- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
V. Gurunathan v. The Assistant Commissioner Of Urban Land Tax And Ceiling Others
Concise Analytical Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner filed a Writ Petition under Article 226 seeking a writ of certiorari and mandamus to call for and quash several orders and notices issued in proceedings R.C.7794/88-B:
- Order dated 12.07.1990 under Section 9(5) declaring 1,400 Sq.Mts. in Survey No.192 of Pozhichalur village as excess vacant land.
- Notice dated 11.03.1993 (Form VII) requiring the land owner to deliver vacant possession to the Tahsildar, Saidapet (certified copies dated 16.11.2003).
- Notice dated 20.09.2003 in Form XII (referenced as Form XIV in one place) under Section 12(7) directing the land owner to attend enquiry for claiming compensation.
The land at issue measured 72 cents (2,900 Sq.Mts.) and had been used to locate and run a blue metal industry ("Sri Vinayaga Agencies"), leased to an operator. The petitioner had filed returns after commencement of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978 and sought exemption under Section 21(1)(a). While the exemption application was pending, the authorities issued notices under the 1978 Act, initially calculating an excess of 900 Sq.Mts. and allowing 2,000 Sq.Mts. as entitlement. An ex parte order dated 19.08.1989 was set aside on appeal and the matter remanded; a revised order dated 12.07.1990 declared 1,400 Sq.Mts. as excess after recalculating family entitlement (1,500 Sq.Mts.).
The petitioner contended that subsequent notices were sent to a wrong address and that no notice under Section 11(6) was issued to the person in occupation; the petitioner further asserted that actual possession was not taken by the authorities and no compensation had been paid. The petitioner made representations to the State Government (including letters dated 26.04.1994 and 20.04.1999); one request was rejected by Government letter dated 16.10.1998 and another remained pending. The Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978 was repealed by the Repeal Act (Act 20 of 1999) effective 16.06.1999; the petitioner relied on the Repeal Act (Section 4 and Section 3(2)) to contend that all pending acquisition proceedings abated.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether acquisition proceedings initiated under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978 abated on the coming into force of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act (Act 20 of 1999) on 16.06.1999.
- Whether the authorities had taken actual possession of the land and paid due compensation prior to repeal — i.e., whether the two conditions required to preserve acquisition proceedings (actual physical possession and payment of compensation) were fulfilled.
- Whether procedural deficiencies alleged by the petitioner (ex parte order, service to wrong address, failure to serve the occupant under Section 11(6)) vitiated the acquisition process and affected the entitlement to proceed post-repeal.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner sought exemption under Section 21(1)(a); the exemption process remained pending and at least one recommendation by the District Industries Centre had been made.
- An ex parte order was passed initially without a personal hearing under Section 9(5); the appellate authority remanded for fresh disposal.
- Notices under Section 11(5) were sent to a wrong address and no notice under Section 11(6) was given to the person in occupation; actual possession had not been taken by the authorities.
- No compensation had been paid; a later notice (20.09.2003) directing the petitioner to attend enquiry for compensation indicated compensation had not been paid as of that date.
- The Repeal Act (Act 20 of 1999), particularly Section 4 (and Section 3(2) as relied upon by the petitioner), abates all proceedings that were pending at the time of repeal where possession was not taken and compensation not paid.
Respondents' Arguments (as per Counter Affidavit)
- A return was filed under Section 7(1) on 29.09.1978; notices under Section 9(4) and draft statements under Section 9(1) were issued in 1981 and served by registered post.
- The owner's exemption application was rejected by Government letter dated 12.08.1988; while the exemption was under consideration the land was leased by the owner by an unregistered lease deed.
- An order under Section 9(5) was originally passed (dated 19.09.1989) declaring 900 Sq.Mts. as excess after allowing 2,000 Sq.Mts. Family entitlement computation was later found incorrect and a fresh Section 9(5) order was passed on 12.07.1990 declaring 1,400 Sq.Mts. excess after allowing 1,500 Sq.Mts. entitlement.
