- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mr. Magadi Shankar R... v. The Commissioner Of ...
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Rathnakala, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
This petition concerns the legality of an order of the Commissioner of Police, Bengaluru (first respondent), which directed that the investigation of a private criminal complaint be transferred from the jurisdictional police to the City Crime Branch (CCB). The fourth respondent filed a private complaint before the JMFC under Section 200 read with Section 190 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr. P.C.) alleging offences under several provisions of the Indian Penal Code (including Sections 403, 406, 409, 420, 464, 468, 471, 477A, 385 and 120B). The Magistrate, acting under Section 156(3) Cr. P.C., referred the matter for police investigation by order dated 01.10.2014, and the case was registered as Crime No. 447/2014 on 11.10.2014.
On a representation made by the complainant’s wife, the Commissioner of Police purportedly transferred the investigation to the Central Crime Branch. The petitioners (challenging the Commissioner’s order) approached the High Court, seeking quashing of that transfer order (referred to in the opinion as Annexure ‘D’ dated 25.04.2015). The petitioners argued the Commissioner lacked authority to intervene with the ongoing investigation ordered by the Magistrate; the fourth respondent and his counsel defended the Commissioner’s action as an exercise of powers under Section 36 Cr. P.C.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a police officer exercising his power under Section 36 of the Code of Criminal Procedure can transfer an investigation to another police officer who is inferior in rank to him (i.e., whether a superior officer may delegate the investigatory power to an inferior investigator).
- Whether the order of the Commissioner of Police (Annexure ‘D’) transferring an ongoing investigation — which had been referred by the Magistrate under Section 156(3) Cr. P.C. to the jurisdictional police — was legally permissible and valid in the middle of such ongoing investigation.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments (as presented in the opinion)
- When the JMFC referred investigation to the jurisdictional local police under Section 156(3) Cr. P.C., the Commissioner of Police had no authority to intervene and alter or “meddle” with that investigation.
- The complainant has no prerogative to choose the investigating agency; if dissatisfied, the complainant’s remedy is to approach the Magistrate who referred the matter under Section 156(3) (relying on CBI v. Rajesh Gandhi and Sakiri Vasu v. State of U.P.).
- Accordingly, the investigation should continue as per the Magistrate’s order with the jurisdictional police and not be handed over to CCB mid-course.
Respondent No. 4's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)
- The fourth respondent described the underlying dispute: the parties were partners in a registered firm; differences led the complainant to resign as Managing Partner (but not from the firm), and the accused allegedly treated that as resignation from the firm and blocked access, prompting the complaint and referral for investigation. The investigating police initially did not act promptly, causing suspicion of collusion with accused.
- The Commissioner lawfully acted on a representation (by the complainant’s wife, a witness) and exercised jurisdiction under Section 36 Cr. P.C. to transfer the investigation to a specialized squad (CCB), which is appropriate for proper investigation.
- By a line of judicial authority, a superior police officer can take over investigation from an inferior officer under Section 36, and delegation to an officer not below the rank of Station House Officer (SHO) for carrying out investigation is within propriety.
- The petitioners cannot challenge the mode of investigation at a premature stage; they can raise objections only after the final report is filed.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| CBI v. Rajesh Gandhi (1997 Crl. L.J. 63) | Cited for the proposition that a complainant does not have the prerogative to select a particular investigating agency. | Referred to in petitioners' submissions to support the argument that the Commissioner could not hand over the investigation to CCB at the complainant’s instance. |
| Sakiri Vasu v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2008 2 SCC 409) | Holds that a Magistrate can order proper investigation and take steps to ensure it is properly conducted. | Cited by petitioners to contend the Magistrate (via Section 156(3)) is the correct forum to seek redress; the court noted this authority but also recorded that later decisions had questioned or limited its scope. |
| Nirmal Singh Kahlon v. State of Punjab (2009 1 SCC 441) | Interprets Section 36 purposively in light of the State's superintendence under the Police Act; questions/casts doubt on the correctness of Sakiri Vasu on some points. | Relied upon by the court to show Section 36 should be read harmoniously with state superintendence and has a wider application; used to support that a superior officer can take over investigation. |
| Kishan Lal v. Dharmendra Bafna (AIR 2009 SC 2932) | Referenced as one of the cases that cast doubt on the correctness of Sakiri Vasu. | Noted by the court as part of judicial views that limited Sakiri Vasu’s proposition about magisterial monitoring of investigation. |
| State of Bihar v. Lalu Singh (2014 1 SCC 663) | Clarified that magisterial monitoring of investigation/trial could render the trial a farce; diluted the doctrine in Sakiri Vasu. | Used by respondents and considered by the court to indicate that limits exist on magistrate-led monitoring and to support the wider reading of Section 36. |
