- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shamlata v. Vishweshwara Tukaram Giripunje
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Second Appeal)
Factual and Procedural Background
The suit was originally instituted by Surendrasing Ramarao Naik through his constituted attorney Vishveshwar Tukaramji Giripunje. Subsequently Surendrasing sold the suit property to his constituted attorney Vishveshwar; both are now plaintiffs in the suit. The plaintiffs claim ownership of an open land in Ward No. 26, Circle No. 6, Zilla Road, Mahal, Nagpur. The defendant, Manohar, whose house lies to the north (Municipal Corporation No. 342/1), is alleged to have encroached upon the plaintiffs' land by constructing a well in 1980, resulting in an asserted encroachment of 159 sq. ft.
The plaintiffs also relied on a prior suit (Civil Suit No. 312/95) against the Collector of Nagpur/Nazul department, which was decreed in their favour and whose appeals were rejected. Plaintiffs allege that while the original plaintiff was away from Nagpur the defendant committed the encroachment and therefore seek removal of the encroachment and decree for possession.
The defendant filed a written statement accepting that the plaintiff owned an area known as Naikwadi but denying plaintiffs' title to the specific plot ABCDEFGH and denying any encroachment. The defendant asserted a title derived from a 1935 purchase by his mother (sale deed Exh. 65), claimed adverse possession for over 40 years, invoked limitation, and relied on a 1982 City Survey Department measurement that allegedly showed no encroachment.
The trial Court framed issues, found in favour of the plaintiffs (holding plaintiff owner of ABCDEFGH and that defendant committed encroachment) and decreed the suit. The appellate Court concurred. The second appeal was admitted by Patel, J. on a ground challenging the foundation for plaintiffs' title and reliance on judgments allegedly inadmissible under Section 43 of the Indian Evidence Act.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Courts below erred in relying upon prior judgments and a certified copy of the plaint (Exhs. 51–54 and Exh. 52) that the appellant contends were not relevant or admissible under the Evidence Act (Sections 40–44 and Section 43) and Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
- Whether the plaint map / measurement map prepared by PW 3 (Exh. 26 / Exh. 76) is a reliable basis to determine the existence and extent of encroachment.
- Whether, given the state of the evidentiary record (including record of rights Exh. 60, City Survey Department map Exh. 61, and defendant's sale deed Exh. 65), the Courts below should have appointed a Commissioner/Surveyor to measure both plaintiffs' and defendant's sites before decreeing possession.
- Whether plaintiffs had sufficiently established the title and the transfer to the second plaintiff on the record relied upon by the Courts below.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Defendant's) Arguments — as raised in written statement and by learned counsel on appeal
- The defendant claimed title by purchase in 1935 (sale deed Exh. 65) and long adverse possession (more than 40 years), asserting limitation as a bar to the suit.
- The defendant argued the 1982 City Survey Department measurement showed no encroachment; the plaintiffs did not appeal that measurement.
- On appeal the defendant's counsel contended that the Courts below relied on judgments and a certified copy of the plaint (Exhs. 51–54 and Exh. 52) which were irrelevant or inadmissible: the prior judgment between plaintiff and the State did not bind the defendant (Section 11 CPC), nor did it fit within Sections 40–44 of the Evidence Act; Section 43 was also invoked as barring reliance because the existence of such judgment was not a fact in issue.
- The certified copy of the plaint in Civil Suit No. 312 of 1965 (Exh. 52) was said to be not a public document in this context and therefore not proved; the original plaint should have been produced to prove it.
Plaintiffs' Contentions (as recorded in the opinion)
- Plaintiffs asserted ownership of the suit land and produced certified copies of the judgments in their earlier suit against the State (Exhs. 51, 53, 54) showing a decree in their favour in Civil Suit No. 312/95.
- Plaintiffs produced a record of rights (Exh. 60) and a City Survey Department map (Exh. 61) showing the plaintiffs' plot area as 124.2 sq. meters (measurement dated 15-5-1982).
- Plaintiffs relied on a plaint map prepared by PW 3 Balwant (Exh. 26 / Exh. 76) to show the encroachment and its extent.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court reviewed the record and analyzed the admissibility and weight of the documents relied upon by the Courts below, and evaluated the adequacy of the measurement evidence on which encroachment findings were based.