- Subsequent appeals were disposed of against the owner; final statements and statutory notifications under Sections 10(1), 11(1) and 11(3) were issued and published in the Government Gazette in 1991–1992. A final notice under Section 11(5) was issued on 11.03.1993 and served on 16.04.1993.
- The respondents assert that when the owner did not surrender possession, the land was taken and handed over to the Firka Revenue Inspector, Alandur, on 30.06.1993.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| M/s. Vijay Foundation (P) Ltd. rep. by its Director, R. Thiagarajan Vs The Principal Commissioner and Commissioner of Land Reforms, Chepauk, Chennai (2006-4-L.W.159) | The court there held that where proceedings were initiated against a person who was not the owner and mandatory conditions in Sections 7–12 were not followed, alleged possession by authorities was vitiated; where possession remained with the petitioner and the Repeal Act came into force, authorities could not proceed further. | The present court relied on that decision to support the conclusion that proceedings which did not satisfy mandatory preconditions and where possession/compensation were absent could not be sustained post-repeal. |
| Sosamma Thampy Vs. The Assistant Commissioner (ULT)-cum-Competent Authority (ULC) and others, (2006) 2 M.L.J. 664; M/s. Anees Leathers Manufacturers rep. by its proprietor Mr. Anees Ahamed Vs The Government of Tamil Nadu (2006-3-L.W.437); Jayaseelan & Ratnaseelan Vs The Government of Tamil Nadu (2006-3-L.W.440) | These decisions held that proceedings initiated under the 1978 Act would abate on the coming into force of the Repeal Act (Act 20 of 1999) if the authorities had not taken actual possession and/or paid due compensation prior to repeal. | The court applied this principle directly: because the two critical conditions (actual possession and payment of compensation) were not shown to be fulfilled, proceedings pending as of 16.06.1999 would abate. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court’s analysis proceeded on the following lines, reflecting the material placed before it and the precedents invoked:
- The court examined the chronology and documentary record (orders, notices, appeals and government letters) submitted by the parties, including the petitioner's submissions that no actual possession was taken and no compensation paid prior to repeal.
- The court noted the respondents' counter-affidavit chronology, which included service of notices, re-computation of family entitlement and subsequent statutory publications and notices. The respondents asserted that the land was taken and handed to the Firka Revenue Inspector on 30.06.1993.
- The court identified the governing statutory framework: the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978 and the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999 (Act 20 of 1999), with emphasis on the effect of the Repeal Act (Section 4 and Section 3(2) references in the pleadings) on pending acquisition proceedings.
- Applying a line of decisions of the High Court (as summarized under Precedents), the court emphasized that mere vesting of land in the Government is not sufficient to preserve acquisition proceedings after repeal: what must be demonstrable is (a) actual physical possession taken by the authorities and (b) payment of due compensation prior to the repeal.
- The court observed that the learned Government Advocate could not produce records conclusively showing that actual possession had been taken in the operative sense and that due compensation had been paid. Although the record indicates the land was "taken and handed over to Firka Revenue Inspector" on 30.06.1993, the court reiterated that such vesting alone does not satisfy the statutory requirements identified in earlier decisions.
- On the facts of the case, the court concluded that both requisite conditions (actual possession and payment of compensation) had not been proved to have been satisfied prior to the Repeal Act coming into force on 16.06.1999.
- Accordingly, consistent with precedent and the statutory effect of the Repeal Act, the court held that the acquisition proceedings pending as of 16.06.1999 stood abated.
Holding and Implications
Holding: WRIT PETITION ALLOWED; THE ACQUISITION PROCEEDINGS PENDING UNDER THE TAMIL NADU URBAN LAND (CEILING & REGULATION) ACT, 1978 ABATED ON THE COMING INTO FORCE OF THE REPEAL ACT (ACT 20 OF 1999) WITH EFFECT FROM 16.06.1999.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The court declared that the acquisition proceedings impugned in the petition could not be sustained and therefore abated because the respondents failed to demonstrate that actual possession had been taken and that compensation had been paid prior to repeal. The writ petition was allowed and the petitioner obtained relief; the court awarded no costs.
