- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
R. Satyanarayana Rao And 3 Others v. M.K Manoharan K. Manoharan And Another
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Civil Revision concerning I.A. No. 15827 of 1999)
Factual and Procedural Background
This Revision arises from an order in I.A. No. 15827 of 1999 (on the file of the First Assistant City Civil Judge's Court, Madras) by which a Commission was issued to measure the suit property. The revision petitioners are defendants 2, 3, 5 and 6 in O.S. No. 12199 of 1989.
The first respondent (plaintiff in the original suit) claims an equitable assignment of the rights of the late M. Rajaram in respect of lands comprised in T.S. Nos. 16 and 21, Block Nos. 38 and 39, Paimash Nos. 967 to 972 in No. 109, Puliyur Strotriem village. The plaintiff's pleaded history includes references to Janakiram Pillai as erstwhile landowner, an earlier suit under Sec. 55 of the Estate Lands Act (O.S. No. 1 of 1938) which went against the father of the first defendant, and the grant of Pattah on 15.11.1947 to P. Kalyanasundaram Pathar who went into exclusive possession and later by will passed rights to Rajaram.
Although a document in favour of the father of the first defendant was alleged to be invalid, the first defendant reportedly conveyed by sale deed to defendants 2–5 and others. The defendants (2 to 7) constructed a large Kalyana Mandapam on the land and proposed an inauguration on 14.12.1989. The plaintiff sought a declaration that he alone was entitled to the ryotwari patta and consequential injunction restraining defendants 2 to 7 from entitlement and from proceeding with construction and inauguration. The defendants denied the plaintiff's rights.
The trial proceeded to close of evidence and arguments. At that stage the plaintiff filed I.A. No. 15827 of 1999 seeking appointment of an Advocate-Commissioner to note physical features and measure the property (with assistance of a surveyor), relying in part on an alleged contradiction between evidence (deposition of DW1 Krishna Rao that defendants 6 and 7 were in possession of more than 22 grounds) and Ex.B-7 (which showed only 14 grounds and 45 cents).
The sixth defendant filed a counter-statement opposing appointment of a Commissioner as unnecessary after arguments had been heard and when the suit was not for recovery of possession and the identity of the property was not disputed. The lower Court nevertheless appointed a Commissioner, and this Revision challenges that appointment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the trial Court was justified in issuing a Commission (appointing an Advocate-Commissioner to note physical features and measure the property) after the close of evidence and after arguments had been heard, where the suit primarily sought a declaration of entitlement to a ryotwari patta and consequential injunction rather than recovery of possession, and where the identity of the property was not in issue.
- Whether a Revision is maintainable to challenge an order appointing a Commissioner where the appointment is alleged to be unnecessary and made without proper consideration of pleadings and necessity.
Arguments of the Parties
Revision Petitioners / Defendants (Applicants challenging the Commission)
- The appointment of an Advocate-Commissioner after arguments had been heard was unnecessary and impermissible.
- There was no necessity to appoint an Advocate-Commissioner to measure the property or to note physical features because the suit was not for recovery of possession and the identity of the property was not disputed.
- Allowing such a Commission at that stage would be inappropriate especially once the evidence was closed and arguments completed.
First Respondent / Plaintiff (Applicant for the Commission)
- Sought appointment of an Advocate-Commissioner to note physical features and measure the property with assistance of a surveyor, citing a contradiction between DW1's deposition (possession of more than 22 grounds) and Ex.B-7 (14 grounds and 45 cents).