- The court examined the certified copies of judgments (Exhs. 51, 53, 54) from the earlier suit between the original plaintiff and the State, and observed that such judgments could not bind the present defendant because he was not a party to that suit. The court noted that reliance upon those judgments did not fall within the scope of Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure or within Sections 40–44 of the Indian Evidence Act. The court also observed that Section 43 was invoked in the admission ground because the existence of such judgment was not a fact in issue.
- The court criticized the trial and first appellate Judges' treatment of the certified copy of the plaint in Civil Suit No. 312 (Exh. 52). It held that a certified copy of the plaint is not a public document that can be read without proof; the original plaint should have been produced to prove its contents. Therefore, the certified copy of the plaint was not properly proved.
- The court acknowledged that the plaintiffs had placed on record two important documents: (a) the record of rights (Exh. 60) showing the plaintiffs' land area as 124.2 sq. meters, and (b) the City Survey Department map (Exh. 61) dated 15-5-1982 showing the same area. These documents were recognized as relevant and material.
- The court analyzed the measurement evidence relied on by the Courts below, namely the plaint map prepared by PW 3 Balwant (the only measurement map on record, cited as Exh. 76 or Exh. 26). The court found that this map was not the result of a scientific or independent measurement: it was drawn based on a 1920 map shown by the plaintiff; PW 3 admitted he had not seen title deeds, did not bring measurement notes, did not identify fixed survey marks, and stated the map was drawn as told by Surendrasing (the plaintiff). Given these deficiencies, the court concluded the measurement map could not be treated as a correct or reliable measurement.
- Given the unreliability of the plaint map and the availability of other documentary aids (defendant's sale deed Exh. 65, the City Survey map Exh. 61, and the plaintiffs' 1923 sanction plan at Article 'B'), the court held that the lower courts erred in not appointing a Commissioner/Surveyor to measure both plaintiffs' and defendant's sites. The court reasoned that a measurement undertaken by an official surveyor (specifically from the City Survey Department) with instructions to use the available documents would be necessary to determine accurately whether encroachment existed and, if so, its extent.
- For these reasons the court concluded that a remand to the trial court for a fresh decision—after official measurement and with liberty to the parties to tender further evidence—was required to finally and effectively decide the suit.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The appeal is allowed; the judgments and decrees passed by the Courts below are set aside; the matter is remanded to the trial Court for fresh decision.
Specific Directives / Disposition
- The matter is remanded to the trial Court. The trial Court shall appoint a Surveyor/Commissioner from the City Survey Department to measure the sites of both the plaintiff and the defendant.
- While appointing the Commissioner the trial Court must instruct the measurer to follow the observations set out in the opinion (i.e., measure with reference to the City Survey map Exh. 61, defendant's sale deed Exh. 65, and the plaintiffs' sanction plan of 1923 at Article 'B') and to obtain a correct measurement map showing any encroachment.
- The parties are given liberty to tender evidence as they may choose in the remanded proceedings.
- The trial Court is directed to decide the suit afresh within six months.
- Each party shall bear their own costs.
Implications
The immediate consequence is that the earlier decrees in favour of the plaintiffs have been set aside and determination of encroachment and possession must be remade after official measurement and any supplementary evidence. The opinion does not state or declare any broader legal principle or new precedent beyond the directive that, in the circumstances presented, an independent official measurement (by a City Survey Department Surveyor/Commissioner) was required before adjudicating encroachment and possession.
Order: Order accordingly (as recorded in the opinion).
1. This is a defendant's second appeal. The facts giving rise to this appeal are as follows-
The suit was initially instituted by one Surendrasing Ramarao Naik through his constituted attorney Shri Vishveshwar Tukaramji Giripunje. Subsequently, the original plaintiff Surendrasing sold the suit property to his constituted attorney Vishvesh-war. Both now are plaintiffs in this suit. The defendant Manohar is the neighbour of plaintiff. The plaintiff is the owner of open land in ward No. 26, Circle No. 6 Zilla Road, Mahal Nagpur.