- Scope vis-à-vis precedent: The court relied on existing High Court decisions interpreting the Repeal Act and applied those principles; the opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond applying established authority that possession and payment of compensation are the crucial factors for preserving proceedings post-repeal.
Note: This summary is strictly confined to the facts, arguments, authorities and conclusions expressly stated in the provided opinion. No additional facts or inferences beyond the opinion's text have been introduced.
(The Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying to issue a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus as stated therein.)
The Writ Petition has been filed praying for the issuance of a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus to call for the connected records of the first respondent relating to his order U/S.9(5) of the Principal Act, in his proceedings R.C.7794/88-B, dated 12.07.1990, declaring an extent of 1400 Sq.Mts. of land as excess vacant land in S.No.192 of pozhichalur village, the notice issued by the first respondent in his Ref.R.C.7794/88-B, dated 11.03.1993, in Form VII requiring the land owner to deliver vacant possession to the Tahsildar, Saidapet (Certified copies issued on 16.11.2003) and the notice issued by him in his Ref.B/1779/95.C, in form XIV U/S.12(7) of the Act, dated 20.09.2003, directing the land owner to attend the enquiry for claiming compensation and quash the same so far as the petitioner is concerned and declaring that all proceedings taken by the first respondent to acquire the alleged excess vacant land shall abate U/S.4 of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 20 of 1999.
2. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner as well as for the respondents.
3. The brief facts of the case, as stated by the petitioner, are as follows:-
The land in Survey No.192 of pozhichalur village measuring to an extent of 72 cents or 2900 Sq.Mts. was owned by the petitioner on the date of the commencement of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978, (hereinafter referred to as the 'Act') and it has been put to use for locating and running a blue metal industry in the name of "Sri Vinayaga Agencies" and registered as a Small Scale Industrial Unit, which was leased out to one Natarajan for running the Unit. Consequent to the commencement of the Act, necessary returns were filed and the petitioner had sought for exemption by applying to the State Government. The application had been processed by the Director of Industries and Commerce. By his letter R.C.No.2404/GA4/96, dated 08.04.1996. The General Manager District Industries Centre had recommended the firm's proposal for exemption to hold the excess vacant land under Section 21(1)(a) of the Act. While the matter was under process, the first respondent had issued a notice under Section 9(4) of the Act duly preparing the statement under Section 9(1) of the Act arriving at an excess extent of 900 Sq.Mts., allowing the petitioner to hold 2000 Sq.Mts. of land , as the entitlement area. He had sent the notice to the land owner, on 14.09.1981, calling him to attend the enquiry and to file his objections, if any, with regard to the said notice. Without giving a reasonable opportunity of being heard in person as contemplated under Section 9(5) of the Act, an ex parte order had been passed by the first respondent in his proceedings, dated 19.08.1989. Therefore, the petitioner had preferred an appeal under Section 33 of the Act and the appellate authority had set aside the ex parte order and remanded the case for fresh disposal as stated in the Special Commissioner's Order Letter No.J2/52948/89, dated 09.10.1990. Accordingly, the revised orders had been passed in the first respondent's proceedings R.C.7794/88/B, dated 12.07.1990. Further, in pursuance of the said order, notice under Section 11(5) of the Act, dated 11.03.1993, is said to have been sent to the petitioner with the wrong address. However, no notice under Section 11(6) of the Act was issued to the person in occupation of the land and actual possession of the land had not been taken from the land owner.
