- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
V.V Suryanarayana Shetty v. V. Prakash & Another
Factual and Procedural Background
This revision petition arises from an eviction order against one of the judgment-debtors. The judgment-debtor sought a stay of further execution proceedings in Execution Case No. 639/1987 before the City Civil Judge (CCH. 7) Bangalore via an interlocutory application (I.A No. 2). The ground for the stay was that the judgment-debtor had filed a separate suit against the decree-holder concerning a different property originally belonging to the second judgment-debtor and from which eviction was also sought. The executing Court refused to grant the stay, holding that it could not go beyond the decree it was executing and noting that the High Court had already refused to grant more time beyond 31st May 1987. Consequently, I.A No. 2 was dismissed, prompting the present revision petition under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether under Order XXI Rule 29 of the C.P.C, the executing Court has the power to grant a stay of execution if a suit between the same parties is filed in the same or any other Court of equal status.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Pujari Subbaiah v. Lakkappanavara Sanjivappa [1982 (1) Karnataka Law Journal 20] | Interpretation of "such Court" in Order XXI Rule 29 of the C.P.C requiring the suit to be pending in the same Court executing the decree. | Supported the view that the suit must be pending in the same Court executing the decree and must relate to the matter under execution. |
| Shaukat Hussain @ Ali Akaram v. Smt. Bhuneshwari Devi (dead) By L.Rs [(1972) 2 SCC 731 : A.I.R 1973 S.C 528] | Clarified that Order XXI Rule 29 applies only if two simultaneous proceedings exist in the same Court: (1) execution proceeding initiated by the decree-holder against the judgment-debtor and (2) a suit by the judgment-debtor against the decree-holder. | Reinforced the requirement of simultaneous proceedings in the same Court for applicability of Order XXI Rule 29, thereby negating the application of the rule in the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the language of Order XXI Rule 29 of the C.P.C, emphasizing the phrase "such Court," which indicates that the suit against the decree-holder must be pending in the same Court executing the decree. The Court relied on the precedent set in Pujari Subbaiah v. Lakkappanavara Sanjivappa to confirm that the pending suit must relate to the subject matter of the execution. Further, the Supreme Court's decision in Shaukat Hussain @ Ali Akaram v. Smt. Bhuneshwari Devi clarified that for the stay to be granted under Order XXI Rule 29, two simultaneous proceedings must be pending in the same Court: the execution proceeding and a suit by the judgment-debtor against the decree-holder. Since these conditions were not met, the Court concluded that the executing Court had no power to grant the stay based on the separate suit filed in another Court.
Holding and Implications
The revision petition is rejected.
The direct effect of this decision is the dismissal of the revision petition challenging the executing Court's refusal to grant a stay of execution. The Court clarified the narrow scope of Order XXI Rule 29 of the C.P.C, reinforcing that the executing Court's power to stay execution is limited to cases where a suit is pending in the same Court executing the decree. No new precedent beyond this interpretation was established.
1. This revision is by one of the judgment-debtors who undisputedly suffered an order of eviction. He, therefore, in Ex. Case No. 639/1987 on the file of the City Civil Judge (CCH. 7) Bangalore sought by an application numbered as I.A No. 2, stay of further execution proceedings on the ground that he had filed a suit against the decree-holder in respect of another property which was in the possession of the decree-holder and which originally belonged to the 2nd Judgment-debtor and from which he had sought eviction of the decree-holder. The Court refused to accede to that contention on the ground that it cannot go beyond the decree which it was executing and therefore once the High Court had refused the judgment-debtor-1 in the case any further time beyond 31st May, 1987 it would not be proper for the executing Court to accede to the contention of the 2nd judgment-debtor. In the result, I.A No. 2 came to be dismissed. Therefore, the present revision petition under Section 115 of the C.P.C
2. The only proposition canvassed in this Court is that under Order XXI Rule 29 of the C.P.C the executing Court has the power to grant stay if the suit between the same parties is filed, whether in that Court or in any other Court of equal status.
3. Such a construction may not be possible on account of language of Rule 29 of Order XXI of the C.P.C which is as follows:
Stay of execution pending suit between decree-holder and judgment-debtor.
29. Where a suit is pending in any Court against the holder of a decree of such Court (or of a decree which is being executed by such Court) on the part of the person against whom the decree was passed, the Court may, on such terms as to security or otherwise, as it thinks fit, stay execution of the decree until the pending suit has been decided: (Provided that if the decree is one for payment of money, the Court shall, if it grants stay without requiring security, record its reasons for so doing).”
4. By the use of the words “such Court” it is clearly indicated that the suit which is filed against the decree-holder must be in the same Court which is executing the decree obtained in another suit and as correctly held by this Court in the case of Pujari Subbaiah… v. Lakkappanavara Sanjivappa…. [1982 (1) Karnataka Law Journal 20] the suit pending in “such Court” must have a bearing in regard to the matter that is being executed in another decree. In the view I have taken, I am fortified by the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Shaukat Hussain @ Ali Akaram v. Smt. Bhuneshwari Devi (dead) By L.Rs [(1972) 2 SCC 731 : A.I.R 1973 S.C 528] in which it has been held that for the applicability of Order 21 Rule 29 of the C.P.C there should be two simultaneous proceedings in one Court viz., (1) a proceeding in execution of the decree of that Court started at the instance of the decree holder against the judgment-debtor and (2) a suit at the instance of the same judgment-debtor against the holder of the decree of that Court. It makes abundantly clear that Order 21 of Rule 29 of the C.P.C is attracted only if the said conditions are satisfied and not otherwise.
5. For the above reasons, this revision petition is misconceived and it is rejected.
Alert