisir Kumar Mukherjee; Nagendra Iyer). Those cases were distinguished on the facts: in the present matter the sale proclamation would note the valuations given by the decree-holders, the Amin and the judgment-debtor. The court relied on Srinivasan v. Andhra Bank Ltd. for the proposition that where values of the decree-holder and judgment-debtor are recorded, the court is not obliged to fix an independent valuation under clause (e) of O.21, R.66(2).
Applying these principles to the facts — the decretal amount to be realised being Rs. 29,730.15 and the Amin's estimate of the undivided half-share at Rs. 3 lakhs — the court concluded that the entire undivided half need not be put up for sale. The court also noted a practical marketability concern: selling a very small fraction (for example 1/8th) of an undivided share might deter purchasers. Balancing the statutory scheme (sale of so much as necessary) with market realities, the court directed that an undivided 1/4th share of the petition-mentioned property (which the court described as being the half-share of the judgment-debtor in proportionate terms) be proclaimed and sold, with values in the proclamation to reflect the proportions noted by the Amin, the decree-holder and the judgment-debtor.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The revision is partly allowed. The court directed that the court below be ordered to proclaim and sell an undivided 1/4th share of the petition-mentioned property instead of the undivided half previously ordered for sale, after noting the proportionate values given by the Amin, the decree-holder and the judgment-debtor in the sale proclamation.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: only an undivided 1/4th share (i.e., half of the judgment-debtor's half-share) is to be proclaimed and sold initially. If sale of that 1/4th share does not fetch the price necessary to satisfy the decree, the decree-holder is permitted to bring the remaining 1/4th share to sale subsequently by appropriate application to the executing court.
- The court imposed no order as to costs.
- The decision applies established principles (as reflected in cited authorities) about limiting sales to what is necessary to satisfy the decree and distinguishing situations where a low valuation accepted by the court may vitiate the sale; the opinion did not purport to create a new legal principle beyond the application of those precedents to the facts of the case.
1. This revision is directed by the judgment-debtor against the order passed by the Sub-Judge, Erode, in E.P No. 80 of 1985.
2. The facts which are necessary for the disposal of this revision are as follows. The respondents-decree-holders obtained a decree in O.S. 376 of 1983 for recovery of a sum of Rs. 25,365 with future interest and cost. They filed the petition for execution in E.P. 80 of 1985 for attachment of the petition mentioned property under Order 21, rule 54, C.P.C, and also for sale of the property after sale proclamation under Order 21, rule 66, C.P.C. for recovery of Rs. 29,730-15. The said application was resisted by the revision petitioner (Judgment-debtor) and in the counter it is stated that the decree holders have valued the property at Rs. 35,000, which is quite low as the property is irrigated by kalingarayan channel and that the property is worth about Rs. 5 lakhs. The Amin fixed the value of the property at Rs. 3 lakhs while effecting attachment of the property. The under-valuation by the respondents herein is improper and contrary to the existing market value which would cause irreparable loss and hardship to the revision petitioner if accepted by the Court.
3. The Subordinate Judge passed an order to the effect that the upset price of the property attached on 27.4.1985 is fixed at Rs. 3 lakhsand the property was directed to be proclaimed and sold on 17-9-1987 after noting the value of the decree holders, the amin and the judgment debtor in the sale proclamation. Aggrieved by the same, this revision is filed.
4. The learned counsed for the revision' petitioner, Mr. Masilamani, submitted that the entire property even as per the upset price fixed by the Court below is worth Rs. 3 lakhs, on the basis of the amin's report, that the entire property should not be sold for recovery of Rs. 29,730-15, and instead the court ought to have ordered sale of thatt portion of the property which would be sufficient to satisfy the decree debt as contemplated under Order 21, Rule 64, C.P.C. According to the learned counsel, instead of selling the undivided half of the petition mentioned property which comes to Rs. 1.12.5 hectres (2-1/2 acres) a portion of the property which would be sufficient to satisfy the decree debt could be sold. Further, by noting the low value given by the decree holder it will create confusion in the minds of the prospective purchasers regarding the real and correct value of the property. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent, Mr. A.K Kumaraswami, submitted that the revision petitioner has not put forth the real contentions in his counter and the only objection raised is about the value of the property to be notified and in the instant case, the court below rightly directed to note the value given by the decree holders, the judgment debtor as well as the amin and fixed the upset price at Rs. 3 lakhs, which was estimated by the amin and as such no intereference is called for.
5. The learned counsel for the revision petitioner, Mr. Masilamani, invited my attention to various decisions in support of his contentions and also relevant provision of O. 21, R. 64, C.P.C. O. 21, R. 64, C.P.C. is to the effect that any court executing a decree may after notice to the decree holder and judgment debtor, order that any property attached by it and liable to sale or such portion thereof as may seem necessary to satisfy the decree, shall be sold and that the proceeds of such sale, or a sufficient portion thereof, shall be paid to the party entitled under the decree to receive the same. In Takkaseela Pedda Subba Reddi v. Pujari Padmavathamm a and others 1 it was held—
“It is manifest that where the amount specified in the proclamation of sale for the recovery of which the sale was ordered is realised by sale of certain items, the sale of further items should be stopped. This, in our opinion, is the logical corollary which flows from O. 21, R. 64 of the Code.”
