Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sanjay Gadekar v. State Of Goa

Bombay High Court
Apr 8, 2011
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a person convicted under Sections 302 and 120B read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life. The petitioner challenged an order dated 13/12/2010 passed by respondent no. 2, which rejected the petitioner's application for furlough. The matter was heard by the court with learned counsel for the petitioner (Ms. Gawas) and the learned Public Prosecutor for the respondent (Mr. Ferreira). By consent the Rule was heard forthwith.

The impugned refusal of furlough was grounded on the assertion that the petitioner had already availed the facility of furlough within a period of one year. The court's record refers to Rule 310 of the Goa Prison Rules, 2006, which, in cases where an accused sentenced to life imprisonment has been released on furlough on two occasions, requires that an application for furlough be considered on its merits within a period of six months of actual imprisonment to be counted from the last return from furlough. The respondents filed a reply disclosing that the petitioner had been released on furlough on two earlier occasions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the rejection of the petitioner's furlough application on the ground that the petitioner had already availed furlough "within one year" was legally sustainable in light of Rule 310 of the Goa Prison Rules, 2006.
  2. Whether the impugned order dated 13/12/2010 rejecting furlough should be quashed and set aside, and if so, what directions should be given to respondent no. 2 regarding reconsideration of the furlough application.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the basis given for refusal of furlough — that the petitioner had availed furlough within one year — and compared it with the requirements of Rule 310 of the Goa Prison Rules, 2006. The Rule, as referenced in the opinion, specifies that where a life-sentenced prisoner has been released on furlough on two occasions, any subsequent application must be considered on merits within six months of actual imprisonment counted from the last return from furlough.

Given the respondents' admission that the petitioner had been released on furlough on two occasions, the court found that rejecting the furlough application on the simplistic ground that the petitioner had availed furlough "within one year" was legally unsustainable. The court therefore concluded that the impugned administrative order lacked proper legal foundation under the applicable prison rule and required quashing and remand for fresh consideration in accordance with the Goa Prison Rules, 2006.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The impugned order dated 13/12/2010 passed by respondent no. 2 rejecting furlough to the petitioner is QUASHED AND SET ASIDE.

Implications and directions:

  • The court directed respondent no. 2 to take a fresh decision on the petitioner's furlough application in accordance with the Goa Prison Rules, 2006, within a period of four weeks from the date of the judgment.
  • The Rule was made absolute in the terms stated in the judgment.
  • No broader precedent or new legal principle was announced beyond the application of the existing provision of Rule 310 of the Goa Prison Rules, 2006; the immediate consequence is limited to requiring fresh consideration of the petitioner's furlough application in conformity with that rule.
Show all summary ...

Judgment:

Heard Ms. Gawas, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Ferreira, learned Public Prosecutor for the respondent.

2. Rule. By consent heard forthwith.

3. The petitioner who has been convicted under Sections 302, 120B r/w 34 of I.P.C and sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life challenges the order dated 13/12/2010 passed by the respondent no. 2 rejecting furlough to the petitioner.

4. The furlough sought by the petitioner has been refused on the ground that the petitioner had already availed the facility of furlough within a period of one year. In terms of Rule 310 of the Goa Prison Rules, 2006 in respect of an accused who has been sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life, his application for furlough is to be considered on merits within a period of six months of actual imprisonment to be counted from last return from furlough, in case the petitioner has been released on furlough on two occasions.

5. Reply filed on behalf of the respondents discloses that the petitioner was released on furlough on earlier two occasions.

6. In view of the above position, it is evident that rejection of furlough to the petitioner on that the ground that he has already availed the facility of furlough within one year is patently unsustainable in law.

7. This being the position, the impugned order rejecting furlough to the petitioner is liable to be quashed and set aside.

8. In view of the above, the impugned order date 13/12/2010 passed by the respondent no. 2 rejecting furlough to the petitioner is quashed and set aside and the respondent no. 2 is directed to take decision afresh in accordance with the Goa Prison Rules, 2006 within a period of four weeks from today.

9. Rule is made absolute in the aforesaid terms.