| Central Bureau of Investigation v. State of Rajasthan (2001 3 SCC 333) | Explains relationship between Section 156(3) and Section 36: magistrate can direct an officer-in-charge to investigate, but a superior officer may exercise the powers of an officer-in-charge by virtue of Section 36; superior officers can take over investigation. | Quoted at length by the court to show that while magistrate directs an officer-in-charge, superior officers may nonetheless exercise equivalent powers — yet the court distinguished taking over personally from delegating to an inferior officer. |
| State of Bihar v. J.A.C. Saldanha (1980 SCC Cri 272) | Supports that the State Government, under Section 3 of the Police Act, has the power to direct further investigation under Section 173(8) Cr. P.C. | Referred to by the court to underscore that selection of investigating agency is ordinarily a matter for the State Government (or High Court under Article 226), not private complainants or the Magistrate. |
| Manohar Lal Sharma v. Principal Secretary (AIR 2014 SC 666) | Explains that courts ordinarily do not intervene in police investigations but may do so in exceptional circumstances to protect personal/proprietary rights of citizens. | Noted by the court as a limiting principle on judicial intervention in the conduct of police investigations. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began with the central statutory provision in question, Section 36 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which provides that police officers superior in rank to an officer in charge of a police station may exercise the same powers throughout the local area as may be exercised by such officer within the limits of his station. A plain reading establishes that a superior officer can exercise the powers of the Station House Officer (SHO) within the superior’s territorial jurisdiction.
The court accepted that, by a line of authorities, a superior officer may take over an investigation from an inferior investigating officer (citing CBI v. State of Rajasthan and related decisions). That principle supports the proposition that the Commissioner of Police, as a superior officer, could have taken over and conducted the investigation himself.
The point of difficulty — the precise legal question the court addressed — was whether such "taking over" of the investigation inherently includes the power to delegate investigatory responsibility to another police officer who is inferior to the superior officer (in this case, assigning the investigation to a CCB officer by directing the Assistant Commissioner of Police (Crimes) to place the matter with CCB).
The court examined whether any statutory provision, police manual direction, or government notification conferred on a superior officer the authority to delegate his Section 36 powers to an inferior officer. It found none. The court noted that the concept of delegation of investigatory power is evident in Section 157(1) Cr. P.C., where the SHO may depute a subordinate to investigate on receipt of information, but beyond that (i.e., for superior officers) no provision in the Code or the Karnataka Police Act expressly contemplates delegation by a superior officer under Section 36.
The court also considered the procedural conflict: the Commissioner’s Annexure ‘D’ stood in confrontation with an ongoing investigation referred by the Magistrate under Section 156(3). The court recited authorities that the selection of the investigating agency is ordinarily a matter for the State Government (and, in certain circumstances, the High Court under its jurisdiction), not a private complainant or the jurisdictional Magistrate. Nevertheless, the court distinguished between a superior officer personally taking over an investigation (which Section 36 permits) and the superior assigning it to an inferior officer without statutory authority (which the court found impermissible).
Having found no statutory power enabling the Commissioner to delegate his Section 36 investigatory power to an inferior officer (i.e., to direct that a CCB officer carry out the investigation), the court concluded that the Commissioner’s order (Annexure ‘D’) effecting such a delegation was without authority and improper.
The court additionally observed that the Magistrate’s order under Section 156(3) — by which the investigation was referred to the jurisdictional police — did not call for interference in this petition and remained valid. The petitioners’ broader challenge to the complaint/FIR itself was not upheld, though they retain the right to challenge any final report arising from the investigation.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The petition is allowed in part. The court quashed the order passed by the Commissioner of Police dated 25.04.2015 (Annexure ‘D’), which had directed further investigation to be carried out by a Police Officer of the City Crime Branch (CCB) pursuant to a delegation through the Assistant Commissioner of Police (Crimes).
Implications and consequences:
- The direct effect is that Annexure ‘D’ (the Commissioner’s order transferring the investigation to CCB by delegation) is quashed and has been declared without authority.
- The Magistrate’s earlier order under Section 156(3) Cr. P.C., referring the complaint for investigation to the jurisdictional police, stands and was not interfered with by this Court in the petition. The court noted that both complainant and accused remain free to challenge the final report of investigation by the remedies available under law.