4. The petitioner had submitted a representation in his letter, dated 26.04.1994, requesting the State Government to grant exemption to hold the alleged excess vacant land and to use the same for industrial purposes, after taking into consideration the total number of his family members and the extent of entitlement of area. The State Government, in their letter No.70872/Na.Nee.03(i) 94-4-Revenue, dated 16.10.1998, had rejected the request of the land owner. Thereafter, the petitioner land owner had made another representation to the State Government in his letter, dated 20.04.1999. However, no orders have been passed on the representation made by the petitioner and the matter relating to the land in question has been pending. While so, the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation), Act, 1978, was repealed, with effect from 16.06.1999, by the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 20 of 1999. According to Section 4 of the said act, all proceedings with regard to the acquisition of excess vacant land would stand abated. Further, it has been stated that the first respondent has issued a notice, in Form XII under Section 12(7) of the Act, dated 20.09.2003, directing the petitioner to furnish the details with regard to the payment of compensation. Therefore, it is evident from the said notice that no amount had been paid as compensation till the date of the said notice. Further, it is evident from the orders of the Government in their letter No. 70872/Na.Ni-u 03(1) / 94-4, dated 16.10.1998, that the possession of the land had not been taken over from the land owner. It has been submitted that the proceedings which were pending at the time of coming into force of the Repeal Act, 20 of 1999, will not be saved in accordance with Section 3(2) of the Repeal Act.
5. In the counter affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents, it has been stated as follows:-
"2. It is submitted that Thiru.V.Gurunathan represented by Thiru.V.Ramamurthy had filed return under Section 7(1) of Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) (Tamil Nadu Act 24 of 1978) (hereinafter referred to as the said Act) for the land held by him in S.No.192 of polichalur village on 29.09.1978. It was stated that the land is a self acquired property of Thiru.V.Gurunathan, vide Doct.No.2652/17.09.1971. Notice under Section 9(4) and Draft statement under Section 9(1) was issued in Rc.4707/80, dated 14.09.1981, for the land in S.No.192 measuring 2900 Sq.Mts. (72 cents) of Polichalur village. This was served to the Power Agent Thiru.V.Ramamurthy on 18.09.1981, through Registered Post with Acknowledgment Due. Meanwhile the Urban Land Owner had applied for exemption under Section 21(1)(a) of the said Act. After verifying the records the Government in their letter No. 1506/Revenue, dated 12.08.1988, rejected the exemption application of Thiru.V.Gurunathan and Thiru.V.Ramamurthy since the petitioners were not running any Industry in the lands S.No.191,192 of Polichalur. While the exemption application was under consideration and the petitioners leased out the land by means of the unregistered lease deed. After scrutinizing the records, order under Section 9(5) of the said Act was passed vide proceedings RC.7794/88(B), dated 19.09.1989, declaring that an extent of 900 Sq.Mts. as excess vide proceedings Rc.7794/88(B), dated 19.09.1989, after allowing 2000 Sq.Mts. towards family entitlement. This was served by Registered Post with Acknowledgment Due on 29.09.1989. On receipt of section 9(5) order, the urban land owner filed an appeal under Section 33 of the Act before the Special Commissioner and Commissioner of Land Reforms. The Special Commissioner and Commissioner of Land Reforms in proceedings J2/52948/89, dated 09.01.1990, had set aside the section 9(5) order and instructed to pass fresh orders after allowing correct entitlement. This case was re-examined and it was found that as regards family entitlement an extent of 2000 Sq.Mts. was computed wrongly as family eligibility considering that the family of the urban land owner, consisted of himself, his wife, two minor children. On a detailed verification, it was found that one of minor children was born only on 12.10.76 i.e., after coming into force of the Act i.e.3.8.76 and that the initial computation of family eligibility as 2000 Sq.Mts. is incorrect and that the family as on 3.8.1976 consisted husband, wife and one minor child only and hence the family entitlement is only 1500 Sq.Mts. and not 2000 Sq.Mts. Accordingly, fresh order under Section 9(5) was passed vide Assistant Commissioner (Urban Land Tax) Tambaram proceedings Rc.B/7794/88, dated 12.7.90, declaring the excess vacant land as 1400 Sq.Mts. after allowing 1500 Sq.Mts. towards family entitlement. This order was served by Registered Post with Acknowledgment Due. Aggrieved by this order, the urban land owner again filed an appeal under Section 33 of the said Act and it was rejected vide Special Commissioner and Commissioner of Land Reforms Procs.12/9654/91, dated 14.10.91. Then final statement under Section 10(1) of the Act was issued on 23.03.1991 and served on 28.11.91. Notification under Section 11(1) of the said Act was got published in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette No.453/92 in Par VI Section-1 at page 337, dated 25.03.92. Notification under Section 11(3) of the Act was published in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette Part VI Section -1/1517/92 at page 1073, dated 09.09.92. Final notice under Section 11(5) of the said Act requesting the urban land owner to surrender possession of the excess vacant land within 30 days from the date of receipt of notice was issued on 11.03.93 and it was served on 16.04.93. As the Urban land owner has not chosen to surrender the possession, it was taken and handed over to Firka Revenue Inspector, Alandur, on 30.06.93. After a long period the urban land owner has now filed a writ petition W.P.31801/2003 in the High Court of Judicature, Madras."
