Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

K. Prakash v. The Registrar General, High Court Of Karnataka, Bangalore

Karnataka High Court
Jan 16, 2007
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a law graduate of Bangalore University who obtained 52% aggregate marks in the LL.B. examination, filed a writ petition seeking a direction to the Registrar General of the High Court of Karnataka to allow him to participate in the recruitment selection for the post of Second Division Assistant pursuant to the High Court's notification dated 21-3-2006 (Annexure-A).

Annexure-A invited applications for 50 posts of Second Division Assistants and specified that selection would be made in accordance with the High Court of Karnataka Service (Conditions of Service and Recruitment) Rules, 1973 and the High Court of Karnataka Service (Direct Recruitment by Selection) Rules, 1984, as amended. The rules set the minimum qualifying aggregate at 55% for General category candidates and 45% for SC/ST candidates. The petitioner, having only 52%, was not called for interview and challenged this exclusion by filing the writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner, having 52% aggregate marks, was entitled to be called for interview despite the Rules prescribing a minimum of 55% for General category candidates.
  2. Whether the prescription of a higher minimum qualification (55%) for the High Court's Second Division Assistant post — where the pay-scale is similar to the State Government's Second Division Assistant post with a lower educational requirement (S.S.L.C.) — is arbitrary or illegal.
  3. Whether the rules' uniform percentage requirement for three-year and five-year law degrees is arbitrary, and whether marks for a five-year degree should be adjusted (doubled) because a five-year course involves more subjects than a three-year course.
  4. Whether conducting selection based solely on viva voce (interview) without a written test is arbitrary or illegal.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that it was arbitrary and illegal for the High Court to prescribe a minimum qualification of 55% for Second Division Assistant when the State Government's Second Division Assistant post (with the same pay-scale) required only S.S.L.C.
  • The petitioner argued that the rules apply the same percentage requirement to both three-year and five-year law degrees; because a five-year LL.B. involves more subjects (33) compared to the three-year course (18), the percentage for five-year degree graduates should be adjusted (the petitioner suggested it should be doubled), which would raise his effective aggregate to 80%.
  • The petitioner asserted that selection based solely on viva voce (without a written test) was arbitrary and illegal.

Respondent's Position (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The selection process and the minimum qualification requirement were governed by the High Court of Karnataka Service (Conditions of Service and Recruitment) Rules, 1973, and the High Court of Karnataka Service (Direct Recruitment by Selection) Rules, 1984, as framed under Article 229 of the Constitution; the petitioner did not dispute that the selection was being conducted in accordance with those rules.
  • Because the petitioner did not meet the minimum qualifying marks (55% for General category), he was not eligible to be called for interview under the Rules and therefore was not called for interview.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by reference to the constitutional and statutory framework expressly relied upon in the notification and by the High Court:

  • The Court noted Article 229(1) and (2) of the Constitution of India as the source of power under which the Chief Justice, with the Governor's approval, framed the High Court of Karnataka Service (Conditions of Service and Recruitment) Rules, 1973, and the High Court of Karnataka Service (Direct Recruitment by Selection) Rules, 1984.
  • The Court set out the operative provisions of the Rules: Rule 7 of the 1973 Rules (method of recruitment) and the 1984 Rules (Rules 4, 5, 6 and 7) which provide that:
    • Recruitment is by selection where direct recruitment is by interview (viva voce).
    • For shortlisting to interview, the Selecting Authority prepares a merit list based on percentage of marks in the qualifying examination and calls in order of merit up to five times the number of vacancies for interview.
    • Interview marks (maximum 50) determine final selection; applications not meeting requirements are to be rejected and reasons given.
  • The Court observed that Annexure-A expressly stated selection would follow the 1973 and 1984 Rules, and the petitioner did not allege any violation of those Rules by the respondent. Instead, the petitioner sought to be treated contrary to the express minimum qualification prescribed by the Rules.
  • Addressing the petitioner's three substantive contentions, the Court held:
    • On parity of pay-scales: Equality of pay-scale between High Court and State Government Second Division Assistants does not compel identical minimum qualifications. The Chief Justice is competent to prescribe a higher qualification for High Court posts in view of differences in duties and functions; therefore the higher qualification is not arbitrary or discriminatory (as alleged by the petitioner).
    • On adjustment of marks for five-year degrees: The suggestion that marks for five-year degree holders should be doubled because they study more subjects was rejected as misconceived. The relevant criterion is the percentage of marks obtained in the qualifying examination; there is no provision or basis for doubling or altering percentage marks based on course length or number of subjects.
    • On selection by viva voce without written tests: The Court explained the selection process under the Rules — only candidates meeting the minimum qualification may apply; only those who are shortlisted on merit (based on qualifying exam percentage) up to five times the vacancies are called for interview; final selection is from among those interviewees based on interview performance. Given that the qualifying-exam marks are used to shortlist and interview performance to make final selection, the process is not arbitrary. There is no rule that every selection must include a written test or that written-test marks must always be taken into account.
  • Because the petitioner neither challenged the validity of the Rules nor the Annexure-A notification, and because the selection process followed the Rules, the Court found no basis for judicial interference with the selection process.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED.