- The court concluded, based on its reasoning, that while a superior police officer may personally take over an investigation under Section 36 Cr. P.C., there is no statutory authority found in the Code or the Karnataka Police Act for a superior officer to delegate that power to an inferior officer in the absence of an express provision permitting such delegation (aside from the limited delegation power given to the SHO under Section 157(1) Cr. P.C.).
The opinion disposed of the related interlocutory applications (I.A. Nos. 2 and 3 of 2015) as infructuous in view of the main petition's disposal.
Rathnakala, J.:— A nice question of law has arisen for consideration in this petition “Whether a police officer exercising his power under Section 36 of Cr. P.C while taking out the investigation of a case from an officer in charge of police station, can transfer the investigation to another police officer inferior to him?”
2. The fact is:
The forth respondent herein filed a private complaint before the jurisdictional Magistrate under Section 200 r/w. Section 190 of Cr. P.C in respect of the offences punishable under Sections 403, 406, 409, 420, 464, 468, 471, 477A, 385 and 120B of IPC and the Learned Magistrate acting under Section 156(3) of Criminal Procedure Code (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Code’) referred the matter for investigation, vide order dated 01.10.2014 to the first respondent police and the case is registered in crime No. 447/2014 on 11.10.2014
3. It appears that on a representation made by the wife of the complainant, the Commissioner of Police/first respondent transferred the investigation to the Central Crime Branch. On the first respondent's representation to the Court seeking permission to transfer the investigation, the accused persons have approached this Court.
4. Sri Arvind Kamath K., Learned Counsel for petitioners submits that when the JMFC Court had referred the investigation to the jurisdictional local police, the first respondent/Commissioner of Police has no authority to intervene and meddle with the investigation. It is not the prerogative of the complainant to select a particular investigating agency as held by the Apex Court in the case of CBI v. Rajesh Gandhi . 1997 Crl. L.J 63. Even if the complainant is not happy with the mode in which investigation is proceeding, the only avenue open for him is to approach the Magistrate who referred investigation under Section 156(3) of the Cr. P.C for the redressal of his grievance. The Magistrate if convinced may order for proper investigation as held by the Apex Court in Sakiri Vasu v. State of Uttar Pradesh . 2008 2 SCC 409. The investigation cannot be handed over to CCB, but shall continue as per the order of the Magistrate with the jurisdictional police only.
5. In reply, Sri C.V Sudhindra, Learned Counsel for respondent No. 4 submits that the petitioners and the fourth respondent /complainant are the partners of a registered partnership firm; the petitioner was the Managing Partner, in view of the differences that arose inter se, it was impossible for the complainant to continue to work as Managing Partner; he had to resign from the position of Managing Partner, but he had not rescinded from the partnership of the firm; the accused persons treated his letter of resignation as the retirement from the partnership firm, though it was in respect of his designation as Managing Partner, they concocted documents and notified to the bank and financial institutions that he has resigned. Thus blocked his access to firm and firm's emails etc. On that he was constrained to file a complaint to the jurisdictional JMFC Court, though the complaint was referred on 29.09.2014 for investigation, the Investigating Officer did not register the case and investigation did not gain speed.
That made the complainant to doubt that the local police are in hand and glove with the accused persons. There is nothing wrong on the part of the Commissioner to act on the representation of his wife, who is also complaint witness to exercise his jurisdiction under Section 36 of the Code in transferring the investigation to the Police Officer of the same rank. The law laid down by the Apex Court in Sakiri Vasu v. State of Uttar Pradesh (supra) that Magistrate can order a proper investigation and take other suitable steps is per incurium and its correctness was doubted in Nirmal Singh Kahlon v. State of Punjab . 2009 1 SCC 441 at Para No. 68 and in Kishan Lal v. Dharmendra Bafna . AIR 2009 SC 2932. Further in the case of State of Bihar v. Lalu Singh . 2014 1 SCC 663, the position of law was clarified that the Magistrate monitoring the investigation would render the trial farce and the legal proposition laid down in Sakiri Vasu's case (supra) was there by diluted.
6. Sri C.V Sudhindra, Learned Counsel for respondent No. 4, further adds that it is the well settled position of law that the complaint referred under Section 156(3) of the Code is preemptory/reminder to the police to investigate. Once reference order is made, the matter comes within the domain of the police to investigate. Section 36 of the Code contemplates that a superior police officer can take up the investigation from the Station House Officer. Transfer of investigation to a specialized squad like CID and CCB, being a specialized squad, which is the appropriate authority to investigate the matter is within the propriety of Section 36 of the Code. By catena of judicial pronouncements it is approved that an Officer superior in rank to an officer in charge of the police station can exercise the power of further investigation by virtue of Section 36 of Code.