- Asserted that defendants 6 and 7 were occupying plaintiff's lands to an extent of 37-1/2 grounds and required a determination of physical facts pending disposal of the suit.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| B. Subramanyam v. Kushal Chand, ILR 2000 Karnataka 571 | Doctrine of finality: amendments or reopening evidence after evidence is over are generally not permitted except in very valid grounds, timely application and not resulting in manifest injustice. | Cited to support the proposition that once evidence is closed and arguments have been heard, reopening the proceedings or permitting procedures akin to re-examination (such as issuing a Commission to examine physical facts) is not appropriate without valid justification; used to reinforce that the Commission was unnecessary at this late stage. |
| S. Anthonidoss & another v. Sabesthiyan & another, 1996 (1) CTC 472 | A Commissioner should not be appointed merely on request; there must be sufficient basis, justification and an effective need; appointment must not be a matter of course or for ulterior motive. | Relied upon to show that appointment of a Commissioner requires an effective need and sufficient basis, which were absent given the plaintiff's admission of defendants' possession and the nature of relief sought. |
| D.S. Reddy rep. by his Power Agent v. Dr. G.V. Reddy rep. by its Power Agent M.S. Murthy, 1999 (1) CTC 172 | Issuance of a Commission must be necessary for the proper disposal of the suit and there must be sufficient reason for appointment. | Used to underscore that the issuance of a Commission must be necessary for proper disposal of the suit; court found such necessity lacking here. |
| Veneu Gopal Tari & others v. Nilconta S. Xete & others, AIR 1975 Goa, Daman & Diu 32 | Where there is a dispute as to identity of the suit property (allegedly bearing two different registration numbers), trial Court should appoint a Commissioner, preferably a trained surveyor, to examine identity. | Cited by respondents but distinguished by the Court because in the present case the identity of the property was not disputed and defendants were admittedly in possession; thus the precedent did not apply. |
| Kutu Ram & another v. Gheesulal & others, (1993) (2) Current Civil Cases 243 | Where a Commissioner has been appointed unnecessarily and the trial Court has passed the Order without proper regard to the pleadings and necessity, the appointment can be condemned as illegal. | Applied to support the view that an unnecessary appointment of a Commissioner, made without considering pleadings or necessity, is susceptible to challenge in revision and can be set aside as illegal. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first reviewed the reliefs claimed in the plaint and noted that the plaintiff's primary relief was a declaration that he alone was entitled to the ryotwari patta and a consequential injunction. The Court observed that the plaintiff admitted defendants 2 to 7 had constructed a Kalyana Mandapam and were in possession of the land, but nevertheless did not seek recovery of possession in the plaint.
The Court reasoned that where the identity of the property is not in dispute and the suit is not for recovery of possession, there is generally no necessity to appoint a Commissioner to note physical features or to carry out measurement. The Court emphasised that the question of entitlement to a ryotwari patta is to be determined primarily on documentary evidence produced before the trial Court.
The Court additionally placed weight on procedural finality: the entire evidence was closed and the matter had been argued by the petitioners' counsel. The Court treated the late-stage application for a Commission as inconsistent with the doctrine of finality and the principles against reopening or prolonging litigation without valid justification.
In support the Court considered and applied authorities which establish that (i) a Commissioner should not be appointed merely on request and must be justified by sufficient basis and effective need, (ii) issuance of a Commission must be necessary for the proper disposal of the suit, and (iii) where identity is disputed (a factual category), a Commissioner may be appropriate—however, that latter principle was distinguishable because identity was not disputed in this case.
The Court also addressed the contention that an order appointing a Commissioner is not amenable to revision, and concluded that where a Commissioner has been appointed unnecessarily and the trial Court has issued the order without due regard to pleadings and necessity, such an order can be challenged as illegal in revision. Consequently, the Court found the impugned appointment to be unjustified.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The impugned order issuing a Commission (I.A. No. 15827 of 1999) was set aside; I.A. No. 15827 of 1999 in O.S. No. 12199 of 1989 is dismissed; the Civil Revision Petition is allowed. There shall be no order as to costs and the connected C.M.Ps are closed.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: the appointment of an Advocate-Commissioner to measure and note the physical features of the suit property is quashed; no Commission will proceed pursuant to I.A. No. 15827 of 1999.
- Proceedings in the suit will continue without the measurement or physical examination ordered by the impugned Commission; the entitlement to a ryotwari patta remains to be decided on the documentary and oral evidence already on record.
- The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel rule of law beyond applying existing principles: the decision is grounded on established requirements that appointment of Commissioners must be necessary for proper disposal and that late-stage fact-finding measures which undermine finality are generally inappropriate. The Court did not state any broader precedent beyond these applications.
End of summary — based exclusively on the provided opinion.
ORDER
Defendants 2, 3, 5 and 6 in O.S No. 12199 of 1989, on the file of First Assistant City Civil Judge's Court, Madras, are the revision petitioners.
2. Petitioners are aggrieved by the order in I.A No. 15827 of 1999 whereby a Commission was issued to measure the property.
3. Material facts could be summarised thus:—
First respondent herein claims that he is the holder of an equitable assignment in respect of rights and interest of late M. Rajaram in respect of the lands comprised in T.S Nos. 16 and 21, Block Nos 38 and 39, Paimash Nos;967 to 972 in No. 109, Puliyur Strotriem village. The entire village, according to first respondent/plaintiff, was an inamand, and one Janakiram Filial was the strotriemdhar. In a dispute between the family members, Janakiram Pillai was appointed as Receiver by this Court, and as per Extract from Land Register, it could be seen that Janakiram Pillai was the erstwhile landowner. Till the Government took over the land, Janakiram was shown as the owner in all the records. It is further said that one Akbar Basha, father of first defendant, purchased some lands from third parties who had no manner of right or interest therein and consequently the sale in favour of first defendant was also invalid. In 1938, father of first defendant instituted a suit as O.S No. 1 of 1938 in the Court of Deputy Collector of Saidapet under Sec. 55 of the Estate Lands Act for issue of Patta. The case went against him. On 15.11.1947, Janakiram Pillai issued Patta to P. Kalyanasundaram Pathar in respect of lands comprised in Paimash Nos. 967 to 972 for valid consideration. From that date onwards, Kalyanasundaram Pathar was in exclusive possession of the properties. He died issueless and he had executed a Will whereby his adopted son one Rajaram acquired right over the property. It is the right of Rajaram that plaintiff claims as holder of equitable assignment.