The defendant has his house towards North of the said land bearing Municipal Corporation No. 342/1. The plaintiff submits that the defendant has committed encroachment shown by letters HBCDNPT as shown in the plaint map, and the encroachment is to the extent of 159 sq. ft. It is alleged that the defendant committed the encroachment by constructing a Well in the year 1980. The plaintiff further contends that there was a dispute regarding the land ABCDEFGH covered by the lines in the plaint map with the Nazul department, who claimed that the land belonged to the nazul department. The plaintiff had, therefore, instituted Civil Suit No. 312/95 against the Collector of Nagpur. The suit came to be decreed in favour of the plaintiff and plaintiff was declared to be the owner. The appeals preferred by the State before the District Judge and the High Court were rejected. The plaintiff submits that since the plaintiff was out of Nagpur for quite some time on account of the fact that he had shifted his residence to village Kawatha, the defendant took disadvantage of the fact and committed encroachment. The plaintiff seeks to remove this encroachment and prays for a decree for possession of the site.
2. The defendant has filed the written statement. The defendant does not dispute that the plaintiff is the owner of area known as Naikwadi and he owns landed property in Nagpur. The defendant denies that the plaintiff is the owner of the plot shown by letters ABCDEFGH. He also denies that he has committed encroachment on the site as contended by the plaintiff. The defendant also denies that there was any dispute between plaintiff and the Government over the suit land and that the proceedings ended in favour of the plaintiff. The defendant submits that his house was purchased in the year 1935 from one Sitabai Giripunje. The defendant has been in possession of the property since more than 40 years adversely, and, to the knowledge of the plaintiff uninterruptedly. It is contended that, therefore, the suit is barred by limitation. It is further contention of the defendant that in the year 1982 there was a measurement by the City Survey Department in which it was found that the defendant has not committed any encroachment and plaintiff did not prefer any appeal against the said measurement. The defendant, therefore, prayed that the suit be dismissed.
3. The learned Judge of the trial Court framed issues and found that the plaintiff is the owner of the site ABCD EFGH and defendant had committed encroachment. He has also found that the defendant was not in adverse possession. Holding so, he decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff. The appellate Court concurred with the findings recorded by the trial Court. The second appeal was admitted by Patel, J. on ground No. 2, which reads as follows-
“That as a matter of fact the entire burden to establish that the title to the property in suit vested originally in plaintiff No. 1 and on his alleged transfer in favour of the plaintiff No. 2 in the plaintiff No. 2 and there being no evidence whatsoever to establish the transaction as result of which title was said to have been created in favour of the said plaintiff, merely putting on record certain irrelevant judgments which were clearly inadmissible in view of the mandatory provisions of Section 43 of the Indian Evidence Act, the Courts below have passed a decree in favour of the plaintiffs for which there is no foundation on the record.”
4. I have heard the learned counsel for the appellant. None appears for the respondents.
5. The learned counsel for the appellant contended that the Courts below have relied upon the documents on which it could not have. The plaintiff has pleaded that he had instituted a suit for declaration of his ownership against the State of Maharastra and the suit was decreed in his favour. The plaintiff has placed on record the judgment delivered in that suit and the appeals thereon. The certified copies of the judgments of the Courts have been filed on record. They are Exhs. 51, 53 and 54. Exh. 51 is the copy of the trial Court judgment. Exh. 53 is the copy of the judgment of the first appellate Court while Exh. 54 is the judgment of the High Court. As said, the suit was between the original plaintiff and the State. It appears that the Nazul Tahsildar had given notice to the plaintiff-tenant to remove the encroachment on the said site and therefore, the suit was filed. The suit was decreed. The question is whether this judgment is at all relevant. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that this judgment does not fall within the scope of Sections 40 to 44. The judgment does not fall within the scope of Section 11 of Code of Civil Procedure since the present defendant was not party to that suit. Obviously, therefore, that judgment does not fall within the scope of Section 40 of the Evidence Act. It is not relevant under Section 41 because it is not a judgment delivered in exercise of probate, matrimonial, admiralty, or insolvency jurisdiction. It is no relevant because it does not relate to matter of public nature. It also does not fall within the scope of Section 43 since existence of such judgment is not fact in issue. The learned Judge of the first appellate Court as well as the trial Court could not have, therefore, looked into this judgment for any purpose, for they are irrelevant. It appears that the learned Judge of the trial Court as well as the appellate Court have relied upon the certified copy of the plaint in Civil Suit No. 312 of 1965 (Exh. 52). Both the Judges have held that the document i.e plaint can be read as it is a public document. Both seem to be under misconception. The certified copy of the plaint is not a public document. Hence, it requires proof. For proving such document, the original plaint should have been called in the Court. That is not done, hence the certified copy of the plaint could not be said to be proved at all. The Courts below, therefore, were not justified in putting reliance on this copy of the plaint. The conclusions of the Courts below, however, are not based on the judgment alone between plaintiff and Government, but independently the Courts below have concurrently found that there is an encroachment on plaintiffs land. In this regard, it is seen that this land house of original plaintiff No. 1 is ancestral and hence there is no document of title with the plaintiffs. Plaintiff No. 2 has purchased the property during the pendency of the suit hence that sale deed carries no importance. But the defendant's title to his house is derivative, in as much as his mother has purchased the house and land in 1935. This sale-deed has been placed on record at Exh. 65. Although the plaintiffs do not have sale-deed and land is claimed to be an ancestral, plaintiffs have placed on record two important documents. They are Exh. 60 - the record of rights. The area of the plaintiffs' land is shown to be 124.2 sq. meter in the said record of right. Second document is Exh. 61 - the map of City Survey Department. The map shows that the land was measured by department in presence of plaintiffs as well as defendant and other adjoining owners. The area of the plaintiffs plot No. 504 is shown to be 124.2 sq. mtr. in this map also. This measurement was done on 15-5-1982.
