Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

A.C Subba Reddy v. Jawahar Internationa...

Madras High Court
Apr 4, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant/plaintiff filed a suit seeking specific performance of an agreement for sale dated 5.3.2004, as amended by a supplemental agreement dated 25.2.2005, requiring the defendants to execute and register sale deed(s) for the suit property upon payment of the balance sale consideration of Rs. 5.35 lakhs. Alternatively, the plaintiff sought refund of the advance amount with interest. The suit also included prayers for permanent injunctions restraining the defendants from interfering with possession or alienating the suit property. The learned Single Judge, in Application No. 4032 of 2006 in Appeal No. 2222 of 2006 (C.S No. 508 of 2006), revoked the leave granted under Clause 12 of Letters Patent, holding that the suit was essentially for land located outside Chennai, thus outside the Court's jurisdiction. The appellant filed this Original Second Appeal (O.S.A) challenging that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit filed by the appellant is maintainable before this Court, given the nature of the reliefs sought and the location of the suit property outside Chennai.
  2. Whether the prayer for permanent injunction restraining interference with possession amounts to control of the suit property, thereby classifying the suit as one for land and affecting jurisdiction.
  3. Whether the appellant can modify the prayers in the suit to exclude the injunction restraining interference with possession to maintain the suit before this Court.
  4. Whether the interim injunction relief can continue in view of the alleged transfer of the property by the defendants to a third party by registered sale deed.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The suit is primarily for specific performance of an agreement for sale and ancillary reliefs, not for possession or title.
  • The prayer for permanent injunction restraining interference with possession (prayer “b”) is ancillary and does not affect title or possession.
  • The appellant is willing to give up the prayer for permanent injunction restraining interference with possession to maintain the suit before the Court.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The learned Single Judge correctly held that the suit is essentially for land situated outside Chennai and hence the Court lacks jurisdiction.
  • The property has already been transferred by registered sale deed to a third party (S.B. Geetha) on 30.6.2006.
  • In view of the transfer, the interim injunction relief sought by the appellant cannot be continued and should be rejected.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the nature of the reliefs sought in the suit, particularly focusing on prayers “a” and “c” which relate to specific performance and injunction against alienation or dealing with the property. It noted that these prayers do not concern title or possession directly. However, the learned Single Judge treated the prayer “b” for permanent injunction restraining interference with possession as amounting to control over the property, thereby classifying the suit as one for land and outside the Court's jurisdiction due to the property's location.

The Court permitted the appellant to delete the prayer “b” for permanent injunction restraining interference with possession, accepting that this would remove the jurisdictional obstacle. Consequently, the Court set aside the learned Single Judge's order revoking leave under Clause 12 of Letters Patent.

Regarding the interim injunction, the Court noted the respondents' contention that the property had already been transferred by registered sale deed to a third party, S.B. Geetha, on 30.6.2006. On this basis, the Court rejected the prayer for continuation of the interim injunction relief.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF.

The Court allowed the appellant to delete the permanent injunction prayer restraining interference with possession, thereby maintaining the suit for specific performance and ancillary injunctions relating to alienation or dealing with the property. The order of the learned Single Judge revoking leave was set aside. The interim injunction was refused due to the subsequent registered sale of the property to a third party. No costs were imposed, and connected miscellaneous petitions were closed. This decision affects the parties directly by permitting the suit to proceed before this Court after modification of the reliefs but does not establish any new precedent.

Show all summary ...

1. Admit. Learned counsel for respondents 2 to 5 waives service. By consent, the Appeal is taken up for hearing.

2. This O.S.A is directed against the order dated 5.1.2007 passed by the learned Single Judge in Application No. 4032 of 2006 in A. No. 2222 of 2006 in C.S No. 508 of 2006 revoking the leave granted under Clause 12 of Letters Patent.

3. The Suit has been filed by the appellant/plaintiff for the following reliefs:

(a) directing the defendants 1 to 5 specifically perform their part of the obligations of the agreement for sale dated 5.3.2004 as merged in supplemental agreement dated 25.2.2005 by executing and registering sale deed or deeds in respect of the suit property and register the name on receipt of the balance sale consideration of Rs. 5.35 lakhs on a date to be fixed by this Hon'ble Court and in default direct the Court to execute and register the deed or deeds of sale in respect of the Plaint schedule property in favour of the plaintiff at the expense of the plaintiff on deposit of the balance sale consideration payable by him to the credit of the Suit or in the alternative direct the refund of the advance amount of Rs. 5,35,000/- paid by the plaintiff with interest at 24% per annum from the date of payment till the date of realization;

(b) For a permanent injunction restraining the defendants 1 to 6 or their men, agents, servants or any person or claim through them or authorized by them from interfering with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the property, more fully described in the schedule hereunder;

(c) For a permanent injunction restraining the defendants 1 to 6 or any other person or persons claiming through them from alienating or encumbering dealing with the suit schedule mentioned property either by way of sale, mortgage, joint development lease or in any other manner detrimental to the interest of the plaintiff except in accordance with law.”

4. If we look at the prayer “a” and “c” alone, it is clear that principally the Suit is for specific performance of the agreement and even the ancillary relief of permanent injunction is also for restraining defendants from alienating or dealing with the suit property in any way. Prayers “a” and “c” are not for title or possession and the injunction relief sought for also does not affect the title or possession.

5. The learned Single Judge has, however, held that the prayer for ‘b’ permanent injunction would amount to control of the suit property and therefore the Suit must be regarded as a Suit for land and since the property is situated outside Chennai, this Court has no jurisdiction to try the Suit.

6. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant wants to give up the prayer for permanent injunction in terms of prayer “b”. We do not see any reason why such a prayer should not be granted and accordingly plaintiff is permitted to delete prayer “b”. Consequently, the order of the learned Single Judge is set aside.

7. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents states that the property has already been transferred on 30.6.2006 to one S.B Geetha by a registered sale deed. In view of the transfer, the prayer for continuance of interim relief of injunction cannot be granted and the same is rejected.

8. O.S.A stands disposed of. No costs. Consequently, connected Miscellaneous Petitions are closed.