6. Further, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners has relied on the following decisions: -
6.1. In M/s.Vijay Foundation (P) Ltd. rep. by its Director, R.Thiagarajan Vs The Principal Commissioner and Commissioner of Land Reforms, Chepauk, Chennai, reported in 2006-4-L.W,159, a learned Judge of this Court, while dealing with the action initiated by the respondents under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978, in view of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act (Act 20 of 1999), has held that the respondents had initiated acquisition proceedings against the person who was not the owner of the lands. As the mandatory conditions mentioned in Sections 7 to 12 of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978, were not followed by the respondent, the alleged possession taken by the respondents was vitiated. Based on the proceedings initiated against the wrong person, the lands of the petitioner cannot be acquired by the respondents. Since the possession of the land is with the petitioner, ever since the date of purchase, and as the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978, was repealed on 16.06.1999, it was not open to the respondents to proceed against the petitioner."
6.2. In Sosamma Thampy Vs. The Assistant Commissioner (ULT)-cum-Competent Authority (ULC) and others reported in (2006) 2 M.L.J. 664, M/s.Anees Leathers Manufacturers rep. by its proprietor Mr.Anees Ahamed Vs The Government of Tamil Nadu rep.by its Secretary, Revenue Department, Fort St.George, Chennai and others, reported in 2006-3-L.W.437, and Jayaseelan & Ratnaseelan Vs The Government of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary, Revenue Department, Fort St.George, Chennai and others, reported in 2006-3-L.W.440, this Court, while dealing with the effect of the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land Ceiling Repeal Act (Act 20 of 1999) on the land acquisition proceedings initiated under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation), Act 1978, has held that all such proceedings initiated under the Act of 1978, would abate on the coming into force of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999, if the possession of the land had not been taken by the authorities concerned prior to the repeal, and if due compensation had not been paid to the petitioners.
7. Based on the above decisions and on the submissions made by the learned counsels appearing for the petitioners as well as for the respondents and on a perusal of the records available before this Court, it is clear that the land acquisition proceedings initiated by the respondents and challenged before this Court cannot be sustained in view of the subsequent coming into force of the Repeal act (act 20 of 1999). From the facts of the present case, it is seen that both the conditions have not been satisfied and therefore, on coming into force of Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 20 of 1999, from 16.06.1999, all proceedings pending would abate.
8. The learned Government Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondents could not produce any record to show that actual possession of the land in question had been taken and due compensation paid. From the records placed before this Court, it is seen that the lands in question had been taken and handed over to Firka Revenue Inspector, Alandur, on 30.06.93. According to the provisions of the Repeal Act 20 of 1999 and based on their interpretation, as found in a series of decisions of this Court, it is clear that mere vesting of the land in the Government is not sufficient. It should be shown that actual possession was taken over. Taking of actual possession of the land and the payment of compensation thereafter, are the crucial factors. If such taking over of possession and payment of compensation is not shown to have been done, all proceedings pending with regard to the lands in question, ought to be taken as abated on coming into the force of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 20 of 1999. In such view of the matter, the writ petition stands allowed. No costs.
Alert