6. Although these two documents are on record, the material thing that needs consideration is whether the plaint map prepared by PW 3 Balwant - retired Talathi - could be relied upon to hold that there is an encroachment on plaintiffs land and if there is one, what is the extent. This is the only map (Exh. 76) on record, as far as measurement of the site is concerned. It appears to me that it would not be proper to rely on this measurement map, for the site does not seem to have been measured scientifically and after notice to the defendant. PW 3 Balwant in examination-in-chief says that he measured the site on the basis of 1920 map and it was shown to him by Surendrasing - the plaintiff. It is not clear if it was a Survey map drawn by Government agency or department or a private map. Whatever that was, that too should have been placed on record. He admits in cross-examination that he had not seen the title-deed of either party. He also states that the map is drawn as told by Surendrasing. He says that he does not know the number of the map and he did not bring those notes of measurement before the Court. It is obvious that the map was drawn as suggested by Suredrasing - the plaintiff. It is not a measurement done independently and on basis of authenticated documents. He does not say if he had seen any document before he measured. One, therefore, wonders as to how then he could determine the boundaries of the plots of the plaintiff as well that of the defendant. He does not say if he found any fixed mark of survey department at any spot and that he measured it taking that point as base point. It is, therefore, clear that the measurement map (Exh. 26) cannot be taken as a correct map. The Courts below, therefore, should have appointed a Commissioner to measure not only the plot of the plaintiff but that of defendant also with reference to defendant's sale deed (Exh. 65) and also with reference to survey map (Exh. 61). It also appears that plaintiff had filed on record a certified copy of the sanction plan of house of plaintiff and it is at Article ‘B’. This sanction plan of plaintiff's house is of the year 1923. Obviously, it is a very old document and material document to determine the exact extent of the land of plaintiff's site. Since sale deed of the plaintiff's site is not available, this document would be of immense help at the time of the measurement. In fact, therefore, the above documents would certainly have helped the measurer to measure the land and for the Court to determine the question of encroachment correctly. To my mind, therefore, the Courts below erred in not appointing a Commissioner to measure the site of the plaintiff and defendant both with reference to these documents. In order that the suit is finally and effectually decided, it is, therefore, desirable to have measurement of both the sites which measurement can be undertaken by Surveyor from the City Survey Department. It Is, therefore, now necessary to remand the matter back to the trial Court.
1) The appeal is, therefore, allowed.
2) The Judgments and decrees passed by the Courts below are set aside.
3) The matter stands remanded to the trial for fresh decision. The trial Court shall appoint Surveyor/Commissioner from the City Survey Department to measure the sites of plaintiff and defendant both.
4) While making an appointment of the Commissioner, the trial Court shall issue instructions to the measurer to measure the land according to the observations in the preceding paragraph of this judgment and obtain the correct measurement map showing encroachment, if any, from the said Commissioner.
5) The parties are given liberty to tender evidence as they may choose in the matter. The trial Court shall then decide the suit afresh within period of six months positively.
6) The parties shall bear their own costs.
Order accordingly.
Alert