7. Learned Counsel continues his submissions, the Apex Court in the case of State of Bihar v. Lalu Singh (supra), held that the Inspector of CID who was entrusted investigation from the Director General of Police (having taken over investigation from the Officer in charge of the Police Station) was competent to submit the report. In the said circumstances, the Commissioner of Police who is authorised under Section 36 of the Code to investigate the matter, if delegates his power to an officer inferior to him who is not less than the rank of a Station House in charge, he is acting so within his jurisdiction and the petitioners cannot question the mode of investigation at this premature stage, i.e, till the final report is filed. If aggrieved by the final report, they can invoke remedy permissible under law to challenge the final report.
8. Section 36 of the Code which is under discussion reads thus:
“Section 36-Powers of superior officers of police:
Police officers superior in rank to an officer in charge of a police station may exercise the same powers, throughout the local area to which they are appointed, as may be exercised by such officer within the limits of his station”,
9. A simple and plain reading of the Section admits an inference that a superior police officer above the rank of officer in charge of the police station within the area of his jurisdiction can exercise all the powers which Station House Officer is exercising within the limits of his station. The authorities quoted by the fourth respondent/complainant would further admit that a superior police officer can take over investigation from an inferior investigating officer to investigate the matter. With this we are landing up over a very fine and sharp point, whether this taking over and carrying out investigation includes in itself delegation of power of investigation to be carried out by another police officer? Such circumstance is not addressed in any of the authorities relied by the fourth respondent/complainant. It is not found either in the police manual or any of the notification of the government that the superior officer of police can delegate his power under Section 36 of the Code.
10. The petitioners are much aggrieved by the order of the Police Commissioner, Bengaluru, as at Annexure ‘D’ dated 25.04.2015, whereby he directed further investigation by City Crime Branch. Assistant Commissioner of Police (Crimes) was directed to order investigation to be carried out by a Police Officer of CCB. The Police Inspector of jurisdictional Police Station was directed to hand over the investigation to such Police Officer of CCB, who would carry out investigation. Consequent upon this order, the Investigating Officer sought permission from the Learned Magistrate to transfer the investigation to CCB as per the letter Annexure ‘X’. It is evident from Annexure ‘D’ that because of the representation of the wife of the complainant, this order is passed. The petitioners among other things are questioning the locus standi and propriety of the wife of the complainant in making representation to the Police Commissioner and the legality of the action taken by the Police Commissioner on her representation. But it is immaterial on whose request and for what reason the order at Annexure ‘D’ is passed. The matter for concern is, the legality of the order at Annexure ‘D’ in the middle of the ongoing investigation by the local police under the order of the jurisdictional Magistrate. A situation has arisen that the order of the Commissioner stands in confrontation viz-a-viz with the judicial order passed by the Magistrate.
11. The territorial jurisdiction of the Commissioner of Police to the entire Bangalore City is as specified by the State Government. Commissioner of Police is a superior police officer as defined by Section 2(22) of Karnataka Police Act, 1963. The Officer incharge of a Police Station is defined in Section 2(o) of the Code usually who is of the rank ofthe Police Inspector, is inferior in rank in the hierarchy of the system.
12. The Apex Court in the case of Nirmal Singh Kahlon v. State of Punjab (supra) along with Another Case.
“27. In terms of Section 3 of the Police Act, 1861, the State has the ultimate say in the matter of superintendence of investigation. Section 36 of the Code must be read harmoniously with the said provision. Therefore, when Section 36 of the Code uses the words “in rank”, it should be given a purposive construction. Although a plain reading of the aforementioned provision appears to be containing three ingredients, namely, (i) the investigation must be carried out by an Officer in charge; (ii) which may be supervised by an Officer superior in rank; and (Hi) in respect of a local area to which they are appointed, but in the context of the power of the State vis-a-vis the provisions of the Act, the same, in our opinion, deserves a wider application.”
By a catena of judicial pronouncements, the scope and ambit of this Section 36 of the Code is well defined and there is no doubt that the Commissioner of Bangalore is the officer superior in rank to an Officer in charge of the Police Station. The powers of the Police Commissioner in the capacity of the superior officer to take over the investigation from the jurisdictional Investigating Officer cannot be a matter of quarrel.