4. Even though the document in favour of the father of first defendant is invalid, it seems that the first defendant executed a sale deed in favour of defendants 2 to 5 and others. The Special Commissioner and Commissioner for Land Administration to the Government of Tamil Nadu was approached for the grant of Ryotwari Patta, and he directed the filing of a regular Revision Petittion to the Assistant Settlement Officer, Tiruvannamalai. The plaintiff filed a Writ Petition and obtained necessary direction. It is alleged that the defendants 2 to 7, in the meanwhile have put up a huge Kalyana Mandapam in the land over which they have no right, and over which the plaintiff alone has right. It is said that the Kalyana Mandapam is to be inaugurated on 14.12.1989, and if the same takes place, plaintiff's right over the land will be seriously affected. The suit was, therefore, laid for the following reliefs:—
“ ….for a declaration that he alone is entitled to the ryotwari patta in respect of the plaint schedule lands and for consequential injunction restraining the defendants 2 to 7 from any entitlement thereto and from proceeding with any construction and the inauguration of any Kalyana Mandapam on the lands set out in the schedule below wherein they have no right and for which they have no ryotwari patta;
for costs of the suit.”
5. In the written statement filed by defendants, they have denied the rights of plaintiff.
6. The parties went on trial, and the entire evidence was closed. The matter was also fully argued by petitioners' counsel. On the request of learned counsel for 1st respondent/plaintiff, the matter was adjourned. At that time, I.A 15827 of 1999 was filed for the following relief:—
“… to appoint an Advocate-Commissioner to note down the physical feature of the 6th and 7th respondents possession of the entire suit schedule property comprised in T.S Nos. 16 and 21 Block Nos. 38 and 39 Paimash Nos. 967 to 972 in No. 109, Puliyur Strotrium Village, measuring an extent of 37-1/2 grounds in T.S No. 21(2) including 21/6 Block No. 39, at Door No. 29-A, Viswanathapuram Main Road, “Saragam - Kodambakkam, Chennai - 600 024 pending disposal of the above suit, and pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper, and thus render justice.”
7. In the affidavit filed in support of the application, it is said that in the deposition of D.W 1., one Krishna Rao, Manager of the 7th defendant appeared before Court and deposed that defendants 6 and 7 are in possession and enjoyment of more than 22 grounds. But in Ex.B-7, the right is confined only to 14 grounds and 45 cents. In view of the contradiction in the deposition and document, an Advocate-Commissioner is to be appointed. He has further averred that plaintiff is having lands comprised in T.S Nos. 16 and 21, Block Nos. 38 and 39 Paimash Nos. 967 to 972 in No. 109, Puliyur Strotriem village measuring an extent of 9 conies and 45 cents, out of which the defendants 6 and 7 are in occupation of plaintiff's lands to an extent of 37-1/2 grounds. They wanted an Advocate-Commissioner to note down the physical features of the property in the occupation of defendants 6 and 7 with the assistance of a Surveyor.
8. A counter-statement was filed on behalf of sixth defendant contending that there is no necessity for issuing a Commission, especially after arguments were heard. It was also contended that there is no necessity to appoint an Advocate-Commissioner to measure the property with the assistance of any Surveyor, nor is there any question of noting down the physical features. The suit is not one for recovery of property, nor its identity is questioned. Therefore, there is no necessity for the issue of a Commission. Even though they raised objection, the lower Court held that to resolve the dispute between the parties, a Commissioner is to be deputed. The same is challenged in this Revision.
9. Heard learned counsel on both sides.
10. After hearing learned counsel on both sides, I do not think that the lower Court was justified in issuing a Commission. I have already extracted the reliefs sought for in the plaint. It is only for declaration of title and consequential injunction. It is admitted by plaintiff in paragraph 12 that defendants 2 to 7 have put up a huge Kalyana Mandapam in the land in which plaintiff has no right. In spite of this statement, plaintiff did not seek for recovery of any property. The main relief is only to declare that he alone is entitled to get a ryotwari patta, and the injunction is only consequential to such a declaration. In the earlier portion of the plaint also, plaintiff has stated that the suit has been filed to protect his interest to get a ryotwari Patta.