The Court dismissed the writ petition. The direct effect is that the petitioner will not be called for interview and the recruitment process will proceed in accordance with the High Court of Karnataka Service (Conditions of Service and Recruitment) Rules, 1973 and the High Court of Karnataka Service (Direct Recruitment by Selection) Rules, 1984. The opinion states that the petitioner's three contentions lack merit and affirms the competence of the Chief Justice to prescribe differing qualifications for High Court posts. The opinion does not purport to lay down any novel precedent beyond application and affirmation of the existing Rules and Article 229 framework; no broader legal principle or new precedent was announced in the text of this judgment.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

Cyriac Joseph, C.J (Oral):— The petitioner is a law graduate from the Bangalore University. He has filed this writ petition praying for a direction to the respondent-Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka to allow him to participate in the selection process for the post of Second Division Assistant in the High Court as per notification dated 21-3-2006 (Annexure-A).

2. The High Court of Karnataka issued Annexure-A notification dated 21-3-2006 inviting applications from qualified candidates for recruitment to 50 posts of Second Division Assistants.

3. As per the notification, selection of candidates will be made in accordance with the High Court of Karnataka Service (Conditions of Service and Recruitment) Rules, 1973 and the High Court of Karnataka Service (Direct Recruitment by Selection) Rules, 1984 as amended from time to time. The minimum qualification for the post is a degree of a recognised University with a minimum of 45 per cent marks in the aggregate for candidates belonging to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and a minimum of 55 per cent marks in aggregate for other candidates. Admittedly the petitioner has got only 52 per cent marks in the qualifying examination i.e, LL.B examination. However, the petitioner submitted his application pursuant to Annexure-A notification. As the petitioner does not possess the minimum qualification, he has not been called for interview. It is in such circumstances that the petitioner filed this writ petition.

4. According to the petitioner, the pay-scale of Second Division Assistant in the High Court and the pay-scale of the Second Division Assistant in the State Government service are the same, but the minimum qualification for the post of Second Division Assistant in the High Court is a degree of a recognised University with a minimum of 55 per cent marks in aggregate for General candidates, whereas, the minimum qualification for the post of Second Division Assistant in the State Government service is only S.S.L.C It is contended that the prescription of such higher qualification for the post of Second Division Assistant in the High Court is arbitrary and illegal. Another contention raised by the petitioner is that the rules prescribe same minimum percentage of marks for the three years degree course and the five years degree course. According to the petitioner, the number of subjects prescribed for three years is 18 subjects and the number of subjects for five years is 33 subjects. Obviously the petitioner might be referring to LL.B Course. The contention is that since a student undergoing the five years course has to study 33 subjects and a student undergoing three years course has to study only 18 subjects, the percentage of marks obtained by the student undergoing five years course must be taken as the double of the actual percentage he obtained. It is contended that in that event, the aggregate marks of the petitioner would be 80 per cent. The third contention of the petitioner is that the selection is based on viva voce without conducting any written test and therefore, the method of selection is arbitrary and illegal.