In the case of CBI v. State of Rajasthan . 2001 3 SCC 333, it was held that when an order under Section 156(3) of the Code is passed by a Magistrate, any officer superior in rank or such officer in charge of the police station can well exercise the power to conduct such an investigation and all such investigation be deemed would be an investigation conducted by an officer in charge of the police station. It was held ‘It is permissible to any superior officer of police to take over the investigation from such officer in charge of the police station either suo motu either on the direction of the Superior Officer or even that of the Government’ Unfortunately, in the case on hand the Commissioner did not take over investigation by himself but directed the Assistant Commissioner of Police (Crimes) to order a Police Officer of CCB unit to conduct the investigation. Now it is argued for the respondents that the Police Commissioner in the capacity of the superior officer while exercising his power under Section 36 of the Code delegated his power to the Assistant Commissioner of Police, to take out investigation from local jurisdiction for proper investigation through another police officer who is not less than the rank of Station in charge. While presenting such submission, the respondents fail to equate the Commissioner of Police of City of Bangalore to the State as contemplated in Article 12 of the Constitution of India to authorize investigation by a different police officer of different unit. Selection of investigating agency is not the prerogative of the complainant nor the choice of the jurisdictional Magistrate that is also well settled by the judicial pronouncements. It is the State Government or the High Court in exercise of its power under Article 226 of the Constitution that can order investigation by any other specialized agency than the local police. It is the State Government under the general powers of superintendence undei Section 3 of the Police Act, 1861 has the power to direct further investigation under Section 173(8) of Cr. P.C (State of Bihar v. J.A.C Saldanha . 1980 SCC Cri 272) The Courts ordinarily do not intervene in the matter of investigatior by police, however, in exceptional circumstances, the Court woulc intervene to protect the personal/propriety rights of the citizer (Manohar Lal Sharma v. Principal Secretary . AIR 2014 SC 666).
13. In Central Bureau of Investigation v. State of Rajasthan (supra), while adjudicating the question of a Magistrate's power to direc investigation by C.B.I under Section 156(3) of the Code, the Apex Court, in the context of Section 36 of the Code, observed thus:
“This means any other police officer, who is superior in rank to an officer in charge of a police station, can exercise the same powers of the officer in charge of police station and when he so exercise the power he would do it in his capacity as officer in charge of the police station. But when a magistrate orders investigation under Section 156(3), he can only direct an officer in charge of a police station to conduct such investigation and not a superior police officer, though such officer can exercise such powers by virtue of Section 36 of the Code. Nonetheless when such an order is passed, any police officer, superior in rank of such officer, can as well exercise the power to conduct investigation, and all such investigations would then be deemed to be the investigation conducted by the officer in charge of a police station. Section 36 of the Code is not meant to substitute the magisterial power envisaged in Section 156(3) of the Code, though it could supplement the powers of an officer in charge of a police station. It is permissible for any superior officer of police to take over the investigation from such officer in charge of the police station either suo motu or on the direction of the superior officer or even that of the government.”
14. The above observation comes in aid to solve the legal puzzle we are faced with. The Commissioner of Police could have exercised his jurisdiction under Section 36 of the Code and could have conducted the investigation by himself. But in the absence of any statutory authority to delegate the power of investigation to an inferior Officer, he could not have assigned the case to the CCB unit. Power to delegate investigation to some extent is vested with the Station House Officer who is acting under Section 157(1) of the Code, whereby on receipt of the information he can depute his subordinate officer not below of such rank as the State Government, may direct to proceed to investigate the fact and circumstances of the case and if necessary, to take measures for the discovery and arrest of the offender. Except the provision at sub-Section (1) of Section 157 of the Code, the concept of delegation of power cannot be perceived either from the Code or Karnataka Police Act. That answers the question raised supra in the beginning of the discussion. Thereby, the order passed by the Commissioner at Annexure ‘D’ is without authority and propriety. Intervening and transferring the case in the middle of investigation which would have been concluded by this time is illegal. The petition is filed touching the legality of registration of the complaint etc. Though the petitioners are seeking to quash the complaint and FIR itself, the order of the Learned Magistrate passed under Section 156(3) of the Code convinces that he has perused the complaint averments and felt it necessary for police investigation and the said order does not call for interference. However, both the complainant and the accused, if aggrieved by the final report of the investigation, will have their opportunity to challenge the said order.
15. The petition is allowed in part.
The order passed by the first respondent dated 25.04.2015 at Annexure ‘D’ is quashed.
In view of the disposal of the main petition, I.A Nos. 2 and 3 of 2015 are also disposed of as having become infructuous.
Alert