Later, in the course of the judgment, it was observed—
“The words ‘necessary to satisfy the decree’ hardly indicate that no sale can be allowed beyond the decretal amount mentioned in the sale proclamation. In other words, where the sale fetches a price equal to or higher than the amount mentioned in the sale proclamation and is sufficient to satisfy the decree, no further sale should be held and the Court should stop at that stage.”
Again it was observed:—
“The fact that the judgment debtor did not raise an objection on this ground before the executing court is not sufficient to put him out of court because this was a matter which went to the very root of the jurisdiction of the executing Court to sell the properties and the non-compliance of the provisions of O. 21, R. 64, of the Code was sufficient to vitiate the same.”
6. In Jyotish Chandra v. Parbati Bala 2, it has been held:
“C.P.C. (1938) O. 21 R. 66 (Calcutta), 90—Sale proclamation—Value of property—fraud on Court —Court's carelessness in accepting low value—Real value more than 10 times the value put on sale proclamation by decree holder—Court accepting low value without verification—Sale in execution—can be set aside on grounds of fraud by decree-holder on court and also carelessness of court in approving sale proclamation”.(Headnote)
That was a case where it was found out that the real value of the property was more than ten times the value given by the decree holder and the Court accepted the value given by the decree holder and proceeded with the same. In the circumstances it was held that the sale was liable to be set aside on the ground of fraud on the part of the decree holder on court and also carelessness of court. In the same effect, it was held in the earlier decision in Sisir Kumar Mukherjee and others v. Kanayaal Jhewar and others 1. In Nagendra Iyer v. Varadaraja 2, it was held that since the proclamation contained only the valuation given by the decree holder and the said valuation is grossly inadequate, that there was a clear intention on the part of the decree holder to conceal from bidders the true valuation and dissuade them from bidding could be inferred.” Consequently it was held in that case, that the sale was liable to be set aside as vitiated. But, that is not the case here. In the instant case, the valuation of the judgment debtor, the decree-holder an d the value given by the amin were mentioned. Even in that case, the judgment of Govinda Menon, J. in Srinivasan v. Andhra Bank Ltd. 3, was relied on, wherein it was held that ‘where the proclamation contained the value of the property as stated by the decree-holder and the judgment debtor, there was no duty cast on this Court by the clause (e) of O. 21, R. 66(2), C.P.C. to fix its own valuation and to insert it in the proclamation of sale”. Thus, the said judgment does not help the case of the revision petitioner with regard to the contention that the decree-holder has given a grossly inadequate valuation and that on that ground alon e the order of the court below is to be set aside. My attention was drawn to the unreported decision rendered by Sengottuvelan, J. in Gurusami Nadar v. Prabakaran 4 , where the learned Judge considered all the decisions and finally relying on the decision of the Supreme Court in Takkaseela Pedda Subba Reddi v. Pujari Padmavathamma and others 5, held that the lower court is not correct in ordering the entire property mentioned in the execution petition for sale even though the sale of a fraction of the property is sufficient to realise the decree amount, in view of O. 21, R. 64, C.P.C. Even in that case, the learned Judge did not accept the contention that the judgment debtor was put to loss on account of the low valuation given by the decree-holder in the sale proclamation. Applying the ratio laid down in the above decisions to the facts of the case, since the amount to be realised by way of execution is only Rs. 29,730.15, and the value of the undivided half share of the judgment-debtor which is now brought to sale, is estimated at Rs. 3 lakhs on the basis of the amin's report, I am of the view that the entire half share of the judgment debtor need not be put up for sale. Since it is an undivided share, there may not be any purchaser if the sale of 1/8th share is ordered as contended by the learned counsel for the revision petitioner, Mr. Masilamani. In the circumstances of the case, I feel that the court below can be directed to proclaim and sell in respect of 1/4th share of the petition mentioned property, i.e., half share of the judgment debtor in the said property and the valuation can be modified to the effect and the sale proclamation can be issued only in respect of undivided 1/4th share of the petition mentioned property instead of undivided half share.
7. In the result the revision is partly allowed and the court below is directed to order, proclaim and sell in respect of 1/4th share of the petition mentioned property instead of undivided half, after noting the proportionate value given by the Amin, the decree holder and the judgment debtor in the said proclamation. However, if the undivided 1/4th share does not fetch the price to satisfy the decree amount, the decree holder is at liberty to bring the remaining 1/4th share also subsequently by making necessary application to the executing court. In the circumstances of the case, there will be no order as to costs.
Alert