5. According to clause (1) of Article 229 of the Constitution of India, appointments of officers and servants of a High Court shall be made by the Chief Justice of the Court or such other Judge or officer of the Court as he may direct: Provided that the Governor of the State may by rule require that in such cases as may be specified in the rule, no person not already attached to the Court shall be appointed to any office connected with the Court save after consultation with the State Public Service Commission. As per clause (2) of Article 229, subject to the provisions of any law made by the Legislature of the State, the conditions of service of officers and servants of a High Court shall be such as may be prescribed by rules made by the Chief Justice of the Court or by some other Judge or officer of the Court authorised by the Chief Justice to make rules for the purpose: Provided that the rules made under this clause shall, so far as they relate to salaries, allowances, leave or pensions, require the approval of the Governor of the State. In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 229(1) and (2) of the Constitution, the Chief Justice of the High Court of Karnataka, with the approval of the Governor of Karnataka, made the High Court of Karnataka Service (Conditions of Service and Recruitment) Rules, 1973. According to Rule 7 of the said rules, recruitment to a post or class of posts shall be made by the Chief Justice as enumerated in Schedule III to the Rules. As per Serial Number 19 of Schedule III, the method of recruitment of Second Division Assistants is 50 per cent by direct recruitment and 50 per cent by promotion. Direct recruitment shall be by selection after calling for application and interviewing the applicants. The minimum qualification for direct recruitment shall be a degree of a recognised University with a minimum of 55 per cent marks in the aggregate for candidates belonging to General category and a minimum of 45 per cent marks in the aggregate for candidates belonging to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. In exercise of the power conferred by Article 229(1) and (2) of the Constitution of India read with Rule 7 of the High Court of Karnataka Service (Conditions of Service and Recruitment) Rules, 1973, the Chief Justice of Karnataka made the High Court of Karnataka Service (Direct Recruitment by Selection) Rules, 1984. According to Rule 4 of the said Rules, recruitment under the Rules shall be made on the basis of the marks secured at the interview under Rule 6. According to Rule 5, for purpose of selection of candidates for interview, the Selecting Authority shall prepare a list of names of candidates on the basis of the percentage of total marks secured in the qualifying examination in the order of merit, and if two or more candidates have secured equal percentage of total marks in the qualifying examination, the order of merit in respect of such candidates shall be fixed on the basis of their age, the person or persons older in age being placed higher in the order of merit. From among the candidates whose names are included in such list, as far as may be such number of candidates as is equal to five times the number of vacancies notified, selected in the order of the merit, shall be called for the interview. According to Rule 6 the Selecting Authority shall interview the eligible candidates selected under Rule 5 and award marks on the basis of their performance in the interview. The maximum marks for interview shall be fifty. The object of such interview is to assess the suitability of the candidates for appointment to the cadre or post applied for by them and their calibre including intellectual and social traits of personality. According to sub-rule (2) of Rule 6, the applications which do not fulfill the requirements shall be rejected. The concerned applicant shall be informed of the reasons for the rejection. According to Rule 7 the Selecting Authority shall on the basis of the marks secured at the interview under Rule 6 and taking into consideration the orders in force relating to reservation of posts for SCs, STs, prepare in the order of merit a list of candidates eligible for appointment to the cadre or posts and if the marks secured at the interview under Rule 6 of two or more candidates are equal, the order of merit in respect of such candidates shall be fixed in accordance with Rule 5. The number of candidates to be included in such list shall be equal to the number of vacancies notified.

6. Annexure-A notification specifically stated that the selection of candidates will be made in accordance with the High Court of Karnataka Service (Conditions of Service and Recruitment) Rules, 1973 and the High Court of Karnataka Service (Direct Recruitment by Selection) Rules, 1984 as amended from time to time. The petitioner has no case that the selection is being made in violation of any provision contained in the said Rules. On the contrary, the petitioner who does not possess the minimum qualification prescribed under the Rules wants to be called for interview in violation of the Rules. So long as the above mentioned Rules are in force, the respondent is bound to make the selection and appointment in accordance with the said Rules. Since the petitioner has no case that the selection is being made in violation of the Rules, no interference by this Court with the selection process is called for.

7. Even though the petitioner is aggrieved by the method of selection conducted by the respondent as per the rules, he has not challenged the validity of the rules. In the absence of any challenge against the rules and Annexure-A notification, the petitioner is not entitled to maintain this writ petition and to contend that the selection being made in accordance with the Rules is illegal or arbitrary. Therefore, the writ petition is a liable to be dismissed. Even otherwise, there is no merit in the three contentions raised by the petitioner. Merely because the pay-scales of the Second Division Assistant in the High Court and the Second Division Assistant in the State Government service are the same, the minimum qualifications for the said posts need not be the same. The Chief Justice of the High Court of Karnataka is competent to prescribe a higher qualification for the post of Second Division Assistant in the High Court, taking into account the difference in the nature of duties and functions of the Second Division Assistant in the High Court when compared to the functions and duties of the Second Division Assistant in any department of the State Government. The prescription of a different qualification for the post of Second Division Assistant in the High Court is not arbitrary or discriminatory. The second contention of the petitioner that the percentage of marks obtained by the students who have taken law degree after undergoing five years course must be doubled as they have studied 33 subjects as against 18 subjects of the three years LL.B course, to say the least, is totally misconceived. Irrespective of the number of years of course and the subjects studied, the relevant consideration is the percentage of marks obtained in the qualifying examination. There is no question of doubling or changing the percentage of marks on the basis of the number of subjects studied in the course. The third contention that the selection based solely on viva voce is illegal, also is devoid of merit. First of all, anybody cannot apply for the post. Only candidates who possess the minimum qualification prescribed under the Rules can apply. Secondly, all those who apply are not invited for the interview. From among the candidates whose names are included in the list of candidates prepared on the basis of percentage of total marks secured in the qualifying examination in the order of merit, as far as may be, such number of candidates equal to five times the number of vacancies notified, selected in the order of merit are called for the interview. In other words, since the number of posts notified is 50, only 250 candidates who are ranked higher in the above mentioned list are called for interview. From among the said 250 candidates, candidates are selected for appointment on the basis of the interview. Thus the marks obtained in the qualifying examination from the basis for short listing the candidates for interview and from the short listed candidates, selection is made on the basis of the performance in the interview. There is nothing illegal or arbitrary about it. There is no law that in every case there will be a written test for selection and the marks obtained in the written test should be taken into account. In the light of the discussion above, we hold that there is no merit in the writ petition.

8. The writ petition is dismissed.