11. When the identity of the property is not a matter in issue, and when the suit is also not one filed for recovery of property, I do not think there is any necessity to issue a Commission, and that too, when the question of issuing ryotwari patta is to be decided on the basis of documentary evidence produced before Court. Again, the relief prayed for in the application for appointment of Advocate-Commissioner is to note down the physical features of 6th and 7th defendant's possession of the entire suit schedule property. When the plaintiff himself has admitted that defendants 6 and 7 are in possession, what is the necessity to note down the physical features of the property in the possession of defendants 6 and 7.
12. Admittedly, the entire evidence is over, and the matter has also been argued by petitioners' counsel. In a very recent decision of the Karnataka High Court reported in ILR 2000 Karnataka 571 (B. Subramanyam v. Kushal Chand), a learned Judge of that High Court has considered the question as to whether any amendment could be allowed after the evidence is over. While considering the same, In para 3 of the judgment, it has been held thus:—
There is a doctrine of finality which attaches itself to different stages of legal proceedings and the principle also applies to pleadings. It is true that the Courts do make certain exceptions provided there is very valid ground but more importantly provided that the application is made in good time and it does not result in manifest injustice. In the present instance, one needs to take note of the fact that the suit has come upto the stage of arguments, that it is six years old and the question is as to whether at this late stage an amendment of the written statement should be permitted and the evidence should be reopened. To my mind, such a procedure cannot be permitted for the reason that among other things, it would result in manifest injustice to the oppossite party. The contention is that the defendant has not repaid the loan and that this is the reason why the plaintiff had to approach the Court for recovery and it is absolutely essential that the time factor should also be taken into consideration by the legal system. Even after the pleadings are complete and the evidence has started in exceptional cases, a Court may allow an amendment but if that stage is over and the evidence has been closed, by permitting reopening of the evidence, to my mind, it would not only be injustice to the opposite party; it would be manifestly unfair to the system itself because it is due to such situations that litigation gets dilated and goes on interminably.
13. Learned counsel for petitioners also brought to my notice a judgment reported in 1996 (1) CTC 472 (S. Anthonidoss and another v. Sabesthiyan and another) wherein Raju, J., as His Lordship then was, has held that a Commissioner is not to be appointed for mere asking. Relevant portion of the judgment reads thus:—
“ …. The questiton of appointment of a Commissioner does not depend upon merely whether any prejudice will be caused to the other side or not. Instead, there should be sufficient basis and justification as also an effective need and an appointment of Commissioner cannot be sought for or obtained as a matter of Course and that too to achieve an ulterior object or motive….”
In this case also, the admitted case of plaintiff is that the entire construction of Kalyana Mandapam is over, and it is to be inaugurated. It was at that time, the suit was filed. In spite of it, plaintiff did not seek for recovery of the property. Probably he did not want to pay Court-fee on the market value. Learned Counsel also brought to my notice that decision reported in 1999 (1) CTC 172 (D.S Reddy rep. by his Power Agent, D.P.S Reddy v. Dr. G.V Reddy rep. by its Power Agent M.S Murthy). Learned Judge has held in that case that there should be sufficient reason for appointment of Commissioner, and that the issuance of a Commission must be necessary for the proper disposal of the suit.
14. Learned counsel for respondents brought to my notice the decision reported in AIR 1975 Goa, Daman & Diu 32 (Veneu Gopal Tari and others v. Nilconta S. Xete and others), with special emphasis on paragraph 7 of that judgment. In that case, learned Judge of that High Court held that ‘where there is a dispute as regards the identity of the suit property allegedly bearing two different registration numbers, the trial Court should appoint a Commissioner, preferably a trained surveyor to examine whether the property bearing two different numbers is in fact the same’. As stated earlier, in the instant case, there is no dispute regarding the identity, and the case of the plaintiff is that he is entitled to get a ryotwari patta. Defendants are admittedly in possession of the property. Therefore, the said decision has no application to the facts of this case.
15. Learned counsel for respondents also submitted that an order appointing Commissioner is not a matter decided, and therefore, a revision is not maintainable. Reliance was also placed on the decision reported in (1993) (2) Current Civil Cases 243 (Kutu Ram and another v. Gheesulal and others). When a Commissioner has been appointed unnecessarily, and when the lower Court has passed that Order without taking into consideration the pleadings in the case, and without considering the fact whether such issuance is necessary, it can certainly be said that the Court has acted illegally. If I am to hold that the Revision is not maintainable, it would amount to admitting an irrelevant piece of evidence. The lower Court has passed the Order ignoring the relevant provisions of law.
16. In the result, the impugned order is set aside, and I.A No. 15827 of 1999 in O.S No. 12199 of 1989, on the file of First Assistant Judge, City Civil Court at Madras is dismissed. The Civil Revision Petition is allowed. There will be no order as to costs. The connected C.M.Ps are closed.
GS/RR/VCS
Alert